High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1736/2011dismissed

Inderwati v. Ranbir And ORS

2019-02-22Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan6 pages

##$$ %!& '!(!

# )!

($*+, !(##$$

-&$,!.!"$+, !(!#

//// 0!$1+(!(#$ !" "" (!#$+ ! ,$$23+4($ ! 5(66!('!&2(&!#!6&2 !&+(!+'!06!+$$!(,!1,$$2 (,!(("!#!$(&(" 7897'$&$&!(#$("((#$& "(,$$23+4($!5(66!:(( #!""+"((&&((&((!(&': (("!(!(&+(!#!,("*& #2#7087("!$&!( #$+"(("!&#$:(&( ("*&#2"$'1!(#$

1!!$!:(2(&#$( #"!(#2:("!&$((& #$ $ # "! ( + (",! " !(&#&(#!,("*&!+"(((1( !2(:((1$"$(2("!&$( (& ( #$ $2 ( !;& #$ '1 ( !(&#(#!,("*&#&#2 !$(!"!&$(#$+$222!,( '!&2((&!#!6&2(

+##!$"! 2(&2((#$($"!2#$ ((";&!!$$1:("!$# $,2#!:((#$"!(&#($ '1"1$2(&(8&!:(($# 7087'1(#$(#$"&$$1"# '1(!((!!(!(1"!&2 ((!##:((#$"#(! "! ( $$2$$1+ "(( ( ( !2( &2 ( !2$$2(#$+(#!1!$ (&

#$"$ (#$2(#!+ $$"2&"!!,!! <

=((!(#$"!#(#&(& $#!. (#$(""($!89> "('$&$&!(#$((!"(? ))

=((!(!@#!,("*&!( #$((""($!08!$&! (#$7#$"(("'2&&('1( #$(? ))

=((!(!$$2$$1!(2&#(#& !$$2$$1$2(2("!&$( #$#2"!(#&? ))

< =((!(#$(&$(#!&?

)

!!#!,(!+(#$2(! !!)='@2-!()=

((!(+((@( 6)$ !+,=+!&#2(= + (=+ ( (!2(=<( ,!=A

," ( 2 &+ ( !$ 8&! #!$1 !(&(('((#!(&"!! $(!("*$(2 "!&$((!1!

4(",6&2 !

>$2 22!, '1 ( 6&2 !+ ( ($##$(8&!!5&2+"((" 2$!5&2+5(66!+"(,6&2 ! B

#(##$+(6&2 !#'1(!$8&!(&(#$

< .""(&!(#$$"( (6&2!#'1$!5&2+5(66! ((**(!(8&!'1"1$2!2&$! ##$#!12(('#+(#&26&2 !#'1$!5&2+5(66!'

22 !2&$! ##$+ ( !#C(,##!'!(8&!(!&2(&$

(,(!$!&$!(#!'22 (!&2((!! ((!'$&$1!( ##$

)!6&$"('1B(# $+ !!1;&'$!$+"(('2! '1(8&!*#2,"(!&( $&2(&(#!#!$(!$ !!2( >!$12'!2!#!6&+ #!##!(2(8&!&"($($2$$ (!$(!(!$1!$! (8&!+(&(!$'2! 8$& < (#$#!,(6&'2!"( (&(#$!(2('&($( ((8&!

D!(+(#$(##!((8&! &'2((2"!&$(!(&#"!( #& 3$8!("##+"(( ,(#&'(!#!'!,2(!(((

A 2(#

<'&

!2,2 &$!(#!!!&##!#! (!&$#!#!2!&2(#$'!,2(((& #$"(!+"(("$!&:((!$1 !&"$$(,2(2('!&2(#2 4(!#!&$$(#$(2 "!&$(!(&('(!"!(;& $2 4(!$8&!!("($#2( !!,!1!21#!(' #+("1+'((#!('!$( !("*$(2"!&$ ((!

4(!$8&!(&$(,"((!(#$( ''$*&!2!#!6&! 2!2!$(!("&&$#!,2(!(!" 2(&'&&2!'((#!&("1 &'$!"($"!#!&$!$1"( (&#"(1&!$ 4(!#'1 (!$8&!"$2$(,'#"(&& ##$ 4(>!##$$8&!(#!#!$1#(##$ (6&2!#'1(!$8&!'!,2 ((!!,($(#$(1!2(+ $!(&#!#!1!#22&!2( #1(&&$6& (&!(!

''!,(,(!"(#$$2(

!!1 !$ 6& '& ( ( * & ( 2 "!(#&#!#!1&!2(#1(#!&+ &(($!$&!(!&(! (!,&!'!2(&

4(!!+ 1!(#!##$ 1 ! &!'( $2$+,$ "$$ ! 6&2#'1($!5&2+5(66!

4(##$!2$1

0!6

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#