← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1579/2011dismissed

Surjit Kaur v. Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee

2015-08-28Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal26 pages

-1- 

     

 ! " #$% &$' ()$%*+ #$$& ,-'

   

         



  & ' ().//$ #$.& ,-'

  

        ! " !   

      

  &/'  )$ #0 #$.& ,-'

  

    # !   

   - 1 23- ) ( - (  $ % %& !!'  (  

 )*  " +,-./0++  1" +203/0+4    )*   " 455+/0+4

%    '  (  

 )*  " 455+/0+4     )*  " +,-./0++  1" +203/0+4

-2-     6+ 7 #8  !          

 (      !   9 (   !    " +,-. /0++ 6/ 7            

  !   !    (

     +3 /0++     8     (  &!

'

:  '   8  !      (

     +- ++ /00,

 8   &!

   ' 8  



      !+   +-  (    " +0.'  " +53'  " 55.)+;+-*    !

  <  8 ' ( :   9      8 

  (  !    

     ( !!           

8          

   :  !     8 

 ;   ((    = 

 ;  8 !    (   '  !      !          

   (  

-3- (8((    "  +..3        !

  ((   " 502(   

     (!   !

  8! ( 

 ((     ! 8      (   :

( ' 

<

 ;  (    !                !          

#  ' !  ' 

!

        1 

      !             !           !    8 +.30   !    

                     

  (                     

  (   !'   (   

       !   " 502     8 +.30 >> !

-4- (    !

                         

  ((!   (  " 502 ! =  

 >

      !  ? !     !(   ( 8 +.3+       (        8 

   (    8   +.30;3+

       !

    

!   

 '

  

(  8 8      !

( '!    $;

                     

                   !"#         !  #  

$    !



    

%                      &    '                      &

-5-

 (           &    )    !#    *+

, 6, 7 @ " + /    (       1      

<      '    ( '

  ((    (8 8 +..3'  

                    !      " 502       >> 8 +.30!

(   (

!  (  

8     !      ? !    !      '  '



 

( '(   

   (  8 8   

<  (     8         

(     

8 !  " 55. 

  8         

A;+   !'

?        !

                   

    

   :

?   

-6-  !

( +.-0   

  8          

'    

        ?  

 ? !    !    

  

8  (!   !

     8! (  

< 

B  8'          

!  ((8

 /4 +/ /000  !

   8   

          8    8   

B  8  !,

' ! 8  

( 

6- <  

        B(

    ((                8!  (    8'  :    !   

    A;/'                        :

      8    

             8  )CB  ;/*  :

   

8    8      !  

  0.

+..3)CB ;5* :

     

-7-    

  !   8                 

 

 

    !

8   :

                         " 5++     "  !

B 

           <       

             ? ! 

 

  !   :

    /4 +/ /000'

 ((   

+D     !!!     8     !,

 1 @ ! !    ( 

  (( :

     

     (( 8!  ' (8!

 (8 

   (           (      (

! CB

+ CB /   !  CB

5  CB !  '"! 

 B  :

                      (   (  

          !    !

  8  %  !!



        >        !

 = 

-8-  ! ? !    :    ((    #      B   

8 

 8     ! !      !? !   !  @( B      ? ! :  ((  2;.8  (

     !((              B ( 

     (!4          (    '

           ! 8        :

       (('   8! (  6.

 8'           1(  !   

    A;/  :

    !     (  (     !

   ! (    @  '

     % : =  6+0  ! A5

       



    1( ! :

  E ! !

 

!  (!8 A;/'

-9-    ( 8(  @ '% : =       

CB +' /  5  ( ( 

 ( :

               :

           !

( '                                !

       '  !/  ,         !(  @ 8'    (     6++ <          !    !

    (   8   

   

        8     !     ? ! :        (    (   (          8! ! !        :

   ( B     ? ! :  ((  2 +08  (

<!  ( (  !  ' (  (  

8 :

       '  8! (    

-10-  

 ! '  ( 6+/ 7   8'# !

  A;4           !

 (( ( ( 

<    !

     (                        

                    +.30 (       '   !/  ,         ( '         

C    ! !          !    (    (    

   !

       !  (   <        !       ? ! 

     !( 6+5 7<  



8  (        !       ( B           8 +.30

! !  '!           !    (  ( :

      ( 

-11-   ! !!      ! !

   :

         8 (  

  6+4 7<      ! !   



   (:   (          ((  ? ! :      2;.8  ( (   A,

(   (

 45( )/#./+ 0.

/00,  6786(9:985;)( 6<= 6  !

  A3 :

    !     !

   :

            !+  +-            !  !   ( +.30;3+   !    8      !? ! : (  @  '        8

 B   !    "   

     :    !

 (( 

   !    ? !     !(     

-12-     ((    6+, 7     " 504/+ 0.

/00,CB ;+ @(

B  '        8    ! !    

  :

   !        !+ F  /          ! !

   !      

 :

       

 # !' !' ! (       6+3 7< (   B !  (  (    

  

   (       8   +.30;3+    ( 

  

 ( 8    &     CB

/      8   +.30;3+'

&   CG

4 8 +.3-;32'&    8 +.-/;-5CB

,'&    8 +.25;24CB

3'&     8 +.22;2.CB

-'&    8 +..5;.4CB

&    8 +..2;..CB

.       (       

        !

" 8

(

-13-  

        8    '    (    ( 18      

 ( 6+- 7< ( CB

5      (  '     (  

 !  "       

   (  @  

(       "

55.   ! !     !+  +-  )   *'>- ./ &

 

         

 ! !   6+2 7% : = 

( 8&    8 +.30;3+ ( 

    @ CB

;5 @ (      

 (      (  8  (       (  (       (          

(   " 6+.

7 ((! ' 

  

  !

  8 8      

 8 8 8  (  ( "!

-14-  (  

( 

8 "!( 

        !  8   !   (    

 <  

8 ( @ 

!  ( @ 8 +.30' (+/5<  

8 (

( ! 

(        

(     

  +.,,      (               =      !   8          8   8    8    ( '    

 (  ( 6/0 7<       !         <               8

      

( ( +.30'

      

     ('   '  

     8 !

     < (8

 (                  

       (  (  8!     

<  8      &    8 +.30;3+/00/;04 

  ( H CB /'CB

4CB +0    ! 8     

(  

-15-    %  !        (         

  !        6/+ 7      <  ( ! !   8  (  !     !  8   

 (  ! 

 8  E   '

  '   (  

      !   (  (        (

    (  (  (   8 (8

(( B(    

  @   (      '

8= (      

8  !!   !  (

 '    (    

B (     8  !

 

       '  

  

 ( 6// <       ( 8

-16-

     

(                  

     '  '  (         !   '     !((  8

 (8   

    !(     ( =        

         !     

   <

      ( ( +.30'        '   8 +.-0   8  6/5

((!  '( 

    

     '    '        8     

   8 8       8



   (   8  8 B!! !              (      8  (!  8 ( 3+?  (

 ( (   (  $++% 5>!

7$++*& '45  6>!.$0 @     '  (

                    (      

-17- (( (         

      

        ( !!    

8

6/4

@

  ? 

  '!   



 ? 

  8

!

(  ( CB +    !

- (  '  5,

 

 (    !

!

 ;

  >- .  

   ;

 +/     !

       

 1   

  (       (( ( (   +  +-    @      (    " 55.

 (  &   ( 

   8  ( 

CB /    8 +.30;3+'              

    (  " 4'       >- - . (       !  " 502)0;2*'55.)+;+-*      !     " 502     

        >-   ./ - ' '  " 55. 

 >-  ./ &

@(" .'  



-18- >

  

              B!  " 502(         " 55.       (                8! (  <                !     ((  8  

     /4 +/ /000       8      <

     8 

B  8  !,

 @( B  '       

B ( (  8 +.4/;45  =  ! ? !    @       ((  

        /4 +/ /000 6/, ? 

      

 

   ( 0.

+..3)CB ;5*    (       (       

<  

  ( 8A;/:  !     8   CB /     

       B                (        (   " !   

 B   

-19-

8   (  

 (   

  

 B        

  (   

   B    (                    (     ' 

   B  A;/  :    !  (     

          8      ( 

( 8         8  (  8               +/ 0.

+..3  ( 8    (   

  !

     A/( B       (     -+',00 ;             

!   (    (  8          8A/

 !

@         

! '   :  !;A/

(      

         8          

%  ' 

  !     

<    A;/:  ! ( (  (  (           

'         

           (     8     (  

-20- (    '(   ! :   !     8CB /! ! 8     

        

   8  

8    8    <

8 

 ( 

  

6/3 7 <  !       

         (



(     (  8      '

 (      (( ! 

 (8  

 !  (   

   (  !  

"!   1 4+  /-    !        (  @    !        (     8! A/:  !

(!  

' !  " +'/ 4 

 8

   6/- @ (    !   6/2





'!  =   

-21- 

 8

 $;

0         

    !  

(1$ 1 

& &

& & 

 &  #    "&



&0 2  " 

!    

 

#  &#

34

 &# 

!  !# "

!

!0  "& #!&   5! #   !

06!7

   #& " !  

0

  6!7

   !



  # #  !   &  

 

0

!     

  3 #  "

  6 

0  8 

7 

 &#  

 

0  8 

7 

-22-

  

! 

  "

!&# 

  6/.

<   ! =     = 

8= 

8  !

 

 (    8   

      0.

+..3  (   8  A  /  :    !

8'    8 A/:  ! 

( 8  +/ 0.

+..3  ( 8   (   

  !

       A/:  !   (       

!    (  8               

!    A/ (   

     8     

  !     8(  C         A/:  !   (   (  

'

  

     (       @      !( ! (                 (   8  8   

-23- (     (    ! (

         =     8CB /! ! 8     

            8  

8    8

   

8  (     8   65+  (8'        

         (          '(  ( ( (    +   +-   @     

(   " 55.

C      " 55. >- ./ &

  &   

   8  ( 

CB / 8 +.30;3+'       

    (  " 4'   '  >-     -  .    (     !  " 502)0;2* 55.)+;+-* @8    (  (  ; ; >- ./ -    " >- ./ &

  " 55.

(" .     >

  2

-2465/ @     '   ( (8   8!      ! 

(

   (     (         B     

   ('  (8  (       ((   /4 +/ /000'         

8     ((    

   8    '       (     (    

8   =  ! ? !    <  

  !        

( (

      

    8  ! 8 +..-

(  +.30    8 '

( 8   (    

     !

 

  +/ 0.

+..3          !(   @            8         A  / :  !( =       (  '     ( ( 

        

                  '

 ' ! ( 8 ? 

  

-25-  ! !   (

(     ((  !  ( 65, 7<   =     

  !  = " ) *   (  I  " )*              !  !  

8 8 '  (!  8      (

(  I " )(* 

!    (                          (        !      C     !          (!  (   

   !        

I " )* ) *  !

    ( 

< =              I " )*   (    ( 8 ? 

   ; ;     

       8 A/ :  !  ((  '              !    (          

-26- ( I " )!*   I " )*     (      

(        !!   

 (   (   ! 8 =  ( 

(      8    (            !

 '       (       !! 8 ? 

  

7 @         '  !   (   8    ?

              

      ((    !     (  ?!      8     (   (( ( '

      ((!8  & - ('

  /2 !'/0+, (