← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9503/2017allowed

Neeraj And ANR v. Vice Chancellor Pt B D Sharma University Of Health Sciences Rohtak And ORS

2017-09-27Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari15 pages



        

    !  "#"$%"&'(    

     

   





! 

 

" #           "#"$%"&'(   $

  

   





!

 

" # )*" &"+,#,'(      !( -.!

 ///.

 % & '#"  (#  

 ) *+,-.,/0  " #  1) .,0/0.,/0

& '

  (#  

  ) .,0/0.,/0

&  2 (#   " #  / -

&

'

&! (#  2

&  "#&!(#   " #  3+

//.  0   " #5  #"  ) *+,-.,0/0 .,/0

 5



" # 2 6

 # 2# ,.

,+ .,/07(8 +9

"  





$ : #5"    7: 9 5 2 " #  # 2 #      2 

  &# "  "" 

       #  &!      " 

      ##   /.

,3 .,/07(8 39

;  ) .,0/0.,/0  <  56

  6 =  # 2

 #

= " 

 

# 6

 $ 2    >

 

#2 #

!

 

-##  # 6

6""  # ? 6

   6 !  ) *+,-.,/0

#



     



 

 

#  1@.,/12# -, ,* .,/1 7(8 /9  "  #5

"   

6

  " # 

 # 

    #     "" 5  2 ,0 // .,/1   #   5#  # #  ., // .,/1 

   

 2 8 ## -, /.

.,/17(8 39 (5

+-+"   

+2 : =2

#" " 

)

  2 # /.

,.

.,/02

 #

" " #   2     #  "      # # -, ,.

.,/07(8 .9  4 " " #   #

 5#    .-

# 2 

  &!    #    5#       3    >  " 

 $ 7"  ) .,0/0.,/092   /,

 ## 2#  #    .> ,- .,/0  # 

   2  2  8#   

  8  #      .* ,- .,/0  " 5 

  #  

  '"5    2 

  # #

 2

 2##2

"  2    3+5

+"   # # 

   ##% A;4B ;B)4:?;CC +-+ :4:?4(?? B (B 4;B  ;B  (4  :

  @ B44 @1@.,/1 )B BBC;4B:&&;44BB ::&:?4B;B (BCC: <:??;B   ( &(;B ;4D :?B(C4;BB :4(':.> .

.,/0/ - .,/0 - - .,/0  1 - .,/0  0 - .,/0  > - .,/0  * - .,/0  /, - .,/0 /+ - .,/0  /0 - .,/0  ., - .,/0  ./ - .,/0  ..

- .,/0 .0 - .,/0.> - .,/0.* - .,/0(-, - .,/0    2       #  ##       #

2 

  6  )   -1*0 +++>1.*>1+/+0,+0#0/+0 .,/0"#5

 <6

6# 5     #5

$"  

/$ 

11  )* )2"

)'&,&)*"#

)*3"$-#)2" /

/,0+-* $ "  :;( (&B '&( .

/,33/> $ "  ( ;4(B;

(&()  -

/,+.1.

$ " 

::E(  BB

/,+>3, $ "  BB (E D;4( +

/,3/>/ $ "  &'B (; C;C (& ;

  

   

 "   

  #   5 ""   



 # 2##

#

#



 ## 52 " #  3+ '#     /.

 4  "

 # ##%

   A$"  

/$ 

11  )* )2"

)'&,&)*"#

)*3"$-#)2" /

/,0+-0 $ " 

::E( '&( ;

BCBB '&( .

/,13-3 $ "  ;( (;

(4D(;

;$ -

/,0+-* $ "  :;( (&B '&( 

/,33/> $ "  ( ;4(B;

(&()  +

/,+.1.

$ " 

::E(  BB   %4 ##   #   /.6 ""# # 

  $  "      6

 " ##  5#      #  6

     "    #  D 

 (

 :

  

2# " #

5#    # #6

 " 

2

  2 !5# &2 

2 2# -, - .,/0 $

 ?



6

=#5#    # #6

"

 " 

"  D 

(

 2



 " #" #



2=# 6 ###$"   6 # 

2 ##

 

""# $"  



  @    6 # #5

   

  "  2  "       6  #  55

#

" #

  5

2 "  



##

#   " 5 5   .- ,3 .,/02 

2

"  2 #   ,- ,+ .,/0 ( #5  #   2# ""   

  ' #  

;

2

  #6

" # 



   " !2

  #6

  "  (

 2  " ##  6    " 

  #  

  "  $#   #  

 "   2

6" ## 2 

##  #""#

 # 

 5

 2

" " #  ##

B 6   

 " #

=#  

 "   2

32 !5# # #5 

 2   2#    -, ,- .,/0  #  6

# 

  "  $#   2

3# #2 ## 4  #  #   6 ##   

   " # 

  

"   2" ##



26        

  ""  5 

  

  

#5



  

 2 5 

  2 ##5" ##2 

## #

   

  "      4   ""    

  #   ,.

,+ .,/0

" " # 22

#2 ,3 ,+ .,/0  2

  #"#  " " #    !

"

3 2 !5# 25 

#

" ##



 

65

  #

2 5 

 #

 #

  

&   7) *+,-.,/09 

6

" " # ##

= 



  #   .> ,- .,/0#



 #

  

6 2# .* ,- .,/02 2

# 8# B

2



< 22

2 2#  -, ,- .,/02 2

# 8#

# #



#6

 " 





#    # 6 !  #  #



  

 5  2  #

&    7  ) .,0/0.,/09     5# 

56

 

5 #

$#   

  2  # #  .0 ,- .,/0  2    

 

   

 #  

-, /.

.,/1#



 # 6 !

 #  

 2 4    56 #

2 "  =  #6###=

" " #  #6 2# 

$ 7"   ) .,0/0.,/092    > #!

  #5

 #5 "#" 

#5

("8 

  

 !    " #$

  % & '(

)

&  ""5



 #

  



 5

" " ""  

25  

" #

=  

#""#

#  #  

#" " # 2 5 #



 #6 #  #5 "# "  '* +* ,# - ! . $   /0 0     

  %&  

& &!  C#         

  "  " #  

 ##" 

#5

("8   .

-  ! *1 (22  %& 

#

#5

( 6#5    3  +* *

 !    " 4!!



%

& 5 #?

( 6#5    ,/ * !    " 4!!

!

0 -



%& 5 

&    ""  5 # 

   <  56

  #  

   2  56   

   2" 

 

# #

2 6 " ##

 2#

 

# 2



"  $#   2 2  6 " ##

 2#

 =   2  "6 

 

#

(

 55   

" 

   

 " 

) *+,-.,/06 6 2# 

  

 2 6 #  6 2 5

 ##   ##

6 6 #2 

56

   6=  #

#

 ) .,0/0.,/0  

 25 

?    #"

 2 #

6!

  56# /.

,3 .,/07(8

39

 # 6 # # ,/ ,+ .,/07(8

 ) 

+96



2

  5  

  ## 2 #  # 5

""   



""   2

   # 

"    #5

## 

  #  6  ##          5  # 

 

  2  #

 #  





  #

#"



 5#  2 6#  .> ,- .,/0 4 " " #  '#   ##

"  $#    

## ("



 #7(8 -9

 22

6  #    .* ,- .,/0  #    ##   5 

  =  2 6#  2 4 #6

"

 "  "  D 

(

 

" " # # #-, ,- .,/02 2 #6

 

 #2 6" ###

26

# 

-, ,- .,/0 

;







##  2 2# -, ,- .,/0 2 #  

2

2  2 8#

# 2 #6   (8 -2 2

 #   # 85

 2 4  "   ##% 4B4(4;B  BCB  :?  B ;?;(4;:  :? :&B4 ;

 #    #

 25## 2 ""#

)

54

 

  "     

   #    /.

,.

.,/0  5

   #    ,1@.,/1    # #   ""  6  

5 

   5#  

 

56

"=  #8"# # 2

#

 (

 

 5 #  

26 2# ""6 

    

   

 #56#  

=# =  #8" ; 2

 

#    #6 2 (

 25##  # #   65

  5  #     52

  "

"" #  "

 "

% :5  B8   ;(/ ? (#  !

!

; 2  

       :

   

!

)*"4$5 /$

*3"

6$%,#,')1 2"$,*1,#* )*"*,2"

7"$, ,+)*,'

$,4,')1 +82"'*# !((

!

)*",2"

 '*"$%,"9 ! (

! $"  7: ,//+ .> ,- .,/0 74# 9 .* ,- .,/0 7)##  

 7) *+,-.,/0922  #"5" 

 

#

6

 5#  2 6" ##

 2  2  ## 

  "    $#         

37 9##% A3 :5   6" ##

 2% 9"    

8888F

  2"  " ###//

  56

    6   #  6  

   2    " 

=    8"  # 

    #   #     (  " /3

$#   2 6#6

  "     "./ 2" ##



5#   #   -

5 # #   #66

#

 2 ///3./# #% A// &6 

 ""  "   ""52

@5  #  2# 



"" 56

"  ""#  4 56

 6  # 6 

 2"

=  8"#

 # #  5 

#

/3 4 @(@@ ## =# 6

@(@@      #  #  6

   "





 2 ;##

6 

 8  7"  9  G  "      @  @ 

@

 

# 5      6""# 4 ""

6=# " #

"  5#   #

 "     B&@B&=#

" # 

    B56

    #  #  6

" H! #

 2  4 ## "" 5   #6  #6

(

G#&# #

./  (""      65  " #  ""      #

5#6 @  

"5 52



 5 #   # 6-

5 #  #  #   

 #"

 "

# #    ( 

   #  6  6

#  

   

 2

  #5

6  2 #6



 G    # 6" # #

6" ###

6

 65 6 2

  " " #  

  2    =     5 5  



8   " #

6 5

5

#

 

 " 

"

# #  

# #

 # 8#  ;



#""

  "  6 # " #

##  #622#6 #6



#

 5

 2 " #

#  

  

## 2 2 # !

"  " 4 8  52 65 

" " #  

62#   #6   

 # 

2     #





   # 

8  5    5

  ;

     # # 5   # ## "" 

  6 

   #  

" 

5

4 #    5     2 

 #

    2  65  ""#   #



##   # 

 

  "    6  "" #    

 4 

2"" 5

""

< 2

#;2 2 

<#



  



  6

"    2 6#6

 # #

-, // /**-"       #5"  

""  4 @&#;   # $ 

 #" # 5 5    ("+739 ""  

"6#"   6  

 #     "      D 

 )   :

   5  2

 

# 2  6 2##

 "   #





2 # 6# 

 2 " #  1) .,0/0 .,/0  #     2   5 

  ""        #  

 2<: #5"    <##" 

 #6

 '6##(   2  2#

      2   6 .,/-       " (8/

2

   #  - 2  6

#6

 "



# #.0 ,- .,/02 2" 

 G  # #

 25

  2# # #  #  4 5 #

 2#



 

#      

  =   65" 6 

 

# 4 2  6" ##

 2"



#  #

6

#5  )2:82)$,;$5)7"92 # 6   





  2

6  # 

#

#

 66

#



 # 6 :## #

# ## # 6 ## ## ""

 

 ###   :   

#:  5 66

# 52

"" 

2 #

!"5 2

 "  

2 6 " #5  

  

2  5

 #

5E#5 ;

2   2 

 #6 #

# 

#  #5

#6 !2 #



# #5  2 # 6""6

 

 11533)'&)7"922 2 5 #6#6

H! ##

      #    6   ##  

   5    #  5#

"  2 #6#

#

  # 25

 

6=

# 

&  ;

"  #

" " # 222



#        5

  =        

   "



# 2  ##6

25

6

=  #5 *81:82)$/3)$2)7"92 #  6""6

#8 #65 6

 5

" #5

#

 # 6" ##2



8 ##  #2 " ##

 2 ;

2 #5  #

# 2

!!  " #



8  2" ## #

 4   # ! # # !"

 

   # 

   #           

8  26#



#



##5 2 # 6 ""6

 

" 

 

? #5  )8$)%/3)$2) 7"92 #6   

 ) .,0/0.,/0

  #

##  :## 6 6  #  

          6

#  

 

    #  

6 

"" #  ###  2 8"

 

 

#  



#5  )2 :82)$  ,;$5) 7"9  2   #  #    2  # 

# 

## "6

 

# #

2#   6!5 #2

#5

("8   # 6###



#5 

2 #

"" 

     

#5  386,'&"$6)1/,'43 7"9 2 #    6  ""6    2 

  "   

#   2 " ##

  6" ##

 2#

2   

# " ## 5#5

56

=

;

#

2  

# 8#2 6

#  =   #  6 =## # 5#

""5 #6#

#

"" # 6 " " "

 5 #

 ;

2 #5    #

!5"6"  #

 

# " ###



 #  6  ;

  

#  " ###



 #  6" ##

"" 

# 5

""   5 

  

 7) .,0/0.,/09  

" 

""

#6

"  "   

 2



 

# #

 2  56 2



# 2 # 6" ##6     6

  2  "       2# 

8

 #  # ,/@,.

,+ .,/0 ##  #5 

""   

# '#   #  2 ) .,0/0.,/0##=

" =  5

56

 ( #5 



""   



 #&!

2

" # .2!  

"

# "

 #  .0 ,* .,/0  //. 

   #

 $ %& "'

( &  #

$  !'

( &