Sandeep Kumar v. Central Administrative Tribunal And ORS.




   
 

   

 !"# #$%&'' 






  

 
 


 
!

 
" # "
$%"

" # "

" 
&
  & ()

' *
'*'*)
  () *' *


+



'

( 
 "

&"

 %

)
"
  
*

"

 %
)

* 

$+"

 %
) 
,


-----
'*'*,%#-,.,/",0'

1,/ "#

"
 
.


 
) 
 %
,,/
)
"
   
)
0 


"

)
"
 


 !

 
" # "
$%"

" # "
1" ) )




2"
!

 34

55,5/
1

6,4
." 
"
7
5/555898,5/
.








"
#  
"
" 
.





% 

 %
"
"
 #


5:5/,5,
1 
64
.

%% 
)
"
# #
)
"
;0&
# 
"
 %

0
.
 %
<
"
!

 
"

.

) "
8
"
) #  
)
"
;0&
."

%"
.

5,58,5,


!" ) 
.
"
"
"

"

 

<
)


.

"
"
# #
)
"
;0&

" 
.

 +
)
"
 #
 .

"
"
;0&

=  

" 
.





% 

 +
"
#

.

"
"
#  
)
"
;0&

"#
"




"


,959,5:
1 6/4
." .
 % 
.



#.

"

 % 
)  
)
"
.
 % 

"
#  
"
"


55,5/
 

 ))
)
<
)

<
 
)
"
 
"
  #"


 %
"
"

)
 #
.




)
& 
,,
)
"
>
%
&  8
 #
"
"




%
. 
 
.

"

"
#  
"
"


 +<

  

)) 
 %
)) 

!"

)
"
#
.

%% 
)
"

   


%


 
;0&
/

5,58,5,

% 
8:/6?

5/
0 
#  

%
 


&"+ 
."

%"
"
"





558,5,
0

 


"

.

"


%% 
 %

.
 "
 
"
"
"




"
"
 #

"


%



 

0

) "
 


"
.
 
"


) 


"

 


"
)


"

 

,/5,5/
)
"



)
"
7

"
)

# #
"
 #
 
"

+

0
.

 


"

 <
  

 <


//8/
"



<
"
0%
? 
)

@!
" # "
."


 #
 
"

)
 #

5/5,5,

 
)
"
 6+
. 
#


".
"
"
 
.
)) 
  

"

)


 
,,5,5
1 
64
# 
,55
%% 
."

%"
"

  

"
"

%
# 
"
 

A
"

 

55,5

A
"
 %

,
<
% 
 

((&
,5

"

 

5,58,5,

A
 

<
,
" 85

 

" )
 %
# 

8
<
% 
 

"

 


((&
,,8


;0&
/

5,58,5,
.
#
# 
"


% 
8:/6?

5/
0 

%
 


&"+ 
."

%"

B# 
.


 %

 <
"
.
 


  # #
"
 
%

 

."

%"
"
).

#
 % #
. 
% %
<
"
 %
 '6
@
%
.


% 
 
)
A7
6:
) . 
<
  
# #  
)
%


%
;0&
/

5,58,5,
@
8:/1?4
5/
0 

 &"+
A <
# 




 
"






"
 
%
0
"


"
"
"



)
>  
% <

 #

0
"


= 

+


%
 
% 
# 
"


0
"


%%  <


"




 

 
)
55,5


 

  



7
,95,,5,
"
 %

5,
<
% 
 

((&

,5

.
 

 
)
 <
%+

5,58,5,
) 
,

 
"
 
%+
)  #
"

)
,
" 

85

 
A

# 
6.

"
 

 )) %
%# 

 
"
% 

%"

 <

6


) 
,

A
.
# 
 %
58
<
% 
 

5,58,5,

((&
',8



#
"


 
 

5858,5, 
"
 <
.

( +
$"+  
"


%
"

#  
# 
%


)
" # "
%
)  #
"


.
"
.





.
%%
 
"

 
"
.
.

%"6))
A7 
% 6:
) %% #
A7 

&"+

"



"

%
;0&

/

5,58,5,

8:/
5/
0 
"

#  
# 






<
%
  
&"+



  # 
"
"






558
,5,
7
558,5,
"
.
  %

"
% 
) ." 
"
) "

)
> 


!"
)  
% %
)
"





1 #
.<
%




 

  4
 #

"

   
D



"
=  
%


%
 "




%%
"
 #


)
 %  
) %

0
.
)
"
 
 
 
"


%
=




% 


&
,,


 %"

) 

 


) 
 

<

) 
"

%


0
"

# <


"


 
)
E

#
.
)"# 

"
*A %
 
% 6:


%







) E 
7&

95,5,
 
"


)) %
"




"
"
 


 
 #

)
58
<
 
 
 %
5/58,5,

%<
)
((&
<
+ <

 

;#6F?F
0
%
"





.



%


%
;0&
/

5,58,5,

8:/
5/

%
 

&"+

558,5,

 <





 6#

.
  %
) 
"
% 
<
"
%% 
%
 
))

558,5,
) ." 
"
.
) "

)
>  


  ;##6F?F




  #
 

)
5/58,5,
0
.
)
 
) 

 



E
)
  



) 
8

 #
 6#
G
& <
"

 #

.


A. 

"

%

%  #
"
"
<
.


 
  
"

%

  <
<
" 


:,5,
1 
684
"
 
 
B #
&"+

"
) 
)
 

%= 
"
%% 
)
"
%" #
) 
# 
"


"<
. 
) % <


7
"

<

9,5,
1 
64


  
.
) 
# #
"
)%
)
"
%= 

"
"
" 


.

"

%=  
) 

"
#

%" 

# <

"
 #

" 

.

" .

A
"


) %
)




 #"

."
.





  
)


 
%


"


"
 

 


. 



"
  
"
"

"
% 

+.
"

%% 
)
"

   

"
%


%
"
"

 #


!"
 
.
>%
<
"
0%
? 
)
@!
" # "

,:5/,58
1 
6/4
<
" #
"
"
.
#

& 
,,
)
"
>
%
& 
8


.
.

"


8
< 
)


%

"
.

  

!"

.



,5,,58
1 
694
<
"
A 
%  <

"
#  
"
"



 

 
)
 " )
"
.


 
 %"
"
!

 
."

%"

 %
"
"
" 
.



%
 +
.

"
"
 #

"
# #
)
"
;0&


!"


)  #
"

% 

%% 
)
"
)%
"
"
!

 
 

%
) % 
 

."

%"
"


)%
% 


%)



."

%"
.

%)


)
"
 #
 
."

%"

  %
 

!" 

  
# #
"
  
"
"
#
%

 
.

"


"



)
  

%% 
)

)) %<
)
"
 
."

%"





"



)

   

A. 

"

.


"
#  
)

% %
 " )
"
"

6 
.
"
)) %<


% %
#






"

)
 #
 #

<
"
% 
 "

<

!"
 
.
 <

"
#  
)
   
)
"
  6 <

"
;0&
/ 
."

%"
"
.

%= 

%% 
)
"
%

 
" 
%  #
"
)

<
 


0
 %"
%

%
.
 
)
"
% 
 
"
"

. 


   .
)
"
.
 
.
<
"

 
*23' ,4"%# 1+,5167' 5%4,8*3,3 ,%#,%$3- 109 
*5:1 2  $513 9'  !"
 
%
.
# #




 %
8
1,4
)
"
   
)
0 



%
)
"
H<

. 
 
.

"

& 
,,
"

 
<
"

) 
"


."

%"

 
% 

"
%%  
"
"

 #

)
 #
" #"
% %"
%  


<

%  )#
)


)



)


%

"
#  
)

% %

.

" 


#
"

<
%" #6" . 



%   
)
"
 
)
%
8
1,4
)
"
   
)
0 

& <
"

.

 

!"


 

"
 

%% 
)
"

 #
.

!"
# 
. 
)

% %

"

"
"
"

.
#"
.

"


%


  # 
"


% 

"
 
.
"
%+#  
)
"



 

& 
 
)
"
 
> # 


 '6
C8
7

%% 
)

"
% 


" )

  
%%  
).
"
"

 #

)
 #
" #"
% %"

%  


<

%  )#
)


)


)


%

"
#  
)

% %
!"

"


.

" 


#
"

<
%" #6 "
.

" 
+ #
)
<
 
)
"

.

" 
#

#
<
   <

".
% 
# 
"
  

)



)


%

.

" 
#

#
<
   <

% 6


"
.





"


"
. 
"

"




%   )
"
 
)
%
81,4
)
"
%   
!"

 #

" )
 


= "


 

.


)
%


 

"


= "


 
"

 #


95
)
"


)


%

.


"
 
)
 

 




% 

 

.
"






"

)
."

%"
"
"

 #
!"


" 
.
.

"
%
!"
 "


%% 

.


<

"
 

."

%"
"

 

%% %
.

"
"



 <

 

<
%


"
 #"
.+
)
"

)
"


> # 

.G


 <

";"/ :: ,/ $7'9<  9 $= 99 >*5?-8"1 *"%@-67'*3,3 $=,1A,%,,%#$3- 17B
% 

55
"



. 
 #

5/599

& 
,,

"

 #

 %"
)
 #
 
"

<
"

 
.
"
.
<

%  )#
)

% 
."

%"
"
+
%

58599

0
.
"
"

.

% 
)

% %

"
"

#


.

"
"
)) %<
)
"


& 
 
)
"
 
 

 '6
C!"

%
"
"
 
)
 #

# 
"
 


 
 %
"
 
 % 



  


%  

# 
" <

& "
."
" 
"<
"
 %"

8 
 #  9
!"

%

"
 %
"<
"
% 
)

"

#


)
6
 
.
  #"

"


" 
"<
 %"
"
" 



)<
"
%

%
)
"
)

 

)  #
"

%

 #
+

% 
# 
& "

0
". 
 
"

"
 # 
9
& "
%  
 
"
 %"

"
 

))
)
"



 <
" )

 #

)
 #
% 



0
 # "
8
)
"
%  6))  
) 

")
)
"

?  %
"


  
 
)
"
. +

% %
)
"

"
 


)
%
%% 
"
"<
. 
 +<

  
)) 
 %
)) 
A. 


"

 
)
"
 # "
) %



"
% 
)
8 
 # 
9



"

%  
.
#
# 
"


% ,

.

"
8
0 

"
 # 
9
"
 = 

"
 #
 
0

"

8 
 # 
9

 
5'85
*
"

"

"
" 
)
"
%  

"
)


"


"
"<




 %"
"
" 

"<
"
)

"

#


)
6  
"

  #"

"
" 
0
<
" 


"
"
 %  
  #
) )


)

 
)
"
 # 
9



 )
 #
 %
"
 %

<
"
 %  
 



<
  
"
%

 
)
"
#
))%
<
"

0

" )
%
)
"
 
)
"
"


)
"
 #
)
"

.
"

% 
)
8 
 # 
9
!"
# 
 
"
"
 


)

$"

. "
+


% 
"
  
. +

% %
)
"



%

#

"
%%  
"
"<
. 
 +<

  
)) 
 %
)) 
<

%  )#

"



)
 #

"
% 
)
8 
 # 
9
0)
"


% 
)
"

 #

"
% 
)

8 
 #  9
0

% <
% 
)

% %

"
"

#


.

"
"
)) %<
)
"






%


% 

>  )<
"
%%  
"
"

. 
 +<

)) 
 %
)) 
0%
)
. +

% %
>  )< #
 %"

) %


) 
"
))  #
.

"
 %
& 
,,
)
"

>
%
& 
;


)
"
 =


)  
)
.
 
,,




) 







. 

."<
  <

%

 
!"
<
%
."

%"
 

" 
. #"
.

"
"
 


)
%

 +

,,




) 






. 

."<
  <

%

 
!"
<
%
."

%"
 

" 
. #"
.

"
"
 


)
%

 +

,,
 


"
% 
)

8 
 # 
9
;
"
"
 
% 
.

"

 
=

<
)

% %
)) %<


% %
 
.
 )) 
"

#
E

" )
)
"
 
"
"
 


)

$"

.

.

>  ) 

 + 
,,
)
"
>
%
& 
8
;
"
 

"

 #
 
)
#

/"
 # 
9

# 
"
"



%

  
!"<
 


= "

E
= "
"



%
"
"

.



6





%
.

"
) 
%+
.#
) ".

"
!"<
.




 

%  


%


%=  
) 

)
"
 
)
 #
"



# 
" 
!"

.




 

"
%
)
"

"

 #" 
!"

 
.
%% #<G
0
"
 
%
"
 
 #
 
."

%"
"


  %
. 
% <
".
"
"
 #

.


%% 
)
"
# #
)
"
;0& 
."

%"
"
"
 = <

%= 

0
"
.
 

) 
) 
"
!

 
"

"

+
"



 <
  
 
"


<
"
0%
? 
)
%
."


 #
"


>

 % 
!"
 
)



//8/

." <
"
"

#

5/5,5,

%% 
)
"
)%
"
" 
.


 
   
."

%"
"
"






>  
% <

  <
.
%= 

,,5,
.
# 

7
%% 
)
"
%= 
"
0%
? 
)
%

,5,5
.
"
  

"
"
"
 

.
 

"
) 
)

". 

 >%

"
)%
"
"
. 

#
<


 

%% 
)
 <

.%
)   


& 
 
)
"
 
 

 '6
C9
!"
 %
.
 



,5,55

.
.

"


"


< 
)


%


  
!"

 


)
%
1746
% 


0&$
" # "

<
 + #
. 

"


 
& 
,,
)
>
%
& 
 #
"
 %
)


%
)
)

#

 
"
"


 +<

  

)) 
 %
)) 
!"
.
%
)
 %
 
% 
<
"
 %

  
)
"

% 
 


<
 )) 
0
"
%
"
"
 %
 
. 



)


%

"
 
)
# 

 
 % #
"
# 
" 


 < > # 
)
"
AF

%
= 
<
"
 % 

 

"
)%
)
"
 
%
0
) 
"
"
 
)


<
"

7
D
 0&$

"
 % 


1."
"
 #
 
. 
4
.
= 
 





"
.
A. 


  
)
"

%  <

% 
 %  <
"
)%
"
"
 %
"

%= 
<
"



% 


% <
"

 


)
 %
"
% 
# 
"
%% 
1 %4
!"



% 
 
 
.

"
"

% #
)
"


 

% 
88
)
"
  

 %"

%

#
"
  

" <

 
"

)
 #

5/656,5,
!"
 %
.






#
<


 

%% 
)
 <

.%
)
"
  #



)
"

)
 #

"

)
% 
> #
A. 

"
 
.



% 
)  
)
<
)  

<
%G
0
 %"
%

%
.
 
)
"
% 
 
"
"
0%
? 
)
%
."




 #
"
  

,:5/,58
1 
6/4
 
+
"


)% 



%
 #<

" )
 
)
%

)
"
   
)
0 
. 

% 
<


"


"
 
0% ? 
)
%
."
"

"

)
>% 
"
%
)

 

,:5/,58

"
.
"
 
))
."
"

"


 

& <

.
%% 
.
)
"
"
  
 
)  


A. 

+ .
"
)%
"
"
 #
.

%% 
)

 
  

.


%% 
)
"


  
"
"
.

  

"
 
%
"
 
%

"
 

<
<
%+.#
)
"



"

 
)
 <

;
"
 
  
.
%
)<
<

"
> # 

,%!--$#4" -,3514" -,?$1  ;7' *5: 1"%3 %# %3 %@"% 10 54,1,3 / !31"!"3A

$,1#0 "22,3%,@,1 54,1,30 99  * <

%"$% $=
%#",,%#$3- 1767',":,/*"%@-0 C*

& 
 )
"
> # 


,":,/ 75:1,


 '6
C7

% ) 
% 
)
"


"





% %  #
"
> # 

 
  #"



.
 
)
"
.
"

.
%%
"

>% #

% 
 
 

"
"

"
.

" 
 

" ) 


%  
<
% 
)
.
<
"


 

%  

  #
 %

% "
%  

)
"







) 
% ) %<
% 
" ) 

 


  #
 %

.
7
# #
"

 #"
"

.


%) 
#  
.

"
"
.
+

I/J


/58
1  4
0)
 %  
."

%"


<
 
%= 
)
"
 
%% 
.

"
"

<
 
)
 "
 )) 
% 
<



7
"
"
" )


% K
"
 <


  %
 
#
  


%


%


) 
% % 
<
"



%
"
#
%= 


 = <
"
 
%

<


) 
) 
.

"
)
" #
+
"

 
)


 %
"
.
 #

 
% %
)

))%



+
 




 



%
= <
"

# 


"
%  

)
"

 

<
% % #
 
 
%%
.

"


.
!" #"
% 
+

"
 
)
"



% 6

 
%

  

"

"



6  


)
"

"
"
 
 #
.

%% 
)
"
%


 % #

% % <
"

 
.
.

"


"

#"

<
%+
.#

"

)
"



"
.




%
!"

%


 

<
)
"



) ."

%"
"<
% 

  
)
"


%
)
"

!"
A #"
 
 .

%



#  


.

#
%+
.#

.

" 
  #


 %"

 
%

% 
= <
"

)

"
A #"
 

)




%
< 
)
%+
.#

 




" <

 


!"

.



 

%+
.#
) "

)
%= 

%
)
"
 
)
< #
"


% 
< 
)
%+
.#
"




.



% 




)


.

" 
<
 +
!"
6

 )

 <
 



)
"

)
"
#"
 
.




.

"


"

<
<
)
<




!"


.

 
)

"
 





" .


* 
&"

" %
 % 
) "


% 
"
%)


"
 
)%
"
"
.



%

<
%+.#


%% #<
"
 
.


 
.

!"
 )
 #

5:5/,5,
1 
64



,:5/,58
1 
6/4
,5,,58
1 
694

<
"
 "



"

)
"
!

 

55,5/
1 6,4

"


)
"
.
 

,959,5:
1 6/4
 

 

!"
.


 


.

"






)
,
"
) "
% 
)
% ) 
%<
)
"


 

A
. 

 

#

 
) 
%  #


<

'*'*)
  



+


''   



 E""
+ # 
'
L






E""
& 
'
L