High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9469/2017allowed

Sudha And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2019-05-22Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa7 pages

" #$

!"#$%& '()*+& *&'+"& )+",!

!+")

() **+,-" %

( '

( . +(((+ #$( '

((.(' +,-" (/0( *&'+"& )+",!

!+") '

-. 2 % $ "* ) 3 ' 4

- 3

#$ 2 5( %6 -4% "

(07*) -- "" ) .4 /8(8(/79:(

22+ 3 %-,*6 " ;

-- <( $ ,

% /:(8(/79:$:

(' ;

-- <2 3 3 4 -6-*$

3 ( =977 % - 3 2 ' + 2 - 2**"( %-*+**"

*- -%* -$6 " "**% 4

*"2- -,4*%* # ( 2 4, %*$ 3 $6 (34*$ --4$ # >(' "**2 36((/8(8(/79:( (/7/8(8(/79:

2 3 4 " 4*%((

"- %6" ? ?

@( ' 4

?4 "$6" 2 * 3- - % $ %% ?

0* 322 % ( " $ %*, 4% 2 44%

% -4% "4*644$

$, 3 ,) 6 2 % $ "*(

% -, 3$

+# 2 4 $*"" $ "*$6 *% 3 3 +((, + (( ((5+ ( %*6 $ "

)%*- /8(8(/79:2 -- " *-*46 2 2 4 "** *- -2 2- **- -%** -4 32 ( $ 2 3*3 - % " % --

-2 4%*-- " 2- % , "

"-4% ( * " %

,4 *6 3 - %% 3*3 - % " ( - ) - 2 3 "? A - "*- -%*( 4 "- "** 3" % 2 *% 3" *- -%*

"*- % -** 3*3 - % " - - ""-* " (2 " $4 ) .4 ;- <2 >=6

"34" 2

( *- 4 *6 -4" - 2

(9@+777A 44 , 4 ( (9 2" %

(/ 0(( 3 2

/ %

3 -+** %

2 -4%**6 % % ;- <( * 3 4*6 3-" -- " 3*3 - % " 2- 4 *6" 2 $ 6% % *6*)" ** "

*- -%* -- "3 , 3*- % *"" -B $ * (

- + - * % 3 %% % 6 4 % $6, 3, 4

4 2 4 $6- 3"

-- " # --

- ) %*- /:(8(/79: -- ""** 32 "*- -%*2 -"

( *" % ,$ * 3 %* 3

- ,$ % , -" - "-01 23- 4- 5

) 316 4-7 8

* - "*- - +2 % -*4 3 -4% 2*$4 $* -*4 - $ *3 -,* (2 " *-4% 4 $

% % -%* *2 ' !-* -+9=CC( %?

&.-:

$-;

)4.

230-7

-0. / * *- -6 *$* %6 -4% , - 2 2 3*3 - % (

*, ? -"#34 "**2 &

! "#

$ !

, 3 "- " % - + 6 3 - 2 $6*- -%*"** - /:(8(/79:2*2 % - 3 4 -6-* --

-- "3 , #

* "( 2, $ ) -- "2 4+$3 "** *- -2 - D *6 *- -%** "**2 -+ 3*3 -

% " $ 2 -" *-*46 $6 - *"""-* " ( + 3-

" 3+% %-"-D 6 - * % 3 2 6"- " 3 D 6$ - - - 2 6 " 3 $ - 2 3 % - %- , 3$ -

3 - A""? "*- -%*( *

% 3,(E-* *64 3 ) 2 4 *6%% % 6 " 3 "-4% ( % + , 3"** *- -2 -- "3,*-62 * *- -%*-4 32 % 2*2 % - 3 4 -6-*( ""- $ , 2 $ 6 "

,- -% - %- "** *- -%* **$6 " )** - -

6% - 64 % , -*) - (2 $6 -4% " 6 -

$#-46 ,

2 - "**% *- -2

6" ** "*- -%* A " 4

-( - A ** + -+"*- -6%* -( $"

D 3 2 -, * (' "** 3" *- -62 - $--% ,* "

*- -%*-4- 32 ( 2*, * 3 - *"** 3"*- - %* - 2 -- " 3*3 -

$$* **6 ( *"

6" --

-- "

# - - ( + -+ *$*%6-4% % "- % -4*2 $6, - - ;

% <-4% 4 2* D $

% % -%* *2 " 2 3-4% '

!-*-+9=CC( %

, 3"- $>= 6

" (2, + ' 4 %

$6,* %*+ ?

>+3"-

$ "*- @/6

%% ?4*6( 2*--%3 "- + -+$@/6

" % "D "6 3 -4% 4 (%

,-*4- 2

(9@+777A % 4 2* 3.

6 %(2, + 4 *A-4 ,$ %% * 322 % %*- - $ -%*( 46+"

) .4 ) %*- /8(8(/79:( 2 4 3 "4*6 -

3" 2" 2-* +22 %

3 - ( % 0"2 % -3 -, 4 3 "

- 2 %

3 - 3 #$ ,

6+ 3 2 "-* "- - 4%

- -+ - '4- (*

$ ,- 2 %6 3" - " -* ( -- -4 - + 2*$ " $*--%,

3 4 *6 -4"- $

(9@+777A ( * -4 "- + -+

(9@+777A % 4 ( %

3* "

$6%?

# $ %&'

$ )"* &

*"+

,'',

) 3 3"- $@/6

" +97F -4 3 2 " % %- ( 9A0 - 2*$4"

4 -42 %

* *, 3?% "

- (.% 3 ,23"- 4*%* "99 2*$%%*$6"**2 3-4"%? )'

) (" &

*" ('

."* / # #

*"+ 0 ,,

-- 3*6+ -4% 4 %6$* $6

"**2 &

( ( *-* 9( * -4% 4

(9@+777A

/( 97F - -42 " % %-

(9@777G9@77H

(9:+@77A

0( 9A0 - 2 %

* *, 3 ?%

9:+@77I00FH

(@>>@A

9:+@77 @>>@H99+7@@A

>( 4% " %%*6 34*%* "99 99+7@@?9/H9+0/+::7A

; * -4< 9+0/+::7?99H9>+@=+/:7A

@( *

(9>+@=+/:7A

-4% 4 4 **$%6$* %

2 % "24 "

4" -%" - "-%6" #34 ( -4% 4 2*$%% "**2 &

;< @7F((

(8+/=+:07A ", "% (9$ 322 "- ;< * -4 "@7F((

(8+/=+:07A $ * D*

((

(0+:>+C9@A - ", "%

(/ 0(( 3 "- % **2 " (

*&'+"& )+",!

!+")

'(,&

*-)6 E %) 3A & A E % $*& A