High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/42945/2023allowed

Naresh Kumar Jain v. State Of Haryana And Another

2023-12-11Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl15 pages

"#$%$ & ''

''''' "!$!$ &"( ''''' "%) &*"&!% + , ' - ./ -

!" # !" $ % & % '

$ ('# )))))

* + " $ " ,-. '' % %

$ " -0* 1* 2 3 (*4 " 5 * 1( 5 . & " *.56 % " ' # "" 7 & # " $ " $"" 7 "! .8* / ! &

9$" 7 % " $ !! 9

%" '

' # "" 7 & " $ " 7

% / "" $"$"

" $ " 7 /

% / ""% 7 " " % :

" 7 "! " + " "! / %! $%$ - " 1* 2 3 (*4 " 7

" 81 & " 7 " " 7 $$ /

% "

$! 2;4 0 7 /

/ 7 16-5(-55 9 / " 2$% 1 " 4 " "" %0 " 7 $$ / ""

/ 7 .,68( -8 "! " 7 $$ / 0 ! " " ""

/ 0 ! " " 7 .*(1*5 9 $ "

% 7 7 " " $ 0 ! " " 7" 7 $$$ <% ' # % $ $ 7 0 ! " " $ !

" =" 7 "! 7" ! / %! $%$ *- " 9 7 ! % " !% 0 ! " " ! % "" 2 3 ( (-4 <% 7 7 / $$ 0 ! " " / % / "$ / ! 66- $ /

% == " 81 & " 7 " + !% $ " / " "

/ / ' "% ! / , 7 7 ! / 3 " 7 3 *8*, $"

!" '(""

/ % / / '( #" ' ';((-5661(- ! ,.-

% / % %

! .6- $ /

% == - > " $ / $ / "

" *1* , 7 7 ! / 3 9 / $ ! ! " $! / $$ " $ 7 77 .* % 7 / $$ " /

' %

9 / $% / % ' $ % %

/ ' / ' =" / $$ " ! *1- 2 3 (*4 $ $ " %

$ / ' 9 /

" $% 7 / 3 $ " $ / " 6 "" 7

/ ! ! % $ "

* ' 9 > " $ $ ! ?/ ' 7 / "

$ "" / / % ; " / " $ ?/ &! #" ' " !"!#$

%&'(#)*+#)*+#*,#!(-& , > " $ / $ % " 9 / "

7 % " % $ $ "! "" $"$" "

" 9 / ! " $ $ /

% 0 ! " " $0" $ 7 ! / $$ % ""

" 7" ! / "! " 9 /

% ! / % / " $ / %

% $ / / " 7 "! " 9 / $ 0 ! " " $ " $"

7 "" $"$"

"0=" 7 "! $ / ! % " 2 3 ( (-4 <% 2"(""

4 7 $" $ 9 / % % 0 ! " " $$$ <% ! $ / / 0 ! " " % $$ <% %% " / % 51 / $ % 7 $ 9 % <% / " " 81 & " " / $%$ - 2$% ,.4 " 2 3 (*4 % % <% ""$ $$ " 7 /

$ ""

" $$ /

7 % " $ 9 % <% / % / "$ / ! 66- $ /

% == "$ / ! ' % " %

/ " @ ? 9 / " $ / % <% $ ! "" %

+ %% "" %

$ !

% / $$ % " %

" @#? 9 / ! $$ "

% '

$ $$ 0 >3 "

$$ 0 !$ $$ 0

/ $ 7 $$ " 0 ! " " % 7 /

7 " % " !% 7 $$ 7 %

$$ ! / ""

$ " 9 / "! $ " / " $ $ 7

/ ! / $% $ "" 6 > " $ $$ $ $ % %

/ "! "" $"$" " 7 0 ! " " *1* 9 7 $ 7 7 $$ $ 9 / % !% / '&; /

/ "! $ $ / ! $ "(""

" 7 " " 7 " 7" 7 $ ! !

% / "" 9 / % % " 0 !

0 " " 7" <% 2"(""

4 $$ / % !% / ! $ $ 6A 0 ! " " 9 / $$ " 7 /

0 ! " " " " $ 6A / 0 ! " " <% / $/ 7 % 0 ! " " 9 / ! "

,651 .8* B " 7 7$$ " / .*(1*5 7" 7 B $ /

/ 7 0 ! " " 7" 7 "! ! ! $ 9 / "! " 7 "

" :

/ " -1 7

$$ 9 / $ " " 81 <% " $ 7 6A / 0 ! " " 9 / "(""

% "" "! / "

7 "! / " $ 0 ! " " 7" $ 6A 9 / $ ! "" %

8 > " $ / / / .*(1*5 $ 9 / $ " " 81 & " / !" 1 + ' " $

1 $ $$(/ 5 9 $ " $ / " " *1* 2 6 4 !% " , 7 7 ! / 3 + $ / ! ! " 9 / $ /! / ?/ " " 7 ""

% / $ "

" ""

! "" %

! " 7" / " -1 & " " ;" % /

(*"( * !"* '

' ) %%"* $& -)"#$ 2 ," 3" !

))" 2 4(2'5 4%5'

6 " % &788 9 & &* !:"(% .%' :" -! !"

;"%!

"&< 2 7" 7 /! ( .

!/0!#!(##!%+!"*+ !% *+(" (1!2!! )%+*"/3*#4*#!+ (*!/!(#("3*#4*+ %&

!)*),%**3+#(, 0,, + % +(5!%*4!#!(%*(2,!+4!

#!$(#",!%%*3+ !"#!)+* %%!"2/+ !$ *#++*)*),"!+ !%(4!0+ *!/!(# 3#*4+ !"(+!*33#(4$*3) (#$!%&.

! !++*!#%"**+

(1! (/ )#4(, (+!)!"!+%& .

!#! % + % %2%+(+(, )*4 ,()!*3!)+**3+ !'6)+& %) )#)4%+()!% 2+0+ *+!7 #!%%$(/1!0%* + !4!#+%*3+ !)(%!

0!"!!4+( #* #(+!+*#!,!(%!+ !

!++*!#%*2(,%28!)++*+ !+!#4%(")*"+*%(%4(/2!

4 *%!"2/+ !.#(,*#+& !

"#$%!

& ( )

+ ,% - $ .!

/ . $ /! 7

7 /! " ?/ ' 7 $ % %

$ " 7 / " -1 & " $$ % " " "

$ 7 !% / " ""

* + C/ ' 9 -)"#$ 2 ," 3" !

))" 2 4(2'5 '106 =$!$%:

*:$> (? @ ) & .%' :"

-! !"

;"%!

"&< 2= ! *5 7 $ /! ( 0! 1.2(1211 & & % - $ & % ) % 3

% 4&

5*6" 71 1212 7(721212 %1789 ( "#$%! $ % 3 3 #$+ !)*#%!*3+ ! !(#$ 0!(#!3*#4!"+ (+ + ! !++*!# (%"!#$*!)%+*"/3*#( !#*"*3/!(# ("4*+ %(%*&9&&.

!+#(,%(+( #!,4(#/ %+($!

(%*,/*!0+!%% (%2!!!7(4!"&.

! !++*!# "*!%*+ (1!(/)#4(,(+!)!"!+%& .(5$ +* )*%"!#(+* + ! !#*" *3 %!+!)!

"!#$*!2/+ ! !++*!#("(,,+ !(++!"$)#)4%+()!% 2+0+ *+!7 #!%%$(/1!0%+ !4!#+%*3+ !)(%!

(#!),!"+*$#(+2(,+*+ ! !++*!#& .

! !++*!#%())*#"$,/ "#!)+!"+*2!#!,!(%!"* 2(,%28!)++* 43#% $2(,2*"%+*+ !%(+%3()+**3 + !.#(,*#+& % - $ $ 89

0 ** $ 7

7 " 7 & " $! " -1 & " 7 / 7 % $ / "% $ 24 % "

$ * 1 7 / 3 $ 24 ! " " * C/ ' ($9$& 2 ))" 2 '6

=:$!!

$%A % 2$ % -7B: % .%' :" -! !"

;"%!

"&< 2= ! 1 7 $ % "" / $ 24 " 7 "

7 * 1 $$3 2& 7 *1*5 %% / 7 14 + ! $ 1'

( 0- :

2(1272 4) ) )6;" (,(127.

% . ) $) + &) ) "7 127, & $ %

%17< )"

# $ % ! 7., ))*#"$+*+ ! #*%!)+* + !( !,,(+0(%3*"+* 2! *%%!%%* *3 (#)*+) %2%+()! &!& :9 2*++,!% *3

!%/"#/, )*$ %/# )*+($ )*"!! 47+#! (2*1! )*44!#)(,;(++/& .

!( !,,(+0(%(##!%+!"*&& (")*+!% +*2!)%+*"/&+( !(#%+ (+*+*30+!%%!%)+!"+*2!

!7(4!"% *#+*3+ !)(%!*3 #*%!)+*3*#0+!%%!%

(1!(,#!("/2!!!7(4!"+ !+#(,& <+ *+!7 #!%%$(/* **+ !4!#+%*#"!4!#+% *3 + ! #1(, %24%%*% (" )*%"!#$ + ! 3()+% ("

)#)4%+()!%*#!)*#"

*#1!0 )(%!3*#2(,%4("!*+& <!+ !#!3*#!

(,,*0+ %( !(,(""#!)+(%"!#= 8 9% = 61 + && + > % ) "#$%! "

9% )

& 0 *- 9 " ($9$& 2 ))" 2 '0

= ) 2 /($%:& !( @ ) 2(7%9 .%' &$ &

&*$ C= ! '

' C/ ' 7 $ /! ( 0-

1271211 4 ) : ;

% >

;)6) "77(@1211 .

( !,,(+%)%+*"/%)! &9&)*!)+*0+

)#4! #!$%+!#!" (% '&&& #4! '*&> #!% !)+ *3 *33!)!% % (2,!"!#!)+*%

#!("0+

*3+ !'(#)*+)#$%("6%/) *+#* )2%+()!%)+

?& + =

;

!+? $

;

% = >

% A

*%"!#$+ !3()+%(")#)4%+()!%*#!)*#"("

+ !,!$+ *3)%+*"/"!#$*!2/+ !( !,,(+ *#1!0 + !)(%!3*#2(,%4("!*+& B 8 9

) & 9 )

= ) 89

& :

& 0 *, $ /!( 7

7 " "

7 $$3 * *1 " 7 & " $ "%

%! "

$ "" / 7 % $ 24 *6 + C/ ' " = : 99 * - 29 & &$ -: $>: .%' :" -! !"

78 ( ! ! 5 $ -)"#$ 2 ," 3" !

))" 2 4(2'5 '

7 /! ( @<!(#!),!"+*#!,!(%!+ ! !++*!#*2(,*,/* + !$#*"+ (+ ! (%% !+(2*++0*/!(#%)%+*"/("

)*),%**3+#(,0,,+(5!%*4!+4!& *%!;!+,/ 0+ *+!7 #!%%$(/1!0%*+ !4!#+% *3+ !)(%!("+(5$+*)*%"!#(+*+ !)%+*"/ !#*"*3 + ! !++*!# + %% !)(,,!(1! !++*%())! +!"("+ !

!++*!# % *#"!#!" +* 2! #!,!(%!" * 2(, %28!)+ +* % 3#% $+ !2(,2*"%+* + !%(+%3()+* *3 + ! !)(,

"$!>)*)!#!".#(,*#+&

$ 89

*8 + /!( " 7 " & " D9; / % " 52"4 *2"4 . " + " $"

7 "! $ 24 7 "

" :

+ C/ ' /! "" / 7 /% % $ 24 % $ / 7 "

*1 + ?/ &! #" ' $&

1 ! = % ** " ""

$ / " 7 $ "

* ' 9 / $ "

! "" %

! " % " -1 & " *5 ' #" ' ! (*"( * !"* '

' ) %%"* $& 00

) -$&<: .%' -! !"

7&8 B % "" %

" ! !% "! "

" :

$$$ 7 "

7 $ * 8 8 % % "" ""

$ /% ! % ""

* ' 9 *. 9 /! 7

/ ! $ " " 7 "! % "(""

" % $ $ "! "

" :

"" $"$"

" " " "

% 0 ! " " / $0" $ 7 $$ / 0 " 7 /

+ " $""

$ $ /!

% / % "" %

/ ! .6- $ /

% == 7" / " @#? $ 7

7 $ " $"

7 3 % $" "! /7 "

% 7 / % "" % / / % "" %

/ '( #" ' ! ,.- $ ';((-5661(- E! $ 7

7 7 3 % $" "! /7 " 7 "

$ ** 9 " $"

$ 0 ! " " 7 *1* " =" 7 "! $ & % !% 7 ! % " "$ 7" ! / 3 7 $ 3 ( (- 9 / % % / $ " ! / 0 ! " " 7" 7 $$ <% $ ! % 51 2 3 (14 / ! 7" / / 0 ! " " ;=!

/ 2 / 0 ! " " 4 / <% $ % 9 " $ <% / " " 81 & " " / $%$ - 2$% ,.4

" 2 3 (*4 % % <% ""$ $$ " 7 /

$ ""

" + <% / % "$ / ! 66- $ /

% == 2 " @ ?4 + :

7 $ 7 " " 0 ! " " 7

= " % " ' 7 %!

$ 7 % D /! " $$ $ $ /% "

$ 7 !

/% , 7 7 ! / 3 " $ ! ! " $ ! % / $ 7" 7

= " % " $ ! "" %

$% !7 /!( " ""

" 7

7 7 /!( = % $ $

7 $ " / %

% / 0 / " ""

' 0& % /=" /% :

" + $

/ /

7% "( 4 + $ 7

$ 7 !" % /4 + $ 7

$ B 0 $"

724 "4 + $ 7

$$ / ' 3 $ $" 3 $

4 + $

" " 7" ""

7" $" 4 + $

" " " $ $ ":

7 " "

% " " ' $ " " $ 7 !" 9 " /" /! " $"

/ / ! $$ " ""

/ ' - 7! % /!

/ "

3$ $ " ' 7

$" $ /! $ " 7" $ $ = "% $ / $ 4./ -

,5 '' #3 F $ %0 <0 F $/ <0