← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7076/2015disposed of

Amar Pal And ORS v. Vijay Kumar And ORS

2018-11-20Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill5 pages

      



!" #"$%&%'( 



) * + , '#!-"+& ..",, '!& /"+&0& /%1 230* + '#!-"+& "&.'#"'!&  

 

+"&"'!( +&- '4%'5-'"+6#7$ !" + + 4'"+6#7$ !" +!-" ..",, '!& +&  #-0 4- +* 6 #7$ !" + +"&.'#"'! 89'&0+ '$" *. '2



 

8:

 " +# + !-" +" &'& *"'!%'"# %' !-" ..,%$ !%' '# !-" +50*"'!& ##+"&&"#6#", 2 8;# 2&%' !-" .." ,%&$'#'"# ..,%$ !%'%& ,,<"#

 -%& .." ,- &=""' %,"#=2!-"$, %* '!&&"">%'5"'- '$"*"'!  !-" $*."'& !%' < +#"# ! !-"* =2 !-" ," +'"# !+ $$%#"'! , %*& +%=0' ,6 !% , ?+%=0' ,@ +&-+!7%#" < +## !"# A A

' $$0'! #" !- -%'#"+ , ,% &-%'#"+4%'5-%' *!+7"-%$," $$%#"'!'

) ;

A -"$, %* '!&6<- +"<% " '#$-%,#+"' !-"#"$" &"#6 %,"#  ."!%!%'0'#"+4"$!%'

!-"!+/"-%$,"&$!&"">%'5$*."'& !%'' $$0'! #" !- -%'#"+ , ,% &-%'#"+4%'5-#0"!%'10+%"&+"$"%7"# %' *!+7"-%$," $$%#"'!<-%$-!>., $"' ) ;

A 8# !"#

; ;

A < & +"5%&!"+"# 0'#"+ 4"$!%'& ;68 A:688) '# A   ! ,%$"4! !%' !+ '6 %&!+%$! !% ,  5 %'&!+"&.'#"'! !< &.," #"#

 !- !!-"#"$" &"# !!-"!%*" -%&#" !-< &<+>%'5 &  &' '##0+%'5 !-"- +7"&!%'5."+%#6-"0&"#!<+> & $'!+ $!+%'5+ %'* +>"!6 !+ ' "< &$, %*"#!="8)2" +&,# !!-"!%*"  $$%#"'!6" +'%'5& 6 9: ."+*'!-*."'& !%'< &!-0&.+ 2"# + B" +'"# +%=0' , ' $'&%#"+ !%'   !-" $!& '# "7%#"'$" ' +"$+# -",# !- ! !-" $$%#"'! %' C0"&!%' !> ., $" #0" ! !-" + &- '# '"5,%5"'! #+%7%'5   !-" 

"'#%'5 7"-%$," =2 %!& #+%7"+ -"+" %& ' #%&.0!" +"5 +#%'5!-" =7"& %# %'#%'5 !-"," +'"#+%=0' ,'!-%&%&&0"6<-%$-- & !! %'"# %' ,%!2 B" +'"# +%=0' , 0+!-"+ $'$,0#"# !-" #"$" &"# ! =" 8) 2" +& ,# !!-"!%*" -%&#" !- '# &&"&&"#-%&%'$*" &&A 9:."+*'!- $'&%#"+%'5 -%* ! =" ' 0'&>%,,"# , =0+"+ "#0$!%'  98+# < & "

"$!"# !< +#& ."+&' , "D."'&"& 0,!%.,%"+   < & ..,%"# >"".%'5 %' 7%"< !-" 5" !-"#"$" &"#-0&6!! , #"."'#"'$2 < & &&"&&"# !&6A 6 9: 8 6 D   &0*   & 6 6 9: < & < +#"# ! $, %* '!   !< +#& ,&&   $'&+!%0* ="&%#"& & 6 9: " $- ! $, %* '!&   ! A !< +#& ,&&   ,7" '#

"$!%' '!-"+ &0*   & 6 9: < & < +#"# !< +#& , &!+%!""D."'&"&-0&6!-"$, %* '!&<"+"-",#"'!%!,"#!!! ,$*."'& !%' &

6) 6 9: ,'5<%!-%'!"+"&!EF."+ ''0* +*!-"# !" $, %*."!%!%'!%,,+" ,%& !%' B" +'"#$0'&", +!-" ..",, '!& +50"&!- !!-"," +'"#+%=0' , - & "++"# %' &&"&&%'5 %'$*"   !-" #"$" &"# & &A 9: ."+ *'!- <-"+" &6 "7"' !-" *%'%*0* < 5"   ' 0'&>%,,"# , =0+"+ %' !-" 4! !"  0'1 = ! !-" !%*"   $$%#"'! < & =0! &

A9:+"7"+6 ' %'$+"*"'! - &=""'

+#"#' $$0'! 0!0+".+&."$!&<"7"+6," +'"#$0'&", + !-" ..",, '!&&0=*%!&!- !$*."'& !%' < +#"#0'#"+$'7"'!%' , -" #& * 2="+"<+>"#%'!"+*& !-"10#5*"'!& '@=,"!-"40.+"*"0+!%'

8  !%' ,'&0+ '$"*. '2B!#/&+ ' 24"!-% '#!-"+&6

A %7%, ; '# 5* "'"+ ,'&0+ '$"*. '2B!#/& '0 * ,% & -0-+0  * '# !-"+&6 %' %7%, .." , ;)  

) #"$%#"# '

) ;

) ! %& 0+!-"+ $'!"'#"# !- ! #"#0$!%'  98+# - & <+'5,2 =""' ..,%"# & '0*="+   #"."'#"'!& +" 0+ " 5+" $*."'& !%' - & =""'

+#"#!!-"$, %* '!&' $$0'! 0'"+ ,"D."'&"& '#'!-%'5- &=""' < +#"#!< +#&,&& "&! !" !%&!-0&.+ 2"#!- !!-%& .." , =" ,,<"# '#$*."'& !%' < +#"#=""'- '$"# B" +'"# $0'&", + +"&.'#"'! 89'&0+ '$" *. '2 - & +"

0!"# !-" =7" & %# +50*"'!& <-%," &0=*%!!%'5 !- ! !-" %*.05'"# < +# - &=""'. &&"#$++"$!,2 '#'5+0'# + '2"'- '$"*"'!%&* #"0! - 7"-" +#," +'"#$0'&", +!-". +!%"& '#- 7"5'"!-+05- !-"+"$+#<%!-!-"%+ =," &&%&! '$" !%&'!%'#%&.0!"!- !-%'#"+ , ,% &-%'#"+4%'5-,&!-%& ,% " #0" ! %'10+%"& +"$"%7"# %'  *!+ 7"-%$," $$%#"'! <-%$- !> ., $" '

) ;

A #0" ! !-" + &- '# '"5,%5"'! #+%7%'5   !-" 

"'#%'5 7"-%$," =2 +"&.'#"'! -"#"$" &"#< &8)2" +&,# !!- !!%*"B" +'"#+%=0' , - & %'#""# "++"# %' &&"&&%'5 !-" %'$*"   !-" #"$" &"# & &A 9: ."+ *'!- &"7"'*%'%*0*< 5"  '0'&>%,,"#, =0+"+%'!-"4! !" 0'1 = ! !-"!%*"  $$%#"'!< & =0!&

A9:!< &.," #"#!- !!-"#"$" &"#< & * &'=2.+ "&&%'" +'%'5& 6 9:."+*'!-=0!!-"+"%&'"7%#"'$" '+"$+#!.+7"!-"& *"<"7"+6-%&%'$*"$ ''!="$'&%#"+"#!=" ,"&&!- '!- ! "7"' '0'&>%,,"#, =0+"+%'!-"4! !" 0'1 = !!-"!%*" !-" $$%#"'!%"' ) ;

A'!-" $!& '#$%+$0*&! '$"& !-"$ &"6%!%& $'&%#"+"# 10&! '# "D."#%"'! ! &&"&& !-" %'$*"   !-" #"$" &"# ! =" &

 9:."+*'!-'7%"< !-"10#5*"'! '@=,"!-"40.+"*"0+!%'

A !-"$ &" + ' 24"!-% '#!-"+&&0.+ 6A F%'$+" &"%'%'$*"- &!="

+#"#' $$0'! 0!0+".+&."$!& "+0& , !-"+"$+#+"7" ,&!- !'0*="+ #"."'#"'!&6%"<% " '#!-+""$-%,#+"'6 +" 0+-"+"

+"6#"#0$!%' 9A!-%'&!" # 98+#- &! =" ..,%"#0,!%.,%"+ - &+%5-!,2=""' ..,%"#>"".%'5%'7%"<!-" 5" !-" #"$" &"# ' 7%"<   !-" 10#5*"'!   '@=," !-" 40.+"*" 0+! %' !-" $ &"    5*  "'"+ , '&0+ '$" *. '2 B!# &0.+ 6 ..",, '!   %& "'!%!,"#!&A 6 9:%'&!" # & 6 6 9:!< +#&&.0& ,$'&+!%0* '# ..",, '!&   ! A +" "'!%!,"# ! &A 6 9: " $- ' $$0'!   . +"'! , $'&+!%0*%'&!" # & 6 9: < +#"# +,&& ,7" '#

"$!%'-" ..",, '!& +" "'!%!,"# ! & 6 9: " $- + ,&&   "&! !" '# 0'"+ , "D."'&"&%'&!" # & 6 9: < +#"#!< +#&, &!+%!"& ..",, '!&:$, %* '!& +"6!-0&6"'!%!,"#!$*."'& !%'6<-%$-%& +":<+>"# &0'#"+(:  

   

 '$*"

 .* %"6;6) 9:."+ ''0*

 ! , %'$*" !"+ ##%!%' ! !-" + !"   A F ' $$0'!  0!0+" .+&."$!& ;6) G8 6;

;6) DA F H

6 9: 8 '$*" !"+ #"#0$!%'  9A!- ' $$0'! ."+&' ,"D."'&"&

6 I 6;8 

6 9A H)86; 9: A ! , #"."'#"'$2 !"+ ..,2%'5  *0,!%.,%"+  )86;  H

6 6) 9:  B&& "&! !"

6 9:

 0'"+ ,"D."'&"&

6 9:  B&& $'&+!%0*! ..",, '!&  !AEA 6 

6 9: A 6 DAH 6 9:  

A6A 6) 9:

 -" *0'!   $*."'& !%' ,+" #2 < +#"# ! !-" ..",, '!&6 '""#,"&& ! & 26 &- ,, &! '# #"#0$!"# +* !-" *0'! $ ,$0, !"# & =7" ..+!%'*"'! '##%&=0+&"*"'! !-"$*."'& !%'&- ,,=" &."+#%+"$!%'& !-"," +'"#+%=0' ,%' < +## !"# A A

..",, '!&&- ,,=""'!%!,"# !%'!"+"&! !!-"+ !" F."+ ''0*'!-""'!%+" *0'! +*!-"# !"

!-"."!%!%'!%,,+" ,%J !%' K%!- !-" =7"& %# *#% %$ !%' %' !-" < +# # !"# A A

6 .+"&"'! .." ,%&#%&.&"#  



  





) &-< + K-"!-"+&." >%'59+" &'"#(:"&9 K-"!-"++".+! =,"(:"&9