High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7555/2015disposed of

M.S Middle School And ANR v. Usha And ORS

2017-09-26Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh10 pages

!"#

$% "!! $ % &&#' "

&& $ () #' "

$% "!!& *") +, ' "&) -./!

01"'&"

&"&&--"* )&" "-'"& )-'& " )

2# " # " )

2 "&& & ' " )

" ' , "-'"& 2 "& #,"&- )3 4 5&2 6)& "

&&,)&) -"", '&&-")7),"") 7)8

& )&-" " -" 9) " -)"" -'"&"&)#" 7) &,"' ) " ) 2)&""* )&"

2: -" /;4#6& 8 " /-& * )" 2# () )8" ," " <=/0," - /1 +2") ,) 2" 9)

"#"" 5)- "( &.-"6)

2.>&" ) 6) 9 &'

& 66 !

41 !

# ' ?" 5)- " 6)

! " " ! #$%&&%& #$' -& ?" 5)- " 6) () *!+!

. ( ! %&&%& /0

! ,-

& () % 0

! 30

0 6)& - " )

2 " )

-"* )&"""&) A*B&&,"" * B"&) 0" B"& # @11 " #>">,"" 7) - &

)& &# !!"" , ")7)#)'&') ") # ) 0@ "#= -"

2 &&2 2

#" #"* )&" -"&2- ' 2 -"') ") -") ' " -'"& ;" - <=/0 &) 2"

&&#

4 ) "'") " 2& - #" ,)&) &&2 "

&&"") , - " ) &2"'"& )& &9# -)" : -" /;4"- &&2"" ), ,") 2

)" 29") " -)" " 5)- & ) 2 )& "

&& 2 '?" -&?""6) & ) " #" #"

&& '2'-" " )" ) " -)"5)-

2"( &.-"6) # '# &2 "- -"""" "#"" & &) 5)- .>&" ) 6) 9

! &2

! #B&6CCC9C

$A/

) " "

5)- 2 -& ?" " 6) ,

! 0@

0# % 0

! & ! ! 44@

4# @

! %3! &4!!

! !! 0

! 9"'" )& " )" 8

)& &2",

)- 9 )&2#?) -3./! 01" - "&?) A*B 9&" ')&2"?)

0 7),- &2 &.-" "&B&&-:")

<=/'& 1 0

@ 4

49& ) "= 2" #, ,," " = 2 2 )7) 6)& "

&& " )"

0#") #" ,

&2")7) )& &9""'"&&& ,""* B"& 7) - ) !!"9 &"

&&""'"& - '"&&&,"2"= ' !!

" *" 7) " && >

D> .>&" ) 6) 9 !

" ) 28- " ' 0@ !!"5)- "6) +!.

! &.%$5$$,& &%&&#

% 5$$,& &%&# &""& 4#7)") .-"6) ,"',"" ,

# " 7) '& 2 " *"',& &2&&)

,") &2'"& &

&'',"" #) "'&2" $&2-'"& ,") *" # 0@ '&&") " *" &2" 5)*"7) &2- ' " &' ") - -&&2 ) .-" 6) ,# " # 5) "&-") &&

4 *" )&7),",)&"

6 -"&5"# ,)& ") 2", # ")-"&,"&&29 " ) "-'" & 2 ' " ) " ) " ) ' -" ) ", #") "&& 7) &)9 2

- " <=)-6) " ),") ", ," )5 "* )& ")-", ') " ) ? & " ) " & #, "-'"&"&&) " ) 2 " ),""") ,&& 2 " & *" - '"& "&& "# ") 292 " <=)-6) "&&8" /-& * )" 2 *" <=)- 6) "&&

,"&, " ,""", "'"&"&&

8 2 ") 9" 2)& "&& " <=)- 6) &F2 &") ) " 2" 2 ",

! " '"& " ) 9 " -"7)) '&',&'" ") ,"" ,)&8 ' 2" ) ") G /-" = &' )"

&2-'"&,") H 0@ "#'&&") " 9"& ") -) 0@ " # -"&5"#,)& " ) 2", ")-"&,"&&2*") ' " ) ", "&& 7) & ) " ) *"'?"5)- $

$ " ) )

&&8 , -" 2"/ *"6) # " 5)- ""&"" -) " ) , 7) ,"" . 2 26)& ")

&&' )," &" )

&& "6*3, ) " ) 2")

&&", " ,2, "'"& 2 ) -'"&,"" . 2, 7) *") 6

&&'& = "6 &"& # ,""

$; &-,""/- 6 " -'"&",,"" "'"&, - -'"& "'"&,- 2 9 2 )"

- 2 7) ) !!"#) " 7) 7) - ) )"'"&," " 52")

&&92 " ' ""'"&,- 2 *" ")

&& ",""

"' ) 0@ "

)& &2," - &&2, " 2 6)& "

&& " & ' 2

-)& -) ","5)- 2"'?"

$ " ) )

&&" ")

2", -&2&&, -" ' 2- ") 9" )" 2# &") , ) &2-'"& )& & ?""6) #& '?":)- $

$ " ) ""& % " ) # &&, &'(

) *

)

+ !

* , - -

* -

-./0 1233

3451

+ !

) 6 *

7 8 9- ," " ' % "

) ""'?"5)- $

$ " ) 82= "5)- !

> ) 9) "

&&7)"' ?"5)- 2 -, -" 2"/ ) ,") &2

-" ' " 5)- H " ) # "

&& ' 2 '-" "'?"5)- /& ) -& ?" 5)- + I, $)& "&% ;$)& 2 "&>

) & &"5)- ) "&?) '"& 2 7) ) ) 7)

&,"" ' !! " *" )" - ) ' ) 2)'&') ")

2) 0@ "#" #2 5)- &- ," ) ,)& ) "

&&)&,"-"* )&"")

&2")7) )& &#)- '& ') " )

2# ")# &- " )

2& = &&2'")-"" ,"&&22"" 2& *" -"6) 5)- "( &.-"6)

")"> ) *"'"&'&'",

@ 6 "88,, :)&2 #

0*" .-"6) ,"& -"""'"& &2 ,") +

&'"& 2- - " , /)&1 "6 & B"&/)&#', ' "5)- # & ") "") & = &&2 2 , " '"& 7) )& - " 5)- ,)& 8'"" " 52)& "

&&""'"&,"" 7)

) !!") )&-5) 2 " 2#) 0@ "'&&" )

2 " # 2

- -#" 2*"5)- , 2 ( &.-"6) ', )& ) & " # " # " & 2 )

& "

&& * "

&&#)&" '

&- <= /0 ," - ) /1

," " * )" 2 6)& "

&&"& )2 '&,+ )&" &2 ), '"&" 2+,"" )" 2 #,)& )) "') 9" , #", '"&" +" - ,"")" 2 #" ")" 2 ) )"&)- - 2"

) 9 " ', " #"

&& ' 2 '- ") /1 + 9',") " #-" * )&""-'"& " &' " )'&') ")

2) 0@ " && -&2 *"* )&" ' 2 -"') " ) -", ' "-'"&9 &-") "' ) !!"*" ) 0@ " '&&") &2 -") ' "'"& "& &,#" ' '"& '2 ) , ") ") H " ) #") & -" ' 2- ' "-'"&)"# - " * )& -'- ' 2 -" - ' " -'"&,&&"5)& )2 " -- #"

&&2", +) ) "

& 2 " ' &&, " #&'-" " , /8"& :)-

!"#

" ;"" 8-+ I+3 ;"" & I+3