Haryana Agro-Industries Corp Ltd v. M/S Zimidara Agro Mills & ANR
!""#$%$&'(")*"+, !-. +/ & 0+1&23%!+$"%+4+ !$&5$)$!"2.6"#!+7 &#-839 44"99 &!
:"+%3%
;%<$)$2 + 0+ $99%.:
6 2$843+.6 2- 3+ .$%!+$#! )3& 0 +
&!-"+ "%4&2"&!%
!
!
"#
$%
=-"!-"+ "4+!"+%9# 94 4"+%) /*" 99>"2!%""!-"?320)"&!@ *"+""++"2!!-" "4+!"+%+&!@ A =-"!-"+!-"?320)"&!%-392*"+"4+!"2$&!-"$0"%!@
+"%"&!'
+ &8 ?34! .2(# !".
+!-" 44"99 &!$& 99!-"# %"% BBBBB !
"#
&'( /!-$%#))&+2"+.%- 992$%4%"!"& 44" 9%*" +$&0 % +/ & 0+1&23%!+$"%+4+ !$&5$)$!"2:"+%3%
;% <$)$2 + 0+ $99% &!-"+ . C +/ & 0+1 &23%!+$"%+4+ !$&5$)$!"2:"+%3% ;%$&2 90+ $99% &!-"+ .
, +/ & 0+1&23%!+$"%+4+ !$&5$)$!"2:"+%3% ;% 6-$( 9$8 $#" "&"+ 9 $99% &!-"+ ., +/ & 0+1 &23%!+$"%+4+ !$&5$)$!"2:"+%3% ;% 9 ?$ $#" "&"+ 9 $99%
&!-"+ . , +/ & 0+1&23%!+$"% +4+ !$& 5$)$!"2 :"+%3% ;%00 +> 9 $#" $99% &!-"+ .,A +/ & 0+1 &23%!+$"%+4+ !$&5$)$!"2:"+%3% ;%$) 9 / 0+&23%!+$"%
&!-"+ . ,7 +/ & 0+1&23%!+$"% +4+ !$& 5$)$!"2 :"+%3% ;% +/ & $#" "&"+ 9 $99% &!-"+ .,
+/ & 0+1&23%!+$"%+4+ !$&5$)$!"2:"+%3% ;% - 6- 8!$
$#" "&"+ 9 $99% &!-"+ .,, +/ & 0+1&23%!+$"% +4+ !$& 5$)$!"2 :"+%3% ;% 02 )* $#" "&"+ 9 $99%
&!-"+ &2, +/ & 0+1&23%!+$"%+4+ !$&5$)$!"2 :"+%3% ;% ("9$ $#"5 &2 &!-"+ %!-"#))&D3"%!$&%9 > &2 #!%$&(9("2$& 99!-"%" 44" 9% +"!-"% )" -"#- 99"&0"$&!-"4+"%"&! 44" 9%$%!!-"$)430&"2+2"+ 2 !"2 4 %%"2 */ !-" 22$!$& 9 $%!+$#! 320". &#-839 .
>-"+"*/ !-" *?"#!$&% $9"2 3&2"+ 6"#!$& A7 !-" +*$!+ !$& &2 &#$9$ !$&#!.CC, +%-+!ECC,#!F +%"!!$&01 %$2"!-" +*$!+ 9 > +22 !"27AA.- ("*""&2$%)$%%"2
+ &8 ?34! .9" +&"2#3&%"9 44" +$&0&*"- 9!-" 44"99 &!1 +/ & 0+1&23%!+$"%+4+ !$&5$)$!"2%3*)$!%!- !!-"#3! 2 !"+2"9$("+/!-"#3%!))$99"2+$#" +%-+!E
F > % AA.>-"+" %!-" $99"+%2$2&!2"9$("+!-"% )"&*"- 9!-" +4+ !$&!!-" &!$)"9 3%" $( !-"6#-"239"4+($2"%!- !
!-"
$%*"2"9$("+"2>$!-$&!-"4"+$2+ )"2-"+*$!+ !+- %&! 44+"#$ !"2!-" +")"&!$&"2 #!.)3#-9"%%!"+)% &2#&2$!$&%!-" 6#-"239" &2"++&"3%9/4+&3&#"2!-" > +2$& (3+!-" $99"+% ("&!-" *?"#!$&03+!2$2&! ##"4!!-"*?"#!$&%*/-92$&0!- !!-" % )">"+"&!>$!-$&!-"4 + )"!"+%6"#!$&A7CC,#!"3+!-"+ %3*)$!%!- !!-"+*$!+ !+- %0+ &!"2!-"4-"&)"& 9$&!"+"%!GH &2. !-"+"+".!-" > +2 &2 %>"99 %!-"+2"+!-" *?"#!$&03+! +" 9$ *9"!*"%"!1 %$2" - ("-" +2!-"9" +&"2#3&%"9+!-" 44"99 &! &2 44+ $%"2 !-"4 4"+*8
) "+" 2("+!$&0!!-" +03)"&!%!-"9" +&"2#3&%"9+!-" 44"99 &!.$!>392*" 4!!+"4+23#"!-"+"9"( &!4+!$&!-" > +2 -"% )"+" 2%!-3%'1 E
!
" #
$
%
& ! " # '
'( )((* +'
+ )('(', ''
)((*+( - )('(.
'&. & /
& 0 ! 1"2 '3 ''
)((* )* ''
)((* .
'4 &/ & 56 !" #78
2 )'))((*/ & 1
.
' . &
'1 )&. & &/ & ! " #
.
+. & &
*
9
#
: "
1 1
; 0 '-+)('( )*<)('(1 ; 0 19! " # )+ + )('( !" #
'* ''
)((* ), ''
)((* '-+)('( )'
, )('( + - )('( ! 6 = " # <))('()())('('*+)('(
6 " #2
+'
, )('(+':)('(. +& ! 6 !
'(,(-(( $ > 2)((* )('(2 !'
'( )((*+'
+ )('( ', ''
)((*+( - )('(56 !" # )'))((* 6
6 " # !
6
! 3 20' 20<
!
* 9
20, 3
'( " !
'(,(-((
.!
5 "
2 7 &6 ?-@ ?',@
A -" *?"#!$&03+!- %3&2!- !!-" 2$2&!%3449/!-"
2"D3 !"%4 #" &2%! +!-"2"9$("+/!-"#3%!))$99"2+$#" &2!-" +*$!+ !+#&%$2"+"2!-""&!$+" 0+"")"&!.>-$#-$Τ"2#9 3%" $( &2 #++"#!9/-"92!- !!-">$!--92$&0!-")$99$&0#- +0"%$&!-"03$%" +"#("+$&0-92$&0#- +0"%> % *%93!"9/$99"0 9 &23&?3%!$$"2>-"&!-" )$99"+%>"+"&!+"%4&%$*9"+2"9$("+$&0!-"#3%!))$99"2+$#" %4"+!-" %#-"239".$& %)3#-. %!- !!-" $9"2!!$)"9/) 8" ++ &0")"&!
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
$050(6708/ 1/4&./9
) *:
'82 '52'9'
',,
8/0&/'.8708/ /2 3,
7;.80,
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
!
" &'70,4
$%