← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9381/2017dismissed

J.D. Sandhu v. The Central Administative Tribunal Chd

2025-09-04Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri5 pages



        

!

!"

# $ %& $!

'(  

       

  



  

   !

    ! "# # $ %&'$!

'(  

       

  



  

   !

    ! "#  )   *+)  , ,) ,,  *+)  ,-.,,



$%

 &' #()*+*, #, -'"

 *('*# .*, #()* -"# *# /////  ,) ,,  /0 +1   0

.'#1""#"-'*2(%3# 11"*'(,(#''*3*#-'*& -)()'-*)*2+*&-34 %56%07 

 ' " " ')'*,,+  '##*# 8009  "*#  2.  '  *,  #3*(  2*,  '*#+*'

)''*#+*':'*--#*;2*,<=*###*# 7007"*#(1"2.1')''!+*, "",)*'*

:= 2#"#-1'*#)'*"-"2-?#(1 -'-3*2,*?#),*#*#600*#'*# "2,'*8@-333-'(#"*.%)*,", +*#"*.*#'"2"*#**-"#'3  *#),*""*+2'*,--'"23 '*'"'*2+*#'"*.%)*,- )3*?!--) :-';

!<=1')'"*.%)*,1*3*#*"",)*2,-3009 1')'1,#*,,1--?*-'"*.*,+1''"'*# (#"*.%)*, )'"#*,*2,2#)#+* '2--*#"*.%)*,'"2.+*#'3"+# #"*#2.'2*, A *#  ),  *""*+    2'*,-  -  '  "# 23'*'"1*()*0091')'),# *,,1--?*-'*,*.*#"'(#"*.%)*,1'* '"2-?#2.*&+)#*'-3*2, *?#),*#*#600*#+#*)- .-B*) 8 4'*('*#,*#),-'"**#'*(+ '+'')*1''*2,**) 9

3*.2)#'*'"'*##-3() **+'*+-"**088'*2+'),# '*(2+*#'2--(#"*.%)*,1')''*2 +*#'3",.1&+"- !1-009' "-3 1')''  " #     * ))## -*) '* ' "1*()*-009')',.),*3 1')'),#'*(2*#2.'"--?+'"

:= *))#*)'(-'"*.%)*,1'--)-3009 '*'*3,'*8@-'333-'"*.%)*,", +*#"*.'(#"*.%)*,-'"- !**"",)*2,-3 009&"+(1+#,- .-B*)'*3 -#+'*2+(2.'2*,'*'*3'*2)3",#1' *#'"-'"2-?#*))#*)1''-)* #2.' (3- #*C*3",3*-(#"*.%)*, 1-009--?+'"*.'"*')*3*.2*# '"'*23'*'8@-'333-'"*.%)*, ",+*#"*.*")2#-'"- !*"(#"*.%)*, 1'--)-3009 7

'+'*22+'')-''1* '1'"<"(#"*.%)*,- !1')'2 (#-3009'*2-?#*"'*#*,*#.# 088 6 D"+    (1  '  *2(  #)  *  +(    ' "#,&*1'''"-'"1*% -?#1-009&"+(1'(#"*.%)*,+(' "-31')''"'*##088 )*' *#2-'*2+('*32?##'"*,+ 1'**-%-?+'"'(#"*.%)*,-'"-3 1')''"#**"",)*2,-30091'*"# -+'1&-3'#*-)"-)".-'# 5 E*  '  ' 1 " :4 %560%07=  1' ' ##)'*,,+##*#0009"*#2.'2*,2.

:A= 1')''*#!+*, "",)*1*#3#'+#'*' *3  )*  -  *)  *  *,  !+*,  "",)*  2*+

9F80F09  '*#  *,*#.  2  #3#    009    ' +#-#,*.*#,*)'1')'! 1*1'#*12.'" -,*(1*"",)*'*#! 1')'(1*"",)*1* #3#07)".-1')''*2*?#"*+ - '"*"2&*,+1''*-3#1" 50

3*.2)#'*'##*#0091')'1* #3#'+#-#,*.*#,*)''*(2)'*,,+#2. '  "  '+'  '  #  #*#  07  "*#    (1 *"",)*    2+  )'*,,+#  *  '  '*#  -  "   !)  ' "##**.+(*)1'+*#'"31', 2+()'*3),#'*(2*#*-.*-' 3  ")*,,.  1'  #,*.    *+  )'  +(*)  *-  )' #*#,*.1*?",*# 5 *#),-'"'*2*2,'1* '1'1"1*3***2,*-)'*#,*.*-3 -3()*#'*1',&+'()2-1')'*,. *#32,#+'()"# )+#3*#-*.

-)  *  '*#  -  '    ")*,,.  1'  '  #  #*# 0092.1')''!+*, "",)*1**,,.#3#' +#-#,*.*#,*)''*(2)'*,,+#'"1 " 0

'*+3'*2*# 00

'*2)-*."(.2+"#'#

:8= #*#808"*#2.'2*,+#3*#--) 2.''1"**))#+,.#3# 0

')".-'#2",*)#'-,-))#)* 0 ,) ,,1   0-.,,

1 ,2345

/!

!"

   4''"*&+F*# G 4''"*2,