High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1104/2013dismissed

Surender Singh v. Land Acquisition Collector And ORS

2015-10-06Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain5 pages

!"# #!

$% &&'' (

)"

''# %#

&

!"

#$%&' ()*+,' -'). +#/ & *# +#, -

.(. #%&&'' +##"

/

0'.&"1(2 #'.3#1

-'). +#/ & 4%&# &&' % 5

' $

% 0# .0%#51%'# "#5'0

%56

51%' 0 # "

'1 /# '1.% #%'

"

#( "

( ''$7 .4%

'

# 2"#$ .0 "$%5)"

#51 %! 3#1

$"& %"%#1( '8 "

# '+'

40

% &.7 .(

.

""

% )"

.9 %#.;%<=

"

%0

"

4% )"

''# :

# %#. % ''#= ( 0# 9

%,#>('" #' ? . . @&## $$# ( $

% 0# % ''#. % ' 0 #

.0% %0## ##%'# '

# -"$.

0%>&

$

0%,# '&' ##51%&# .

%56

'51%' 0 #5

$ ,5##( 0# 8

%

0#0% %

,&"$

%&# &&'

# "

' # % &&'' "5, % % %# ' 0 # .0% ' 0 )"

#( ,

.%(5

0# % $%# ,&

. 0%# '1 % &&'' % 5

4%1%

'&&'

9"

9

%$

%0#

#,>

$# % '# "#5'0 #

, #,&

4%'# "# 5'0( 0# .

% ,5

$ ,5## 80 "5, %%

##51%'# "#5'0% %#

'51%' 0 #0 ,5##.#''1## "

3 "5, %

#, %&#(

9 %.%

"'5

'0

0#

%' 0 # #&# % , &# "

, %0#8

%# . 0"'50

0> #,% ''#"

%#0

#,% %''#< 0#.0% A& #

4%56

51%&&'' %"'5

#0

'

%%#% .'# "

' #%! "5, % '1

$56

5 4%'# "#5'0%

$%'1#6%' , %&&'' 5

$ ,5## 3#'# "

' #%&# &#"

%&&#@ 5> 4% . 0% % # ( #, % ## # %

"

%0

" 4% ''#

"

% 0#

8

51 % &&'' %%%# (%,&

#' .#%# %&'> 51%&&'' 5 #%"#5'00 %%

%# % >%(

'%56 %&&'' "

#%

,&#

%%%

'% , %# .0% %

&".

%%56

0#

'51%&&'' 9 % "' ,# A. %

" 0% % #

#

# 51%

"#

. 0%%#%56

'51% &&'' #5#0

,51

$%'

#,% %&&'' ' ,%%% # (%,"

,&

#,%%, '1%%> 0'$

"

, 0#4%, %&&''

%%%

'%56

9 %%%> 0'$ %

"

, %0# 51%''#

9 %

A#5'0 C0 '''#,'*(*1:= 1&#

# 0%%

& % 0# ,1. 51 0# &&'

% ''#.#)"

#%%,#5# ##51%''#

#%#,

%"#.0%%#%

56 5 %, "#, %' .%,"

,&

.% &#

0%,

&15'.#%&&# , ,&

, $%&#

# :

=4%&&'

%'' %$#"

0% %56

%0#

>

*#( %(#1 "%&&'

%''5,.@ :=

%&# ,>

$ &# ##&# 5 ''#% ,0% %,%

0#.0

0> %''#< 0#D :5=

%# .0

#,%''#"

. =.#

%''#< 0#.

0% %''

A& #E 4% &#( %

1 &#

# &%0#.%,1510# &&'

% ''##)"

#%%,#5# ##%"#4%56

5#$#

$, "#, %' .%,"

,&

.% &#

0%,

&15' # % &&# , ,&

, %&#

# 4%&&'

%"'

%$#"

0% %%0#

56*#(

9 %&#( #%&#

0% %%56

"'5

' '"

:=%# &#( %

&#

&# ##&# 5 # % ''# % ,

"

, % 0#. %

5

'0

%''#<

0#'"

:5=&#( %

%# .%56

5

#,%''#"

:

%#0

''#< 0#.

0% A& #

B

# !& '"1: )"

= %#( !%, +

'' % "'' %# . : = ! . 3 <5' % !"&#,"#

#%

" 0%%#'

&#( # "

9:

%

$56

5A 0

0#

$ (*#$#&% 9%# #A# 5'0 C 8

5#,,5#%% )"

:, , =: 9 9 =0 &#

$% A#

%&0#"

. '

A'"% ,"& " 1$# 51% "# 4>

$ $

F % '

&# 5

&#(

9.%&#(

0# A&#

'1A 4%"$%!

:

%

( '5'. %'

&#(

9,15#5

& ''0.

%5 "% &&'

51 )"

:, , = : 9 9 =. %

&

''1,

50 %''# %"# %''#B&# #, '1 "#1"

"

#%.

'"

$ 0% ',>

$# "

98

"'

#"%%''#B 0% ',>

$# "

9. "#1"%# 1

'' "# # % &"#& ! % 9 4%"$%%# ,15.

0 &

&#( "

#&#(

! 9:

%.

0# %

#( 0%

5 &&'

% &#(

:

=

94%''#B.%# #.

"#0%

% "#1"%# 1"

9:=4%# #.

%

5&&'

#A

%&# '

&# 5"

#&#(

94%3 $%"#.%# #.0 $%

$%%''#

"#"

% E:,&%

"&&'

= 4% , ( 0 0 ''0

! 7# > ( A", .:

=9! 51%

"#

G

99 .9 @

9 .

@

9

@

!"# $ " .

9 0 % "

'0.%'1

56

$

%0# %''#

5 8

% .%&&'' 0''0#

&#

4%0#0 &

51%''#

4%&&''

% 56

9. 0% % 0# '#'1 51 % &# &# 5"

#%

$% "',# A.8

%

''$'

1% 5 ,, 51%'# "#

%56

'51%&&'' ,5###

$'1.%&&'

:6 %/

'= (

-"$