High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4839/2023dismissed

Sandeep Sood v. M/S Bagga Singh And Sons And Others

2023-12-13Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti10 pages

$%% %& !

( )*$+, !

-.!/0, (( -/ $(//0 # $ %& ' !%(")*% + '! $ %,%$%-' %(")*% + ' .....

(( -/ $(//01 - 00 '% %!!-*% /* 0 + !-%*

* "'! "

4* % 1)"+%1+' *" "%"565756% "585756% "

' % 9 " '%!!-*% '%9 %--:"% "

% " % %; * "

$% ""!"+

'! /% "!/"+-"*)- ) *- +' + "%%1% 9! 1 " "%"5756 !%"<&-%

" )- "12 ) 4(= "'% % )-/ >>?8+56-"% /% "!/")$@%11%/

/ (% "

! " '%'!

'%"+-" +

! % 1'"+ "% (' %1 (%

&( )% (*+ 9 + 1 !%*+ -! "! 1'9 + 9'!

&9% 1?>8A% "<% 1B'% % 9<

%"% --%1% %+/%"% ('-% " *= "'% %%- 1:'

"% & " * 1'"+ "% % "'% ") ' 1 %-%1 9 @-9 "%"556'! ++ %- 1:' -++! + 9" & %9! 1' %" -9 @%1 9 "%" 556 =%

" * - + ' <9"'%'!

'%"!

*'%"'!

& )" 1 " %- "" "%" 855> % " 9 % :% %- % " '+%) '"+ "% % ": ! + ' !

& % % ' !

) :

(05(55(555@:% % 1%1% "+ "% % "+ ' -%8&% '' *-+'! : %--& 1 ' & A '9% :%-"<: '!% :'' ) + !%-B '% :%-"'%'! :-- *-%9'%+ %" %' ''%--!%&% ' 9+ ?5(55(555@ "+ "% % " - +)%*% 1'!

&'!

'%"1) 05(55(555@"+ "% % ":'*':%!%"%+

:'"

%: 1'%9 + 9 %** :%+ ' -"'%' :--!%&% ' 9+ 5(55(555@"+ "% % " + :'*' 0(55(555@: !%" *%'% "<%-% *+ 0(55(555@: !%"'

1'*'A ' + (%%-+ ?5(55(555@: !%" ' <%+%"-9 "%"556 !

% *+'-9

6 '"+ "% % ")%*%"'!

9% "'% "") ' ! '!

565756('"+ "% %- 1:'

9 % *%- -9 " "! ' ! + 9 ' & A "+ ' % (' + !

:%+-"'*!&+!-% % "%&%!!-*%

% "

!*)-&'-%

" %- %+ %!!

*% 1'+%*+'*% % "'"* 9 (1 % "3!% +% A +%) +' )" "%"505756:'*'

6'*!& + *9!

9@-9 "%" 556

8 ' < 1:

+'!

&'%"+-" /*

6+% ,%<

<% * *(>8>%1% '"+ "% :'*':%! 1 *5+ '3* +*9!

9(' %" :%:'"

575756'*!&+

"%">585

0% "*!&+ "%"575756

? ' @"+ "% '%"%-+-"% +

"*-% % " '&% 55% "%&:%1 % " ' %"*)- '*!&+ )-/ "%"5555

% "*!&+%& "%"55>58

7/ *'9%

:% -" <: ' !% % ! -9 @%1 9 "%"

5562

84(' %"+:'"

%: ' 2

49%"%%9 <+ ' " & 1' %"*9!

9'*!&+ "%"5>5756

> ' +-"%!!-*% + )%*% 1'%& "%"

505756 ' +-"<&'! ++'%"%!!-*%

5 ' -%

" %- :' %!!

*% 1 ' !* -% +%*% "* * 9% *+'*%)%*%"'%&1 % "

8 +%) + ' ! ++ <& !% 1 9! 1 " "%"

5756 ' %+ ( ' !

! +-" ' !

*)-

) ' -%

" * - + ' ! % 1 " '% ' 9! 1 " !%" <& ' -%

" %- :' % & , +*% ' 9 + -9 @*9!

9 "%" 556 2

84:--< %'9++ %-%", "*% +'*% ' * *%-9 +!

) -1% :'-+- 1' +

! +%*'!

! + & A ' <% + *9!

9 "%" 556 2

84 ' !'1 %!' + ' ! %<-' ' !

'9% %-+%*% "'"* 9 '%) < %--&1 ":'-!% 1'9! 1 " "%"5756 <9"'%'%+ %" :' , +*% "' %99%&; "-&<%"% "'%&%!!-*% <"*""

9 6

' ' '% "( ' -%

" * - + @"+ "% % 1 "'%'! 9 "'!

*+-%:<& * *%- 19% %-+%*:%$@%11%/ "/ (%!% '!

+ 9'

1'/'%: / 1''%"+-" + "*-% % %- 1:'

! %1% ! B 9% % " ' :'*' ' /% "!/":%%

%&"%"+ "% 7'*!& +!-%

'%"*)- (%!!-*% + %&

6> -% " %":'/* 0 :%+-"% "'%& %!!-*% :%"*"" ' +%) <&!% "%"55>58 :'*'

7 %-%"'%/% "!/"'%"+-"

0 ,*9 %1% $@%11%/ "/ /* 6+ % ,%<

<% * *(>8> '&% 5'*!& +,*9

0''*%: ! 1<+ "++ * % " ' !

*" 1 : 1 1 *9!

9@-9 :% %

)" % )" *9!

9 "" "%"

5562

84 +%*%+%;"* 9 % "' 1 %- + ' %9 '% < !

" *" <& ' ! ' !

+-"% ' *)- ; 1! %:--% "% & %1% $@%11%/ "/ "' %1"<% %& "%"505756<&* *%- 1'!

) -1% :'*':%%- %"&1 '!

" '"! "*9!

9@-9 "%"556+ '+ 9 1'!

*" 1+*)- +-"<&$@%11%/ "/

5>5756 :'*' :% *%1 *%--& " " <& ' '

-)% C9 "%"5>5756

> % 1 "'%) %+ '%--1"*9!

9@-9 "%"556('!

*" 1 '*)- * "'!

:'"

:',*9 ' %< *( ':

+%* *'*9!

9:%)

)"%' '

*)"% &%9 '% "") ')%*% ! +''! '!

+%*'! '

1'% *%--9 *%9' '!% ""%9%1"' !

&% "-% ! ' -*;

''!% 1'9% "' %+ (1'!'1 %!'*-*;" %<-''! *%' :%% &*9!

9@-9 "%"5562

84%*-%9"<&'!

( ' :% % %;+ *<-! %:%*%! "

*%9 % '! "

)

+%"+%1%- !-%&" ' *-% +&'+%* %-! '-1'+%+ %"

* * 9% *('% A "%"505756:% 1'-&)%*%" '%!-%*" * "'!'1 %!' 1% 1+ *<-"!

'%!!-*% + !-*'-!!

*'-+% -< &

6 '1 % "! "-9 "%"

55613%9 "+ 9% ":

1% " 1 3! % ' !

? 9!-% :% %- +-" <+ ' $%1 %+ 1 % + :'*'

% 1 "'% '-%

" )- "12 ) 4(= "'% %'% 1'-&!%"' "%"5756% "" A % & + *' + ( '*)- ) !

"<&'!

:' 9 8 '%)* " "'% 1 9 %")% *"<+ 9% " '%)*% + --&1 '

1''"* 9 * "%9% +

* "'%+ -&($@%11%/ "/ (%!% '!+ 9'

%: / 1' +' 1 "!% +-" + "*-% % ! 1% 1''!(: ;'!(1":

%"%-"

' !-% %1% ! B 9% % " ' *- " 1 ' !

/% "!/":':%%

%&"%"+ "% 7 '%"

*)- :%+-" '&% 56 !&+'!-%

$@%11%/ "/ '%)%-+-"%!!-*%

6> - % " %":'/* 0 (:'*':%%--:")" "%"

55>58:'*'

7 ' %+ ('!

/% "!/"+-",*9 /* 6+% ,%<

<% * *( >8> + ' )* + $@ %11%/ "/ + 9'!

&9% 1?>8A&% "!% +

&%"%-" '! '*!&+,*9

0 1'! *&+%+ %"-1% ('!

/% "! /" *-%9" '% :' ' ) + !%- '% ' 9% :% %--1"-& *9!

9" )" *9!

9@-9 "%"556:'*'

8 ' ! %-+%"*9!

9@-9 2

84 "*%'%%+

*) 19 &%"%-" '%"*9!

9($@%11%/ / '% "") ! +'!

& +%) +! /% "!/"% ":%%-"*""<: '9:'"

%:'*% :'*': +-"%1% %*'' '%+ %"*9!

9@-9 "%"5562

84" "<&$@%11%/ "/

% ":%*-%9"'% 9 &:% *)"<&'9' '& '% "") '! +!

9 +%) +/% "!/"

' :%% &-9 1% 1:'"

%:%-+'*%+-"%1% %*'' '! %-+ * "':'%',*9 +-"

<&/% "!/":%:'"

)" "%"575756'*!& +%"

? '! %-+ "%"5>5756 2

>4 "*% '% :' /% "! /" *-%9" ' *9!

9@-9 "%"556( + "*-% % '%9 :%" "<&$@%11%/ "/ '

1'' !% %:

/ 1''*!&+C9 "%"5>5756

1'-&! " <&'-%

"* -+ ' '%"! '%--1"*9!

9"%"5562

84('!

*" : 1 ' + "*-% % "'*9!

9@-9 :% ) %--1"!

5>5756+ ' 1'-&! " '% ',*9 :%:'"

<&'! 5>5756%

7 '% '!

*+ :% 9% ;" "9"-&( ' :%%& "%"55>582

74 +%) +$@ %11% / 1' % " / ! ' %+ %" -1% ( ' !

+-" + ! "9% "% &

%1% $@%11%/ "/ '*!&+!-%

'*!&+%&%!!-*% +-" '%"*)-

% '3!% % A "%"505756 +%) +/% "!/"

6 '*!&+!-% 2

4('!

++ <%" ' *% ' <% + "! "

*9!

9@-9 "%"556 !% %6+'!-% ( :%9 "'%D *' 9-% !

*" 1'!% ' '%9 <,*9% ' ! '%< "*""

<&% & +-%:3*!'!

) -1% <: '!% :'*' '%" :'"

% ! *9!

9E ' !*+*

+ *+' + "*-% % +-"<&$@%11%/ "/

,*9 +-"<&/% "!/":'*':%:'"

"%"575756' @"+ "% :'-"! ' 9+*9!

9"%"5562

84'%" -" !

+%1 * "" % :'*':%" -&!-%&" ' ': 1 ' 9%

:'*' 9 % *%- ! " ' & A "'-*;:%! ''!% 1'9% -% '!'1 %!': 1*-*;" + +'%"'! =%

"* - !

1' 1-&" "

'3* +%"*9!

9@-9 "%"5562

84% ":%%--1"'%:%%+%;"* 9 '-%

"* - + '%)%-!-%*" * " ! +% ":

> 1 3! 2

?4 ' +-"%!!-*%

"%"5757562

5)%*%'%&1 % " +%) + '! ++

6> -8 :'*'

% #

'-%

" %- <& -& 1 ! '9% %-%)%-%<- <+ ' !%" ' 9! 1 " "%" 5756 :'*' *'%-- 1" <& +- 1 ' !

*)- ) ' % ' *& + *9!

9@-9 "%"5562

84%:--%'

! +% ":

1% " 1 3! 2

?4*% <

1 ' !

*" 1 + )- / +-" <& ' ! ++ /9-% -&' :'*'!-%&" ' :--<%!!

*%""

' %-+'*% ''!% :--< A "-%"'

!*))" *!

)' ) 1'! *&+'

5 ( <"&*% <! 9"%;'-%: ':

'% "' + ( 'A *+) % "'"* 9 *- " 1 !-%&" '

<1 "%'%1 ' + ( 9& ! ' 9! 1 " "%"

5756!%"<&-%

" )- "12 ) 4(= "'% % " A % & + *%'%1% "'%9%** 1-& !'-"% "'*)- ) !

"<&'!

++ %** 1-&"*- " 1%!!-*% 24(+% &('%--%-% ""!"+ 656 (( -/ $(//0 # $

-.2, F'' !%; 1@ % "# @ F'' ! %<-# @