← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/8954/2014allowed

State Of Haryana Through Deputy Commissioner Mewat v. Juber Etc.

2019-05-06Mr. Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan9 pages



 ! " #$%&$'() %* # ) "%  

  +  ,  

'-.

  

   /   &01-0  

 

  

3  3 3 '-.+24  

&01-0

    ) ) 25/  

           



 !"#"$%&%"'"" () "**++" , )-./0)(1230 "#() *)#)1 , )/4-/)(1234 "#() *)#)4 , )03-5)(1230  # ""%#$)6"() "**++"  , )03-5)(1230"#()  *)#). , )-./0)(1230  "

#

 %#$)6"() 

& *"%#$)6"() "**++"

, )/4-/)(1234"# () *)# )3)- , )-./0)(1230"#()

 

 *)# )3"#0)32  " 7"

%#$)6"8   "#"""+ )"%#$)6"()  *)#9

"6):*"' ;;;;

    %< "+ #:= #

3#

 2

"# 

"**+ 6" ) "

>( +#)> "+()( "**+ 6"?"**++"9

")("'"" # 6 )/)(  " )6 @ 6)#)" ))( #+"')(41/#"'

A 6  "

)66 # *(  * "**"+ $ A)( "$: :"#  "**+ 6" )% ":

"++)A# "##+"')(41/#"'

A 6  "

)66 #  *(  * "**"+%

>'6)#)# #

#

 2 /

"# 

"**+ 6" ) "

>( +#)> "+()( "**+ 6"?"**++"9 :7 :"<# $)( )((# $ 6+= # 6 )/)(  " ) 6 @ 6)#)" ))(#+"')(3/0#"'

A 6  "

)66 # *(  * "**"+ $ A)( "$: :"#  "**+ 6" )% ":

"++)A# "##+"')(3/0#"'

A 6  "

)66 #  *(  * "**"+%

>'6)#)#  

6 /  3 3 

)# "++#

*) )(, )-./0)(1230< ")("'""

$  >"#)  =%, )03-5)(1230<:7 :"$ "(

""# )  ="#, )/4-/)(1234< >

 "#)  $ :7 :""#

3

)  =++ "() # "**"+ "

) )( 6)::) #:#"# 432B1234*"

# +"

: ))4-)(1231>' ))66 # +"

 "+% 

 6A"<() )%  "+= , )/4-/)(1234 "

>*(#>' 6+"

:" ()  "6:)("A"##6):* )":) A "

, )03-5)(1230 >*(#>' # $)( )((# $ 6+A "

, )-./0 )(1230  "

> *(# >'  ")("'"""

  )A)(  6)6#$ 6+%"

+  *")( "() ##6

))(  "+>'

6   "

() # " # $"#)A ) +'"# $"++'+ ">+() *"':)(6):* )":)  

"6):*"' "

># 6#) *"' 6):* )":) ) 6+"

:"A  + >')6)$  ": (): # $"#)A

)("6 A 6 "6

"'()6)

#" ))(  "#

 :"#"

#9C

32211231% #6"

#> # ))( >"# +": ))(  +":

## A6):

():"

")$ ++"

* ):))6'6+ >" 

" ) ) 9/199.120 > # $>' +":  "6)6 :"()++)A   + "#  #> #<

6#6"

#=A"

 )  " ")( :))6'6+">) B22%A  '"6 #" "#) $ ++" *  % )((# $ 6+> # $>' *)#)39:

:"  "

+'  "#  + +'  6":       >"6@ 

#  "#    )     :))6'6+():"

#%# )A 6 %> #<#6"

#="# +":(++#)A "+)A   :))6'6+) )"# +":(++#)A) >:

#)(  )"# )((# $ 6+")$) >)#')(> #%# )A 6 > # 6 $#   )

 "## #)  *) +":"+ )6 $#

  # $)()((# $ 6+(+#"A"'():  *)"@  "#$"")(

 

:)> "(% >)#')( #6"

#A"

"@)% A   *) :):D":

" ))(

>)#'A"

6)# 6#6"

#9> #A"

3.

'" )+#"#A"

" #)(33  "#"#"#A"

" 

-%222?9>'

#) " + "+A)@, )32-#"#23241231 # 6 )1B.%44B "#4209A"



#")+ 6 " )  "() #>"6@) #)(("6 "+:" D%"++ "() #  "**"+  "$> "#"#"> 6)

##""+))

   :)( " )("++  "**"+  "

> "#>'

+"#6) +()  "**++"9:7 :"<# $)( )((# $ 6+= , )03-5)(1230"#"**++"9 ")("'""<"

)A)(  6)6#$ 6+= , )-./0)(1230 " '")6 "++  ( # 6)##>'  "+ " "66 #A"



+)("

"# + # $ )( )((# $ 6+"  '")+'6 "++  " *")(  :* # #:>'A 6   "+ "

# 6# 

"6 ):*"')6):* " 6+"

:">'*"'

 "A"##":) )  6+"

:""#% "(%6)$  ":():>) % % # $"#)A  "() #>"6@) #)( :"%

) A) +#))

) #"

+"

) )A "66 #))@*+"6"# #A "("6 "# 6 "6 %  "+ "

 +# " "66 #A"

"

+)("

"# + # $ >' # $)( )((# $ 6+%"

 

)6 "++ ) ( # )(  "+"#  " ,  +'%A) +#"@ *, )/4-/)(1234()6)

#" )   )+

A 6  "

>"

#)> "+()( 6+"

:" "**++" , )/4-/)(1234

 " 6):* )":) 

"+)A

#

6)## " )   ' "$6+"

:# " #6"

#A"

"# ">)   3.  '"  "#  A"

 "  #  )(  33  "#"#  "#  A"

 "+ )  "

 

-%222?9  *  :)  >'  #)   " + "+  A)@%      "+  "

 )+'

6)

##

6):"

4%222?9*:) ) ) # " 

) *))("# 

6):"$"

+">+) ( +,):*

"+)( 6)#

"**" ") 6) +#>>)  ) ">+

 " #6"

#A"

" 

-%222?9*:)  

6 "

)% :'6)

##$ A% AA)6)  )*)  "+E(  A"

)6)

# :"

" #"#( D) )"+

6):"#  6)#))6)

# :"

"" + "+A)@"#( D

6): "66)#"6A  +"A>   "> 6)("'#)6 : ">+

 "() #("6% A) +#>$'# (( +)"@"')( ">)$+  D6+

$+')A% )+') )* )"$"

+">+)  "+A"

)( D

6): "

 *     :

: A" ( D#  >'    "  )(  "'""  >' "'

) ( 6" )) )+ ) "#6) +() "**++" "

>:

# ""

*  #6

)  )(  "  )(  "'""  :"#  ((6 $  (): " "'  23%  1231%    :A"( D#()  @ ++#+">) A"

0-0B3B?9 :')* )%  "> 6)( "') :" "+% " ) +# "$>"@)>  6):)( #6"

#"  :)(

#"    "66 #A 6 ))@*+"6)32241231)A$%  "+ "

* "*

"@  6):) )"++'"

4%222?9*:) > )"

) "

>

#>' "

) )A

6  6):A"

"

#>'  "#6) +"**" ()  *)#9

"6):*"'

A++"

# $"# )A""+ )) *)

))6))$  "() #$ A " :

:A""$"

+">+) @ ++#+">) #)  #")("66 # ) +# "$>"@"

  6):)( #6"

#

/

66)# +'%"("@  )"66)  "() #) ( 6" ))(   ")("'""%"6)*')(A 6  "

>*)# 6#>'+"#6) +()  "**++""  :)(  " )(

6"

"#"(:"@  ") # (

%  6):)( #6"

#

"

#"

/%222?9   6)#) #A 6  "

>"

#>'+"#6) +()  "**++" 96+"

:" , )/4-/)(1234

 ")  "

> $ )A"# +)

)(( *) *6 :'$ A%  "+ ) +# "$"A"## # "() # "#02F)( :) +' 6):"

"

# :

)( #6

))(  )>+

*:) ##  27  - #08,9:

 &,+2 6 ; %#%#2<27 6 *" +" $ A)(

)> $" ):"# *"""* )53< $= ,)>"**6 )% "() #*"

"():&,+2 +-8

D"6#"#*)# 6#"

#9 G53< $=6"

 #6"

#A"

+(9:*+)'#))"

( D# "+"'%""## ))(02F)(  ">+

# 6): ) +#>  A""A  #6"

#A"

>+)A ")(02'" "## ) )(1/FA  #6"

#A"

>A ")(02)/2'" "# 32FA  #6"

#A"

>A ")(/2)52'" ) +#> "##  "

    6

"'  : )#  )(  6):* " )      ">+

#

6)::"   6)::

 "D6):*)H 

(  6)## ")+'

/%222?9 "

>"A"## #   "#)(, "+D* "# #) 6)$ )"+ "# %())

)( ""#)

)() )

:%)  "

>"A"## :'$ A%

3/%222?96) +#"

+' "$>"A"## #  "#)(( "+D* "#"+ )()+)

)( " )(""

+)

)(6) )

6)6#% $ A)( #6

))()>+*D)  40"7

 - #9:

-%072 #--%0 6  

;

%#%#2<273336**++" )3"#1%>) (" "#:) A) +#>  +#(), + "+) )

:) D)(

02%222?9 )  % (" "

A++"

 >) "#

  "$)>6)

##)> #*#

*)     6):  )(     #6"

#  >   )  ("  "

    , + "+  ) )

:

6)6#%>)  *" %(" "#:) )( #6"

#A) +# "$ )>6)

##"# +#()  ": 

6 %     A"#  )(      "+  "#  :)# ( #  "#  9 6"+6 +"#"

#9 +   #08 2 0- 3 6):

/%222?9*:) 1 ## ))(, ) *6 <I)( 02F)( 6):= <

/%222J

1%222=K

B%222?9 4 # 6 )<3?1# > >"6 +)=() * )"+D*

B%2229

4%/22K

4%/22?9 0  + *+ <"#3.'" = 3- / )"++)

)(#*#6'

4%/22D31D3-K

B%/5%222?9 5

  "# 9 < =, "+D*

3/%222?9 <

=)

)( "

3/%222?9 B ""+  6) )

:  )  "**++"

)3"#1<(" 8:) =

02%222?9  *"'">+  )  "6 % % 6): )

-2%222?9 7 08 2 % 6//6= !  08 20- % 6//6% 36 6 >%  63;6= ,  %       ("6  "#  6 6 "6  )(     6"

%    :'

6)

##)* )%   "

"+ )L

#)> 6"

#():5F* " :)B/F*" :"#  ":>6"+6 +"#(): #")(( + )(  6+"

:* ) ++ #")(*"':)( "A"##":)   

+%, )/4-/)(1234< >

 "#)  $ :7 :""#)  = "# "++)A#"# :* # #:"#A"#)(



  "+

:)# ( #"# "A"##":) "#   ()

 "6#) D"

# 6"#">)$

 A)"**"+ >" , )03-5)(1230<:7 :"$ "(

""#)  ="#, )-./0)(1230< ")("'""$  >"# )  = "$>( +#>' # $"# )A)( $ 6+ *6 $+'   :)( " %>)  6) +() "**++"%     *6 $"**"+ % "$6)( #  *"')+') *")(  :* #  #:>'A 6   *)#9

"6):*"' "

> $+ >'

)6)$ 6):* )":)  ) +'(): # $"# )A"( *"':)(  ":) 6+"

:" "**" ():  :* # #:)(  "+ "% $ A)( ("6 " # $A"

 "$ "+ 66()  ))  6+ < =>  A"

# $ "

:)$ 6+A 6 A"

6"*">+)(6"'

)(.J3 *"

%  "+ "

 +# " # $A"

) "$ "$"+ #+ 66 ) #")("66 # )A$% :'6)

##)* )%"() #( # 6)##>'

  "+

))

"

 )((# $ 6+

"

#)"# 

" ) ( 6"< = "

>>)  )6)#"

D 91 "#

6+"+' # 6"#   " 6+"

)( $ 6+

  ))  6+ < = 

6 "

)% :'6)

##)* )% A"

)*)*) )+# " # $A"

) "$ "$"+ ## $ + 66"

"#:

#+'% A"

"$ "$"+ #+ 66) #")( "66 #()*+'

  ))  6+ < =  

+% >)   "**"+ %, )03-5)(1230 "# , )-./0)(1230  ""+ )"++)A#"# ( # 6)##  "

 

6)6 )

L #"# "

# 66)# +'%  *)#9

"6):*"'A) +#>+ ">+)

#: (' )A)( $ 6+"

  ":A"

#A    )A$% *" A) +#>"  )A6) "6)*')(

)#>*+"6#) ( + )() 6)6# "**"+ )%%:

%' '$)"!

252/123.

 "+ ? 8@24= A* = ?8.7A * =