Gian Singh v. Ashok & ORS
! "#$ % $ $ &'$'())*
) +),- ..'// & 0'12 -3 &-'1 '.'&
!2-.
&-'1 ..'// & 0'12 -3 &-'1 '.'&
*
!"
"#$
"% & & &'(
) * "#$
+ , -.
"
/
&
0 /
2$3 , 44
!"
"#$ - &. , '
) * "#$ , '
/.
544 /.
2"3 6 / . ( " #* "#$ /7 54
/ 8'
9 :
/:;
6 #) $" "#$0 / )0# , &. .
< .
47
7 ( (.
= &. ( 7.
47 / $# ## ( 7 = > &. 5 ? ./. ( /7 5 8'
4 4 / .. 4 .
47 , &. '
. 47 = &. = &. . 47 .
@7 '
4 ( 4
$ /
/ 4 . . .
= &. 4/ /7 & 0# % A5 ( 8
"
?B
5 8'
( ( .
8
0 4 /.
@
2 3 5 ( 4 4 4 5 '
@ 4. < 5 5 - &. '
( 7 5 @4 '
.
.
7 4 ? @ .
2*3
/
$ @ '
.. .
.
/ ( 4 4 8 0# C
0
/
!" # $ %&'()*+, -'.
.
.
44
/7 .
./. A ( 4 / .
.
.
( 7 4 .
? / 7 D/7 . 4 4 / 7 4 A ( .4 % (
. . 5 8' / . 5 .4 ?B 8) 8$# 4 .4 4 .4 /7 5 5 47 .
B
2 3 A ( /7 5 - &. / 7 4 4
7 4 4 4 - &. (
/
-*0% 1%&'- 2+3 - &. 7
"% 4 /7 4E
+ / 54
/ 8'
5 5 8'
54 (.
4 = &. 2!3 A ( ( 4 /7 547 & $0 95; $ + $ ) $*+ $+# ,
'
* ( 4 ( /.
7.
7 7
.
'
4 /. ?B 8%$ . / ( . 4 .7 7 ( /..
7 D .
?B 8%"
"0 #$ "#$*
2)3
2$#3 A 2" 3
$ #4 $5
67#"
%&'8)*+ )!4+''' ( .
. 4 4 .7 ( 4 D. 4 & "9"$;
( (. / & "9"$;
& "9$*;
"9 !;
& B 4 . 4 /7 44
* E$))
2$$3 4/ . (. ( B +*## '. ( . 4
.
. 4 & $#9";
9;
( 4 4/ . (. ( B +*## '. 4 % (. ( B +*## '.
(7 4 @ . 4 4 / & $#9";9;
44 * E$))
2$"3
44 ( $ $$ $)) ( /.
5 9;
9;
& $#9";
(
44 . & $#9";9; F44 . 4 G & $#9";9; 7 . & $#9";9.;
F7 . 4 G & $#9";9;
B : :
/ & $#9";9;
7 / 7 A B 4 ( & $#9";9;
& "9 $;
. 4
2$03
44
4
/7 .
F G 7 . ( ( / 7 $)) / .
F. 4 G 4 / . @4 / 4 A .
. 4 ( 7 4
7 / . ( ( ( 44
* E$)) ( ( /. .7
2$ 3 /. 7 ( 7 7 /7 .
/
5 ) 6$+ ( /
( "
$5
#"
,$94%&&0)'+ )!4+ '.0
,$94:5 ) 6$;
/ % 2"
3 5 ) 6$+ 7 ( ( > .
H:/ B 5 7 44
.4 ( %
!
"
"
" #
#
$
%&'%
"
"
(
%)% *
)%*)* +& + ,&,
-
. "
/ "
0 "
"
.
)%*)* /1 2 0
"
"
"
"
)%* )* )*
1
3 ) */4 "
0
% )% *
"
%)% *
%) 5* %)&*
.
"
6 57 ,, )
*
" "
.85!" "
/ " 0
. 85!"
"
"
(
)%*)*
" "
.85!"
#
" (
.85!" 1
"
)%*)*
57 ,, %&'%
)
* 1
6 57 ,,
,,
")* )*
)%*
"
(
)%*)* "
)%*)* "
)%*)"* "
(
)%*)* .
/ 0
)%*)*
.
)%*)*
%) * "
) *1 $
(
"
,,
"
"
(
"
" "
( 2$*3
. /7 <%% < ( .
4 ( 7 4 .
7 . ( /7 '.
/ % .4 . 5 8'
& / /7 5 5
2$ 3 ? ( ( 776
;
# "" $5 67#"
" # $%&'<)<+
)!4+-(* ( /7 . .
.
. 4 / .
44
2"
3 5 ) 6$+ ( / 4 /7 47
2$+3 D
##$ ,$"
##
" $ $# $6 $#
# 4 $5 67#"
" # $ %&'0)<+ %8< .4 .
9$"
$4 $5 67#"
#
" $=$ " # $ %&'&)%*+ )!4+<%(6 !)3"
3+
$6'..*)'+, -( 3"
$5 :#"
$ " # $ '..% ) 4+
<%. ( 4 . ( 7 ' B / 4 47 / ( /.
7 / 4 ( 4 ? 47 / ( 4
2$!3 A ( 7 / ' /7 547 7
2$)3 D
##$,$"
##
"$ $# $6 $#
=4 " # $ %&'')<+
)!4+ 0%- 4 @ . 5
( ( 7 ( & $ 7 7 7
@4 ( 7 /7
2"#3
(. /4 (. . 2" 3 5 ) 6$+ ( / 2"$3 D .4 /7 47 / 7 547 4 / 7 8. ( ( 5 7 7 / 7 4 ( /7 4 4 (
2""3 A . 4 .
. 7 ? ( . / 4' 74 4 ( ( $ 5# $=
3"
$5
#"
" # $%&'()*+ )!4+.<0 ( ( .4 % .4 7 / .4 ( (
47 5 4 % .4
. ( ( 4 4 A / @ 7.
4 4 4 4
2"03
/ ( ( ( 4 47 (
/
-.-( 1%&'-)> + 2" 3 .
4
/ 4 8 $ ""*E% 4 H (' ('.
H7 5 &. D4 8'
H ..
7 B 4 ( ..
0*I / 7 .
/ 4 8 0###*+#E% .
J + * I 4 4 .
4 4
2"*3 D /4 47 4 /7
/ (
(.
7 8 "" *#E% 4 B 4 0*I / 7 8 "" *#E%
.
('
2" 3 /4 4 /7
2"+3 7 9B $$;
( ( ..
7 8 "" *#E% 4 7 B 4 0*I / 7 .
/ / 4 / 47 4 (
2"!3 A ( 7 7 B 4 4 8 $0*)##E% 9"" *# K ;
B B 4 ..
0*I / 7 8 +)"+E% 7 B B 4 4 8 !!00!E% 9"" *#%+)"+;
A (7 7 4 8 "" "0!E%
2")3 A ( ( # 4 $5
# "!
,$7 #%&'8'%8& *#I 4 A (7 4 ( 4 8 00 0*+E% *#I ( $E 8 ! #!)E% '.
( 4/ 4 ( B 7.
4 77 7 ( 4
8 "*"" !E% 900 0*+%! #!);
.
( . ( $4 $!
4 $ $## $6 $# %&&. '%.0)+ 4 $* 4 ( 4 8 0+! #"#E% ( 4 8 0####E% ( ( (
# 4 $5
# "!
,$7 # 5 ) 6$+ .7 4 ( 4 8 0!$ #"#E% 20#3 A ( $4 $5
#"
!
4 $ >$
%&'0)*+ )!4+ <<< 4 8 ####E% 4 ( 4 8 ####E% ( 4 4 . 4 8 "#####E% 8 *####E% 4 . ( A (7 4 4 ( 8 $0 #"#E% 90!$ #"#L!####L ####L"#####;
&
/ . 4 8 0###*+#E% 4 4 8 $$00 *#E% 9 $0 #"#%0###*+#;
20$3
4 8 $$00 *#E% 7 J + *I 4 4 .
4
4 ( ( 4 47 ( "* # "#$) "+ 9
" $
4-'&-'11'
'5.'
3), %'5 4-'&-'11'.1& 6/' %'5