High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7516/2015dismissed

Municipal Corporation Th Its Commissioner v. Sanjay Kundu And ANR

2015-11-19Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

!""#$%$&'(")*"+,-

.&$#$/ 0+/+ !$&-!1+.21$!%))$%%$&"+- 1! 3 //"00 &!

4"+%.% 5 &6 78.&9.&!+ #!+ &!1"+ "%/&9"&!%

:1"!1"+ "/+!"+%0# 0/ /"+%) 7*" 00;"9!%""!1"6.92)"&!< *"+""++"9!!1" "/+!"+%+&!< = :1"!1"+!1"6.92)"&!%1.09*"+"/+!"9$&!1"$2"%!<

+"%"&!'

+ +9""/ 6/.!-9(# !"- +!1" //"00 &!

+ 6"%17 0-9(# !"- ++"%/&9"&! >>>>> !

&'( 1" //"00 &!?

.&$#$/ 0 +/+ !$& $% $& //" 0 .&9"+ 5"#!$&=!1"+*$!+ !$& &9&#$0$ !$&#!-,, +%1+!@,, #!A 2 $&%!!1"+9"+9 !"9-;1"+"*7!1"*6"#!$&%$0"9.&9"+ 5"#!$&=B,,#!+%"!!$&2? %$9"!1" ; +99 !"9,-1 (" *""&9$%)$%%"9

+ +9""/ 6/.!-0" +&"9#.&%"0 //" +$&2&*"1 0!1" //"00 &!?+/+ !$&%.*)$!%!1 !!1";+3+#&%!+.#!$&!1"+ 9 ; %!*"#)/0"!"9;$!1$& /"+$9&$&")&!1%1"#&!+ #!; % 00!!"9&C,-*.!!1"#&!+ #!+9$9&!#)/0"!"!1";+3 &9- !1"+"+"-!1"+/+ !$&0"($"9 /"& 0!7 %/"+!1"!"+)% &9#&9$!$&% !1"#&!+ #! &99"9.#!"9!1"% )"+)!1"%"#.+$!79"/%$!"9*7!1"

#&!+ #!+ 1" +*$!+ !+ &9 !1" *6"#!$&2 .+! 1 (" #))$!!"9 $00"2 0$!7 &9/"+("+%$!7$&&!&!$#$&2!1" +")"&!$&"9 #!;"("+- !1"+*$!+ !+&!$#"9!1 !!1"+"; %%)"#)/0 $&! &9-!1"+"+"-!1" ;+3; %%!//"91"#)/0 $&!$%!1"7" + &9-!1.%-$!$%*"7&9 !1"%!$/.0 !"9/"+$9&$&")&!1%-!1"+"+"-!1"#&!+ #!+# &&!*" 2$("&!1"*"&"$! &9-!1.%-/+ 7%+%"!!$&2? %$9"0 $)=

+ 6"%1 7 0- 0" +&"9 #.&%"0 //" +$&2 & *"1 0 +"%/&9"&!?#&!+ #!+%.*)$!%!1 !!1"$)/%$!$&!1"/"& 0!7; % &!&!1"* %$%!1"#)/0 $&!-*.!;$&2!!1" +")"&!$&"9 #!+% 0%-$"-&&? ( $0 *$0$!7; !"+ &9%";"+ 2"$&!;#0&$"%-& )"07- 6$! &9)+$!1$% #!1 %*""&&!$#"9*7!1" *6"#!$&2.+!$& / + 2+ /1!1"+9"+ &9-!1.%-/+ 7%!1 !&#"!1";+3; %%!//"9 *7!1"+/+ !$&-$!; %&!;$!1$&!1"+" 0)!1"+/+ !$&!$)/%" !1"/"& 0!7 &99"9.#!!1"% )"+)!1"%"#.+$!7 &9-!1.%-/+ 7%+ 9$%)$%% 0!1" //" 0 1 ("1" +9!1"0" +&"9#.&%"0+!1"/ +!$"% &9 //+ $%"9 !1"/ /"+*3 !;.09*" /!!+"/+9.#"!1"$&9$&2%!1"+*$!+ !+($%? ?($%0 $)= &9 %;"00 %!1" *6"#!$&2.+!-;1$#1+" 9!1.%'? @ $&9$&2%!1"+*$!+ !+

!"##$%&'( )(&*

$%&' + $,-&%-%%%./"

0 1

!"##$%&'( )( &*

$%&'

)

$2$ !$$"%*"$%%2

3 ,%4

5 -

36 7 "## 8 # "## 88

9 7 8- # $, &% : 0 ; : . <

$&9$&2%!1" *6"#!$&2.+!

# 8

0 8

= 8 7 79 > !

8 8 -

; 8 8 ; 9? 8!3 = 0 8 - 1 @8 A 7 1 1 88 8 "## 8 #

$, &%

8 5 8 -

* 8 $%&% 7 -@8 A # 3 8 8 8 8 1 8 8

8 "## 8 88 0 8 - 9 <

+)!1"/"+.% 0!1" +")"&!$&"9$&9$&2%-$!$%"($9"&! 1 !!1"%0"2+.&9+&!#)/0"!$&2!1";+3; %&&? ( $0 *$0$!7 ; !"+ &9%";"+ 2" &9$&!1$%+"2 +9- +"/+!1 9*""&%.*)$!!"9*7!1" .&$+&2$&""+!1 !!$00!1"!$)"%";"+ 2" &9/$/"0$&"%;"+"&!0 $9-!1" ;+3#&%!+.#!$&!1"+ 9*"3"/!&109&($";%.#1%$!. $&- !1" //"00 &!?+/+ !$& #.09 &! 1 (" $)/%"9 /"& 0!7- ).#1 0"%%- 9"9.#!"9!1"% )"+)!1"%"#.+$!79"/%$!"9*7!1"#&!+ #!+9&! $&!"&9!9$"+;$!1!1"$&9$&2%1"*6"#!$&%# &&!*"% $9!*";$!1$& / + )"!"+%5"#!$&=B,,#! !$%&; %"!!0"90 ;!1 !$&;1 !#$+#.)%! &#"%-!1" ; +91 % ! *" $&!"+"+"9 ;$!1 1" D."%!$&- ;1$#1 $% &; + $%"9 $& !1" +")"&!$&"9 //" 0-1 % 0+" 97*""& &%;"+"9*7!

1"&E*0"5./+")" .+!$&# !"& 6.92)"&!%-;1"+"$&$!1 %*""&0 $99;&!1 !.&!$0 &9 .&0"%% !1" ; +9 %."+% +)$00"2 0$!7 % %! +$07/+"%#+$*"9 .&9"+ 5"#!$&=B!1"#!-!1"% )"# &&!*"$&!"+"+"9;$!1&!1$%#&!"F!- $&!"&9 ! +""+ !1" 6.92)"&!% &E*0" 5./+")" .+! $& ++,-'.

0-(1/&+ 2+ $/(3- $/4/(56/7.

0.3&-.8 ) *9 '71 '41'8'

'++

7./&.'-76/7.

.1 2+

6:-7/+

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

1"1 9/ +!$#$/ !"9$&!1"/+#""9$&2% &9;"+"2$("&/+/"+&!$#" &!&07;$!1+"2 +9!!1" //$&!)"&!!1"+*$!+ !+*.!($%? ($% /+#""9$&2%&)7($";-!1" ; +9!1"+*$!+ !+9"%&!%."++) &7$00"2 0$!7$& %).#1 %!1"+*$!+ !+-;1$%"F/"+!-1 %9" 0!;$!1!1" ) !!"+ &99"#$9"9!1"#0 $)%+"%/"#!$("/ +!$"%!!

& )7 ($";- !1" ; +9 +" 9 % ;10" $% 6.%!- $+ &9 +" %& *0"!$%&; %"!!0"90 ;!1 !!1"+*$!+ !+$%!1"%0"6.92" D. 0$!7 &9D. &!$!7!1""($9"&#"*"+"1$) &99"#$9"&!1"* %$% !1" ( $0 *0""($9"&#" 1" //" 0$% ##+9$&2079$%)$%%"9 4/6:/& 9#

" &'6/+3