← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7083/2015disposed of

Anita And ORS v. Sohan And ORS

2018-11-22Mr. Justice Satpal7 pages

      

 !"# $#%&'&()

  *+"(&"!!($",#-' ..#//!("' 0#-'1' *,!(!($",#-' #'.($#("'  

 

-#'#(") -*2!(!3$4%!"# -",#!..#//!("' #'.($#(" #5.!-"#4&$#-$#-$!"#$   6 - 1."!3$4%!"# --#'.($#(" 7('1-!(%# +.!(8



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

!-4&($#-<!' //<&(;",#+"-%8%/# &=#($#-#'.($#("3$-&4#- ",#

#($&(;"-1%:C6@C  3.!-:#$",#'!+#(",#-!$<&",1"

 !(8&($&%!"-3-# /#%"--'&;(!/D,#( &=#($#-!($ !-4&($#--#!%,#$(#!- ",# <!"#-<-:'   0&//!;# D!E&-.1-3 #,'&/ #-&3 &'"-&%" ,!==!-3 &=#($#- %1/$ (" '## ",# 

#($&(; "-1%: $1# " ",# '"-(; /&;,"'   ",# (%+&(; 4#,&%/#' ('#F1#("/83 ,&' +"-%8%/# '"-1%: !;!&('" ",# "-1%:3 <,&%, <!' .!-:#$(",#-!$<&",1"!(8&($&%!"---# /#%"- &=#($#- #//$<(!($ 9#%!+# 1(%('%&1' &=#($#- <!' 9-1;," " 4#-(+#(" '.&"!/3 #-&3 <,#-#,#<!'$#%/!-#$$#!$

$!"#$  <!'-#;&'"#-#$ 1($#-*#%"&(' AC!($

 !" /&%#*"!"&( #-&!;!&('"-#'.($#(" (",#'"!"#+#(" !-4&($#-"<!'./#!$#$",!"",#$#%#!'#$!"",# "&+# ,&'$#!",<!'!(!;-&%1/"1-&'"#!-(&(;'A 3 7C.#-+(",#<!' 8#!-'/$!"",#"&+# !%%&$#("+.#('!"&(<!'3",1'3.-!8#$ - G#!-(#$-&91(!/%(%/1$#$",#$#%#!'#$"9#A 8#!-'/$!" ",# "&+#   ,&' $#!", !($ !''#''#$ ,&' &(%+# !' ' 3 7C .#- +(", #$1%"&( 7A",<!'#

#%"#$"<!-$'.#-'(!/#5.#('#'1/"&./&#- A <!' !../&#$ ,1'3 ""!/ $#.#($#(%8 <!' !''#''#$ !" '3 3 7C @ 5 5A  '1+   ' 3 7C <!' !<!-$#$ "<!-$' 1(#-!/ !($ "-!('.-"#5.#('#'(",#-'1+ ' 3 7C<!'!<!-$#$"<!-$'/'' /4#!($!

#%"&(9#'&$#'' 3 7C"<!-$'/'' %('-"&1+"!/ %+.#('!"&( '63 3 7C<!'!''#''#$G#!-(#$-&91(!/%(%/1$#$ ",!" ",# !%%&$#(" &( F1#'"&( <!' %!1'#$ $1# " ",# -!', !($ (#;/&;#(" $-&4&(; ",#$-&4#- ",#

#($&(;"-1%:!'<#//!'(#;/&;#(%#(",#.!-"

&=#($#- ,&+'#/  " <!' ,#/$ ",!" ",# .-#'#(" &' ! %!'#   %("-&91"-8 (#;/&;#(%# ( ",# .!-"   ",# $#%#!'#$ ("-&91"-8 (#;/&;#(%# <!' !''#''#$!' B(",#.!-" ",#$#%#!'#$!' <#//!'",#$-&4#- ",#

#($&(; "-1%: ,#-# -#3 !+1("   %+.#('!"&( " 9# -#/#!'#$ " ",# %/!&+!("'<!'-#$1%#$98 B/!&+!("'<#-#!%%-$&(;/8,#/$#("&"/#$"

 %+.#('!"&( ' 3 3 7C!/(;<&",&("#-#'"H B.#-!((1+ -+",# $!"# &/&(; %/!&+.#"&"&("&//-#!/&'!"&( G#!-(#$ %1('#/ - ",# !..#//!("' !-;1#' ",!" ",# /#!-(#$ -&91(!/,!'<-(;/8%(%/1$#$",!"",#-#<!'%("-&91"-8(#;/&;#(%#(",# .!-" ",#$#%#!'#$!($",1'!<!-$#$(/8 B ",#%+.#('!"&(' .#- #4&$#(%# ( -#%-$3 

#($&(; 4#,&%/# <!' .!-:#$ ( ",# -!$ <&",1" !(8 &($&%!"- !($7- -# /#%"- ,#-# -#3 ",# !..#//!(" %!((" 9# ,#/$ (#;/&;#(" &( !(8 +!((#- " &' 1-",#- '19+&""#$ ",!" ",#-# &' ( $&'.1"# -#;!-$&(; ",# &(%+#   ",# $#%#!'#$ " 9# ' 3 7C .#- +(", !' !''#''#$98",#/#!-(#$-&91(!/3,<#4#-3(&(%-#+#(",!'9##(!

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

-$#$ " ",# %/!&+!("' -#4#-3 ",# #4&$#(%# ( -#%-$ %/#!-/8 ',<' ",!" ",#-# <!' %("-&91"-8 (#;/&;#(%# ( ",# .!-"   ",# $#%#!'#$ # -#/&#' 1.( ",# =1$;+#(" ",&'1-".!''#$&(!=2!1-!($",#-'0'1-(!+*&(;,!($ ",#-'     &4&/  " %("#($ ",!" &( %!'# ",# $-&4#-   ",# +"-%8%/# $#%#!'#$ <!'

#($&(; 4#,&%/# !" ! -#!'(!9/#

A '.##$3 ,# %1/$ ,!4# !4#-"#$ ",# !%%&$#("3 #4#( &  ,# <!' 9/&($#$ 98 .<#- 1//&;,"' 4#,&%/#'%+&(; -+",#..'&"#'&$#"&'3",1'3.-!8#$ ",!"",&'!..#!/9#$&'+&''#$  ,!4# ,#!-$ /#!-(#$ %1('#/ - ",# .!-"&#' !($ ,!4# ;(# ",-1;,",#-#%-$<&",",#&-!9/#!''&'"!(%# " &' (" &( $&'.1"# ",!" &=#($#- /'" ,&' /& # $1# " &(=1-&#' -#%#&4#$&(!+"-4#,&%/#!%%&$#("<,&%,":./!%#!"!91" 6 .+( 6  5 <!'-#;&'"#-#$(",#'"!"#+#(" !-4&($#-3 

!-4&($#-'.#%& &%!//8'"!"#$",!"(6  !"!91" 6 .+3,# !/(; <&", ,&' (#&;,91- &=#($#- $#%#!'#$ <#-# ;&(; " ,"!: -+ 0&//!;#   !=-! ( ",#&- '#.!-!"# +"-C%8%/#' !-4&($#- <!'

//<&(; &=#($#-$#%#!'#$,#

#($&(;"-1%:<!'.!-:#$(#;/&;#("/8( ",#+&$$/# ",#-!$<&",1"!(8&($&%!"---# /#%"-1#"",#/&;," ",# (%+&(;"-!

&%3 &=#($#-$#%#!'#$%1/$("'##",#

#($&(;"-1%:<,&%, <!' .!-:#$ ( ",# -!$ !$+&""#$/8 <&",1" !(8 &($&%!"- - -# /#%"- !($ '"-1%: ,&' +"-%8%/# !;!&('" ",# 

#($&(; 4#,&%/# # -#%#&4#$ '#-&1' &(=1-&#'&(",#'!&$!%%&$#("!($/!"#-'1%%1+9#$"",#+ '"C+-"#+<!' %($1%"#$(",#9$8 ",#$#%#!'#$  ,!4# .#-1'#$ ",# "#'"&+(8  !-4&($#- -;1+#(" -!&'#$98/#!-(#$%1('#/ -",#('1-!(%#+.!(8",!"!

&$!4&" 5 7%1/$("9#-#!$&(#4&$#(%#3",#'!&$!

&$!4&",!4&(;("9##( '&;(#$ 98 ,&+3 &' $#4&$   +#-&" !" ",&' '"!;#  " &' (" $#(&#$ ",!" ",# !

&$!4&" 5 7 <!' '&;(#$ 98 D (&"! <,#-#!' !

&$!4&" 5 D7 <!''&;(#$98 !-4&($#-9=#%"&(<!'-!&'#$&(",&'-#;!-$98",# ('1-!(%# +.!(8 !" !(8 #!-/&#- '"!;#  ",&(; " ",&' #

#%" &' #4#( -# /#%"#$&(",#%-''#5!+&(!"&( <,&%,<!'$1/8%($1%"#$,#-# &'&($##$(",&(;&(",#%-''#5!+&(!"&(<,&%,&+.#!%,#'",#4#-'&(.1"



-", 98 !-4&($#-3 !( #8# <&"(#''   ",# !%%&$#("  ,!' &($##$ -#&"#-!"#$ !($ -#!

&-+#$ ",# 4#-'&( <,&%, ,# ;!4# !" ",# 1"'#"3 ( ",# 9!'&' <,&%,

<!'-#;&'"#-#$(",#4#-8'!+#$!8 (?9/#*1.-#+#1-"&(-%,&"*!&(&!($!(",#-0'-&#("!/ ('1-!(%#+.!(8G"$!($",#-' *A <,&/#$#!/&(;<&", ",#+!""#-<,#-#&(!!'!(:#-<!'.!-:#$<&",1"!(8&($&%!"--.!-:&(; /&;,"3,!'9'#-4#$",!"<,#-#!4#,&%/#$!',#'!;!&('"!'"!"&(!-84#,&%/#3 ",!"98&"'#/ $#'("(#%#''!-&/8/#!$"!(&(#4&"!9/#%(%/1'&(",!"",#-# &' .#- -%# %("-&91"-8 (#;/&;#(%# ( ",# .!-"   ",# $#%#!'#$ ( ",# .-#'#(" %!'# !' <#//3 ",#-# &' ( #4&$#(%# ( -#%-$ " .-4# ",!" ",#

#($&(;"-1%:<!'(".!-:#$!'!//#;#$<&",1"!(8&($&%!"---# /#%"- #"%-",!"",#!..#//!("<!'("9/&($#$98.<#- 1//&;,"' ",#(%+&(; "-!

&% ,#-# -#3 ",# /#!-(#$ -&91(!/ ,!' <-(;/8 %(%/1$#$ ",!" ",# $#%#!'#$<!';1&/"8 !(8%("-&91"-8(#;/&;#(%#,#!%%&$#("&(F1#'"&( <!' <,//8 %!1'#$ $1# " ",# -!', !($ (#;/&;#(" !%"   ",# $-&4#-   ",#

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

6 $#%#!'#$<!'-&;,"/8!''#''#$98",#/#!-(#$-&91(!/!'' 3 7C.#- +(",<#4#-3&(4&#< ",#=1$;+#(" (?9/#",#*1.-#+#1-"&(",# %!'# -!(!8*#",&!($",#-''1.-!3 B&(%-#!'#&(&(%+#,!'"9# !

-$#$(!%%1(" 1"1-#.-'.#%"'!'",#$#%#!'#$<!'A 8#!-'/$!" ",# "&+#   ,&' $#!", #$1%"&(   7 -$ "<!-$' .#-'(!/ #5.#('#' ,!' -&;,"/89##(#

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

     (%+# 7C.+ &#33AA3 7C.#-!((1+

 "!/ &(%+# !

"#- !$$&"&( !" ",# -!"#  B ( !%%1("  1"1-# .-'.#%"' 3AA3 I 63 3AA3 5 B J3 3 7C

 (%+# !

"#- $#$1%"&(   7A", ( !%%1(" .#-'(!/#5.#('#' 3 3 KA3 3 3 7  J3 3 7C A "!/ $#.#($#(%8 !

"#- !../8&(; ! +1/"&./&#- A 3 3 AJ 3@ 3 7C  G'' #'"!"# 3 7C 6 1(#-!/#5.#('#' 3 7C  G'' %('-"&1+"",#!..#//!("'

36 3 7C HA 3 7CA 3 5AJ36 3 7C  

3 7C

 ,#!+1(" %+.#('!"&(!/-#!$8!<!-$#$"",#!..#//!("'3 (##$/#''"'!83',!//'"!($$#$1%"#$ -+",#!+1("%!/%1/!"#$!'!94# ..#//!("'',!//9##("&"/#$"&("#-#'"!"",#-!"# B.#-!((1+(",# #("&-#!+1(" -+",#$!"# &/&(; ",#.#"&"&("&//-#!/&E!"&( D&",",#!94#'!&$+$& &%!"&(&(",#!<!-$$!"#$ @ A 3 .-#'#("!..#!/&'$&'.'#$  



  

 ',<!- D,#",#-'.#!:&(;7-#!'(#$)C #'7 D,#",#--#.-"!9/#)C #'7