High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6538/2018allowed

Satinder Kumar Jindal v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2024-03-12Mr. Justice Namit Kumar13 pages

" #

% &

' ( )*&+,$% + !

" #-)

,. # -))/-% & ,)# !

( 0 1

2 (

& #) #

2 '

3 '*

4 5)6 7 ( &+ ( 0 -2''

( '

&# '

' (

# ' (

' (

!(# +8 '

( * ' '

&+ '(

(# '2 (

(

% '

( 0 ; % &

87 44 ) #= > '

+ -2

'/ !

% &.'!(# +

(

2 * &+ ' ?!(# +8 9*#

-4- *

2''!(# +

' ! 2 * !(# +8 !(# +8 '

( 1 '+ -

'!2

' !(# +

' (

2 @

-2'&+

( '!2 #

! "#$#"% & '(

' ) *+

! , -

./ - ! 0 ) *+ !1

03 4)5#6 7 / 89#8: ,;5254 3 +.3

. , < (0 < ! 7 =

) !. ), < + < . !< + > ! .3 ?8,3 @ ! .+ < (0 ;<3 < + ! .

. . +3 <A

+. +

< +

+* + @ +. . < 8. <

<!+ ,)B5.4 3<.<! ! * !

), 5. ) B

-6 @ <+ A 8. 3< . 3.

+* .4

< +. <+

< , ! <

C < ..

! 8 .

. <+ D

C <..

! -8

+ <+< +., < ! !+.3 E . ! 3 3

< <

. '8 ! .<+ 1 . < ! . ), ;<3 , 2 ! $B 7 % 1 + 3 ! . 0 8 4) B

4 < + +. 2 ! ! F 5,G6F <+ G6F <+ . ! !+. !+ + . + <

. . , ,; F# /;3F 85F FH ) ?3# 3 8;5 3 -3 0 2 ! !FI 1(

'!&

2 ' % &

?!(# + 9 *#

-4(

44 * ##

.' !!

" " !

B 82 ! !F3 ),3; 6 8

F 2 ! 3),

,)2 !3,B3?

)2 !3,B3H , -

2 ! 3), " # $

# <

), 5'0

- 03 '' 03 . < E ! ! 7 . < # + + +. @ + < + J ! < . 3 + .

. . E + !

<> !

+ + $ < %< ' .

# ? 86))6/89#8: ,;#5B2 5/$588% B2 #F#/5,86/

6), F25'

&(& ( 3F 85F= 0 .+ < G 6 3),; 6 0 ,;#5B2 5/$588% B2 #F#/5,86/ ) '# !-(

2 2 =* / 2 )

% &

* @ !*

= 2

& ' !!

- ' *' ' '

, *- (

( '!- ' *' ' A , *- -

*- 445)67)

(

& !(

' 3

( '! '

& ( > 2-

' ! - 2' (

' ( +&

( '!-' !

= 2

= '

'!&+ '(

-( '3 2'&+'

( '!

' *'( ( '

((

' ' &+ 2

#*0

(

&+ '! !

'! .' 2 (

2 (

4 4-&+ * (

' (

(

- #

= (( (

'# 2-2 ' (

'- '

(

@ 4- (

2 !!

' !(*

4- ( &+ ( 0 - 2'&+ #

' (

& #

# (( + 2 #+

!(# + 2'

#> '(

B #

' (

(

2 *#+#

6&+

2 '*

'!.' (

2 * '

& ! #>

(

2##

'!(# +-2'

- 2 * ' 9 '! >

' (

!(# +

## 2* '(

-2'

#6'

'! !

+ > '

(% 2 # &

- '&3

(

(( 1((

-# # (# # ' %*!

' > 8&# (! &'()& *+,-(.+/+& 0-+/+&1 # 012+,3 - &(0& 04 &'() )&' 012+,3567

8)9.:11)1)1+ ,)&3;0,10,;0,)1(0&)&' 012+,3-32(12)<,)=0,1>)&'012+,35? 6:;,+/+0:,17

' %04@2):'2),>2),)& (&A2 ),>)&)A,(.:91:,)9&(-+,3(1>)&')&012+,-2),)/;)9@ ;)33+'0&> # &!

- -4C 5!(# +8'

97#+*2 ' '

' !

' ) - # #

( 0

(

# +6'

' # '!

9> '

44- ((

2 *

#+ !(# +2'

* '

#- 2-(

# +*'

2 ' 9 '!.'

-&3

#+ &% &+ '(

!(* 1 ((

-# #

( 0 (# # ( ' %*!

' 04 @ 02)&%)9-+;3: 0)' ,)&3;0,10,;0,)1(0&%(/(1+'5)1()9))&' 012+,3)&'012+,.0&&+.1+'.)3+3@'+.('+'0&? 4 1 '

' # #

' ( (

#+- (

'! 2

'!(# + '

2 '

# '!

' /

'! D( #+- (

2 ' ' 9 '! .'

- !!

44- (

* ##

- 2 ' +

'!(# +2'

# .' 3

' ( (

2' ' '(

& ## 2

'!2

- ' # +

9 '!-(

' ##

2 ## #+ !(# +2'

* '

' > 8&# (! 09 <<),) 6 +1'7 - 0-+,&/+&104&'()56!7

-!!

'((# #

( &

& 8 !

< 8.= $%# ! !

3 ++. +.. ! E . !

# !+

+ E . 3 < +!+! < < > #

3 +

+ !

+ < $+%G !< > !

> + $ % < ! 3< < >3 ! ! !

+ <E +. ! < > + < ! # <

3 < <

> +! 3< ! > +

< 3 < .3 < . + ! KLM 6 + @ !

. . 8 !. < >3 .

! 8. . @

! . < . @ ! .

+ .$ .%@ !

+. +. ! ! !

+* !

> 8&# (! &'()& *+,-(.+/+& 0-+/+&1 - &(0& 04 &'()5 67

# +* 2 ((# * * ' (

2#! ( +'! &( ( #+

((#> 2- ''!

* * ( &

> 8&# (! &(-+,3(1> 04 +92( - /1 2)32(B(,)&)&'012+,356?7 ?'

'# N

8 -0 . ! . J + 3<

. *

+ < !# -0 . + @ < )B3 !.

. +

,)B3 . E .3 < .

. < F G

- ! & &'

(3 . * ! & &

(0 < <.

)B <<

& &

(03 . < + )B

,)B<

.@ +

3< < < ! + 3

> !

+. > !

3 + + +.<.

! +. 3 <<,)B3< @ ! < .+ . & &

(0 < .+ +.)B# @

+ ! J + + < . ' 6 3 + > .

-0 . < !

< . < < +

)B# +.+ <

& &'

( <

3 <

+. . . )B

+. 3

< < ! 8 ' . < . <.

+ +. + < + #

8 ' , . & &

!3 . ! ! ! < + 33+

3 < +. !H

! ! & H

! / O + < < & & !( +3 ! +

,)B<(C

', ! P 3 <3 +.F G ;! , J + . @@ ! +

,)B<(C #

+ !3 . J + . + < )B G

I 1 ' ( - &

'!- ## '!(# +

2 '9 '! '!(# +2'

2'! ' ' (#

! 2 #*&#

( '! .' !(# +2'

6 +

' !(# +- #* (

- 2'

9 '! 2 =( ' ?!(# + 9 *#

- 4

&3 #+- ' (

!(# + 2'

2 ' ' (&C (#

( .'- ( ((

& ( # #+2'!# &

2 *

!# #+

!(# +-

'!A #% *'-2'

- *'

# )(

- :

# *' '

- 2'

% ( 0

44-**

-2''2 ( &+ '(

' 9

4-C 2 #

'! > 2- '3

-'2 ((

'&+ ( 0 >2 * '&

# 2## '

* !9

( '! 9 '- '!(# +8'

- -C ##2 ' (

(

&(!

) #

1 :* !

#!(# +- '

+ !(# + ' !!

##+ 0 (%2 #&

( * ''

'! '

& ##*#

!(# +- ' !

&2 ''#

!# #+

!(# + *' '+ '

6 '

# .'

2 - '

6!E ' !&

' ( *

'! 1

' &3

' ((

* !(# +

'!- &%

(

' '

2 !(# '

&% &

' %*! 02)& %)9C3 5( 7 & *

' (

'( 1 ' -#

(* * ' !(# +- '

- '+ 2 &

? D

. (

?!(# + C/

/ # 9*#

- 1 2

* * - ' ( (

## 2 !(*

45)6 7( &+( 0 - (

* ( + &

' (

' /

'! + ##

( + &

% * !

(

'!- +- &

+ ( !

- -4C !(# +8 '

#+* 2 ' '

- & !

# - ' (

' '

(

' '( =*C FC0 ' '(

&# FC0