← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5831/2016dismissed

Bharti Axa General Insurance Co. Ltd v. Jag Pal And ORS

2017-04-27Mr. Justice Hari Pal Verma7 pages

 

     

  

  

 ! "

"#$$ %% & '( ) * #   $     !

" #  !$

 ++++ *'   ,'-.' /01 &

 1

',' - &

2%1 &

 1

'0 $$ %% ++++   

   *'2 '    0  $$%     ( '    3 

 0 4  



%2

35 2 %/0 $'  $$ %   0  .    

 0  0  6'

 6  $ 57 ' $2

0 4 6$' $'

357   ''

$

' $2

0 -( /4 10 4 6 

0 & %#

0 (' 4$2 10 '   '10 & %#

 0 4  0  / %#

0  / % #

0 8 0 

  % 0 $'  $$ % 0 '   '1

4 '

( '24 (6$' $'

37  '

4$% /0 ' % &

(4  4 ' 10    % 6

++   ( %0'

(/0 (' ' 0 4 6'

& 70$'

(' 1 %2

35 20

(''

 %/ 0 $'  $$ % 0& 0 '

% ' ( %

'0 $$% +$$ %% 0  "

('     0  0  9$%   /&   .2  0 $$% +$$ %% 8/



%2

35 2 %/ 0 $$ %(

 

 0  %2 

/%210 $'  $$%   %%  ",+::::+"+7 *'2 '0 $$%  ( 3

"*"



%2

 2'

%/0 $$ % ;

'0 '   0 $$%  14 %%

 %2

 2'

%/0 $$ %

 ;#+35+7 0  $$ %%+('  "

4$2  0   0  $'   $$ %/0 6'

 57$ .2, '

 "%4'.(%1  $<

'0 '1=0 '.(%=>160 ' .20  %4 $  .20  %4+)/*%<' $ 

0 ' >1(

  77 

 0  , '  ? 0 %    1  :1 

'  /' 

4$  

(

-(' ( .2044 & 0 (%'

60 0

8$% :516

$

0  %460 %  %

4$ 

31@+.20 '.(%

+5+ ' %2 1$ ' %4$  1 :510

%4+' $  

+)/  *%  % /  60  ?8'4   ,-  6 ' / /  '. '/' /'

+7+31. /

'& .2   (.00A0   (.00  '('/0& 0

40  (0 ' 

?%%/ ,( %<  $>$'



/ 0  ( % %% 0& 0 %  '   '  $* '

%*(4$1 0 

/  & 0 %  . '/  ' /'  

+33 +31  . /

'& .2?& 0<' $ 

0 ' > $ '0%2

 /%/ %2 60 ( 0 '/ 0 '

'(% 1 4  40

$$   '( 8/0   '  ' 4/ 0 6'

/     (    0  4$ 1  0  %4  (  4(%$% /' & (-('  0$ '   '0 

10 60 

* , %"

%% / 1B0$('B%160 ' 0 64 +% /%%2 94 / ' 4 

'$  0  ( '/

$ '

'0% / ;

'0  

1;

 

:5( :@55*"6' / '

60* %

  

0  /  0  '& ' 

 0 

/  & 0 %     $ 

 #   1  9 $  0  6 ' 

 0 

/  & 0 <' $ 

0 ' >1%%0 ' $ $$ '



/%21 ' $  

+ 6 '  6  $'

 9  $'    0  '& '  

($ '

'

 0 

/ & 0 %  <' $ 

  5 0 '  ' $ & %2> 0 '- 6'  4  2/0 & '4  4 0  %4$    0 %   0. /

++ ' / '

/0  '& ' %2  9' 4$   0  ('  "

4$2  <$$ %%  0 ' >  %

6'  4 18/$' %4'2 .- ' /'

/%

( 1

( 

      4.%2 

 0  $      0  %4 $  .

'4-  '  +- 

 '2$'  0 ('0 ' 00  '& '+' $ 

6 0 / &%

&  '&/%

/& 0 % 6. /

'&  '& 

(' $ % 2 #0 .

(' .(  & 10 '.(%0 % 0 0  

  6  ( (    '0     /%/   '&/ 

' $ 

+?& 0(  0 

10  %4(

' (' 

.

0.

 '/0% /1

'60 010 6 $ ' ($ * , %"

%% / 1B0$('B%  '  '/%%0  & 1  0  '.(%1  &  6'

  571  6'

 

4$ 

31@+< 1@+ 6'

C .%2D 31@+ 6'

$ (

'/D 1@+ 6'

 

' 4 D1@+ 6'

0 %02   '$ ' > //' &  /  0  

'   6'

1  0  $$ %%+ (' 4$20 0 $$ %  ' ( %

'0 $$ %%0'/( 00  '& '

/& 0 % 6 0 /&%

&  '&/ %

/& 0 % 6. / '&  '& 

(' $ % 2 0  4$  6'

.20 '.(% 0/0 ' 0 4 . 2   % 6 %% ''2

+3+ 0  % %60 '.(%06'

/%20 % 00 %% / 



8$% (  '0  /%/  '&/

/& 0 %   +33 +3  0 ('0 ''/( 0 .%26  4$ ''210 '

' 10  %40  (

2$ ('2% 



(

C .%20 '

' 10 '.(%160% $/ 0 4$(/ 6'

106'

/%26'

4 (

1@+ 6'

C 4$ ''2 .%2 4%'%210  %40 % 

$'

(   '

/    & /  &    $'

&  0 9$  

' 4 1.(%%0 '.(%06'

0 4 % 9$   (%4 '60 (  '/0 (0  2

0  

(4 0 '.(%06'

/%20 % 00  '& '

0

/& 0 % 60 /&%

&  '&/% 60 '  ( 0 '&/% 6 90. .

' 0 '.(%

0 4 6 %24'8

(4  0 ('0 ''/( 00 $$ %%+('  "

4$2 (%     $'

(  0  ' $ '    0

'&/% 0 '

6 E 600  0& 0 '

% ' ( %

'0 $$ %% ;'

40   &%.%  '

10 

60 0

$% :51 $( 0  %40 (

 $'

&/0 

6 %%-(' (

.2040 

 0  %4$$ '

*A+ 0 0%  94 ' * 0'4*A+1,- *A+56 %% ('  ' /0*A+  (. 0  10 0' % ($ '

(4   $2

,< 9*+>1 .%2 '  < 9*+>1.

0   8 < 9*+

+7+ 5>1

%% 6+($  0'/  '

< 9*+>1 $2

;< 9*+3>

%.%% '

$ 9"+ "+F0  %40 8  ' 4  4* , %"

%% / 1B0$('B%160 ' 0 6 +% /%%2 94 / ' 4 

'$ ' * 0'4160 $$ '

*A10 $'

& 00  %4(

/' & (  -('       $ '  0  ,  < 9*+>1  0  0  (

.%2 0  9 

C1$ ' .%2 '  < 9*+>

0  %4  0    $   0(/  4 (    ' 4 1  4  1 '$ '  0 %02    0 '

' 10 -(' 1' 4   0  9$  6 '  (%2$'

& 

'    0  '/(4  

 0  % ' ( % 

'  0 $$ %%+(' 4$200  '& '6 0 /&%

'&/  %    0 

/  & 0 %  6  . /  '&   

'& 

0  '4G  

(' $ % 21 40

$2

'&/% ,'8+10. $'

& 00 4 6 ( 4 /(0 '21;''(80. 6&% 6   : 60 ' 0 

1H(  1

8$%

:50(1 0 ' % &  10  '& '

/ & 0 % 60 /&% '&/%  0  % 6 4 

'&/, % 60/ '1,? ? %2  6

(4. ($ 0 $$ %%+(' 4$2 / 0 

'&/% & ' 40 (0 '2 ' 1.( (

'64 .20 $$ %%+(' 4$2 0(1 0 .

 & '

''

@&%.%  '

1 .%0 0

++ 0  %40(

$'

&/0  ' /'

/



0 -('  & 6

.

& 10"

('

  2%% /%2 0 6 %%'  6'

$ .20 '.(% 

/%210 $$ % .20 $$ %%+(' 4$2  4    !$



   - & A0 0 '$ 8/@'  I F @

A0 0 '' $ '.% I F @