High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/85/2014allowed

Kulwinderpal Singh v. Rajan Singh & ORS

2019-04-12Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan8 pages

# $% !"" $ ! "#" $%&%'(

$"")*+,-./01-(% $()%-22%,,-'(

$"3'4)-,./01-(% $()%'&*$-'1%52-'6 &'' ()(*+,)- )% -7-$/ /-(%/ 8

9 2-&&%/ :6 ()% ($ 113/%'( ,-35& $3:*'-,. -(%)4-$) "-)3: ;

$ &)$(. ()% $3:*'-, < )-& :%%'

-&&-3,%/ :6 ()% )*&:-'/ "5( -'2$%%( =-*$ ;/%1%-&%/< &%%+3'4 %')-'1%5%'( 152%'&-(3'-7-$/%/*'/%$"%1(3' >> ()% ($ #%)31,%&1(. 8;

$&)$(. ()%1( < )% /$30%$. $%43&(%$%/ 7'%$ -'/ 3'&*$%$ ;3% '3(%/ '/3- '&*$-'1% 52-'6< 322%$?($*1+ :%-$3'4 $%43&($-(3' ?

? ? 9 ;)%$%3'- (%$ $% %$$%/ -&

%'/3'4 0%)31,% < )-0% :%%'

-$$-6%/-&$%&2'/%'(& (9$%&2%1(30%,63'()%-22%-,-$%'(&-'/

-()%$?3'?,-7 ()%/%1%-&%/)-0%:%%'-$$-6%/-&2$ $5-$%&2'/%'(& (> )% -1(*5 -113/%'(3&'(/3&2*(%/:6()%2-$(3%&5($ 0%)31*,-$-113/%'((+2,-1%'

)%-113/%'(2$0%/ -(-, $

-'2$%%(=-*$-4%/ 6%-$&)%-113/%'(7-&$%&*,( $-&)-'/'%4,34%'( /$303'4 ()%

%'/3'40%)31,%)%7'%$./$30%$-'/()%3'&*$%$

%'/3'4 0%)31,% 7%$% )%,/ @3'(,6 -'/ &%0%$-,,6 ,3-:,% ( 2-6 ()% 152%'&-(3' '()%1,-352%(3(3'.3(7-&2,%-/%/()-(()%/%1%-&%/7-& %-$'3'4

A? 2%$ /-6 :6 )%,23'4 )%$ )*&:-'/ 3' ()% :*&3'%&&

5-'* -1(*$3'4 &5-,,2-$(& &%73'45-1)3'%)%1,-35-'(& -3,%/( 2$0%()%11*2-(3'-'/%-$'3'4 ()%/%1%-&%/)%$3:*'-,-&&%&&%/()% 5'(),6%-$'3'4 ()%)*&:-'/ ()%/%1%-&%/-&.

A?-'/(+ A9$/ ()%&-3/-5*'(-&3'15% ()%/%1%-&%/ *,(32,3%$

7-& -22,3%/)%$3:*'-,-7-$/%/-&*5 .

A?)%-5*'(-7-$/%/ 3'1,*/%/

A? $,&& 1'&$(3*5. .

A? $ *'%$-,%B2%'&%&-'/ .

A? $,&& ,0%-'/-

%1(3' %-$/,%-$'%/1*'&%, $()%2-$(3%&-'/2%$*&%/()%$%1$/ !%-$'%/ 1*'&%, $ ()% -22%,,-'( -$4*%& ()-( ()% 3'15% -&&%&&%/:6()%$3:*'-,3&'()%,7%$&3/%-'/()%&-5%3&5*1),%&&()-' ()%53'35*57-4%&2$%0-,%'(3'()%"(-(%-(()%(35% -113/%'(3& 4$3%0-'1% 3& ()-( 5*,(32,3%$

)-& 7$'4,6 :%%' -22,3%/ :6 '( 1'&3/%$3'4()%-4% ()%/%1%-&%/ % *$()%$-$4*%&()-(()%-5*'(& -7-$/%/*'/%$()%1'0%'(3'-,)%-/&-$%'()%,7%$&3/% !%-$'%/1*'&%, $()%3'&*$%$-$4*%&()-(()%1,-35-'(& -3,%/ (2$0%()%11*2-(3'-'/%-$'3'4 ()%/%1%-&%/-'/()%3'15%)-& $34)(,6:%%'-&&%&&%/ )% 1,-35-'(& -3,%/ ( 2$0% ()% 11*2-(3' -'/ 5'(),6 %-$'3'4 ()%/%1%-&%/)%$%3&'&%$3*&/3&2*(%$-3&%/(()% -1(()-( &)%7-&-)*&%5-+%$'($3:*(3' -)*&%5-+%$3''/3-'&13%(6

9 1-''(:%*'/%$%&(35-(%/")%)-&5*,(3 -$3*&$,%&3'()% -53,6)% "*2$%5%*$(3') "/"0 1 #" #/ /2" " ,-

. 33 45)%,/-&*'/%$ C0%'-&&*53'4-60-'(3:%'3(%'/$-$30%/37-&'(&%,

%52,6%//3'4%5:$3/%$6-'/(-3,$3'47$+.()% -1( $%5-3'&()-(&)%7-&-)*&%73 %-'/-)5%5-+%$(3& )-$/(5'%(3D%()%/5%&(317$+/'%:6-)*&% 5()%$)%&%$031%& ()%5()%$A73 %3&-0-3,-:,% )*$& -'/ )%$ /*(3%& -$% '%0%$ 3B%/ *$(& )-0% $%14'3&%/()%1'($3:*(3'5-/%:6()%73 %(()%)*&% 3&*'0-,*-:,%-'/()-(3(1-''(:%152*(%/3'(%$5&

5'%6)*&%73 %A)5%?5-+%$/%&'(7$+:6()% 1,1+ -'/ &)% 3& 3'1'&(-'( -((%'/-'1% ()% -53,6 ()$*4)*( -'/ &*1) &%$031%& $%'/%$%/ :6 ()% )5% 5-+%$ )-& ( :% '%1%&&-$3,6 +%2( 3' 03%7 7)3,% 1-,1*,-(3'4()%,&& /%2%'/%'16E -03'4-1,*% $5()%53'35*57-4%&-(()%(35% -113/%'(.

'(3'-,5'(),63'15% ()%/%1%-&%/3&-&&%&&%/-& 9.F

A?&()% '(3'-,3'15%3&:%3'4-&&%&&%/.'/%/*1(3' $&%, ?%B2%'&%&3&(:% 5-/%)3&*$(3'6 /% !"" # 2!" !" 7!!" ,

4-.68$4 )%,/-&*'/%$ (%$()%/%13&3'3'!-(-G-/)7- &1-&%;&*2$-<. ()% '(3'-, 3'15% ()% )*&%73 % 3& %&(35-(%/ -11$/3'4 ( ()%3$ -4% )% '(3'-, 3'15% ()% )*&%73 %7-&(-+%'(:%&9.

A?2%$5'()3 &)% )-/:%%':%(7%%'()%-4%4$*2 9( 8-(()%(35%

-113/%'()%',6$3//,%7)31)3&(:%&,0%/:6*&3&-& (7)%()%$ A9$/ 1*(&)*,/:%-22,3%/'()%'(3'-, 3'15%$'(H)%-'&7%$(()3&I*%&(3'3&1*1)%/3' ()%- $%&-3/%B($-1(%/2-$-4$-2) ()%@*/45%'( !-(- G-/)7- & 1-&% ;&*2$-<. -& 3' ()-( 1-&%. ()% "*2$%5% *$(7-&&%-$1)3'4 $-5/%&('(3'-,3'15% )*&%73 %7)7-&'(%-$'3'4-'3'15%:*($%'/%$3'4 5*,(3 -$3*&&%$031%&7)3,%5-'-43'4-,,()%1)$%&

-53,6"3'1%3(3&-1-&%7)%$%()%*$(&-$%1' $'(%/ 73()()%'(3'-,3'15% ()%)*&%73 %'-11*'(

)%$5*,(3 -$3*&&%$031%&7)31)'(',63'1,*/%&$%-$3'4 ()% 1)3,/$%' :*( -,& 2%$ $53'4 -,, 5-($35'3-, :,34-(3'&.3'*$1'&3/%$%/03%7.()%/%/*1(3' A9$/ *( )%$'(3'-,3'15%3&'(7-$$-'(%/E )% $3:*'-, %$$%/ 3' -22,63'4 ()% 5*,(32,3%$ :6 '( 1'&3/%$3'4()%-4% ()%/%1%-&%/)%3&&*%$%4-$/3'4-22,31-(3'

5*,(32,3%$1'&3/%$3'4()%-4% ()%/%1%-&%/3&','4%$

)% "*2$%5%*$(3' 2 !"" # "9/ !"-. " ,-

.4 33 )-&)%,/-&*'/%$ C'()%:-&3& ()% 3'/3'4$%1$/%/:6()%$3:*'-,-'/ -

3$5%/ :6 ()% 34) *$(. 3( 3& %03/%'( ()-( ()% /%1%-&%/7-& 96%-$& -4%'()%/-(% -113/%'(3%

8%7-&*'5-$$3%/-'/)3&2-$%'(&7) 3,%/ ()%2%(3(3' $152%'&-(3'7%$%3'()%-4%4$*2

( 6%-$&)%34)*$(.$%,63'4'()%/%13&3' 3'()%1-&% &)03':)-3-6-'(3,-, /3;&*2$-<.)%,/

()-(5*,(32,3%$ 73,,:%-22,31-:,%3'()%2$%&%'(1-&%.

+%%23'43'53'/()%-4% ()%2-$%'(& ()%/%1%-&%/ )%,%4-,2&3(3'.)7%0%$.3&'5$% '

()%1-&% *''-!-,-3';&*2$-</%13/%/:6-()$%% */4% %'1) ()3& *$(.3( 3& )%,/ ()-( 5*,(32,3%$ &)*,//%2%'/'()%-4% ()%/%1%-&%/-'/'('()% -4% ()%/%2%'/-'(&E

)%"*2$%5%*$(3'3(&$%1%'(/%13&3'3'3# ::

;<=$9 /

* 3/98 # < >! + " ,

)-& $%3(%$-(%/()3& -1(-'/)%,/-&*'/%$ C8 )% 1*& $/%(%$53'-(3' &*1)1,-353&()% /%1%-&%/-'/7)-(7*,/:%)3&1'($3:*(3'(7-$/&()% /%2%'/%'(&7*,/)%(:%-,30%. $()%:%'% 3(& /%2%'/%'(&(3&($3(%(&-6.-'/3' -1(1'1%/%/:6()% ,%-$'%/1*'&%, $()%3'&*$-'1%152-'6.()-(3'1-&% ()%/%1%-&%/3&-5-$$3%/2%$&'.3(3&()%-4% /%1%-&%/7)31)3&(:%(-+%'3'(-11*'()%I*%&(3' 3&7)%()%$3'1-&%()%/%1%-&%/3&-:-1)%,$.-/3

%$%'( 2$3'132,% $ 1-,1*,-(3' ()% 5*,(32,3%$ &)*,/ :% -22,3%/:6&)3 (3'4()% 1*&(()%-4% ()%1,-35-'(&H G%-$% ()%03%7()-( ()%-'&7%$ ( ()3& I*%&(3' &)*,/:%3'()%'%4-(30%

G%5-6-,&'(%()%352$(-'1% -22,63'4*'3 $5 &%((,%/ 2$3'132,% ( &*1) 1-&%& %$(-3'(6 ,-7 3&

> 352$(-'( '1% ()% ,-7 3& &%((,%/. 3( &)*,/ '( :% $%2%-(%/,61)-'4%/-&()-(3(&%, 1-*&%&1'

*&3'-'/ ,3(34-(3'(3&73()()3&:@%1(3'()-(()3&*$()-& %'/%-0*$%/(&%((,%,%4-,2$3'132,%&3'$%&2%1( 5-((%$3'I*%&(3'

$%-/3'4 ()%@*/45%'(3'"*:%"3'4);&*2$-< &)7&()-(7)%$%-()$%%*/4%%'1))-&1-(%4$31-,,6 (-+%'()%03%7()-(3(3&()%-4% ()%/%1%-&%/-'/'( ()%-4% ()%2-$%'(&()-(7*,/:%()% -1($ $()% 2*$2&%& (-+3'4 ()% 5*,(32,3%$ ( :%-22,3%/ )3& @*/45%'(*'/*:(%/,6$%,3%/*2'()%1-&% *''-!-, -3';&*2$-<7)31)3&-,&-()$%%*/4%%'1)@*/45%'( 3'()3&:%)-, )%$%,%0-'(2$(3' ()%@*/45%'()-& -,&:%%'%B($-1(%/'1%-4-3'()%%B($-1(%/2$(3'3' (*$'$% %$&(()%@*/45%'( -()$%%*/4%%'1)3'

%&)5-=*5-$3J$&0 -/-' )-'J'$.;

9< 8"> )%$%,%0-'(2$(3' %&)5-=*5-$33'

(*$')-&$% %$$%/("-$,-#%$5-;&*2$-<1-&%-'/430%'

3(&352$35-(*$(()%&-5%)%,&& /%2%'/%'163& ()*&&(-(%/(:%:-&%/';3<-//3(3'&A/%/*1(3'&(:% 5-/% $-$$303'4-(()%3'15%K;33<()%/%/*1(3'&(:% 5-/% (7-$/& ()% 2%$&'-, ,303'4 %B2%'&%& ()% /%1%-&%/K -'/ ;333< ()% 5*,(32,3%$ ( :% -22,3%/ 73() $% %$%'1%(()%-4% ()%/%1%-&%/(3&()%()3$/-&2%1( 7)31) 3& &34'3 31-'1% -'/ %&)5- =*5-$3 1-(%4$31-,,6&(-(%&()-(3(/%&'(7-'(($%03&3(()%,-7

F &%((,%/3'"-$,-#%$5-1-&%3'()3&:%)-,

( ',6 ()3&. ()% &*:&%I*%'( @*/45%'( ()% '&(3(*(3':%'1)3'$-'-6"%()3;&*2$-<)-&-,&:%%' $% %$$%/(3'"*:%"3'4) $()%2*$2&% 1-,1*,-(3'

()%5*,(32,3%$

9G%-$%1'03'1%/()-(()%$%3&''%%/('1%-4-3' (-+%*2()3&3&&*%&%((,%/:6()%- $%&-3/@*/45%'(&

()$%%*/4%:%'1)-'/-,&$%,63'4*2'()%'&(3(*(3' %'1)()-(3(3&()%-4% ()%/%1%-&%/7)31))-&(:% (-+%'3'(-11*'(-'/'(()%-4% ()%/%2%'/%'(&E '()%2,%-/3'4&.3(7-&2,%-/%/()-(()%/%1%-&%/7-& >6%-$& -4%.3'()%2&(?5$(%5$%2$(.()%-4%)-&:%%'5%'(3'%/-& 6%-$& )%$%3&'()%$2$ '()%$%1$/(%&(-:,3&)()%-4% ()%/%1%-&%/ '&3/%$3'4()%-4% ()%)*&:-'/ -'/(-+3'43'(1'&3/%$-(3'()% 2,%-/3'4&.()%/%1%-&%/3&1'&3/%$%/3'()%-4%4$*2 >?9 6%-$&-'/ 5*,(32,3%$ F 3&(:%-22,3%/ ' 1'&'-'1% 73() ()% /%13&3' ()% "*2$%5% *$( 3'

* 3/98/#6 9 "" ,*$

5 3 5.()%1,-35-'(&-$%%'(3(,%/(

A?%-1) $ *'%$-, %B2%'&%&-'/ $,&& %&(-(%

A?3&-7-$/%/ $,&& 1'&$(3*5 (()%&2*&% '03%7 -:0%/3&1*&&3'.152%'&-(3'3&$%?1-,1*,-(%/-& *'/%$

'(),63'15% 9.F

*,(32,3%$

!&& 3'15% 9.F

FLF. .

*'%$-,%B2%'&%&

!&& %&(-(%

AA?

!&& 1'&$(3*5

(-,152%'&-(3'-7-$/%/ .

)%-7-$//-(%/8

93&5/3 3%/(()%%B(%'(()-(-5*'( .

A?-7-$/%/:6()%$3:*'-,3&%')-'1%/(. .

A? )%1,-35-'(&)-,,:%%'(3(,%/(()%%')-'1%/-5*'(-,'4 73()3'(%$%&(MF N2%$-''*5 $5()%/-(% 3,3'4 ()%1,-352%(3(3'

(3,,$%-,3D-(3' ()%-5*'( )%-22%-,3&-,,7%/ -&'' ()(*+.

)?+'

5+ G)%()%$&2%-+3'4A$%-&'%/

%&A G)%()%$$%2$(-:,%

%&A