Shashi Jain v. Sukhwant Singh And ORS

  


  

   



 

      

!

"#$% &'' 

!

# ( )(*+( % ,'' -.

// (% 0'' Whether only the operative part of the judgment is pronounced? No Whether full judgment is pronounced?

Yes %  12 3'

3  3

3      

 
     ! 

  
  "      
    !  # $%& '

"

((((( 3

3

'

) * 



 !

   $+ ,+ $,)-   "

   '

 *  . 
  

!

 
)//!  

 )0++1!2 *  34! 

! 

 

   ! +56656$7%  809

    !    !     :              $6 ,) $,)$ $



 !  

 !  ; ! 

  "

 *   

 ! ! !    ; 

  !  !

" 

3 
2   32


  3 *

  

!  %

  

   "

 *       

  * !    "       

 

   



 

    -     

   

 !      #  $%&

'

" 

 " 

 *     

  & '

"  !

 FAO No. 10215"2014 titled asReliance General Insurance Co. Ltd vs. Shashi Jain and others4  $+ ,+ $,)- !; !



  * !  "!  !

<  &  

  

!  

  

! 

3

2 25

 3

/ =3




'   ! Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 67

3)-#+  )#

""

 8    

! 



 ! 

  % >30
 

    

   

      

              

   

     

 

  
   

 

      

          

 

    !"#$   

 

%#  !"&$

  

&'   !"($      


31
)

       

       
*           (+,                  







  

  


-  

   

 

      

         $        
. 

/

 

        

 

        

       
*  





               



 

             

        
32
 

                   (+,                      

   

  (+,     
  

          

 

  

                             

   

 

   

       
* * * * * *

42.)     



    &$          0

 1   $        !2    !(%+ %!

%(

 $ 

    

  3!4 %'#+

 3!'#!#(

 3!(#'&+

 3!&&!&(

  3!#&'(+

 



    

  3!!(!((

 35(''+

 34'!'(

  3( ''4+

 =3




 '        !  National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 6 ,

3 98 ! 

 
)//)/5% )/+!  

 )0++

!



% ?

   ! 

      @

      



 A 1B4

! 



 !

 A 1'4

!

  !

" 

A 1?4 

!     

" !

 !  !  @

    A 1C4 . 

!

   !

!!!

  

 D A

!%

"

!@  "  *

 ! D



  % >52. 6  conventional heads 



  

   

 7/

8
*    7
%(+++  

7 !+++++

&  

   7 !+++++ 



  

   
     

       

   
7/

 0  9 

 



               



   

          

    



     

  
:      

               
 6

         
       

      

 

    

             




      

     

  

   


; 



 

      

   

                 

     



    

      

    
    

  

*

    



      





 

 

  

 7
!(+++7
&++++ 
!(+++


           

  
<     



   


 )  

        



 

    

  



    !+,   


)   

 



 

 



  = = = = = 59.3
)   

  (+,   



 





 / 

  &+

   
 

 #+,  

  

&+ (+


* 

  

 (+ '+

     !(,
6        


59.4
* 







 $ 

   &+,

 

  

    &+


6  %(,

  

  &+(+

  !+,





 (+'+

    



 


 

    
59.5
.             

     

    #+#%0> ? 

  

    59.6.

         

  0> @ &%/



, 59.7
         

               
59.8
7   

        





 

    



 !(+++  7  &++++     7  !(+++  


 



    

  !+,




A +  =3




'   ! :+

(# .

(")# (*  +- (;

2<+< / ="'

() +

.< "

>)>#) + >#"

6 9 9

3 8 !    3 #.

=#+ ")-#

# ( ;

>< 3)-#

 

     

 ! 



  % B21
6  <

  C  0 8        

      

;



  




 *     

  D  D    

   



D    D D   D D  D
 

         

 

 

 

  

  
)

 

 

  



%!
!
Spousal consortium   

        

         

    



D  

   

     

 /  D
%!
%
Parental consortium     



              

   D    

   

     

   

     D
%!
#
Filial consortium             

  

 

   
6 

      

           




 

   

     

                

 

          
22
  



 

     

      
3 /     

 

  

E  

   

   

  
3 /       

   

    


     

 

  

       


 23
 3> 

6  

    

     

  

 

   

* 

       

          

      


C       

    

    6 
6     

    

      

  

  

     



 24
  

         

 

   D

  D   C  0 8
*  



      

   7 &++++ 





 ! 

   

 <5 "

  

!    

 "  

 

 !

 *   "   !

 <5 
! 

! 

    '

D

!   

! & '

" FAO No.

10215"2014 titled as Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd vs. Shashi Jain and others 

 !!

 *  ; 

! 

! 

  * ! !   ; ! 

 ; 

),

! 

 !  

 *  

 " 

! 

 !

?



 ! 



 

 

 ))

! 

 !  

 *    "   )75 @

 !

 @

 .  

! 

    ! !  

  * !   ;  !

 ! '  23

)$ & !   " =3




'

 !

 D

 



  *  $+ ,+ $,)-  !   " *   

  ! 



      % % Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded )  "& 

  -/<6)7% $ . 

8),9  -/<67%1),9!-/<6)4 ?

    



@

 )75  )6,6/7%1<)$$+E)754 - * & 

 5-)<$7%1<)$$+%)6,6/4 -  

 )) <

 ?

  "  -<,+,/-7%15-)<$E)$E))4 / F!C

 $<,,,7% .  C@

  $<,,,7% +   

 -$,-,-67% F!'

 )$,,,,7%   -,,,,7%@)    -,,,,7%@$

.

 +-("

< ( "'99494 @ /)* < (

   " *  "'94,,4,@ (> (*/

+ )(

"'&404,7@ 999 9,,,

)5
!      

 "=3




'Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma  7 

 ,  R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation 

& 3)-#+  )#

""

,4        809

    !   !! ! 



  ! G )-  # $%& '

" 



  ! 

   *  

! ! 

!  "!D

 * *         ! 

     !  

 $+ ,+ $,)- *  

 !      * 

)<  

 !"   !

3

3



,''

   H  

7%

 I 7# H  



 I