High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7508/2015allowed

Simranjeet Kaur v. Union Of India

2019-01-17Mr. Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan10 pages

!"!#$ % &!'( #) * +( #!# #,!

!"# $"

&%'

( !"# $" ))))

* %+ % #"& %$"

, & #" "$, ,

% , ,# ( , -& (.

/01231/4

, " 5631/7611809:""##, % ,. ,9& ,( # ,( *, $$ ,9& %+ 9:;,# #% ,."$

6#% 5 -< &$"#".

," ."&"$

8% # 9-# 9:,9& %"("& ;

9" $,

(

6#% 5 - < & #% ,. , ,," $,% 9$",9& % "301=31/3 /41

( %"(;,& .%: ,%< & ." , .%:

!, < &:;#".,($".., "

- &

9"& 711 ; : # < &

: ,"

6#% (" "; ,""#"%%#$ ;

$ >,(;

; ;

:,("9"

, $"";

(" "; " : #> ","$,. ,;

."! &%"$;,# %$ ;

#& % " & , ,"& ,-&, ""

"$9"

: $&#% ,. ,#% ,. ,," # & "$ ;

?# ,!#";

, &"

( ; & ,(

&%%,( #" % ,. -< &, %"" ,(9 # %,

,(" : #> ;

>"' %"

, %

$" . % "

&,(, "# & ;

%" ;,#;

#" ,,(( #% :,#> &# 9:$".., "

- & "..": # "$

, & &# ,#> $" %% " ;"; !%%,("( &",:$,% , ;, .$&,(#% ,."$

>,(& "$ # ",#>;

#"! $".

" ,""$

*,-& + ;

> ;

(

#,! ,-&, &"";#,., (%,(# .9,( %$5,$%,# ,-&, ;

",% $" :

#".

,"& #,"/385"$

: # /@=@*, $$

#+;

% " 9: : ":"$%" "$

& ,."$ , $"&(9# &

"%"

( : ";, #" ,9& %"#" , ,""$,!

% %

,( "$

, $ .

$"%%";,(, & 5

# $

%!$&

#&(

- " " 9%, #% ,.

%$ A5/ % "9"&(& "#" #,$, #"

:"$?5/ ;,#, ,-&: " ?53,#,$, #"

:"$ ."$ ,. - < &9$"'

%"(;,, % ," ?57#,$, #"

:"$ ."$ ,%< &9$"'

%"(;,, % ," ?58 #,$, #"

:"$ ."$'& #" 9:'

%"(;,, % ,"?54, #,$,

:"$ ."$ %"(;,, % ," ?50 , #,$, #"

:"$ ..", & 9: ," < & ?52"?5/@ #"

, "$ . ,# %#" ?531, #,$, #"

:"$" ?3/, #"

:"$ 9,%,:#,$,# ?533#"

:"$9 > ##"& #,$,#

9 %$ "$ : &",: "

99"&("#" , , . "$ A5/

. % " &:

"#",%" A53

% " &:(& ! % "99"&("#" ,9& % #"."#"#%& ," ,, &9%,!

9% #% 5,-&

%" ,#> !% ,! &# ,,#> 9$"'

;,%9,(?

., , $&&9%,!

9% '

,."$,! ,( ," ;"&% ! > $",#> "$% ,! & ,, " 9%, #% 5,-& ;

"% ,(

,#> ;

!%%,(;,% ,! , ,%< &

!, < & , $& '

#" ."$ ,. -< & ,%< & " &:(& $ 9"&758." $" ,# "9 #" , "9%, 9% #, %%:; ,%< &

!, < &#"&%

"9?

., 9:#% 5,-& 9$",9& % % "9 "9 ! ,$% ,! ; !%%,("( ;

" ";:

,#> ;"&% ! 9 &# 9 , "$ &# "9 !

," ,9& % #" $, ,( #% 5,-& ;

" 9"

(

. #"& %$"

&9., , "

, #

#:"!

, ,", ..

9$" '

,9& % ;, ""

"$#" 5?

., ," % "

, ." ,.

" ";"#"&% !

( ,(,#, , .

$ ;

.$ % %:,

$$,

!, 9$" ,9& % #"&% ! 9 ."%, 9: ,. "$ #" 5?

., ," %: ,# "%:

., %$ % ,! ;"?

., "&( ."$" "$.;

#" 9:'

"$ .

99"&(" #" 9:

,# "9% ;

(, " ";: ":"$%"" ,( & ,."$

# "99%,! ) * % #"& %

,( $" :

&",: &9., , " .9$" "%,#( ,(%" "$

& ,9:

"9: ,%< && , ":# "9 9%,! "9& ""

;

!%%,(;,"&,#> & # "9#" , 9"

( #" B&#"$ ;"&% "9,% $" :#".

,, % "

'& ! ," ;

:,("9"

"&,( , $"

"##& #,#&. # , "9 ## ;

!,#,."$";#,., %(%,(# ,-&, %$5,$%,# " #"& % " ;"&% "9,% $" :#".

," ";! !,( #" , ,!

%#"," "$

, , "&$, $"# , &9., ," , " 9 %$"$

$" $"%%";,( " 5 ,

., # < &

5 #% . ;, ,. "$ 9"

,( , '&

! ," , ;

,( &,( , 9& ,9& %

, 9%,! 9# & #"&% " &# (& .." "#"

,%" "%:#" ,, "9""> ";".$%% "; ,-&

%$" $". . $%% ";$". ," $".

..""$ ," % " &

" ! ,""$'& ;,# 9 9%,! 9:,9& %,(%:& ! ,""$ &",: ;

:,("9"

&,( " " 9%,

5 #% .%: "? ,."$9"

,( , %,

&" & &%%"$#";

;

(( ," :%,

"9& ""

; $%% "; ","$,. , ."!,(;,# # & #& ,(,-&:& "%,.9;,#

&9 B&%:"9 .

& " "9 , "$ "#&. &# 9: &",:, %$ , " "

;

,( &,( , .

>,( .#" :"#" ;"&% ! 9%, #% ,."$ &",:!,$,, & , "9"

."!,( , ";,, ;%% % .;"&% % "9#"! ;,,. ,("$ &";

,#, ".,(".

,, &,;

;

(""C

$5#"& % ,! ! "

" ?

., . %! 9$",9& % 9&#% 5,-& %$ 9?

$,% $$,

!, 9#" 5?

., % " %(9: :

&",: ! #" 5?

., ," ;,#, !

,% 9%"#" "$ ";"& .:"

,," #"&% "9 >9:#"& %$" :

&",: &,(#" 5?

., ,"

$". 9"! $ # &5 ,% < & #" .9$" "%,# % " ;,#, !

,% 9%"#" ,;,#

" ! ," "$

" $ %" "$ & , #"# # "9% "9&& & %,( #"& %$" , B& ," ,$ & ;

%" ","$,."$ ;:"9"

#"$ " .#"&% "$"& "& .:#" , !,; .# "9 , ( " #"& % "9# & ,, "#% ; & $%%" ,""

$"." : #>

$". 9"! . 9.

" $$,

!, ;, ""

.,#" 5?

., ,"

&:;

% "# & " &",, ".

> #$" " 9%"(,( " , " $". " : #> "" $

9&, ",("#" " "; &#? ,! #;

, ",#>" &# & ""9%"(,( #"&% 9 $"& "& , ( $#, .

" #, ,""$ %,,("& ,

9% .," , #

#, , ,.":"$:5;, ;" !%% , . , ;, # # "9 , ( 9:

,( :

#,# %

# , "& , , #$&% (. ;, $" !,;

9:% ,(%& ("$ %,,("&;"&% 9 %;

" ,9,%,:"$%"" ,(,#>" &#%

& ,.; " %$$%% ";$". ;

,"& %: !%: (,!"& %:,-& B& ,";"&% , 5;, &# ,& ," " :9"

:;";

!%%,(;, ;"&% .

>,( #$" & "!:9"

,";"&% 9" >""

, %$" .C ;;"&% 9

"9!,"& $, ,",:;"&% 9(,!".

> (. $"(,( ,-& "

, % ;"&% " ,9,%,:"$%"" ,( & " ,#>,, "# &;

&",: C: ".

> : #"$ , #"$"##&#$"#"!:"$ :!, %#%&"!, # ,B&,:;

% % ( , $.&# % : ;;"&% 9"

" ,9,%,:"$$, ,("& :,(

" $ B& ," " ; '

> $"

&#,""$,#> "" ;'

"&% ! ","" ;"&% , ,, # '

:,! ,( .

, #"#.

" ! ,#"# .

9& ;"&% " # ( ,! !, # , $ !"&"$ &",, &""5 ."$%" "$ & 9$"'

" ("& "$"5 &,,(!,#,.;"&% ,.:"

,," 9%,> >,( !::

#,# %!,;"$.

#"& %$"

, &

""$, #","

$ -& (."$ ,(%#"$, "& , +

* .

% #&"&# " / * #" ,$ !,#,.

$%% ";$".#";

, "!, # !,#,.;

!%%,(;, ,#> , "9 &. !,#,.;

( , " "$ ;%% #%9 -& (. ,

!"# !

#* ?"& %

. #"$ 9"

:" ., ;,%%"9#"#%& ,!""%

,-& " # ;

9" $,

( $" ;,# #% ,. $" #".

,"#"&% 9.

, , ";! . 9 #"$,#>;, &# ,-& " # ;,%% % ""( ,!#% ,.,,, %9& ;,%%9" #% ;,## 9 , # ( 9:$,%,( $$,

!, ,(%!

$ #

9& ;,%% ,$" : $ , &# 9 #, " $ # ";" ,(#,#&. # .:#" , !,; ,#, ",("#" " ";

? ,! #;

$"$, ,("&,#>""9%"(,( "$ !,#,.,.. %: $ 9: &",, , 9 # "$ ,;"&% 9!: ,$$,#&%" , %"

(

"#"& ;

( & ,.:#" , "

,," ,9& % ,#" ,(

$, ,(" &.

," &.

," ,#'

> :

B& ," ( ,( ,#> ,#

,#> ; %%( %:

&# $" " 9&,#> &# 9:!,#,.;

"$"&

$". " ," ;

( &#$, ,( "9 % ""& "9 ,#>" & #" ,,(,#> #"&% !9%" , ,"" : #>"" $".", ;

:;,-& ;

>""

, %"!,"

, %; ;

9,( #% 5,-& # "9$ ;,%, 9,%,:".

# #"%%# %%!, # "# & ,#> !"&(

","$,.

&$$ .&%, %(,!"& ,-&,

$".9,( :

5#,# %!,; , ;,%%9,&.

# % " ##" ,(%: $, ,("$,9& %;, #", &"/, B& ,, % ,$ # #,#&. # "$# ,-& ;"&% !"9#" , 9"

(

"$ $, ,(;, #", &"3, #"# , & % , $ # #,#&. # , #& 9"! !,; "$ ,9& %

9# .!,#,."$ ; %,

,."$9"

,( < & : ," , & %

#" B&# "$ , , $& % , " 9 >

% &";

,#, & #,"/375*3+"$

: # /@=@*, $ $ #+ #" B&#"$

, % "9,%

$"#".

,"& #,"/385"$#

"$ #".

," ."&, #"# ,;"&% !"

9 ";

;

?"$,-&: # , ,#"! & 5" 5"$ # &% # "

:##, ";

#, *".

,"+ &% /@@1 ""$%$ 9%";%9";

"9 .

& . ,# % " &9., 9:,!,% &(" ,

;,# 99"&("#" ?53/ . , #%"

&$$ .

9,%,: "$ /11D &# # " 9 #" , & &%7*3+"$ $" &% 9 ,!

$".#

#,:" " :;">& #".

,"# 9 8 # $" &% !,;"$/11D 9,%,: &" .

& ,""$&

%,.9$".

9%";%9"; ,;

# "$ 0) ' ) 0* ;,#,

$". . ,# % " % "

& " ;

, %"# ,"

,*;"%+ , , #%" $".. ,# % " "$

-, "

, % , !

,% 9%,#" ;

#"..,&

$ #& , %"# ,""$ 5/3 5/!9 ;,.

> , #

! %"$ #& !9 ";, ;,# &% , ) ' ) &

#"& %$" : !.%: (&

9 !,#,. # ;"&% 9#"! & 5"$

# $ + " # *

22.

;,# $"$ #&"$ ,;,

%(, "%: 3% # , "9(,! ";! $"( ;

& ,""$%$%,.9 % "

;,## "9,(" ,# "9 >& 1& "%:"$

$" &% $"$ #&"$ ,;,

%(, ., %:$"%" "$ "&.9 $"&$,( "$"

" .

& ," , %"8"$ # &% # "$ $" &%

."&"$#".

,", "9(,! 3 81 11165 # ;"&% 9 #"! & ) ,,, "$ # &% # " # $ + " # *

22.&

< ,(,!,;"$$ # # , #"! & ) !,,,

1&%

9""$ $" &% "%,.9

9 .

& 9%";%9";

&$$ $ #&"$ , ;,

%(, % " #"& % ;,$ # ,!,% &(" "

, /11D 9,%,: % "$ # ,$9" >"( ;,%% ?# ."& "$ 8 % # , : #" , !,; -& $ , #".

,";"&% 9 8% # ;,#, .

?,.&.(,!& #.

$". 9"!

;"&% % "9,%

$", & " ;

."& &%

%, %%";

"$,.

&( & (., B& "? , #& 9"!

, % "9,% $"#".

,""$ 8% # %"(;,, E@D& "

;

."&"9# %#&% $".

"$ ,%%

:."$ #".

," * + ' /21/31/@ - A >,(6 " CF 6"

A " 9%C F 6"