← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2183/2011dismissed

Food Corpn. Of India, Area Manager, Karnal v. M/S Bajrang Bali Rice Mills, Karnal

2016-05-10Mr. Justice Arun Monga11 pages





           !"# $   %

&%#'(# ) * +

,-.-,"- "/-0 %%%..00 1-2

34-50  00" 50 ,"- ,6"/-0* !- %%% ., #%

&%#7((# ) * +

,-.-,"- "/-0 %%%..00 1-2

3&-! ,-0 00" 2,&!8 2- ,"/-0* !- %%% ., (%

&%###9# ) * +

,-.-,"- "/-0 %%%..00 1-2

3 0  00"2,0"/-0*!- %%% ., 9%

&%#$ # #) * +

0-,5:. ";#; "4 ,":<0*!- %%%..00 1-2

,-.-, %%% ., ;%

&%#$9;# #) * +

3&2:-,5%1005/!2,/!2-,"5,!- ,"":<0 *!- %%%..00 1-2

,-.-, %%% .,



 !"#$%&' ()%)(*$+&',-% % =!!- .--00..-: <006,!42,5:> #% <---,! .---> (% =!!-!42,5:!20,<-.-,!5>

-

8/&!-:",8"

-!..00 &%#'("###9,#7((# * -!-.,)+ &%#$ ,#$9;# #%

2!/2:--5",8"

-!..00 &%#$9;# #%

-%%%0",8"

-!..00 &%#$ # #%

-%1%/%,0"&-,86!

,-&% 2",8"

-!-., &%###9"#7((,#'(# % ????? )(*$+&   ! -,-"   ,   ,.   8 520- &, ..0<-5%#'("#7(("###9# "#$ ,#$9;# # !::@206,808,00!..0-! :%

&%#'("#7((,###9# -! ! ,-.-,)-!-A B+5!42,5:, ,-"6!-< !20,5!:00-/-0!8< ,:,, &%#$ ,#$9;# #!8<0,< !

00-5!42,5:,,-"6!-< !20,<!0 ! < 8C5!42-,2-:<0"!8< ,-,%!-<5C-: &%#'(# % ! 0,2--8- " 9"(D"$9(%$ 5! ,,!-25!- 5-"- "/-0"6!!< 2!-,< !E0 5-, -.0 - 0!2 <!0!.-:!8,---5F2:F:005



.,, -8,-: 24<-5 <-2- "DD;%!< 005,!.-0-,,7%#%DD;",,-,!00; @20.,, -:,,<,-:,,--8, < ! ,0,.,2: " 3F-: 05 6!-%!2-!-<.0,,!.0!! "8, 05-:,,#%#%DD;"8 ,!.-!,, -:%

8/&!-:"0-,20..-5<!0 !..00F 2<:!!,5-,-,< <!!2- <06,:5!2-0 0050<2.-8-":2!0 -<-- ,002!2-<06!8G:,! !C60,5:"---,<8"<2.-!.-8 & ,D!-"'7#".!2- -      02,,  -  ,    2..-    !  -:, 2<:"-0,2.!42,5:-,-,< !:< 5!2- .

/)  0 1230$0 4// 

5

/+6 )  # 789     2-!-  2<:  !  !  :00-  !,  58   2,-C5!00!2:00,.,, ! 00-!& 24< !,  5    -C  -    05  ,  -5  !  .,,  -:  ! .-2-:5,65!!-5.03."!.,,

6-,!:000,- &"0!<-,-

24<-!.2-.2::005"!2"!<-:0 5-:!85-,620,0,:0!2 !5-2,!!-6-%:---,!2 :2.,, @206-,!:00!,,, !-  :00-  ,  !    6  0  C60,5,  !-25!  8-2

:

,2:%!6:.2<0!,!6..-,:<0 8,,"!--"!2-20,!8C!5H%! -05-:-,<6!.-02,,,<,5 -% !2!,<,:,65-2,")+!-6 02,,-<6!.-I,)+!260,< ! ,20 2!-, -.0 -.-!.-8 -,-#D 20  % 2-!-2<:!86!060,,6! 42,5:-,-, 0# ; )

.4//(/7 7// *

  0.

 7 9

 01/+)66<# 789=+

.-!85<  2!-,  <  !  :. 2!-     0

:.5!.0"<20..-!6<G%.- !::-,2:!2"!:!,<0,!-25!!-

5-"  6!  !,  <  ,20  2!-,  <  E0  5-  ,  ! .-.06!0<2.!0,< !J<0&2.-:2- '

.0 # ; )

.4///157

 01/+66<)

 ! 6:)G%=3+ .2<0!, A,G.-B ,,$%%DD;66!-5-,!00:.,, C-! .2-.:005/-0%!-:,6:20, .-802.!42,0:,-:.-- !-0, ,2:- 8,.0,--,%!2-6-4,2. <05,,!2-,<-C5-8- ! 2<0 :2    !  .-.,-    ! -0  ,  ,2:-

8,%  !  .  C"    ,  ,  ,2    !  -.,

=

,!.25!-!,5!-,.C 2-!-!. -":-FG2! 5-:620,0!,42,!,.2,"!2" 2-5!2--:20!00652<0@206 + =!!-    2  0,  <  ,20  2!-H,  K -.0 -J!-.-2,- -,-F#D 20F -, 6!  &  (7    !  ,  -.-     D$9  < ,-,<.-.-0 2,*.-.-0 0,80 2> #+ =!!-!6:.2<0!,!6..-- ,:<02,-8,6!2!-.-C !.0-5-8,,.-,2-0:!: .-820> (+ =!!--05-:-,<6!.- ,2-!-!-.C.--:!-   5-,  620,  :2    <,5  -  <6  ! .->

-%1%/%,0"  0-,  &-  20  ,  <

,-&% 2,8"..-5<!0!-.,

&%###9"#7((,#'(# 2<:!:0-26-0 2,8-22-"<2!::<,:,, !:--!,!2- 520-&,..0%97D(# 9 0,A ,-.-,1-2 3 -!, 0 2C,L0 ,!-B",,,7%D%# ;,!2-"-,25!- 8,  !-,<-"  -:,    .  !  !-  6    02,, 5-:<6! ,!:00---5!.,, %!-6

>

.-8 -<6!.-,!.,, -,! .-::00-66!!,:! ,6!0<0

! C.!.,, !,,.-8!,:5" !:5!!.-.-!0053:005%2-!-2<: !! !,05!-2-,-:!2-:. , 8C,  !  42-,    !  0  2:-  .2  ,-0 ::"60!< 05 -50 %#;;DDD0, ,-.-,1-2 36,2-%L,%"<2 !::,:,!."6!0--85,5!! .,, !,0-, <,:5,6!!2-.0 6<,% 2-!-2<:!<!!2-<06"-G:5!8, G"-:,.!!-6.-8 -, !<!-"005,C60,5:620,! 2!.-.

-!-%!005,C60,5: -80!!:00-!,:!-2! --5! .,, 65!-20!:00-!& 24<0! .,, -!.2-.2::005"!<4,: <!,!C60,5:60 -!.2-.-5, !005%    8-:  5 "  6!2  !85  -,     5-:3-"---2<0@2 .,, - 2::005%8!-6"6!-!:00---- !.2-.2::005!-"! --@2-,G2! <C52-,0. !2- %.6-C< ! -.-!-5-,"!--"-5!0 "!2-<06!8 ,:,!

-%%%0"  0-,  20  ..-5    <!0    !

<

..00 &%#$ # #2<:!<!!2-<06!8 ::,0050 ,.-8- ,-5!2,.!! !-  6    .-8    -  ,  !80  -0,  2.  !  005, 5-:%  ,.  ! -52:  2<:,   <!0   -%,0 ..-5<!0!:003:00-0,/-0,"!2"2-5 !  2-    -:20  !  0065  2<0  @2    06  - ,-:< !2- + =!!-    !  <      02,,  -3 .-8 -<6!:00-,! "2- -8- :<0-> #+ =!!-!2-<06!8:-,!,2: ,!,5--,50 :.0,< !80 -0 5 2.!005,C60,5::25.-8- >

-%,0!0-0,2.!42,5:-,-, ?/ .

;7/4@0 -78!4//)

. .  0.

$0 +66  .3. <6,!!,-5-:-!5 <6!.-"620,<-2,02,,-<6! .-%!0,!42,5:-,-,A

  0.

  )

.4//# 35

 01/+6)2 B8 +6!- !<!0,!!- 5-! ,-.- :.6-,,2!<!0!-.-,!80

86,:,%

8/&!-:"-<20"!0-0,2.! 42,5:-,-,< !J<0&2.-:2-5 . .7  

891.// 00.34//(/@019  

891.// 00.3/

 01/+)6> 7 0



,!6!-!.-!,!6!6!,"-:0 5-:,-62.<,<<2,< !-, .% !8!-,!0-,20-!.-,..-, !..-<C,!86!!-2<!2<:   8  /  &!-:"  6!-  !-    -  ,  :-    ! 2<: -%%%0,"!2"!..00,<!0!

-0<0<,:,,!!:00--0<0<006, !00655-2, + 2,.2,!-:05-:3-!, <  -,    <6  !  :00-  ,  !  %  ! -35-:858-2G5!!. ,"  :2!  0    -<-  02        

,.2I #+ !  5-:  0  85  -      < .--:,<!0!:00-"%%"2-!52- ,8,<C52-%:---,! 2!<C52--2- " .:"6 2<:,< !:00-%! !,0,.0--,  -.8FF82..0 !.,, ":2!0  - 5.!I (+ ! !0,.0,!5-,&  7!-"6!!,06!-,25%, !-<2!.0,5".-!.!.0 !,: -  8FF8  !  -  ,  C60,5:"  <2    ! <2!.0,5"!-:,8,

6

<0C,I 9+ .-200-,,#(%#%DD;)G%;+"#D%%DD7 )G%$+"#7%D%DD$)G%D+,7%#%DD')G%#+, !!-6-%!-.--<,.--:- !85-,-6!!8-:5 ,:00-%"! !,,2:.,!25C.,,

65!,!:00-0!.,, -! .2-.2::005"-"..!:0006  2,,2:.53C.,, <!0!.-2-: 5%"-5.,, 2.-2-: 5%8"2:-20-!8<.0,--, <!0!,,-@25! 0!.,,

-:!.-:!.,, 6<,,,0.,, ,,!!0<,< !0 2:-.2 ,-0::"60! -,-,,(%'%# 9., -50 %#;; DDD"6!-!-!<5-,5!,:5! .,, !,0-, 2--,.--(%'%DD;"%%"!, !  .0  ,"  !2"  !  .    .-:2:  <  ! 2-:. ,0,!-.-0,5! 0:I ;+

=F#0/!,:,!!-.0.--: 5-:)G%#(+-:005,-5!.,, % 0,:,!-:,,6-0,6!! ,,6!-5-,!:005F2:F-5%"! -FG:"  ,:,  !    5-:  6  -<,



<6!:00-,! ,!5,:, G% 6-!C,< @20 -0,6!G%

6G2,"!-:,.,, 6!C,<

!:-6!C,!.-%,:,!G%

62,-!.,, !,0-, <-,,! -5!.,, 60!C,< !:%2-!- ,:,  !  !  "  -  05  !  .,,  -:  ! ,,J.-:",,5:00,-: !-- !00-"-!-!.,, 60,< 85,-%!, .,, 6-,C!0-!:00%!-6- 6,-,6,.0C%!2":

86"!  !0,0 2,C5!-8- ! :200!2"!--"!42,5:,,- -,-,@2-8- :2 &%#'("#7((, ###9    #   -  !-<  -:,  ,  !  42,5: , ,-  -,-,    & %#$  , #$9;    # # - !-< F,I $+ -5-,!,5!2-<066!-5-, !:. !- 5-25!2" :!86!2!,56!! .-8 -,-#D 20 !<!0,!

.-2!-,<!0!-.-,.-5 !.0%!::-,2:!.00-0 !6!! 2!,<0,!-25!- 5-"6!!,< ,20 2!-,< !E0 5-, -.0 - ! %-,-0,2..-:

<-8"-0 2.



!42,5:-,-,< !J<0&2.-:2-

DD7&(% /.5    86    !  -:,    , -2:" @2%-:,!-@2 8/ &!-:    6-,    82-    !  ..00F.0F     & %#'("#7((,###9# ,5!-.,F,," 6!-@2%#,(-6-,5!..00F.0 ,82-!-.,F,,% !@206-:,!-@2 -%%%0- 6-,82-!..00F.0 &%#$ ,#$9; # #,5!-.,F % -,50 "  &  %#'("  #7((  ,  ###9    #   - ,:,"6!- &%#$ ,#$9;# #-006,% 901+>   )(*$

7/1 &',-%