High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23386/2021dismissed

Sudarshan Kumar Bhagat v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-09-22Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari10 pages

!"# $%& '

!$%$(%)# $%&

*& +, *

- -- .

+, *

., !" # $#%#& '(# )$

* #+&

+ &#!##,$

## $ #& &#!##

* #+& '(#,$

$#+ # #($# #& '(#

$'#% #& '(#

-#%#& '(##

$#$#& '(# ) . //// -- .

$ (+#% %# $ # , ) # %# #% %# $ (( &&%) $ +(! # 01234205)$#!## '%&$ !&$

+# +# )%#(6&$&$ (% .#+'# +) )$6 +( 4

$ +# (+ #

# ) $ $#

)()++! ( & ! +#* %& $ %# # ) (020) $$#7% ## # #(! 8# (6& $# +# # +% (& 4209 :$#) ) $ ) # $ ;( ) 4209;< # (#% ( # $=()4209;&$$#!##(40)4205&

',$)#>#( $#)&$#$ +# # .#+'# +)$+'# +( $)&$ $## $#$ +# & (')$#++#($

#(6 ( $ 8# (6 (& 0531 :$#))$(#++ #$;()0531;<$ (%)++!

%# &#$#.#+#'# +) )$ +'# +( &$ !$!#!#'#+# +) (% +# )%#(6

! " # $ # # " %# &$ " &"'( )"

&" '( * +

""-"".

, +" " " "

# " # " +

# #/#""-"".

, +"#0 "+" + " " #+0 "#"# ! #"

$ "

,##""! " "$ ##

"1#

+ , "#" # ! + + "#

,#0" ", # 0!"+" #+0 #" +# "-"".

, +"2 9 ?$# #' $, &$#$ $!(#+ )$ +# # $#(' #!

(% #++ # $ $#'#(6 $+# +!)

' )$ '# + $ $##*

)$ ;+# # $#%(# #!

* ) 1

'& #+( $#$ $#'

( # $ #(()' (%#&#%($ #&$ +#$+# )$+# ,# @#( $ +# &,$#&$ ! ( @( $ +# #(6& $$ %#* $ %

)(#:< A ?# %$$#$ #+

7B.0904.0351 ) $ 7& ($#++ $ #(6

( &,$($,##++, $$# %# 422A4201 ', ) $ ' ) ( 41:4< ) $ ;( ) 4209; ,'&$ .###+ $#)' ( )$ ; + >7$$)+#8 $# 8,# #++, $$# %# 42244205 C ?)$#' $, &$#',) (+#D)$ +(! # 01234205)$#!## '%&$ #(6 +# +# )%#(6 $+'# )$

+(!: #<>#( $#) 3 4 "

"%,- ++"" """##

" + ! /+0 " " $ 0 # "+"

# " !0

)* "$ ## + ,#

"# )* /"" +" + " "

" # ! ) * " #+0 "# "+#"

$ " # )* /"" + "

,#0" "# 0!"+" #+0 "

"1" $ # #

+ "# 60 ""$ ##

"" 7/"

)*8,#+ "!

" "$ # #! + "

"1"

!"! $ ##"

" 9"

$ "

" "

+ +" + " + " ##"

# "0 ".

, +"

! /""0 + " , + 0# ! " ".

, +""

## !"

# "" ""

" !" $ "

+ # 0 "

" "$ ##

)*9

"#+ "!

" " $ ##! " ""1#

!"! $ #"

+ "#/" )*

"" " ", , +,

:"#" "

"!"" ",

$ ## D

$ $##+)+ #:>.

45< )$#$(( *+#)$+# ',)$ +(!: #< 5 $&$# #' $, &$#$ .#(6 +# $ !# (# +E$+# #!%# $&$ +# +#

)%#(6 '# +.#+ 3

$ +# (+ #

# ) $ $#

+#* $ %&#'+)(020: #<#,++#& #($)(+#D)$ +(! # 01234205)$#!##

'%& ! $ # % (% (% ++!

$ &$)#()# ()((> ### $ 0D)$ +!&#)) #'&#)$ $ !$ (( &(,$)#>#( $#)

;34"" " +""#""" # " #

#0 " # $ "

$ ### "

" ! 0

#"4# """

< -"

&. 0 +#" " " # "

"# #

,#4# """ "

0 '

+ "0

+" !# ,

#4 !

"#$ " ### , +

,0"

! "#! $ #4 " "

/# !" &/ =

">#

" < "2 02 # ) $ # (& %#* # $( %(:<&$#$ +# ##%#* )$#

+( # $ !#+E &#+E# +&# &# '# +))#(+#$#

+( 76+!&$ (+)$ (##&$#$ +# #$ .#+'# +))#(+#$#

+( $(#,++#!#% % &$ ')( 020)$;()4209;',)$ +(! # 01234205 7#+!& '#+ %# ) #+ +#($ #(6

( $;()0531;&$ !$&)#!& )$ +# & !$ & (#++!,$$!' +!

.'$ +( &$#$(% ++!+#,)+ $ # $#$# ' % #'+)(020 )$;()4209; & +(! # 01234205&(% ++!

(# (# #+# #! $# $#$#!

$&#

#.#+!'# +!)$

+# &$))#(+#$#

+( &#$ # &#'+) @('(% +#&#%# !$ #$! (( & # ( $ # ' @(' $ (% +#& %#)#'& $# $ +# # # #+(% )$+#! +#+#$(% +)$ +'# +( $)& $ +# (+ ) $

$## +! +#* $# '#%&$ % $ ')(020)$;()4209;# F& &

+(! # 01234205 00 7 (+! ' ) ,$ ' $ #(6 +# & $ (( & $ $#

#(:<))(#:<: #<&$ !,$$# (% # +,)$#(6 +# +#+!$'%) (% + # + ,$ ' $ #(6 +# $ .#&$%#*,++% , ,$$#% )$ ' ( !; + >7$(#)

!"#!$

'%#*#+)$ #(6 +# $$ +(#( $&$') +E &$>()$# ' , !## +,& #$# +&#$ !$#(%# (%)($ !

$#)#!##&$,+ #++$ .'% $ +( :< $)&>( #'!#>( #+ ((%#(&#%($#& ((() , +:

> # % ) (% # % % & $ %#*$+6 #&(## $# >($6&$&$ !$#! ##%).#+!

'# +!))$#(6 +# &%#! (%# !

$#)#!##,'&$# '>( ##'#+# + $( )$(# 04 7 (+!#+,$$# # !$+#

#+ '(# #+&#!##$#,$ #,#+)$ +(!

: #< #('( #)$ # $#'!

$+!$ +(!: #<+*+! .(#++ 09 $&$7#+(#+ # %&

'()

* "+)

, - .)/.01

/ 3

% ##$4//"45! $+6&$# +$

#+,$%+##$#, $+'#

### $)$' (: #<#>#( $#) ;3?

+" , "

#"0 +

+#" #

" " " !0

#" +" # #:#"

,0": "# " " 789

0 .

+ 1 #$

;

1<.

( :=

( + .1 1:

1( .,:

(

1<.

1 > ?@ 789

+ 1 #$10, 1. 1 ,.

1 0 . 11.

1<. ) 1

0 .

1 > ?@ 789

1<.

1( .,:

0 .

;

1 .

)

) .1 (

@ 34 0-" "&" "+"# " " " #$ # # " &" ""

+#"#" ##"

, +#" #

# ,

+ " #" ">0 , "

, "

"# $ ## "&" ""# "

,"$"# $ ## " &" '( '4

#!""+#+" # " "

"# $ ## "&" '( "-"" 0 " "#"

, -" &" &" "

0 &"9 '" + ! 0"$ 0"

"6-"".

, +""

# " " # $ # # " &" '(

$ "

#0 ! "# ! " +"#" # , +;,2

;

"2 !, "" "0! "

/+0 " """ ,#" "

-" & " &" "

0 " -"" &+#+"&") *,0"

### " """# ( -" & "# " -"" 0 " !" " "" "

"" " -"" .

, +"6$ 0"

+" ,0 "

-" " &" '(3 # ""

, " + " !"$ # # +;,2#;

4 +# " -" "&" #-" "&" '(3 +"#" # " -" &4 ,0

0# -" "&" '(3!

# ""

"/""

# # -" & 4

" ! "

# " # , " -" & , >#!""! """

0 #"

# 4

"# " " $ ##

! # !""# + " , # "! #" ! " +#"

" -"" .

, +" "

+ :", !">0"

# " " 0 " " ? " +

, -" &# "

, "# " ! "-"".

, +"

# " " "# ! +#"1#

0 " " +

" " ;,"2

;

""2 " $ ##

0""

11.).:1 ).

) 7 ().))

'& "

" ,#

! "

" ! ## !" A- + "" ##""

""" "0 " #" " -" &"&" "" "1#

$ ## " "

+# :" "

+ ! " -"".

, +""

# " # !, $ ## "&" '( #!, +;,2#;

" # "0,#

/"0;

" 0" " 0

) *" #" """ 0"# !

" -"" .

, +" >0 #

" " "$ ## / !

# # -" & " &" !, " -" # "0,"+, "# 0"

>+#+

# " " "$ # # &!

" +#+

+" 0"

! B" , "# 0"

#! +#+ "

# " "

") * #4

0 +#+ " "

") * # "

/+" "" """

- "

" " "$ ##

3C"# ! $ #", "

"-"" .

, +"6$ 0"

" #

+ + #" " "# ! # # ", " "

$ ##!" "# #

! " ! $ #

,! " ,

"+# #

+"# ,

" "# ! # " " /"

"# +

;AB B'C37 4"" "0 " # " -" &"&" ""

";"1#2 $ ## " "

+# :" "

" , +" "

# " # $ # # " &" '( # ! , + ;,2#;

""0

AB B'C37

4 ! "

9 )*

0",4 " -" &# "0, "

" , "# !

0"! ##$ "

# "&" '( AB B'C37

4 ! "

0", 4 # !

# ",, "# 0""

"""" $ # # , + ;,2 # ;

"2 "0

#"" # , ""

"1#

"" # " " "

"# !

, "

"! #2 2%34 !#!

$5 $(!6

01 ?#)%#$&$7) %$, & $#% (% ++!)'+&$6 %

,$( $)&$#% % ,$()A2&222F.

)$,$ !$ ,$$;/(1 ) +##$%)%#$##+ #$ #(( 0A ($%#(#+)$# ( &$&#++$

+(#:<&)#!&#+# :< )

8-- .9

8., 9

*#'$ 767!

:3;2%< !3 $%# &

$ 767!

!:$!63=4 &