← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24524/2019dismissed

Mohan Ram And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-09-29Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur13 pages

    

  !  

   

 

        







     !

   "   !   "    







    !

 #  "

   !

  







    !

  #$% &   $%&'()  

!

 *! +, (-).(   &'  *  

 $$ !



/!

0 "1 232

( 

23

(  $4



 

 $$/!

   0 (    "(    !

   67 23

/!!

  $ 6$%/!

 67 322

  

/ $$ !!

!



%(- 0 6 /%     $-!  

  /      0 "$8  0    !      * !

 !

    $" $        

!

 *!

 671 322

  

      0 !

  !

 6$%  6$5  !

 "  9!

4 !0     $6$$ &  6$6' $(::)!!

  /0 !

/!  (/ $ / $ 0  "$ ;

/!! $

   

$



 $$$  4$  !4  !  !0    6$$ $

 :: /   !

 

% 6$%)!$(4$

;!  4 

!!

 6$%    (/0 / 

0

  0<  

" ( =

% =    6$5  "

     !

$ ! ( / "  $/ 

 > * "/

 ?@ "$ ! "! 

3?# /  ! !$ (

  !

6$%0   0/





!!

 0  !

 /( 

   2:(

 $

::/  0  !

 "

1 555 )!! ;= 

!!



6$%  0   )!   (

 !!

     !

 6$%      (  $$ !!0   ! " 0

  0   !!

"    /   !

 

 

# !!

   * "

$      0 "$      / 

 0 .

  # * !

( /    0  !    6$% !!    !

 % ";!

" !

% "

 ! !

 (//

    ( ( $     $"$

 0 "  

  : 



 

 / %

  $"$

(  !

 /

   !! 6 0 / 

$ "671 2##

# $  

     

(// !

 

     2  #/ 

!



 $

!

5 !$ 

 ! 0  6 

2  #($

!

/

  0  !

     / <         # #   2 #! 0 !

1 

" ! " !  !

6$%  $4$

 !

 !        $

 ::  

    2:)"" "    ! 0 !

1 ( !

" !!  6 0 / 

671 3##

# $  

    

/

       : # $  "6 

  "

  ;!

/

$;

 $ 

 !   

;*     : #/ $$ " 0 !

0

-

=  A)1 3 

#(//        #  # $  "

 ; !

/

$;

 $:

   $6$$

2 &  6$B6>'$(::( !    0%  $

% " "   !( (  

  

   $;

(   "   0    =$$ (-

=  $ 

$; $ 0;  

(  ! 0  "$C "/   A)/ !

 

/ 

!

1 

 $

!



$;





 !$$ 5 /

 

! 0 -

=  A)1 3 

#(!

1 / $

# 2 2 !

1 "  "$;

!

 " ! ( /( !

 (!

1 ) 

$6

  .



     !  0$ $;  ! 



   $  * ( !

 1   - . $

 $(       : 2     ! 

    2: !

  !    $ 4$

!

6$% 

($

!



"

$   

6$%/<  2  "$ /

 !

0 $$ "

    2: /   $6$$&  6$B6>' $(::/  (!

" !!  6 0 

$ " 67 1 :D#

  D $      

        

  /(   .

     

   #/0  !/0 /  @$"0$  *   6 ! )!!

 )!!$

 & @*6'  !

    

 !

    !

 6$% /  

3 !$    "   $ !

 /    )    ; 6$%(/  0 . !-!

    

0 0$ ! !$$ (   !

 !   !  @*6  5  !     

 

(  $

   !  /       "$ ( / 0 0<

$$ "  /!

(//$00  " $  "/ $ 0 !

- " 



/!



2  ( "!

 

%!$   4

 ! "  @*6  !

  

#! !  !

  : #:( 

4

! " !(-

= <     !$ /$  $  "   

 4

 ! ! !!$

   #*!$$$   !

/"  ;!

        #!  A) 2:

  # $       

        

! 0 -

= /$ < 0  $  " < " ! 

 A) 

 / /6     "

";!

" ! 3     /   

  / !

 0 " 1 :D#

D$

"/

 !

 "0

-

= ( $     $   $  !

  

#          #   

  /  / 0     /$$ !$ $ ! @*6($

4 /$$

$$ /*   

  / !  0   6             

D

( /(/ $ / 0   #

$ $$ !5/  $  $$

/   0

  0"  / 4  !  "

 0

 

! " (  / 0   6$5 !

 

!

 D * ( $    3 

.



     /

          !    67 1 2#

(:D#

 2 3#

:( 

/% 

 $$   !

 /   0  !      !

 6$%  

#$$ $ @*6    4$ @*6 ; $$ 0 !      $$   /   0  !    

#(  " ; 

 /  ( !

 $ $*  &!

 $  $' /$      0 $$ /   $$!

 /  0   

!

@*6*

 $/!

" !



 3  / !

 

/

$    3    0   !

(   " 0    

   *  $  

  !

 /   0 !     #  4    ! @*6     !

   0  !   0

 #( 

( 

$  "    0  "     $        !

 

 "   

$      !

(  !

 " $

"  "  !



: : A    $ !!

  !

 / $  

   !

  $  0  !   !   #   

(    

 !   !       $   $  

$ (/0 /$ 0 !

$ !

$    :  &)

; ' /0 

  ( 6$% / /!

D   /$$ / 

$ 0  "

$    !

 /   0  !      !

 6$%  

#$$ $ @*6  /!   !

6$%0

 #(  



!!$0$   

4  ! @*6*!

 



" 

(  " 0 $$ / 0 

$   

($   $!!

0$

!

  / $  "     0  

      $$   

  

  0  %   !

> $

 "



$   /  ! "  !    

 !

  6$%

< 5 0  /

  

#(    $

   $6$$ &  6$555'$(::/   !$)&'( ; "6$%/ 0 . !-  ( / 

!  ! "$$ 4    $( $$   !

    !   ! "     @$"0$ * 6 !)!!

)!!$

& @*6'F $

/ "



!!$0$ 



  

 3



. !-!$ (/ 0   !

 6$%   #              0   ) 

$6   .



  ( -! ( /$   !   !

(/ 0 !  6$%0

 #4  ! !!

    $ *

(  !$

 !



 "



$ / ! " !

0     5 $   $

! /   "

  "  !! 0

%  *   4

      0

   / /!

(/ /!  

0%  ( 0    0 

 

0 0$ ! !*  !



!

 / !  6$5  !

         !

 ! $$    4$  !4  ! 

  6$$$(::*$"

/ 0  !

% ";!

 ! " !(/!  /

     (  /(       #  # !    A) 3 

#( 

/  !



  $

!



$;



! " !  $:

::$ !$$ *- . $

 $

    

  !

   

 "(      " ;!

    !

  ! "   ! (  /(    

  

 / .

  

!

/$$ < 0 ! "!%   04  (  / !

 / $  0  $$    !

    !  $  "!

 (/  ";!



" !?

@*6(  (  

  

#(.



  0  !/  @$"0$  *   6 ! )!!

 )!!$

 & @*6'  * / $0 0

-

= 

6 (   /!





0

/   $

   !  /   ( % " !

@*6    

!

!

6$% 6$5 !

/$$

"

 0 $$ " 5 0 

/!



$ ( ! / "% ";!

@*6

" 

$ 

(;!

 0 "    !

- " 

  "(-

= // 8 

(      2   "

%



D!

 0 "  ;!

 " !(  /( ;!    !

  !

    !

 6$% / $  $   $%$$ %

/$ "

!!!$

%$$

 !

 " " 



6$%*4

   /

 !!$

   # / $  0 ! ! 6 /

!

 

 0!!$   (/ / % "6$% % "$ 

6$%( 0   /  4

    !  / " ;!

( / / $    

(  6  



    / %    $

%     !

$$    $$ / ";!

0"  (// $  $"

      (   ! 

  

 "  0   -

= (

  0 $  6 0 6  

  .



    /   /  

@*6 0   !$  

$$ $ / % "6$%

$$ / /    / %  6$%

 !

 0      *  .

  0  $  " !

   #       #   

 ( / / $   

$    /   0  !     # $$   $  ! @*6*

/! 0 6  $  "  / 0    #

$ $$ ! ! ?

@*6F ( /    0

  0 "  / 4  ! !

 0

 / 0"

! "(/ $

  / 0   6$5 !

 

!

( /$$ 0 "      !     4

( $ " /

4 

$$ /5/$$  !      B    

  





  

      !

  

"

 

#  

 

   *!

 

 0 (

$  !( / / 

 !

    

 



  / $

::*4

!

 (/ $  0 $  ;!

" !( / ") !$

   #/ $ 

$  $

 

$

 0! * ! / 0  /  @$"0$  *   6 ! )!!

)!!$

& @*6'!

4 

6$%( 

* !( C $ 

"!   $ 

"!  



!!

  /" ; "6$%(/ 0  6$5 !

 

!  !$$ 4  

$ 0 !

 ! ! @*6E !$  

  

(!$ $6$%(/ 

! 6$5 !

/ $  !

 ! !  @*6* 

/ %



!!  0   -

 = 

  6  *   4 

  

# / $  0 $     

 /  

 !      

  /$$  !$ $     !  ( / $ 

$  !

/ $  ! @*6=   

 0     

    ( /  

 ! !  ( :$/

 / $  ! !(/ $  ;!  

(6 

!

  ! 

  !

 % " ;!

 ! "   !

0     F (    

 

 

 / $

!

% ";!

" !(0 

! /

(   0 $$ /   5 !

  6 (  "  " 

 (

  " !

0 %

%



6 0  $ " /!

/0    $$   " ;!

 ! "   !     $   

0  $$ /      5  A) 1 3 

  #(  "  

 /   !



 

!



" ;!

 ! "   !   !$$ (   /

   < 0 ! "!%  5 !

 ( 

 ! 0 -

=  $0 

/!

(671 2#

0 "$ (/ $ 

 $ / 

" ";!

" ! !

5/

$  @*6//     0! 0 !

(/ /!!

 ?!

!

6$%   # !

(/  0   !

6$%0  

! !( !

/"  !  !  @*6   /    0"   * 

  !  !

    0 (



0$(

 



$    $"$        /     / 

  

  ! $   " "   

$$ "/ %!$ # * $

!

 $ " !

 0  ;!   ! "   !      

  E  



0

! ( $4$

! " ! 

!

6$%0;!  0$ )! $ ! !



$/()$2

6



5 0 

!

 !

 4$  $

 

" 4$   @   $ /0       /(    

      !

 ;!!

 " ! !    $  !!

 $( / 6 $ /$$0!! " $$"$ 5 

()(* *+( *,-)./ *0)+1+2 342*56**' 

!  "7/$ $ "/

!

4$  0  !"!D 

# $%&'





   # 

  (# )



 

" "

" )  "

  



'

   

#

  )

 "      #   



# #  

#  

 "  

 

*#

 "   # +

)#  

(#



  "  



#

    

  #   

    

  )

  

 

 ) 

"

 )

   )

 !    

, 2 *!

 

 !

    !

 $$ / 



!

6$% !   

0 0$ ! !( " 



0 ""

$ (

0   "/!

 3 /

"  0 6 (/!

  

&!   *8(*90*5'   %<G 7!% "?

  ,?1 7!

0$ ,?1