New India Assurance Company Limited v. Gurdeep Kaur And ORS.
!"#
$ %&' %% (( ) *
%+ ,
%
- *
%+ , %% (( ) .!.#/,,
% ! "
# !$
% %
&'(')* 0 1
,0(,2 %% ((3#
4 % 3# -4 0 #5#!(2 , %% ((3# -4 % 3#
4 %
+
$ 6, 7 !%% (, # ! - % 7&, 0
$(# 6#7 (2$, #/,3, # 8, 6#7 (9,4, 7 #/ #% 7&,# 1 6, 7 #/
,7
#( 7&, "
$ %& #/# #!, 6#7 (!,
-,7
#( 7&, (#
:#/ ,
#! , #
,
7 #/:
&
.
# (&2, , , 2;1# .#/,,#3#
4,## ,## %(
# )#((/ 6(# #((#/,#
(, !,# ,% % , ,:
(( & ,## (& .#/,3 % 4(# ,## ( .#
.#/,! !
((2, .!.#/, % (#, 7 02.!.#/,! #/, (( & %, ( #, ,
#, /(#/ %
6, % % , %71
,###/#
,, 7 , #%&&,
:,# (( &/#;1#.#/,!,!#/, # / ,#,
, # % 2;1#.#/, # (#%( /# #1 # , # 2.!.#/,( ,
(/!#,, (( &;1#.#/,!:
*"0< 2$,#/,#%# ,# 7& # .#/,5#.#/,!, , !
(
;1#.#/,! & / , # ,# , ;
!, #
0=,#> #( '2,#/# /# #
$,#/,!/ #/ ,(&(& 2
=(/!#,
= &
((!
= , # 7&,# #, %&
,2,
! (# , 7
#/ ?2
=% ,!# @%&
6:#/#
, # @ #( 7&,
2 6#7 ( ,##
=% ,+
%#/## !
/
7 , & 7 7 (! & 2# # A! #,## 6, 2, (#
! 2
?= ,#, (# !
!,#% ( @% (#%(# 8 9!%%(# ",#!&2 ( #2# #/7,%
#&%
#& / 2 2- ?
=!! , %% ((= (# #,#
(# % ##(/!#,# A% ,
# 7 %#7&, %% (("
$ %&"! , #
,# #
%&%#, !#,#% # ,2, # , - A% ! (
% - '
(,
$ %&,#/ (& #( , # % / !, / ,, # , #/ ,# !,(#/&(#(#
# # ,# '#/,0) ,# 3'0)4;
!##/ (( &!,#( ,###/ (#
(&% # ,# # = =1
%= & 6, ( 6#7 (, ##/#/, ,, ##/(#
# ! (###/, (( & '0) , 2( (/
,, ,# #B
#!% ,# !7 #/
#( ,# 6, 2, !7 ,, # #,
(# &
#,# /! , 1 /
,#$ #
-
#
(/!#,, 1 , ;97( .
%
$ # - -./.0 ;
, (# %
! "
- -./.0
1 #
- #
1 $ %
-
# 2)3 % & $%$%% ''
- % ? ;
, ,,
,
, ( ,
,# (2, !#/7 ,#, (( &!, , ! #/"!
,#( : #,,
, :
%(
6, ( 6#7 (,!/(& (# %, , "
, #,,
#B
#
!#,, # ,# , (/#/, "
# # %, /(#/
% =# .!.#/,3#
4 7#, 7 #2, ( (,
$ %&, /, ## #, !%& ,
&#/,7 / ,
$ %& '
(, (# ,#( ,, # % / !, / ,, 6#7 (,#/ , ( " 6@
3"6 4!#, &(# 6, ##/, (&,
!
((, 6@
.
36.4, & ! (&% <@ 6, (
,:
%(
2, 2
# (#7( #
% (&,
, & !#(7(
2 6#7 (2!#, & / 2,#/ , ;
, 7 # ,, ;
/,, 7
# 7&, 6#7 (!,#( #/, #6, ( (, (# ,%(
(#
%, & ! #(&
-
-./.0 1) %*'
)#
-
#
2)3 & + &
! &+
- % -./.0 %%,# #;
( ,, / # , ##
!#,, ( (! %4%
# %% Having heard counsel for the parties and perusing the record of the case with their able assistance, this Court is of the opinion that the amount of compensation needs to be redetermined as per the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
+
- %
+ ,$ "
2 - %
6,
$ %&,( & #
7# # (# , (( &# #( ,# , # , #/ ,# !,#/(#(#
# #( ,# , #
2, ! #
!,#( , #/, % %% ( 6,#$ ,7 , ((!#/ C
,
5 > ,, ;97( .
%
$ #!565)3
'72)82) /$ &.')*20 )(5&2)9'
:;<2)= #.;.*'3 - -./.0
+ % :#/, /,5 #
0#,, (,
!!!
+ &-.
""#$ %&'&$'%((#)$ ""#% *'' +, '
-
.
.
/ / /
/
(#+$ % 01
* * $ %
.
+/"
""2$ %&'&$'%+( )$ ""2%( *'' 23
0 -
4
4
5 $ %' ) /(20
6 7 ' 8
' 9* *$ ""#% *'' +, -
* $ %#$ %("$ %(#+ :;0 #, 4 6
0 -
4
4
/ % (, %(# &% # , 3<@ 4,!, % # !7 #/ ,/ ,#%& / , !
(( #( , 2!,# , & / ( 7&,#%& #
$ %&, ,/ % #
, #
/ ,#%&2, #, 1 #
,+
0 % )0.)'
!
((%
,+$
-
% ! (7 %%(# 7(
-
"!5 > ,, ;97( .
%
$ # '
1
-%
+ % :#/, /,5 #
.>.#,,!,#( # ##/ %% (, %, (, #(!(#!7&, (,#;#/,$ ((!#/7 #!
3 .
.
<'
= >
* (#, 0. 6
/?
' ? ? / . 0
'
(, ""
) /* 9 . . ? (* *
'
) $% 4
$
% -
: ;
0 '
4
$%@
/
* (#A (#,
4
B
C
* $(#% 0
$ %&,
% # ,# %&2# % #(#7#(#&"# !, #
,
, #(#!#,
#
##2,#$ # # %## , , "
$ %& # (#7( %& ,
#, (# , #
# #/ ;
, (&
# #2!5 > ,, ;97( .
%
?
$ # & + & 2
30 % :#/ , /, 5 #
.> .#,2 ((!#/7 #
21
D@ 0 ED< & 0 E
- !5 > ,, ;97( .
%
$ #),+
+ ! $
+ -
% 2, # (&, (,%7 & 7( 7
7 %%(# #
, .% :#/, /,5 #
+*/ (&2# !, (((! C(3
.
.
.
F <'
? 6, ;97( .
%
$ #! #2
3."
+ $ % 0 -
% 2, (,, #7 # #(%#
( /#(#,
7
, $ /,7 #, #1 =
% , 2, ;97( .
%
$ #+(, +
1 2 -
% -&.$ 2, /# ((&, (, # 7 / , 0) ,# #
# 7& #/ ,# 6, #(,#%, (, !, , ,# # #&
7 :!2, ,
((!#,#, %
@% #8 ,# 9
#%
#/(&2 ( # #, /
7, %# % (,
2, ## #, ((!#/ 6,#$
#%% , (&,
2 =% , "6 , &
?
=#
@6, # #(#(7(
##
#%;
7 /(&#
2 #(!& %, (& , 2#
/
!
& 2#
!#,
2
32 %%
A / "(#/,, ,,
! # ,,
% 3!# ! # ,#( 42
#=#7
(#%(# #7 %%(# ## !, (!(#!#
3 "##, 7 2 2
=#! ( @ % 2
=(
= ,, (# ( # 2## !
2
3
= #/ (##/# @% %&$ :$ '23 ;:5)* ("
2 = 6@
?2 = "
#6@3 2 D
?2 4
2?2 = %
3 A4 =
@ 2?2 E
22 =
' " 3 2?2 F
22 4
2 -2- =
#3=4 =@2 -2- =E 2 2 ?= - ' % & 3 -- D
?4
2
2=
? (#%(# 3 43 2
2=@ 4
2-2?= '<
2
= (<@%
2
= '$#
2
=@E
22
= '##/#<@%
=
$ :*20 ;:5)* :> :;<')(2*.:) ($++? $
(&2, %% (#( 7&, (# # -#((!
, %% (#( 7&,
$ %&#
## # 6,
$ %&##
%&, # # ?22?=!#,#% #! , , %#/,# (/!#,# , - % , #(#/, (# % ###((# (#G#"
& #%#!, #7&,
$ %&2 ,((7
, # #
#/%%(# #342#&2,(((#%
/#&##
%&,# ( 0
$(# 6#7 (2$,#/,=<@
#/$ %(#
- %
$ $ H, % :#/= I = H, %7( I =