High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7037/2015dismissed

Oriental Insurance Company Ltd v. Gurmail Singh And ORS

2019-07-25Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

!"#$%& &&&"" '

( !)*%

&&&+ " %

( !)*%

&&&""

,-%)*%

&&&+ " %

"#$ %

&'% ( ( % , .

&!/ 01%- 2 ""3

!"# %2 " %4 &3

!"# &

&,5671%- 2 "" %2 " % 4 &

&8 5)*1%-

2 " %4 &9 % 2 " %4 & &

&/# 51%- 2

&+ , 61%- 2 " %4 & % 2 " %4 & & ::::

( %) ;# %1 % "

20 && 2% 82 2""

!"#%

2% 82 2"" 3( !)*% 0 - 2 !

%& ;2# %2 2

2)% 7 <%7 !*% % %

%10 5" =& & 2 2)" 5* #1/%1

%#% %**%-* 2;

58*

4 &> %*4 &($>9 22% 22%*- 8#,-%)*3 " %4 & 1 " ?

&&( !)*1*%8 # 3

8%1

( %")*<(""

1*%8 # 3! %

&( "7 1*%8 =# 3% * 2 %)% 7 <%7 %8 * !" %) 2 ' 1 = 22% * " % &&,-%)*3%-1) 5%-)*3 0%

!"# $%&

2 22%* - 1

!* !" 2+ &

*0 & 4 2 !" 0 *- " % 0 "

"" % 22% &

! 02!%& " 022 %% %@ "" %-% & 2*%

2 " 1%

% !

8 1 ;% -% 0% %% &&

0% ! " "# % *% !" 2 + 1=1? *0 <& A" !2 !% 2 2* 2" B @

"#88# " %4 &3

!"#& "" ?" ?

8* 2-0 !" 0%%0 0 %1-"" % 8#0# 22*"" 5* ! 2 !" & %1 " %4 &3

!"# 2*!

2 !" 0%% * %

2%""& 4 2"" 0

% " % 10 "

"" *

& -%%

2 " 8 % * * * %& 8 %*2 %

* 2-% %%

%8#" % %%

4 & 2- 2 % * " % %* " %4 & 0 2

%8# %**

9 %-* 2 22%*- &)

2%* " "%"" " %% 2 #2 & 4C !*

4 &18 %5* 2 % % # 1

%! # ! + &91 ?8*

5% 0 5 !" #% 0 )" 5* #1 D%1 ;%& E 0-1 %% 0% 2 " " 0 !%& -0 2 2 #

## $"

- #9A 2!

8%%% 0% 2 " " &> *! # ! 2% % 5 + &91 F G+ &1?& 4 % 810 !% 8 2!#8#% *

% %* 5*1 * 10 *

%!**

%22 % %22

@ 2#

- %% 8#

% %# 2!#1 0-1 8!

85*%& &'

()

!"## $"*+1"C

%- % 8 2

%02+ &1?" ! &0

%10 5" ==&6 %*! "

% 8# % ; % , -

/ !"#!

/1 !2

020 5 8+ 1?% %% 0 !% 0% 2 " " & 9 2 9-*,0

% %% 9&& 8# %; 2 1 ! 2

020

% 8+ 1?"! & 2 9 -*)

#2 3

% %% & & 8# %; 2 1 ! 2

020

% 8+ &1?"! & 85 -0% %0 % *

%0 5 % !!

*%% 8%%% 0% ! # ! %* - 2!#

% &

! 2+ &1? %%% ! # ! 2% %& > * ! # ! 2% % !

+ &1FG=1?& 8 *#%%

% ?% 2 !

0% 2C" !

2 #

4 5 1

% +"

## $" > *%"% # 2 ! + &1?"! 1 %"% # ! + &C G + &919?& 8

" 2 10 5"* -0* 2% % 8" "#

%&> *

!" "#8 ! + &919C G 1=19?& 8 2 0%% !" 2+ & 1? 0% 2 C" %+ & 1? 0% -%22 & E 0-1-0 2 2 #

"1 % * !" % - % &&+ 1?

2 1+ &91? 0%

2 !%+ 1? 2 C" 1 + &1?& !" ! + & 1=19F1G 119?& 8 0%% !" 2+ 1=1?& 0#1 %!

! + &1919?

119 1=1& 0 %8% * < & A" !2 !% 22* 2"" B %!

2+ &1919?"#88# " %4 &3

!"#& H

! %2 1 2% 82 2 0%"#0

* %

!"#

%* ! " %4 & 0 "

*-%% 22 -%-* ! 2

%12

!"# 8 "## !" !

&E 0-1

" 8%*8#8 "4 & 10 2 %#2 " %

% %.

!"#$% !!

% !!

& ' !(!

!) *+,,

-,** ! ) #!

!) ././0 !!%

! !% ( % !!

& ) !

! !

% !!

& * ! ! %!1 !

% !!

& ! ! ! % 1 "#2 % !!

3 ! !

& ***,4 ! "!

! & 5.-6+4,78

! ) ) ) 8*,*

+*,-! !

% !9+,*(

% !!

& )! !!

) !

! !% 1 !

( % !!

* ! ! %!1 !

%! !

% !!

& ! (

%! ! % !!

& *! ! %!1

% 1!

! ! % !!

! 1%

2 2% # , .

4'6

!"## $"

0 8%0 %- %* %-I*! - I1 !" %-I " - I 2 * #0 " 2 % ! %- " - & @ #1

2% 82 2

!"# % % !

%& && = * ( %+ ;6 ,--../0123

0 ,--..1.45 0