High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/8677/2014dismissed

Reliance General Insurance Co Ltd v. Raj Rani Alias Rani & ORS

2016-11-30Mr. Justice Arun Palli9 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*

#+&!(%##(#,!+('-,!(%#./!(01&.&"#$ //#++!("

2#,'-'

!3!(&4!(&!($"5#,'

#'/($#("'

) 6 1 717

,#'#(") ,7!(3##28$!(9$2%!"#9

,"5#!//#++!("

,'5!(75!,.!9$2%!"#9

,,#'/($#("'(!($

,,(!27$9$2%!"#9

,,#'/($#("'(*!($ 179 ,!+ 5&'&'!(!//#!+ &+#$:0"5#&('-,!(%#%./!(0"5!"5!$&('-,#$ "5#2#5&%+#&(2+2#$&(!(!%%&$#("9&(;5&%5(#8#'!,7&(<5-( ,"-(!"#+0 +'"5&'+& #&';&$;!($.&(,'(5!2&(< &+#$!%+!&./#"&"&(-($#, 7#%"&( "5#",=#5&%+#'%"9>9:# ,#"5#",%%&$#("

+!&.',&:-(!+9'5&!,/-,9'##?&(<%./#('!"&(9'-%5%./#('!"&(" "5#"-(# '9>@9

AB;!'!;!,$#$""5#.2&$#"5#&./-<(#$;!,$

5# !%"'9!'"!?#( ,."5#;!,$9!,#"5!"&";!'%+!&.#$:0"5# ,#'/($#("' 5#,#&(!

"#, " :# ,# #,,#$ " !' C"5# %+!&.!("'D9 "5!" (

*98#'!,7&(<5!+(<;&"55&'(#/5#;!(/,##"7&(<59;!'<&(< ""5#5-'# (#,75&($ 2&++!<#1!(<#,&9( .",%0%+#:#!,&(< ,#<&'",!"&(

B @@*"!:-"@

/.;5#("5#0,#!%5#$&("5#

!,#! "5#%5;?(#!,"5#5-'# 7!,/!(%5!(3&"7&(<59!0-($!&B %!,9:#!,&(<,#<&'",!"&(

B#./ 9%!.#!($'",-%?!<!&('"

"5#.",%0%+#9;&"58#'!,7&(<5'&""&(</&++&(:#5&($5&'(#/5#;5#0 ;#,#$,!<<#$"!$&'"!(%# "@?!,!.'9$-#";5&%5"5#0'-'"!&(#$ .-+"&/+#&(3-,&#'

"5"5#&(3-,#$;#,#"!?#(""5#&2&+'/&"!+9!5&+/-,9:0

!';&($#,7&(<5!($7-?53&"7&(<59;5#,#8#'!,7&(<59$-#"5&''#,&-' %($&"&(9 ;!' ,# #,,#$ " ! 5'/&"!+ &( 1-$5&!(!9 ;5#,# 5# $&#$ (

*9&#(#.("5+!"#, $!"#$

* ;!' &(&"&!++0 ,#<&'"#,#$ , "5# !++#<#$%..&''&(

#(%#'/-(&'5!:+#-($#,7#%"&('

>9** 9**9

("5#'"!"#.#(" !(/,##"7&(<51!"#,9!

"#,"5#$#!"5 8#'!, 7&(<59!(

#(%#/-(&'5!:+#-($#,7#%"&(* ;!'!+'!$$#$

B '/#,"5#%+!&./#"&"&(98#'!,7&(<5;!'"5#'+#:,#!$#!,(#, "5# !.&+09;5;!'@ 0#!,'+$!($;!'!/#,.!(#("#./+0##!'! #( &("5#2#,(.#("&<57%5+985#,!9#!,(&(<'*

AB/#,.("5 ";!' -,"5#,%+!&.#$"5!"' +!%';#,#'/#("(5&'",#!".#("

"&++5&'$#!"5!($"5!"'

AB;!''/#("(5&'",!('/,"!"&(!($ -(#,!+ ('#E-#("+09!%./#('!"&( '@ +!%';!''-<5"9!+(<;&"5&("#,#'"

"5#,#-/( * /(("&%#&''-#$""5#,#'/($#("'9,#'/($#("'(!($ &#"5#$,&2#,!($;(#, "5#%!,!

,#'!&$9 &+#$!3&(";,&""#('"!"#.#("9 $#(0&(<"5#!%%&$#("!($"5#,# ,#/+#!$&(<"5!""5#%+!&./#"&"&(;!'("

.!&("!&(!:+# ";!'!+'%("#($#$"5!""5#;!'!C !+'#(#D!($"5!"&(

* !(0%!'#"5#%!,;!'&('-,#$;&"5,#'/($#("(*9&#"5#/,#'#("!//#++!("B &('-,!(%#%./!(0 "5#,!2#,.#("'.!$#&("5#%+!&./#"&"&(;#,#!+'$#(&#$ (!'#/!,!"#;,&""#('"!"#.#("9"5#/,#'#("!//#++!("!+'"? "5#/+#! "5#%+!&./#"&"&((":#&(<.!&("!&(!:+#9,#'/($#("((" 5+$&(<!2!+&$#

#%"&2#$,&2&(<+&%#(%#9 "5#%!,:#&(</+&#$;&"5-"!

,#<&'",!"&(%#,"& &%!"#!($;&"5,#<!,$".&'3&($#,!($((B3&($#, "5# (#%#''!,0/!,"&#' ++-'&(:#";##("5#%+!&.!("'!($"5# &,'",#'/($#(";!'

!+' !++#<#$9 "5-<5 "5# 2#5&%+# :#&(< &('-,#$ ;&"5 "5# %./!(0 ;!' !$.&""#$9C'-:3#%""2#,& &%!"&(D5#%./#('!"&(!.-("%+!&.#$;!' !+'%("#($#$":##F,:&"!(" @ ("5#!

,#'!&$/+#!$&(<'9"5# ++;&(<&''-#';#,# ,!.#$:0 "5#+#!,(#$,&:-(!+)B C G5#"5#,$#!"5 8#'!,7&(<5 "?/+!%#&( ,!$ !%%&$#("(

*&("5#!,#! 5;?(#!,"5#5-'# 7!,/!(%5 !(3&"7&(<51!++&9%!-'#$$-#",!'5!($(#<+&<#("$,&2&(< B %!,

B#./ :0,#'/($#("( '9&"'#

#%"H

&''-#(/,2#$9";5!"!.-(" %./#('!"&( %+!&.!("'#("&"+#$!($ ,.;5.H

* G5#"5#,,#'/($#("(;!'("5+$&(<2!+&$!($ #

#%"&2# $,&2&(< +&%#(%# !($ "5#

#($&(< 2#5&%+# ;!' (" 5!2&(< ,#<&'",!"&(%#,"& &%!"#!""5#"&.# !%%&$#(" '9&"'#

#%"H * #+&# D 5#%+!&.!("'5!2&(<#F!.&(#$"5#!

,#'!&$!(/,##"7&(<5!'

!(#0#;&"(#''GB*95&''"!"#.#("""5##

#%""5!""5#%!,%!.#!($5&"

"5# .",B%0%+# ,. :#5&($9 ;&"5-" :+;&(< !(0 5,(9 ;!' !%%#/"#$9 :#%!-'# 9 &,'"+09"5#5!2&(<:##(+$<#$/,./"+0! "#,"5#!%%&$#("

!($ -,"5#,9("5&(<'##(#2#( ,."5#%,''B#F!.&(!"&( "5&';&"(#''

;5&%5%-+$#'"!:+&'5"5!""5#!%%&$#("$&$(""!?#/+!%#&("5#.!((#, $#'%,&:#$5#,#<&'",!"&((-.:#, "5#%!,;!'!+',#%,$#$&("5# !($"5#,# ,#9"5-<5(,#/,"-($#,7#%"&( *, 5!$:##( &+#$!'

/#,"5#"#'"&.(0 GB 977-,3&"8-.!,9&";!'5#+$"5!""5#(#<+&<#(%# &(%!-'&(<"5#!%%&$#(";!'/,2#$":#"5!" ,#'/($#("( ";!'

:'#,2#$:0"5#+#!,(#$,&:-(!+"5!"((B/,#'#("!"&( "5#%5!++!(#2#(I 0#!,'!

"#,"5#!%%&$#(";!'$-#""5#+!F&"0 "5#/+&%#9 ,;5&%5"5# %+!&.!("'%-+$(":#:+!.#$ ('#E-#("+09"5#&''-# (#<+&<#(%#;!'$#%&$#$&( !2-,

"5#%+!&.!("'

',#<!,$'"5#E-!("-. %./#('!"&(9&";!' -($"5!""5#,# ;!'($%-.#("!,0/, '5;&(<"5!"' +!%'5!$:##('/#("("5# ",#!".#(" "5#$#%#!'#$9:-""5#"#'"&.(0 GB#'"!:+&'5#$"5!".#$&%!+ :&++'""5#"-(# ' 9

AB5!$:##('-:.&""#$ ,,#&.:-,'#.#("

"5!"!.-("5#,#&.:-,'#.#("%#,"& &%!"#9F'*"B@9!+(<;&"5"5#

,.'-:.&""#$;#,# -($"5!2#:##(/,2#$9"5-<5&";!',#%,$#$"5!" !%"-!+,#&.:-,'#.#("5!$'"&++(":##(.!$# ('#E-#("+09%./#('!"&( ,.#$&%!+",#!".#("""5#"-(#

' 9

AB;!'!;!,$#$""5#%+!&.!("' 8#'!,7&(<5;!' -($":#@ 0#!,'!($*.("5' !<#!""5# "&.# "5#!%%&$#("95&'$!"# :&,"5:#&(< >>@ 9!'/#,5&''#,2&%# ,#%,$ /,2#$ :0GB 9 ;5 !+' /,2#$ 5&' %!,,0 5.# '!+!,0 " :# '

AB/#,.("5 +$&(<"5!"&(%.#"!F;!':2&-'+0$#$-%"#$ ,.5&'%!,,0

@ 5.#'!+!,0;&"5"5#""!+'!+!,0:#&(<' 9@ AB9!($ -,"5#,5+$&(<"5!"

'&(%#5#;!'@ 0#!,' !<#9(+'' -"-,#/,'/#%"' !(&(%,#!'#$ &(%.#;#,#!;!,$!:+#9"5#.("5+0'!+!,0 "5#$#%#!'#$;!'"!?#(":# '

AB,' 9

AB/#,!((-. A*,$!.-(" "5!";!'$#$-%"#$";!,$'"5#/#,'(!+#F/#('#' "5#$#%#!'#$9"5#,#:0!''#''&(<"5#!((-!++'' &(%.#""5#%+!&.!("'

":#'9

AB .-+"&/+&#, 6>6;!'!//+&#$""5!"'-.9"5#,#:0%.&(<"! ""!++'' '9

AB ' @9

AB ;!' !;!,$#$ :0 ;!0 -(#,!+ #F/#('#' !($ '@

AB(!%%-(" +'' %(',"&-.""5# &,'"%+!&.!("9,#'/($#("

(5#,#&( ("5#,'@

AB;!'!;!,$#$(!%%-(" +'' +2#!($ !

#%"&(!($! -,"5#,'-. '@

AB(!%%-(" +'' #'"!"# 5-'9 ;&"5 ' 9

AB !+' 5!2&(< :##( !;!,$#$ ";!,$' .#$&%!+#F/#('#'9"5#""!+%./#('!"&(!;!,$#$;!''9>@9

AB 5#%("#("&( "5#%-('#+ ,"5#/,#'#("!//#++!(" ;!'

,#3#%"#$9""5##

#%""5!"!'"5# &,'"%+!&.!("5!$ <"#./+0.#("( %./!''&(!"#:!'&'!($5!$,#%#&2#$!'-. ' 9 9AB!'$#!"5B%-.B ,#"&,#.#("<,!"-&"09!'!+''9 *9>AB:0;!0 <#(#,!+/,2&$#(" -($9 "5#'!&$!.-("''5-+$:#$#$-%"#$ ,."5#%./#('!"&(!;!,$#$ 5+$!'!:2#9!3-$<.#(" "5#7-/,#.#-,"&(

* 7 9;!'

%&"#$:0"5#,&:-(!+9!+(<;&"53-$<.#("' "5&'-,"9""5##

#%""5!"( !.-(",#%#&2#$:0%+!&.!("':0;!0 /,2&$#(" -($9/#('&(!($ !.&+0

/#('&(9&'":#$#$-%"#$ ,."5#%./#('!"&(/!0!:+# ('#E-#("+09"5#/,#'#("!//#!+:0"5#&('-,!(%#%./!(0 >

# ,#"5&'-,"9,7!(3&28$!(9+#!,(#$%-('#+!//#!,&(<

,"5#!//#++!("95!$!,<-#$(!(#!,+&#,$!"# 5#!,&(<9"5!"-($#,"5#5#!$ +'' #!,(&(<9"5#%+!&.!("'%!((+0%+!&.!(0!.-("!'&'("/!&$" "5#.:0"5##./+0#, "5#$#%#!'#$9:0;!0 !''&'"!(%#(!%%-(" "5# $#!"5 "5#$#%#!'#$("5&',#<!,$9+#!,(#$%-('#+5!$,#+&#$-/(! 3-$<.#(" "5#5(6:+#7-/,#.#-,"&(

9/!''#$&(&2&+//#!+> @

9$#%&$#$( *,$7#/"#.:#,9

5&'-,"5!$("&%#$("5!"$!"#"5!"&("5#! ,#'!&$%!'#9"5# $#%#!'#$5!$:##(#./+0#$;&"5"5#!,0!(!2#,(.#("!($"5#,# ,#95&'

;&$;!($"5#,$#/#($#("';#,#<2#,(#$:0"5#!,0!(!./!''&(!"# ''&'"!(%#""5# #/#($#("' "5# #%#!'#$2#,(.#("./+0##'-+#'9

9:0;5&%5"5# !.&+0 "5##./+0##;-+$%("&(-#"$,!;9:0;!0

&(!(%&!+!''&'"!(%#9!'-.#E-!+""5#/!0!($"5#,!++;!(%#'"5!";!'+!'" $,!;(:0"5#$#%#!'#$B#./+0##9-/"&++"5#!<# '-/#,!((-!"&(9'-:3#%"" "5#%($&"&('+!&$$;(&("5#'!&$,-+#' ("5#"5#,5!($9&("5#/,#'#("%!'#9"5#$#%#!'#$;!'!( #./+0## "5# -(3!:2#,(.#("!($%('#E-#("+09"5#+#!,(#$%-('#+

,"5#!//#++!("5!$:##($&,#%"#$ "/+!%#(,#%,$#2#(:0;!0

!$$&"&(!+ #2&$#(%#9 "5# ,-+#' <2#,(&(< !''&'"!(%#A %./!''&(!"# !//&(".#("9&("5#%!'# !$#%#!'#$#./+0## "5#2#,(.#("

-(3!: ( ,#'/('# "5#,#"9 +#!,(#$ %-('#+ , "5# !//#++!(" 5!'

/,$-%#$&(-,""$!0!/5"%/0 "5# -(3!:&2&+7#,2&%#'-+#'9 =+-.#B9!($5!'/&("#$"7#%"&(="5#,# 9;5&%5%("!&('-+#

!($"5#!((#F-,#!//#($#$"5#,#"9:0;5&%5!(#FB<,!"&!<,!("&'&("#($#$" :#/,2&$#$!',#+&# ""5# !.&+0 !2#,(.#("#./+0##;5$&#';5&+# &('#,2&%#;#2#,9 ,."5#+!"#'"#$&"&( "5#!

,#'!&$-+#'9&"&''##( "5!""5#!((#F-,#!//#($#$"5#,#"!+'%("!&('!/,2&'&(""5##

#%""5!"

"5#<,!(";-+$:#/,2&$#$!"!-(& ,.,!"# '9

AB&(!++%!'#' 5-'9&"&'!//!,#(""5!"&"&'!(#"&.#<,!("""&$#2#,"5#$&

&%-+"0 !%#$ :0"5#:#,#!2#$ !.&+0!($&"&'("!/#,#((&!+'-,%# &(%.#""5#

!.&+09!'.!0/''&:+0:#$#$-%"&:+#;5&+#%!+%-+!"&(<"5#+'' &(%.#" "5#. 1#!,(#$%-('#+ ,"5#!//#++!("95;#2#,9'-:.&"'"5!""5# $#%#!'#$:#&(<@ 0#!,'!($*.("5'+$95#;-+$5!2#,#"&,#$!""5#!<#

0#!,'!($!''-%59"5#.-+"&/+&#, >!//+&#$:0"5#+#!,(#$", %%&$#(" +!&.' ,&:-(!+9 '5&!,/-,9 " "5# %!,,0 5.# '!+!,0

AB/#,.("5' 9

AB!((-!++09&'5&<5+0#F%#''&2# !2&(<%('&$#,#$"5#!

,#'!&$!,<-.#("9 &($(.#,&"&(&"9 &(2&#; "5# !%""5!"5!$"5#$#%#!'#$%("&(-#$"+&2#:-" ,"5# !%%&$#("9#2#(!

"#,,#"&,#.#("95#;-+$5!2#$,!;(5&' -++/#('&(9#E-!+ "!:-"@ J 5&''!+!,09;5#,#!'5&''#,2&%#&"'#+ 5!2&(<:##(%-"'5,":0 .,#"5!("5,##!($5!+ 0#!,'95&' !.&+0$&$("$,!;"5#:#(# &" "5# -++ '!+!,0 ,"5#,#.!&(&(</!," 5&''#,2&%#9&(%+-$&(<"5#&(%,#.#("'!($ $#!,(#''!++;!(%#"5!"5#;-+$5!2#$,!;("5#,#-/(9!($"5#0!+'$&$ ("<#" "5#:#(# &" "5# -++/#('&( "5!"5#;-+$5!2#$,!;(-/( '-/#,!((-!"&(9;5&%5;-+$!+'5!2#:##(%!+%-+!"#$!'/#,5&'+!'"/!0

$,!;(!:-""5,##0#!,'!($(&(#.("5'!

"#,5&'$#!"5 1#!,(#$ %-('#+ , ,#'/($#("' !($ %+!&.!("' 5!'

'-:.&""#$"5!"9&( !%"9,#'/($#("(9&#"5#;&$;9&'$,!;&(<(+0A*,$ "5#%!,,05.#'!+!,0 "5#$#%#!'#$ (2&#; "5#!:2#9'##(#,,,&("5#&./-<(#$;!,$ /!''#$:0"5#+#!,(#$,&:-(!+9:0;5&%5!.-+"&/+&#, >;!'!//+&#$9&( "#,.' "5#,!"& "5#3-$<.#(" "5#7-/,#.#-,"&(7!,+!=#,.!!($ "5#,'2' #+5&,!('/,",/,!"&(!($!("5#,9

>*&2&+

;5#,#&(&"5!':##('"&/-+!"#$"5!"& "5#$#%#!'#$;!':#";##(@ " 0#!,'

!<#9!.-+"&/+&#, >'5-+$:#!//+&#$ ("#,.' "5#,!"& "5# !

,#'!&$3-$<.#("9"5#+#!,(#$ ,&:-(!+ ,&<5"+0 !+' $&$ (" !//+0 !(0 +'' -"-,# /,'/#%"' !( &(%,#!'#$&(%.#""5#%+!&.!("'9#2#("5-<5"5#$#%#!'#$;!'!/#,.!(#(" 2#,(.#("#./+0## "5#,/&("5!':##(!,<-#$ ;#2#,9!""5#"&.# "5# $&%"!"&( "5#3-$<.#("9"5# !%""5!"' 9

AB;!'!;!,$#$(!%%-("

.#$&%!+ #F/#('#' 5!' :##( ("&%#$9 ;5&%5 "5#,;&'# ;-+$ :# ,#&.:-,'!:+# " "5# ,#'/($#("'B%+!&.!("'9 "5# $#%#!'#$ 5!2&(< :##( ! 2#,(.#(" #./+0###"9! &($&(< 5!' :##( ,#%,$#$ :0"5#+#!,(#$ ,&:-(!+9!'!+,#!$0("&%#$9"5!""5#'!&$!.-("5!$(":##(!%"-!++0 ,#&.:-,'#$""5#%+!&.!("'#2&$#(%#;5!"'#2#,5!':##('5;(""5&' -,"""5#%(",!,09!($5#(%#"5!" &($&(< "5#,&:-(!+&'!+'!%%#/"#$ !''-%5 * ('#E-#("+09 &( 2&#; !++ "5!" 5!' :##( $&'%-''#$ 5#,#&( !:2#9 &($(#,,,&("5#&./-<(#$;!,$ "5#+#!,(#$,&:-(!+!($

> "5#,# ,#9"5#!//#!+&'$&'.&''#$9;&"5%'"' '

AB 5#&("#,&.,$#,$!"#$

@'"!($'2!%!"#$ 5#!.-(" ' @9

AB$#/'&"#$!""5#"&.# &+&(< "5&'

!//#!+'5!++:#,# -($#$""5#!//#++!(" *

#$% G5#"5#,'/#!?&(<A,#!'(#$ #'A G5#"5#,#/,"!:+# #'A