Manisha Gupta v. State Of Punjab And Others
!
"#$# %&'(( ) %#$* +,
(((((((((
# # % - . / / /
+%0 1 %! -$ ((((((((((
$, %!
%
)& 23) ( /. /(
!
" # $
%%%% . /( 4( - 5
'
( ) !
*
!
+ ,-
,
. /
/ /
!
/ *
/ /
(0+ !*
* !*
6
! ! 1123114 5
/ 33
" # " $ +!*
,4 ,, 19,,:
/
!!
!! !!* !/!!* + + *
/ #
+ + !
/
! +
+ " #
'
* ;+
+ + / !+ < 9# 9# 19,,
+
;
/
!+ < +
! / * !
! !!
+ 19,-
$
5
!!
" # ! !
+ / *!
7!
*!
# + + /
/ / / + + !
!
+
+ +
/ +
+! +!* /
/! ,4 ,, 19,,
5 / !! " #'
* ;+ / +
.!+ !!/ + / ! / !
+ * ! !+ ! *
!
*
" # !! ! !
+
!! " # /! !
/! !
! +
!
+
!
/
+
!
0 ,1= /!!
+! $->3=923#$,3#$ 5 / !
5
!!
9> ,9 1919 " # !
/ " $ + /* !
/ + !!
+ !
!
! 1=
( * +!* ;+
" / !*
+ !
!
+ / + + !* ! +
/
) 7 3 =
/ !
!
* +
/ + + + ! * !+
?!!* /
/ //
&
!
/* ? 7* !
* /
/ @1
!"#$% &' $&$&( $& $ !"# ) &$&$&
& &) $$&$&* + * * ,, * -
,
*
, . " - / + * *"
." (0 * ( /
*)
* * + * *, 1 " * * *
, " , , *
,, 2 3," 4 * , 5 ! -( " - /
, & $$&$&
,,5! -("
*
" (- / & $$&$& 6 7 6 + #8 !
) ?,3& /
+ /
!/
/ / / (
- ( "
#'
* ;+ ! / !!
+
! ! !!
* !
+
+!
/
+ / !
A.!!*
/! !* )+ / ) * !
! !
+ !
+ !
!
! +
!!
/*
/ /
*
+ " #
! / !!*
5
!* $ + + ! !
! !!*
'
! * " # 9= ,9
+
!
8!
! +
!
*
!/ %7 - /&% &$&$& / * , ,/, / * * *
* * / / 9 * 7 6 + # &% &$&$&
: ,
; (- / -
*
; * *
;
, * * *
* * * *
(
&% &$&$&( & * * % &$&$& , : < 9 7 .
,
* 8 >
! !
5
/ + / !
! " # / +
= !
* /
+ /
" #
/
* " # / ! !
) -
5
! / ! + + +
/
/ =>? 7 , ,( * , * >?
5 * * ( &$&$$&$ ( 3-
3 6( ( 6, (( (
26
! * ,
( * , > ?
( 3-
3 ** 0 * ( , *
9
* ( **
/ *
0 * / /
/
3 4 )3
& ,9
7
+
* !
! " # $ /
:
" ,4 ,9
53,31911
!
B 0+ !* !
*
1=
(
+
. /
! !
!
!
+ /
*
!
B
( " #
+ +
+3 ! * + +
!
!
B 0+ !*
) = $
, ( / 0
: * @ (
, , *
* 0 * ( , * * : * , * ( , * ! : , , *
, *6: (
*
, * *
, ( /
* , ,
,
(
, *
,# - / ( , ,, * * ,
# * * # ! , (
0 * (
* / *
,
* * *# 6 * *
4
*
( , 6
,/ *
, " (, :
" * , 6 7 *( 8 )/ ,, ( !
+
/
0+ !* ! !
! !
+
!"#$%&'!"#% ( +*
(
/
/ !
*
;
/ !
+ ! !
! +
C ! +
+
)*+,-+ , ,-!"#$%./'!"#0%/ )/ / ( ,1
- (!
" # ! !
+
, +12 , !/&&.#%""
3$ )
%$ 7 " * (
, , , , * * ( , , * ** (" 6 * 6( , (* *3 ( (( ( ,
* 0 , ( ,* :(
( (
, * * * ( " (* " 8 13.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the facts of the instant case as well as the documents appended along with. Besides, the precedent judgments of Supreme Court that have been referred to by the parties have also been considered. ANALYSIS 14.
D !
!* +
+ /
. +
!
* /
/ !
!
* ! +* /!
) /
/!!
!
/ + /!
!* / !* * +* ! ! /
!
+! +* /
,=
. / )
/ * /
!
C!/!
!! !C
/
+ !
!
* !*
(
,2
!
+ /!!
! / !
* /
!! !
!/!
?
+
*
,-=2
! +
!/ ' * 2 A * 2 (
>6 * ?( A >? ,
* A ( ( C
*
,
>,? *, *
* A ( ( >?
* A , C-
, * A >? ,2 (
,? , , * > ? >
?@6 A (6
= = 8 ,4
!
+ /! /
!
!* + +
+ !
!/
< !
+ . / /! @ !! !
!/!F
0!!
+ <+,, == 5 %! -$.$(* #$ ( 55 "
- %!#$ ( ) >#$ -
4*#-+?
55+-#$ -#"
4*#-+?
55+- %! -$ (( #% $(484994:9 %!
,
*
" / * , , * 9 "
( , : ,
,
4
,
* >?9
>?9
, >?9 * *
, , > ? , , * ,
>?, >,? >?
D >? D >? ,
> ?6 / $ : , * :
, 76" " * :
, , , , *
* ,
$7 ( "
,
, * ,
,
,
, , , ( * ( * *
,
* 6
, 6 ( ,, 8 !/ * / *
!
!! !
!/!
+
0
* !
/
!
+
! / !/
8
! !/
!! !
0+ !*
* / !+ /!
/
!
!
/
! !/* +
/ /!
,>
5
+ !
!
!
!
B 0+ !* ) * + / +
!* + /!
*
!!
/ !/
/ /
!!
!
B 0+ !*
!! !
!
"!
8 + + !* B /!
/!
*
+ /!!
! !
* + /!
/! /!
!
*
"
+
!
B 0+ !* !
!/
,-
5 /! !
+
C ! +
+ 425 +67 8 45!/&$%#0""3/ /
C ! + ,-
2, * 6 * 2, * *
2, *
6
( , ,
D
,
( 2* " * *
: ,
*
: , ! " 2*" ( (
(
, , ,
* $&
(
2 < 7 < 9 7 , * * < 9 7(
'
,
6 *
, : < 9 7 6
,
9
( * ,
9 : : ( 6 6 6 ( *
, 6 6 , $ (
,
E 9 ! ' 2 < 7(
* **
* , *
* F
6
* 2 ( (
( (, * * ( / *6 / * 7 $$' "
0
+ $&%$& )
1-7
' $& G ! + 9:; ( = , ( * H 7(
(
, ( , , * , 2, " , / *
9 1 ! *H*
, * * , $,* * < 9 7 0 " ,
, ,
, , (
; ", , * , ,
1 ( ** * (
(
, ! : , * , , , / ,
,
2 ( * * :
, * < 9 7 / , " 9 (
8 1,
+
+ *< + 9821
<8 309/&/& & &./&/&( *7 C @,$;
( ,
( *
, ,*
*
# ! * :
: 8
:
5
+
+ /
* + +
.!
(
/
/
! ! !
*
+ +
! + +
!
!
+ !*
+
!
B 0+ !*
1=
(
!!
!
B 0+ !* + !*
!
B
) !*
!
* ) !
+ / /!
< + !
+
! +
1#
5 /
!/ + * !
!
!! !
!/!
! +
+ * !/
!
!
* ! +* ! +*
/ +
! +
/ !
! !*
)+
( /
+ .
+ /!
+! *
!
! + )+ / /!
!
+! +* /!
!
(
!/
. ! !*
!
* !
!!
) * + /! *
(
+
+
!* +
. /( '((
%#5 9 / *# C I # 9 , I #