High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/725/2015dismissed

Satish v. Kamla

2015-02-11Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri9 pages

!"#$"%

'''

( )*( +((* )*( " , -. ("$#.$/ #..&012$. ".3 $44 55$-. '''

!"#$%& '!()##*& + ,(-!&(%& $(#!# " .((# / ,+&0!#+" ##(# #12/11 /3 # $%&, (# (4!#+)5 ",%'!(6!(+ )#"+& !#(/2787 8 #7$8&#! (( +)/9 7&():&/9;8 (#$% ,, ( & 7&( ((((# :&(;8(#,!&" (( + *&(# ", $%* % #(#-()& ,* ,# 1 & (,- *&& # $ ( !, # ( !#(<

& " (( + $* & ( * ,"=# / /1/99> (#+#!( #(" 6!(+ ( " (( +&%& $# &!$ # #* #*&,#() ",%) & 7# !+&(8 #6 !( -? "(78*($(!& *#,. 12 91

/ # 11 91

3 (-,% -,, + & ""#!(4& ( & &(&(#& ###"!&(( &(" (( +&(#* ,,( #,#(&( &(, ##& & !",,( % # + &(# "&.*,#+ (" (( + # -(%, + ( # (&*(&(*&"&", ( ( %( & (# $+ &( "(# , #% * ",,%!#(&,!&( ",%""$(&(!(=# &",- ( ("& ",% #*&&(!#)& (# @! ((,+*&&"&* (-## ,,"(%&&( # ,,%", &" #*(% &*!,#(@!

,%, -(&( ( ,&" # %&((,+,,&& # ,"/1 % ( &( ( ,&"!& ,(#&(" (( +& # $(@!+&($& -((,% # $ ("@! ((,+$! & ,#(("&(" ( ,#!& ,* %!# $!- # & (&, +! +* (#& ",% #!,#&" #&#-*& ( &#&"(- (!(,+!

," ,%)&! ( (#*&&(# %&* # #$ ""( ++(-* (#&" #& (!#(&"+!# &("&( #,#($(&(&*

6 "!#$%&($(&(A&" #4 +)*&*(!" ((# #& !# ,"%&,&",&!#, -& " (" ,&" #*!,#(!(!(,%&(- & & % &*!,#"$ .$!& + *!,#-(%, - &0!+ ," %"$()1

3& $ ##&(6 !( - ? "( #*&( ( ,&"&.# !+&( & *&&(*&!&-#-( , & % # 5$(! (% (& 1 / & (!(# &" # &( &,#( *( #"#& *( !$,&,)& "" #!()!(+&!() 6!(+ 9 31 / &$& -!(&(#,,## & + &##("&" $,&" ( ,(, *&&( ) &( & # $ &% , (, & $* &" "$(1

35 ,,%) 1 21 /1&(#,&" #& . * %&# !+&(*&&(*&&(B "*(""

21 /1,,(" #$%&"$(+&($ .(-#!, & (!#(!(C&& ( #!$"&(( %#( #,!&" (( +*&&(#&+(!#(!,% ##( 2 & (# #& &, ##& & (* (,& ( ( #& #,,(, *&& $(&(D** ,-+*&&(,,+ ,,%&!#$$ $% &" # $ ## &( ( , &" A ! & -, $& -!(&& #!# ((!#(12718 &(C"("" ,)1

*&&*

7 ###&( -!(1E 1 /)$!#&#(+-& ( #& ",%""$(& # ,#(-#&(&(@!(# " &(#!(&(, ##& &* ,-+*&&( ( , ",% ,+*&&("(# !+&( 1 21 /1)$ ! &(& #&(*&(!("&" (" ,&"A+ # #*&&#*(%+-$%&( ( &"" (( +) &* $ #,,( # ,%$%&(&##& &( ",%& #",#&( $!&(#! ( + # , ##& & ,* %(("# ,,&(" (" ,#!((,% '(-(+ ,,&( -("" #&)&( %#( #" ,& 3 & , #+ & () ,,*+ ! *( ( "#<

7/8 C&&(&(,#( #( #-(&+(!# "#&) ,,+#F

, A& & ( ##!# -# !$ &( (- &(# &*$B C/ # (( #& ,,+ + &(# ,B "#& $(&(C1-#(!" ( #C2&.!" ()*&!(#& -( &&(& #)&(#&(, (# C/

#" # ,(-+ "("&( -() & , B "#&("(# !+&( C1 & E ,%=+ & -# ##!# $% & ( # & !$"" # &($& ,), (#( ,'!( #+& & ( &!$ #& #!(,% ,#(-& && #$( # *&(!,% && # &(# * ### ! / + &" (!,&()&* #"#*& > 5,+ ++(-# $%& "!+# 0!#+" # #( # #12/11 /3 #$%, (#( ,!() ,, &(((# & , G &!$"" #$%(6 ! "!), (#!, ((+& ,, & -$#(# 9 #"#,%)& (*(" ((#/ /1/99> #* &,#(*($(!

&(*#,. (#!,(& ,, (+!#& &#& ,, + - # ,# (( & ##!&(#*&&* !(-& & & #$( +&"*&(!,%*&! % !,& (& ,, #& &(#* @! ((," # ++(- !( #!#"$& -*&&"("&-(%$++&,-# ,*&&" #"( &( ( ,&"&##* ,-*& & ",% # , (!# (("&!&,#&( #(&( (!()& ,, . ( (#%&(#.

8 (! #&("$ .,%$%.+(-$(&(&# ,%)*&&,&" (" ,&")&. * %&# !+&( *&&(0!*&&( ,B " * ( (# !, ## & & # & ,, * !(#$%&$(&( C1 -#(!" ( C2 &.!" ()*&* (, #& ,, ,(($( #& -(&"%& ,, !,#*&& "& *(-#& $,(& ,, ,-*&& (#!#(& "($ !&((!# #& (&$& -!( / (!=+&-#,#$%& (&,+& ,,+ ,-,,#$%& ,, + &(#)&#+ ((##$%, (#( ,!( ( !#(<

"#$

(

) ) *) +"$,,$" $-

// (#!,(& ,, ,#! % ,,+ ,%((-(%&#+, (#( ,!("(++(" " ( ("( #+&-#& ,, :'(!,%; (&!(/27/87 8$ . $& -!($% !* (#&&(*&& !( $, (&& "#&, (& (&"(&(!& " (" ,(, &*&&&(& & # ,, ,,+ ,-,,#$%& ,, + &(#*(+( , !(

+,#!,#$ (( #$%&"*&&!,#" & "$:(!,%; $(-# $- &()&*# !+&( #&*$B#,&#!* (#&( #&( "&(

&(":(!,%;& $B, # !#(<

/ / 0 * / 0

# .

* #

(

0 /1 "( ,%) " -# & & (# (#+&(,(& " &!*&&& ,, (#+$-& )*&&(# (#&*$B)

9 &!(+&,%B(#&(*,,+00!+ ," %& ,, (#( ,!((+&,%&,#& &(&+((# *&& # & & (# B&$# % #( & ,, (& ",%(& && #-("#!#&(, &() &-(& ,, & &(#& # $ ##&"(&( ( ,&" ,#$%& & &,,,-+&&! *&&("(# !+&( (,%)&*& !, .+ (&( #&(# !+&( &!) & #+ , (# ( , !( # * (( (- #&($+"(& ,)&($%#"# : +((*;

!"#$"%

! "# $ % &'()