← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/199/2011dismissed

Parveen Kumar & ORS. v. Kamal Kishore

2015-02-11Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj12 pages

      

 

 ! !"#$#%&

'

()!!%*+,(($ --!..% $ )$ *,.*#$/(! !$-%0!%  & 12     



      

    

  

  

!! 

(3+!045&6

(7#$/.(380)" !

( /!--!..% $

((# ,#%3/#%#80)" !

( /!(!$-%0!%   8  !

!

  "  

!     #$% $$ 

      &

  '

(  !

! !)*  !'

!!

!

 !   !+ !



 !

!!

(!



 !

!

!

! ! !!! ( ,  *!





! 

!

./0





1!-

&(#%2/

*!(3#%2&40  ,

 *!( ! !  

 '

 67*!8 

%9 8!

* 





8 

 .

! 

!

!! *  8 

!!

66!

 ( 

 

. !  !

! 

 

  

!+      

!   !

!1!

!  !

  % 

 !

 

67*!

! !!

:6!

/!

0  ! !!  !*   

%   !!    8 ! ! !!

!*!

!

 : 6!

"

  !!!;

!!

) ! $$#<#  * ! 9 !*

!* +!!

 

67*!)

 !!

 !  !

 !

 )   !

! 

 !67*!! =

!



*!(!'

!

!





!& !!   !!

 ! * ! !  !!

! )

( ! &

'

  !!    *!

 !

    !!



 

:6!

 )  !

! $$#<# 

%!!!



 

   ! ! 8  !(* ! 7!

!

!! !! (  *  !

 )*  

 ! *     !!

 )  



  &

'

  !  *!-67*!  !!  

 :6!

1   -67*! 89!

!! !

!! 

:6!

 !   

!  8 !*!

!

.

/0

1!-

&(#%2)



!

(!     % $/($7$($9 /#4#%(

:

;<'8(/,7( % ,/(, /,%0.

7$*%/5..3.($

=  #)#.

= 8, !%# #  7$  3/+4#(  ($08  

  #)#.

 

$#.,%# +0.#(($7$ 0. (#9,#% /$9,#

. 9,#% /$9,#/#(+>#.($  < :'

' )   !!

 !   ! 

 

   ! 

   ! 

  !!

( !   

  !

  ! !! (  !   !!    +!

  !! !    7!%> (?    ($  7$  7#05%!

+(!(0?-!(+,. /(2($%0 /!($

= =  #)#.

@<8!! 7$% #%3/

<

 #)#.

';@8 !/(/%0 $7$2.4+#00#A+!($

@

 #)#.

< :87#%5 *(#$/%7$*!$/)/%0(%0% /!( =    '@8 $ #,%(7$/(#%3/ $#%"!0!"!$!0 /(+3/2$

%0 /!($

 '

 #)#.

:::!)#2.7$/>(% %(



2@:@ )   !(67*!  

 



!    !9  !

!

! !!  !! 9!

!  !



 

(!!

 

  ! + !

  



 

!  !

  9!

!  !!  ! ! 

!!  ) *   .

#%2& !  >8

%   



 

   

 

 

 

   



 

        

   



    

  

  

  

 

      ! "#

 "



 

$     %  %  

   



  

  

  %

 

   

   

 

  

 

 

&

 

 

     %  

 



    &

 

   '  !  

 

   

   

  

   

  % 

  

  

  

      

 

   



( ) &

    *"

   



 

   



&

   

  

    

       

 %



     

 



&

        



           

  

   

$ -!

./ 0!

9 !

 ./0!

 

!

!! *!!

* !

! !  !! !  9-!

./0!   

9

!!

 9 !- '

!   







  

    !"## :

    !    !  

    !    *! 9!

!!

 ) !



2      !!

         !    !( 

  

!!

+ !

!* *! ! :6!

!!

!?9@ !

!

!

 !

 67*!!

 !

  (    !!

 

  * *  !*

!+  



!



66!

 8 !!



!

!:6!

 !

!

!

   ! ! !

(!

!  

!



*!

   & *!  !  !!!( 

!+!  !!

!

:6!





!

!!

 ,*!

!! ,(!! !!* !

!



)/#)0!)*+( 452$($7$(!9.8  

=<

8!

  !+ !

!* *  !!!  *! 

 !  

#%2&) !

1!

!* !

!  !           !  -!

  .(    !          !A! 

  !

*!

*!

./0

#%2& !

 !A 

B # >8 + #

 % 



   

,





 

  

  

   

%

B  





, -  

   

 

     

     &

&

%    

&



   

./0 1 *

 

./0     2  $  %% &'()* * &)

   

 

   



 

        

   



    

  

  

  

 

      ( ) &

    "



   



 

   



&

   

  

    

       



%



      + 

%&

+&&      





    

 , *   ,(  ),

  -    

. -       

% %



% 



  

 

 

   

./0

 % 

"

 (

%  

 

  

% 



 &

 



  

    

    

 

 



&

 )(  .&&  

    

 , *     ,(  



 

)  $ *(,#),(+($8 &) #B-'B.%(

!!  !

     !      -   '

      9!! 

!      



  

!(   !!!



* *

< !* !!

 !* !    

  *!

& #%2( ( 1!   !! 

! 

      

   !  9  !    *  !



 )%!! 2. C ! )>+. ($8&) #B2-'B#.D3%#%3//70 E ) /%9% #%((/ $ 0 -''2 < )0/+#%3/)+(09(/#4(#>!F= (&)

$$2-' < (- '

! !!

 > B, 

 %

 

  



%&

  & (     









'





 

 -   

    &

 % 

  

 

 

#

%   *

 (



  



+(+ *)(*&   ( ,,&    */ , % , #  



  

    

     %  

     





 



*

 (

 &

  

*

 

%  



%   

 



 

  

  

#%  

*

 







   

 

'&



 '

*

  (  

   #

  '

 

!   

   



 $

&  *

 

    



 

   





 

 * 

    & 

 &  

#     *

    %  *

     



 

  % 

 



 &    



  

&

%  

&



    

 

5 ' 



&

      - '

! 

   >8 3 -

 %

%







   





 

    &%  

 

   $

& ,  &

 

    

 

 *

 

./0

 & 

 

 

   



     &

%





   

 6  

 



% 

%

*

  

./0

%

*

 ( 

./0

    *

 (

%  

 

 %   

 

  



 

% 





  

      

 

 

 ,  &

&%&   

 

   $



  

 %  

   

./0

   





  

  $  *!!

 *!

./0

#%2& !



 !!

 !! -!

./0

  !(!

( *(!!

!1!

 

    !   !  !  

 

  

    

$ !    

!*!'

(  ! ! 

!

 !( *!

-8

!

/0

!.

#%2& * 

!!

 *!

-8 !

/ 0

  

 



 

!

 89!

!! !

(

(  !

        !+!



! !,-  !

        !      !

 

  

3%#%3/  /(+3/2$7$/%9% #%(

 < :%0-!**6"

 / 0   !*

 !

!

 

!

! !!

 ,

  ;

1!E %!!

B  >8 7   &

* *

 

 ! 





 



  % 

 

    



       



    





   

  

 

 % 



     



    

  

 *

 (   *    

  



 &

      

        $  !!

  *!



(-!

.

/0

&!

 

  1!   !



 !!   ! !



1!-

&1 "- '

! 00,,>(#$/%(!005($7$00,,#!005

 %(

= -!C+( +03,!% ':@  ! !!   )            G  @  9   !

  

!

 !*!  !! ! ! !





 !

!

-G- )

!

!

 !*!!!

!!

  

  * * G !G@/  0!!  #%B !

! -  9

!+!

! &  

- G ! ! !





!

,! 

!  

 ! ! !!

!

!! ! 



-  89!

!!

!! 

 G@!

  !



! 

 1 " - '

!

 9!

!!  +!

 !! !



! 

!   !



9 !



  !

!!  !!

  !



  !

!

! !!   !!  

   !

 !

 !!!!

!

-67*! '

 !



 !

 

!* !

 !!!* !!

(! !

!

!

    ,

 !(



!

!  ! !!!

!

 7!!

!

!

  !!

  

,!

! 8)!

  67*!!!!'

 *

  ! ! !!

!

! !*!

 !!  !!  -!67*! !! !     9 !*

 



    ! * !!

!*! 

!



(66!

  !!



   ! !

 !!

  

!

  )

 !

   &  +!!



 !

()

! !!!



'

 !!



!

+ !

(

 !+ !

(  !

 !    !        

   

  !

!

!

 

'

   H!