High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9321/2017dismissed

Kuldeep Kumar And ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2017-09-06Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages

!"##$%&%'( )

*+,-##.*+/!0"1#0& #"%"%'#0& 3#0&+& 4"!"# +'5!6!'-"1#0& #&.'-#'"&

0#&#'"(2 0!7!/4%'819-:$!"#0"1#.#"%"%'#0& ;;;

#"%"%'#0&9<1!0#"10##%''+/6#09!0#!880%#:#-"1#%0 ''2&#,#$"%'!'-!..%'"/#'"""1#.&"+,"%.+0.&##!,"107#0

!,# +'&#,&+6/%"&"1!"!6! !0%- '%:#0&%"=#!,"14$%#'$#&9

!0%-7" %&&+#- !' !-:#0"%&#/#'">'"%$# -!"#- ? ) %':%"%'8 !..,%$!"%'& 0 %,,%'8 +. ) .&"& +,"%.+0.&# #!,"1 07#0

!,# %'"1##.!0"/#'"#!,"1 !/%,=#,!0#94"!"#

+0"1#0 &+6/%""#- "1!" "1# .#"%"%'#0& .&&#&& "1# 0#@+%&%"# #-+$!"%'!, @+!,%%$!"%'&!'-&+6/%""#-"1#%0!..,%$!"%'&<%"1%'"1#&"%.+,!"#-"%/# 0!/# +0"1#0+08#-"1!".#"%"%'#0&<#0##:#'.#0/%""#-".!0"%$%.!"#%'! 0#$0+%"/#'""#&" $'-+$"#- ' ) !'- %' "1# .0:%&%'!,0#&+,"

-#$,!0#- !" ''#A+0# 2B !,, "1# .#"%"%'#0& 1!:# &#$+0#- ?C /!07&

0#$%&# 80%#:!'$# %& "1!" !& .#0 /#0%" ,%&" $!'-%-!"#& &#,#$"#- 0 $+'&#,%'8!"''#A+0# 2)9$!'-%-!"#&1!:%'8&#$+0#-!'%'#0%0/#0%" .&%"%'!'-+."? /!07&91!:#6##'%'$,+-#-6+""1#'!/#&"1# .0#&#'".#"%"%'#0&-'"%'-!/#'"%'%'&+$1,%&"0$+'&#,%'81# !$"%'%&&"!"#-"6#!06%"0!0=!'-:%,!"%:#0"%$,#?"1#'&"%"+"%'

22 '-%! +'&#,0"1#.#"%"%'#0&1!&6##'1#!0-!",#'8"1

#0+&!,"1#'"%$#>!-:#0"%&#/#'"%&&+#-6="1#0#&.'-#'" +'%:#0&%"=-!"#-? ) ''#A+0#.2 <+,-0#:#!,"1!""1#0#<!&!

&.#$%%$$'-%"%'!&0#8!0-&"1#.0&.#$"%:#$!'-%-!"#&"6#0#&%-#'"& "1#4"!"# +'5!6 1#0#,#:!'"$'-%"%'<!&$%'#-%'"1#,,<%'8 "#0/&(2 D

"%&"1#.,#!-#-$!&#"1#.#"%"%'#0&"1#/&#,:#&"1!""1#=!0# 0#&%-#'"&"1#4"!"#!0=!'!+'&#,<+,-!""#/.""-0!</%,#!8# 0/ ! $#0"%%$!"# .,!$#- ' 0#$0- !" ''#A+0# 2 %&&+#- 6= "1# #.!0"/#'"#!,"14#0:%$#&!'- !/%,=#,!0#94"!"# +'5!6!'- <1%$1 <+,- $#0"%= "1!" .#"%"%'#0 ' 1!- &+$$#&&+,,= $/.,#"#- ! "0!%'%'8 $+0&# !" +'5!6 '&"%"+"# !0!/#-%$!, 4$%#'$#&9 +7"&!0

+'5!6 4+$1 $#0"%%$!"# %& ',= %'-%$!"%:# "1# .#"%"%'#0 1!:%'8 $/.,#"#-!"0!%'%'8$+0&#$'-+$"#-%'!'%'&"%"+"#&%"+!"#-%'"1#4"!"#

+'5!61%&/!=1,-"0+##:#'0"1#"1#0"<.#"%"%'#0&#"1!"!&%" /!=9!$#0"%%$!"#%'"1#'!"+0#''#A+0# 2<+,-'"&!"%&="1# /!'-!"#"1##,%8%6%,%"=$'-%"%'$'"!%'#-%'"1#!-:#0"%&#/#'""1# .0&.#$"%:#$!'-%-!"#&>!..,%$!'"&"6#0#&%-#'"&"1#4"!"# '"#'"%'0!%&#-6=$+'&#,"1!""1#.#"%"%'#0&1!:%'86##' .#0/%""#- " .!0"%$%.!"# %' ! 0#$0+%"/#'" .0$#&& !'- 1!:%'8 &#$+0#- &+%$%#'",=1%81/#0%".&%"%'<+,-:#&"%'"1#/!0%81"!..%'"/#'"9%& /%&$'$#%:#- !0"%$%.!"%'"1#.#"%"%'#0&>$!'-%-!"#&%'!0#$0+%"/#'"

22 "#&"<!&&+65#$""+0'%&1%'80#@+%&%"#-$+/#'"&%'&+..0""1#:!0%+& #,%8%6%,%"= $'-%"%'& &"%.+,!"#- %' "1# !-:#0"%&#/#'" !" "1# "%/# $+'&#,%'8'"1#0<0-&.!0"%$%.!"%'%'"1#0#$0+%"/#'""#&"<!&/#0#,= .0:%&%'!, '$#-#-,=9"1#.#"%"%'#0&!0#0#&%-#'"&!0=!'!!'--'" +,%,,"1##&&#'"%!,#,%8%6%,%"=$'-%"%'&6#%'80#&%-#'"&"1#4"!"#

"/!=6#'"%$#-"1!"#:#'"1+819!.0!=#01!&6##'/!-#%' "1# %'&"!'" .#"%"%' " &"0%7# -<' "1# '"%$#>!-:#0"%&#/#'" -!"#- ? ) ''#A+0# 2 %'&!0!&%/.&%'8!$'-%"%'6#%'8 0#&%-#'"&4"!"# +'5!69=#"9&+$1$1!,,#'8#<!&'#:#00!%&#-6="1# .#"%"%'#0&!""1#"10#&1,-"%$#<!&%&&+#-%'#$#/6#09 )!'-"1# 0#$0+%"/#'".0$#&&%&'<!""1#%'!,&"!8#&+'&#,1%/&#,$'$#-#& "1!"#:#'"1#.0$#&&$+'&#,%'8%&+'-#0<!= :#'"1#0<%&#9!.!0" 0/0!%&%'8!.0!=#0&##7%'8"1#&#""%'8!&%-#"1##'-%'8$,!+&#%'"1# '"%$#>!-:#0"%&#/#'" -!"#-? ) ''#A+0# 2 '!08+/#'"&%'

&+..0"&+$1.0!=#0<#0#!-:!'$#- ':%#<"1#!6:#9"1#%'&"!'"<0%".#"%"%' /#0%"&!'- %&9!$$0-%'8,=9-%&/%&&#-

,+$7= 1#"1#0&.#!7%'8>0#!&'#-( #&> 1#"1#0 #.0"!6,#( #&>