Rama Nathan And ORS v. Meet Lal And ORS
! "#$%&!'()'*+ &!&,"+**%
!"# $
!
$ !"# %!& !&,"+**%-( '$ #
(
)(* $ # !!,-$##(!.
'(,/
0% ( $ 1$ '(,/
1 ( * ! ! $ 2( 0$ ) ( "$(#/
##(!$ )%
# & & '$'(,/
!(# ! 3 45 !!/#!6+ !%
7% ( & %
% ! ! # %/! !%!#- $ / 8 459 !!((
/ 45 7% /
! % ! 45 ##/ !!
)(*
# ( 45 % - +($ ( $ 6 % / $ !
%(( (
(:
( ./ $
$ /, (!$ $'(,/
*(", //%%#$7 6($ (*$
;/!* <1, $%7./ ! " # $%&' &(% '$ !# ! + /
(!
$ !2$ <+ $ - * $( ##/# $ !
((, (+/ !, 3($
(*$ ;/!* <1, $ %7 ./ !) ! * ) + ,* - - #$%%./'0 / + *0112 $5=/!*,#$!#((( )3,)
44 #$%&'&$5' !4,6* + , - 3,) ! ) # $%&5/'0 / + *0 ((1 $ /, ((
! ,- #/ ( $ #
!!/!#"(
$ !!$ # ./ $ (/ # # - $ # - +/ ! /*$ $
+($* !* //%%#(%!(* #(! ( , > * ?#$ <1, $ 0/% ./ 9!( (# $#
,
+!, //%%#
/%(* //%%#
*+($( ( - $/ ! ,!(,/!$#
!$
-,!%(!( (7! @%(#(%(
$!#((,-$> *?#$9/%% $ #( $$ (!/%!% !,-<1, $0/% ./ * , 7 )-8 6 ! 3*9* %(( 0%#(
> "%%
.("( 3&4 A($ * ! ( ( ( */! $ $ '(,/
$ (*$ - & $ , ( % !9/%% $#( $$ (!/%;/!* <1, $ 0/% ./
!:,* 4" # * 7 *, 7 6 #$%&;$(%%
& 9$ "$ !#/ $% ( %/!$% %5,) (#/
-$ !% !,-$'(,/
'$'(,/
+!, (# ((#
// %%# '$
# $ $ B/( +($ * ! // %%# ( %!(* #(! ( , > * ?#$ $ %7 ./(/
(#(!-$ (!, ((
$;/!* ( ;$
! $1 # /% ( "
(! (! 0
$ % (/ # # - $ $
/ %(* !!(( // %%#
*+($($(B/(!,!%(!( (7! @%(#(%(
$!#((,-$> *?#$,- -(*/%! !
! &% !,-<1, $0/% ./ $
!" ,;#! 9 0 $ C$ !
1 # /% $
% ! , $0/% ./+ )%%!(*!/#
(#(*!#((
!!(#(+($* !!%(+
! (( / $(./+/ !, (
-!(%(* $
$(/ ## - % (( * ,- -(* /% ! !
! &% !,-$0/% ./ '$( ,(* $ ./ $ ( , !%! ( $ *("
# !#(#/ #90
$./(
,(*/( (-($%# # "$(#/
##(!#
(!!+# (%(#(% +($* ! ( !!/#( //%%#'$./$ !$ ;/(#
! ;/
B/
(- ( #(#- $/*$( !;/!(#
( !/( (-($!#((5
)(*%# !$!#((A$( (
-,%(, $ "
$
(#
%#(( (!(#
! ( (* # (
(
#$/ ! ! !($
*A$$
#4(%/ $
!$
*
%(#(% $
#(#- !/( (- !!("*# )( $/ !, $ / !;/!(# ( (" ;/ # ( 9 !(
'(,/
#
#/
#
#/
(!(
-$
# $#
$ ((* $#
+(
,# /! %% 7! !,+( !! $ ( (*( (# !("*#
* '(,/
( ! ((* $ B/ / # ((
# (+(
!!(5 (
#(
!!(/($- 9$ # <1, =/!*+##(/ $
# ! $ /
(!%+$( !
(*+($$B/( !!/#($7 6,- )(* "(+$ $ $
+(
,#(!! !%!> ($
C/
(1# $
(+)!/(0
+
( !+($
!!(($ (# * !(/% - (%#(" 0#( 88 8&5/!+$(#$$#
# ($ ,
! ( $ (!(# ! ( $ 0#! 0#$!/ $ $(# # 33/,;###( %(! /(# 8 $ %% !(0
$/ ! ,
+!0(
$!#(((D0$ )/
$%7./(/ >
= !$# $ $ !(%
B/!$/5 '$
((* B/( ( - ( '$ <(*$ ./
+(*0 $@"(/% $ ) & $ (A$$ $ ($/ !!%!$ * $!%!
$ $ ! $ ,$ *(* ( ( F,/$ $ ,*(" B/(/ ,- $ $5=/!* ?#$ !#(( ( $
C/
( /% 9+ $ !$ $ ((,/!+($ #$
* ! ,$ $(# (-+($ * ! $ ! ,/
$ !%!
( ##! $+(
-, !(%/ +$$$ *
$ ! -/* " $ " * # ( , ) ' B/ E&890
$(./$ ! "/!( -$ $+(# 77#( !%!#-
! ! ( ( # ( ( #
! /! 0#( 88 9 $ , (*$ - ! ( 0
$ $
( # ! $ #
$ %/% / ($ * !F,(# !F !#$/ , !%!
' (" $ !%!#- $ '(,/
/ #(! (
!!((4!!/#(,
! ("(* $(# F(( $!!/#(,
!+ !$%
("(*7% !F ! ((( $ ( , %% (! +($ # $ ! A ! $() ( ( # - /"(($
+$%( + (
* +($$"(+(0
G 9"(+ /#( (
+
(!!+(0
/% ! $ ;/!* !! ,- $5=/!* ?#$ ( $
C/
(1# !/ >
= $1# 9 (! (!(
(#/ ,%/ !!,-$/, (( #/ $(/ # -$ $'(,/
## ( % * ! ( %
# $ "(#( $(
$ ! + $ - * %%%( ( ( $ #(#/ # +/ ! , 3 ( %
# &
+(* , ( (# ( (# // %%# %% -(* 3
!%!#- ( #
#/
!
3845 H&3
345 3 &45 /!! 7 7 3 I
45 6 // %%#J
38456!!/#(+ !%
7%K L!#"(
$ !
/ 45 !! ,-$'(,/
7%!(/ /
! % ((
( ! '$ $ !( !!
/ 45 "
#( !$#
$
,( !
/ 45 9 "(+ ,"
# ( # & 38
$ $ #! ( 8 845
& 3845 5 45 '$ $ #! # ( $
-( $ 6% / $!
%(((
(:
( % - 7# /(" - $ !'$$ #! ( $
, !%(! ( (7! @%( #(% ( (
(:!, ) %(! - '$
(% -
+!($
(! 4 &&#$%&; 3460 M@2/
(N A$$% )(*4 ! -4 A$$% -4