← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/9142/2014disposed of

Bimla Devi & ANR v. Mani Ram & ORS

2018-07-30Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages



     

 ! "#$ % $& '"()*)*+ ,# '- ./%/'"(0*)*+ /!1, &/,"'#2 $ 33 11,"#% 4 $% ,"/ ,!'#2 $%  %3'"

"#%  

      

$ % "#( $*2 3/"

$2,"2,%5 &'.,# -'$#2 ,33 11,"#%* $* *6*,$5***5,$7,",-'$ $ %3'"

"#%"'*0* $*4/"'

2,

2,$75 &'.,# -'$$ %3'"

"#"'**       2/%  /%  .1,/!,"#%9  ,33 ,1  % :/"  "2,". ! "#  '- .'!3 "%,#/'"* $/ --,.#%#2,#!,7; "'#/.

,$ #2,# 2 7<2,! /", !'#'$& 2/.1 ,../ "#'"**0=2 "2 =,%%#$ .:;7,,$7,",

', =,7%   %  ; ,$/"  $ /%#$,#/'"  "'*   >)0++  =2/1  2  =,% 3$'.

/"'",'3 * 2 .1,/!3 #/#/'"=,%-/1  "

$< .#/'"??'-#2 '#'$ 4 2/.1 .#5++; -'$ #2 '#'$../ "#1,/!%$/;

",12 $ /",-# $ #'; $ - $$ ,%#2 $/;

",1 52/=,"/;7#2 .1,/!,"#%@3$ % "#,33 11,"#% /* *#2 3,$ "#%* '!3 "%,#/'"#'#2 # " '- %*01,.%=,%.1,/!

*

3'"31 , /"%'-#2 3,$#/ %5#2 -'11'=/"/%% %= $ -$,!

;7#2 $/;

",1*   



   

             



    !"#  



     

&'()  !)!"

(* )!)  +  , ,

      %)-.)#"// ,      0



1(22 ! 3

 



$0 + 

   

   

   0

 0  + 



   +1(22 #     +    



   $  

 

    

1(2)

   4 A/#2$ ,$ #'#2  ,#2'- 2 7<2,!2,&/"; ".,

#'$,%2,"

" 1/ "# $/&/"'-#2 & 2/.1 /"B %#/'";7$ %3'"

"# "'*/* * $/& $'-#2 '-- "

/"& 2/.1 5-/"

/"%2,& ; "$ # $"

/"

-,&'

$'-#2 .1,/!,"#%* %  $ ,$ %  /%%  '-  "#/#1 ! "#  #'  .'!3 "%,#/'"  ,"

 #2 ,"# !#2 $ '-5$/;

",12,%#,: "#2 !'"#217/".'! '-#2 

%*?@*</".  =,% "!,$$/ ,"

=,%,;,.2 1'$,##2 #/! '- ,../ "#5>C

.#/'"2,%; "!, #'=,$ %3 $%'",1 D3 "% %'-#2

,"

#2 ,""

,1 3 "

".7B ,#2 .1,/!,"#%2,%; ",%% %%

%*0)5@0D *!

1#/31/ $'-2,%; ",331/ ;7#,:/"/"#'

$ .:'"/"#2 , '-#2 .1,/!,"#%,"

,..'$ /"17.'!3 "%,#/'"2,%; "

='$:

'

##' %*>55+@* 

" $,1 D3 "% %2,& ; ",%% %% E

%*>5@*   2  #'#,1  .'!3 "%,#/'"  ,!' "#  ,=,$

5  ,%  % .25  /%

%*>5>5+@,"

#'; 3,/ #'#2 .1,/!,"#%/" B ,1%2,$ ,1'"=/#2 /"# $ %#E?C3 $,""

!-$'!#2  ,# '--/1/"'-#2 .1,/!3 #/#/'"#/11 $ ,1/F,#/'"'-#2 ,!'

"#* </". #2 '"17/%% ,$/%/"/"#2 /"%#,"#,33 ,1/%=/#2$ ,$

#'  B ,"# !  '-  .'!3 "%,#/'"5    2,&  2 ,$  $*  2 3/"

$  2,"2,% &'.,#  -'$  #2  ,33 11,"#%  ,"

 $*  4/"'

 2,

2,$75   &'.,#  -'$ .'"# %#/"$ %3'"

"#"'*@"% $,". '!3,"7*

0 2  D3$ %%/'"  GH %# .'!3 "%,#/'"I =,% .'"%/  ;7#2 '"9;1 < 3$ ! '

$#/".,% '- 

         





    

,"

/#=,% 2 1 #2,##2 .'!3 "%,#/'",=,$

;7,$/;

",1 ' %"'#; .'! GH %#I ! $ 17; ., % #2 $/;

",1.'"%/ /##'; GH %#I*G %#.'!3 "%,#/'"I ='

! ,", ,# .'!3 "%,#/'"=2/.2/%-,/$,"

 B /#,;1 '"#2 -,.#% ,"

./$.

!%#,". %'-,.,% %',%#'!,: ''

#2 1'%%% -- $ ,%,$ % 1# '-#2 =$'",%-,$,%!'" 7.," '%';7,3317/"= 11% ##1 3$/"./31 % $ 1,#/"#',=,$ '-.'!3 "%,#/'"* & $#/";,.:#'#2 -,.#%,"

./$.

!%#,". %'-#2 3$ % "# .,% 5#2/%'

$#/%'-#2 .'"%/ &/ =#2,##2 .'!3 "%,#/'",=,$

;7 #2 $/;

",1/%'"#2 1'= $%/ ,"

"

%#';  "2,".

@$ &/% ,%3 $

1/" %- $"/%2 ;7#2 3 D'

$#/" .,% % 3$, ,1%'  /" 

  !

" #    $  %

   & $     

 '

(   ' & "#2'

25.1,/!,"#%2, %#,# #2,##2 /$%'" 2 7<2,!

%/". 

=,%,%.$,3 ,1 $,"

 ,$"/" %*>5@3 $!'"#257 #5 "'.' "#,"

.'".1 %/&  &/ ". 2, ; ",

.

#'% ;%#,"#/,# % .2 .1,/!*3,$#-$'!#2 '$,1%#,# ! "#!, ;7 A,"/ ,!@,33 11,"#"'

'#2 $ &/ ". =,%;$'

2#-'$#2*';,":%#,# ! "#%'-  2 7 <2,!2, ; "3$'

.

*2 $/;

",1=/#2'

#,%%/"/","7$ ,%'"2,% ,%% %% #2 !'"#217/".'! '-#2  #';  %*?@3 $!'"#2 /".1

/"- # $ 3$'%3 .#%*'

"% 1-'$#2 .'"# %#/""% $,". '!3,"7 2,%"'#; ",;1 #' /%3 # #2,##2 !/"/!

!=, %'-," "%:/11 ='$: $ ,%3 $<#,# '&#*,##2 $ 1 &,"#3'/"#'-#/! = $  %*?@,##2 & $7 1 ,%#*"#2 .'"%/ &/ ='-#2/%'

$#5#2 $/;

",12,% $$ /""'#

 $,"#/"C/".$ ,% /"/".'! '& $,"

,;'&  %*?@#'=,$ %- # 3$'%3 .#%*2/%='

; 3,$#/.

1,$17%',%, '- =,%$ -1 .# 07 ,$%/"#2  '%#'$# ! 3'$#D* *

$#2 $!'$ 5,%3 $ 1/" % - $"/%2 /" .,% % 3$, 5,!

1#/31/ $'-+2,%#'; ,331/

: 3/"/"&/ =#2 , '-#2  *& "-'$$,"#'-.'!3 "%,#/'"

"

$.'"& "#/'",12 , %/* *#'=,$ %- " $,1 D3 "% % #.*5#2 ,!'

"#'- .'!3 "%,#/'"$ B /$ %#';  "2,".

-$'! %*>5@#' %*05@* "  &/ =  '-  #2  /%.

%%/'"  !,  ,;'& 5  #2  .'!3 "%,#/'"

,=,$

#'#2 .1,/!,"#%@,33 11,"#%/%$ ,%% %% ,%-'11'=%( <$*'*  ,

,1.

1,#/'"

* ".'!

?@3*!* 5 C/".$ ,% /"/".'! #'=,$ - # $ 3$'%3 .#% ?JCK+?+@ 0* >C

.#/'"%#'=,$ %3 $%'",1 D3 "% %'-#2 

+?+K0  * '!3 "%,#/'",-# $,3317/"

!

1#/31/ $'-+* 0DK>5+@ >5+D+K50)5@ >* '"& "#/'",12 , - " $,1 D3 "% %,"

1'%%'- %#,#  #.*

05@ '#,1 50)5J05 K %*5?)5@* 2 ,-'$ %,/  "2,".

.'!3 "%,#/'"='

; ,33'$#/'"

,117,!'"%##2 ,33 11,"#%,"

='

; 3,/ #'#2 !,1'"=/#2 /"# $ %#E?C-$'!#2  ,# '--/1/"'-#2 /"%#,"#,33 ,1,"

#/11#2  ,# '- ,.# ,1$ ,1/F,#/'"* 33 ,1/%,11'= /"#2 ,-'$ %,/ # $!%*         

.:7 A2 #2 $%3 ,:/"@$ ,%'"

(  %@'

A2 #2 $ 3'$#,;1 (  %@'