High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/8493/2014disposed of

Shakuntla & ORS v. Kuldeep @ Solu@Sonu & ORS

2015-09-10Mr. Justice Satpal6 pages

!"# $#%&'&() * +,!-.("/!!($",#0' 11#//!("'

2#0'.' 3./$##14+/.4+(.!($",#0' #'1($#("'

! !

0#'#(") 0!5#($#0,!.,!(6$7%!"#

0",#!11#//!("' '2!($!(!!/,"0!6$7%!"#8&", '(&-! !(90!6$7%!"#

00#'1($#(" :::

"! #

0#'#(" !11#!/ ,!' ;##( 10# #00#$ ;< ",# %/!&5!("'

10!<&(9 0#(,!(%#5#(" %51#('!"&(!8!0$#$;</#!0(#$"0 %%&$#(" /!&5' 0&;.(!/6 ,&8!(& ,#0#&(!

"#0 0# #00#$ " !'

=0&;.(!/=7&$#!8!0$$!"#$ > (!%%.(" $#!", 2&1&( /!&5!("'!0#1!0#("'!($5&(0'&'"#0' ",#$#%#!'#$ !%"' !' 0#7#!/#$ &( ",# %/!&5 1#"&"&( !0# ",!" 2&1&( $#%#!'#$8!' 0#".0(&(9,5# 05!"#51/#( !"

!;."@ !5#'&9(!//#$!!0<!(!!$8!<';.'"'"1 ;."&(",#5#!("&5#10&7!"#;.';#!0&(90#9&'"0!"&(A?A

?> $0&7#( !" ,&9, '1##$ &( ! 0!', !($ (#9/&9#(" 5!((#0 ;< 0#'1($#("B3./$##1%!5#"8!0$'2&1&(!($'"0.%-!9!&('",&5 &'0&9,"/#98!'%0.',#$.($#0",#"<0# ",#!;7#'!&$10&7!"# ;.'%%&$#("8!'8&"(#''#$;<+.(&/3.5!06 !",#0 2&1&(0&7#0 '"11#$,&';.'!"!/&""/#$&'"!(%#!($8!'&$#("& &#$!'3./$##14 +/.4+(.# /#$ 05",#'1"/#!7&(9",#;.'2&1&(8!'"!-#( " +,"!-;<,&' !",#0#8!'"!-#("C& #!0#'1&"!/6 ,"!-",#(+!&+('651/#D6,"!-",#0#! "#0!"

00! '1&"!/6 &'!0 !($ /!'"/< " &'!0 #6 ,8#7#06 '.%%.5;#$ " ,&' &(E.0&#' ( > $!"#$ D

8!'0#9&'"#0#$.($#0+#%"&(' > 6

>6 !9!&('"0#'1($#("A3./$##1!" /&%#+"!"&(+!$!0 ,&8!(& ('"!("%/!&51#"&"&(8!'10# #00#$.($#0+#%"&(??

"02#,&%/#'%"6 %/!&5&(9%51#('!"&("",#".(# * /!-,'(!%%.(" $#!", 2&1&(8,8!'!//#9#$";# <#!0'

/$#(9!9#$&(!90&%./".0!/80-6$!&0< !05&(9!'8#//!'101#0"< $#!/&(9#8!''"!"#$";##!0(&(9 6@A1#05(", 05!// '.0%#' ?/!-,'8!'&(%.00#$(",#"0#!"5#("65#$&%&(#'!($ "0!('10"!"&( ",#$#%#!'#$ //8&(9&''.#'8#0# 0!5#$;<",#/#!0(#$0&;.(!/)A F,#",#0!%%&$#("%!.'&(9",#$#!", 2&1&("-1/!%# ( $.#"0!',!($(#9/&9#("$0&7&(9

7#,&%/#;.';#!0&(90#9&'"0!"&(A?A?>;< 0#'1($#(" 3./$##1 4 +/. 4 +(.6 !' !//#9#$G

&''.#&'107#$68,#",#0%/!&5!("'!0##("&"/#$

0 %51#('!"&(6 & '6 " 8,!" !5.(" !($ 05 8,5G

F,#",#00#'1($#(" ( 8!' (" ,!7&(9 ! 7!/&$ $0&7&(9/&%#(%#!"",#"&5# !%%&$#("G A

#/&# C#!0(#$ 0&;.(!/ ( %('&$#0&(9 ",# #("&0# !%"' !($ %&0%.5'"!(%#' ,#/$ ",!" 2&1&( /'" ,&' /& # ( !%%.(" &(E.0&#'

'.'"!&(#$;<,&5&(",#!%%&$#("8,&%,"-1/!%#(

$.#"0!',!($(#9/&9#("$0&7&(9 ",#

#($&(9;.';<0#'1($#("

B3./$##1+!&$ &($&(9,!'!""!&(#$ &(!/&"< "!/%51#('!"&( 6?6? @A8!'!8!0$#$;<",# 0&;.(!/"",#!11#//!("A1!0#("'/!&5!("'@!11#//!("' !($ ;#&(9 '&'"#0' ",# $#%#!'#$ 8#0# (" ,#/$ #("&"/#$ " !(< %51#('!"&((%5# ",#$#%#!'#$8!'!''#''#$!" ?6 @A &(%/.'&7# ",# %51(#(" /'' .".0# 10'1#%"' *H $#$.%"&(8!'#

#%"#$!($!((.!/$#1#($#(%<8!'80-#$."!" >6 @A./"&1/&#0 *8!'!11/&#$-##1&(9&(7&#8",#!9# ",# 1!0#("'51#('!"&(8!'!8!0$#$!'.($#0)A C'' $#1#($#(%< *6*6@A .(#0!/#D1#('#' *6@A #$&%!/#D1#('#'

66? @A '1&"!/%,!09#' *6@A "!/ @A C#!0(#$ %.('#/ 0 ",# !11#//!(" !09.#' ",!" /''

.".0#10'1#%"',!'(";#!

0$#$"",#%/!&5!("'./"&1/&#0&( ",&'%!'#,!';##(80(9/<!11/&#$(",#;!'&' ",#!9# ",# 1!0#("'",&(9,!';##(!8!0$#$(!%%.(" /'' /7#!($ !

#%"&("",#1!0#("'C#!0(#$%.('#/10!<' 0#(,!(%#5#("

%51#('!"&(!8!0$#$"",#%/!&5!("' C#!0(#$ %.('#/ 0 ",# 0#'1($#("6 ( ",# %("0!0< '.;5&"' ",!" ( .0",#0 #(,!(%#5#(" &' %!//#$ 0 &( ",&' %!'# 51(#(" .".0#10'1#%"',!'!/0#!$<;##(&(%010!"#$&(",# &(%5#!''#''#$&#?6 @A1#05(",.0",#050#65./"&1/&#0,!'

;##(%00#%"/<!11/&#$!'1#0",#!9# ",#1!0#(""&'("0#I.&0#$ ",!" 5./"&1/&#0 ',./$ ;# !11/&#$ !%%0$&(9 " ",# !9# ",# $#%#!'#$&(",&'%!'#9# ",#$#%#!'#$&'6,8#7#06("$&'1."#$ ";# <#!0'!"",#"&5# !%%&$#(""&'&( 05#$",!"(!11#!/ ,!';##(10# #00#$;<",#&('.0!(%#%51!(<I.!",#&51.9(#$ !8!0$ ,!7#,#!0$/#!0(#$%.('#/ 0",#1!0"&#'!($9(# ",0.9,",# &/# "&'";#("#$",!"",#0#&'($%.5#("!0<#7&$#(%#" ',8",!"$#%#!'#$2&1&(6!9#$ <#!0'68!'#!0(&(9!(<&(%5# ( !%%.(" 101#0"< $#!/&(96 #(9!9&(9 &( !90&%./".0# 0 $&!0<

!05&(9#/&!(%# 8!'1/!%#$ (",##7&$#(%# F!7&($#0 3.5!068,,!'$#1'#$",!"2&1&(8!'80-&(98&",,&5&(0#'1#%" '!/#!($1.0%,!'# 101#0"< 05 !(.!0< "&//",#$!"#

!%%&$#(" &# ,&' 8&"(#'' 8!'6 ,8#7#06 .(!;/# " 10$.%#!(<0#9&'"0!"&((.5;#00/&%#(%# 0$&(9",#;.'&(#''

101#0"<$#!/&(9!%%.(";-'@0#%0$ ",#101#0"<8&",8,&%, ",#<,!$$#!/"8&",0",#!5.("",#<5!<,!7##!0(#$",#0# 05 8!'1/!%#$(0#%0$"&'&(",#'#%&0%.5'"!(%#'",!"",#/#!0(#$ 0&;.(!/!''#''#$",#5(",/<&(%5# ",#$#%#!'#$!'?6 @A 8,&/#,#$9&(9&(",#%51(#(" .".0#10'1#%"'

* C#!0(#$%.('#/ 0",#!11#//!("&'.(!;/#"1&("."

!(<#7&$#(%#(0#%0$68,&%,5!<E.'"& <!(<!$$&"&(&(",#&(%5# '!''#''#$;<",#0&;.(!/ 8#7#06 -##1&(9 &( 7&#8 ",# E.$95#(" (=;/# +.10#5#.0"&(

*?+ >6&"&'!5./"&1/&#0 8,&%, ',./$ ;# !11/&#$ &( ",&' %!'# -##1&(9 &( 7&#8 ",# !9# ",# $#%#!'#$,#0&;.(!/,!'#00#$&(!11/<&(9",#5./"&1/&#0 * -##1&(9&(7&#8",#!9# ",#1!0#("'#$.%"&( *H,!';##( 0&9,"/<#

#%"#$-##1&(9&(7&#8",#$&%".5

&7&/>>6",#0# 0#6"!-&(9",#5(",/<&(%5# ",#$#%#!'#$ ";#?

@A&(%/.'&7# .".0#10'1#%"'6!$#$.%"&( *H&'" ;#!11/&#$6$#%#!'#$;#&(9! !%,#/0&# @A1#05(",!($ >6 @A1#0!((.5./"&1/&#0 &'!11/&#$C'' $#1#($!(%< &'6",.'6!''#''#$!"?6?

6?@A !0#("'!0#!/'#("&"/#$"/''

/7#!($!

#%"&(!"",#0!"# *6@A#!%, C#!0(#$%.('#/ 0",#!11#//!(",!'("10#''#$",# %/!&5I.!",#'&'"#0' ",#$#%#!'#$/!&5!("A1!0#("'!0#6",.'6 #("&"/#$"#(,!(%#$%51#('!"&(!'$#"!&/#$,#0#.($#0)A C'' $#1#($#(%< ?6?

6?@A C'' /7#!($!

#%"&(*6@A#!%,"",# 1!0#("'

66@A .(#0!/#D1#('#'

*6@A #$&%!/#D1#('#' 66? @A '1&"!/%,!09#'

*6@A $%& # # '

5.(" %51#('!"&( !/0#!$< !8!0$#$ " ",# !11#//!("' ',!// '"!($ $#$.%"#$ 05 ",# !5.(" %!/%./!"#$ !'

!;7#11#//!("A1!0#("'!0# .0",#0#("&"/#$"&("#0#'"!"",#0!"#

>*H 1#0 !((.5 ( ",# #("&0# %51#('!"&( &('"#!$ ?H 1#0 !((.5!'!8!0$#$;<",#0&;.(!/ 05",#$!"# &/&(9 ",# 1#"&"&("&//0#!/&J!"&( F&", ",# !;7#'!&$ 5$& &%!"&( &( ",# !5.("

%51#('!"&(610#'#("!11#!/&'$&'1'#$ ()%"(&& +#1"#5;#06 * *+,- 0"'