High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6409/2016allowed

United India Insurance Company Ltd v. Sushma And ORS

2023-10-06Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh11 pages

!"#$%&'& ()$*+, ,$%-&

# ..//(%) 0 $% .$%#%)

&'

$ & $% ..//(%) 0 '()

.$%#%) - 23

14 1 * + ,&-&$% .

/ .

!!11

! & ' / / .

!!11

! & 2222222 4 15 3%

%11 ! !!1 ) * 1

1 /& $%

* !* !!1 ) * 1 $ & $% /& '()

1 5!!11

%

!

1 )1.

6%4

% .

7% )18 / !* &9& &

) 0

1 :& $% 44 4%1

:& ( * ) " &

&& ) + !& &.

( /11* 3 $ :&;' # 4% / '()

4% %"

%

/11* <%11 6% 4.

)1 )11 1"

'()

4%1 "* / 1 1

3 $ = * & >

.

( ! >>'

:&

?&& 1* $ 3%

*

& 0 3 $ 4

! :&

! :&& 1 = % %1"

5&

*%

% 9 1=%

% ( 0

*1".

1 !

$

,% 1 &

&

1 !

!& '! :&

( 4% %"

= !1

.

3 $ /

! :&

!& ;4/ %"

! 0 (

( %

0

= !1

% = !1 *1*

! :&

& '! :& ! =* 1 )(

%/* 00 / /1 /* 1 11*

"

!& .

0

& 1 ( * 5

%& 0

!1 3 $ 4 *

!

/ 1"

) 11*

.

4

)

/

%

4 B "B

"

9& !1* .

0114* 4

+

& C%%

= !1

&& ) + !& & )4 /11* <%11 6% 4.

011* 4% $ 3% .

/1/ 00* && 3 $ ) *

* :&;' #

1*

% (

%( ' D @@& & 0 &

/.

4%

4% .

! 1

!D @@ & C%%

1 ! )1D @'

& C%%

!

01 !D @'

9& C%%

! &

%1* /1 00 / * /* 1 11*

0 .

!1 /1

"D

@'& & '10&

&

1

E $% 44 @C

FE&@

@ 1*

!"

!

E

!

(

!"

/* 1

! :& '()

&

%.

1 !! * )%10

! :&

E 'C '()

1

! :& / FE&'

?& 0

% *

1

.

11 0/

%1"

5

% .. 5

H

! :&

! 4% 9 ".

01* 4% %.

!" H

& 11 %

! 4 (1"

/ 11"

%1 &

&

** / & F/

0 % &

&

1

4%1 1* !* % )

.

4* =11 =

4 0E 995 $ ; " % %1"

5

A % 995& % ) 0

4%1 !* !* .

* ! 0 ! 4% 1 * =&

1

% 0

) !* .

*

/1 % 1

.

1 1 1/

00

14 1 4 ;B)1 !E

(),$%(/ % 6!(%+$7.(%83,7,)#/&

!(%(81)9,(%#$)9!

$

?

(:7(%!(/% 6!(%+$7.(%83,7,)#/& (%6 (7;

969!6 (75

?

?

$

%.

1 !! * )%10

% )

"

1 &

1

% 0

) ).

3 $ !!11

1/ ) FE&'

B@ =* "B ) $ "5 1)1"

*

"& % ) 0

*1 '>

&

& .

*

7$ "8&

1

% 0

.

( %

!1"

*

3 $ %.

FE&'

/

0 *1 '>& !!

% * .

1

! :& % !1

1 ;B)1 $!

%,)#%#,(% 6!(%+$7.(%83,7,)#519,7/(/&

,/(<1,%:9(%#$)9!

'

'

/1

?

4% %1 %

%

)1"

( !11

4 4%1 % *

1

% 0

0

(),$%(/% 6!(%+$7.(%83,7,)# /& (/(<!, 9(%(%(%#(%$)9!

'

'

/1 4% 1.

;B)1 $!

%1

B "B 4% 00 0*

%/5@ =*

B "B.

/11*

4% (

&

&

)1.

1

% *

1 E

1)1"

1"

& 0

) %

1/

! :&

%.

%

1 *

1

% 0

) *1 '> )* 411 %

& 0

)

,% 1 .

)4 B "B

B@ =* "B % ) %1 %

? 9

I6<

:&9 J 19,"

3$+9(%1,%:9;9$/( /& (),$%(/% 6!(%+$7.(%83,7,)#(%# $)9! = &

&

&

)

1

&

9& 1".

1 !

$

,% 1

*

% (

:&

&

1 :&

44 (&

%1 $

,% 1 .

1* 1 / .5

&

.

1)1

* 1 4% * ) " & */

.

1

*%1"

%1"

5 1 5& 1

*%1"

5 4 1 E! %.

1 !

.5& * " .

1

*%1"

!!1 1!1

?

% 1 !

.9. 5& 1 1 / 0 1 E! !

% * % 9.5

%

1=%

) =* 1 )* 1

.. 5&

&

%11* 0

1 )%10 4

A& ;4/

=* %

1 )1& 3%

/4

1 :&

40 1 * 9 .5 1

.95 1

1 4

!(%(81)9,2 +( !

& ;4/

1 * "

1

% 0 ! !

$

,% 1 %1 $

,% 1 .

/ /

0 ! &

& $.

.

! 1

A % .95 1*

1

1 ! 11

1K&

?& 011"

/

.

( /11* 3 $ :&;' # / '()

1".

)1 )11

/ 1.

'()

1

= *

.

(

!

>>'

:&

?&&

* $ 3%

*

& 0 3 $ !!11

FE&'

1".

%

4

3 $ A&

1 FE&'

/ B1)1"

1"

"B B$ "5 "B 41

1"

% "

=& > ( $*% 4% /11* 3 $

1

% "

%

% *

.

01 "

1

!

!5*

1&

!5*

/

% "

1

%/ =* 1 !

& 0)1

0 %

*

(* ,/(<1,%:92 +(

!

4% !11

4%

*

%1

"& %!(/ (%(:!5 %,)#%#,( % 6!(%+$7.(%83,7,)#/&

3(>7,(%#$)9! 5 <

.

;B)1 $!

4%1 !1 *

1

1 4 ,/(< 1,%:92 +( !

.

114 !!1

E

% !11

!11

*

(/(<!, 9(%(%2 +( !

.

;B)1 !E

* %1 B "B 00 0*

%/

K

! / .

0 ".

=* 1 / 0

1

/ %/5@ =* "8.

1)1"

41 0 0

0*

00 ;*%

.

%"

)&

& #=4.

;B)1 !E

!,%)(/ % 6!(%+ $7.(%83,7,)#/& 16!%#!(()93$$7?((%#$)9!

'

'

/1 4%1

1"* ! 14 1 4 ,/(<1,%:92 +(

!

.

) / 0114 + /4 0 0 1 ! 11 ) %/5! =* "8 41

1)1"

!"

!

/1 7 "8 00 0* % %/5@ =* "8&

1 !

1

'>.

4% 1"

% ".

%

! * %/5@ =* "8

1)1".

"

!

* & C "

%

1 0"

1

4

! 7 "8 4% 1"

% "

!

6.

0 %/5@ =* "8.

1)1"

41

& 3% ! 4

6%*"1=%

!

.

0 .

0

1 *

6 %& C ! %= "

0

1 *

6 '>.

4% 1"

% ".

%

1 0 ! *

1 4% )

!

(* >1% ;*%

4 1

!

&8

/4 0 % / ;B)1 !E

%1*

!5!*

/

% ".

0*

.

.

0 .

11*1

)/

14 1 4 ;B)1 $!

& /4 1 ! 14.

)/.

= "

)0

! %

19,"3$+9(%1,%:9;9$/(2

!

&

.

/ 7 "8 1

/

0 .

1)1"

0

*1".

% )"

1)1"

0 4

!

1 &

& /4 )/.

!!11

114 !* A !!11

!"&

& 1"

114 ! 1 % .95 1* % ) 1 )1&

1* %

! 4

A.

1 :& $% 44 (&

4 1

+)$?!5& @ % -

C%%

!=*5 L5:

C%%

!

)1 L5: