High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6593/2016dismissed

Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd v. M/S Jay Bee Industries & ANR

2016-11-08Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!"##$%&%'()#*+#,-. /# 0'1!+2"!"# 3#,,4,!"%'5%*%"#6. !"%!7!

44#77!'"

8#,&0& 9&!:##'60&",%#&.!70" !6.!"/%'6! !'"/#, #&4'6#'"&

# $

,#&#'"( , ,!)##'/!'6#,:!7.6)$!"#.

,"/#!44#77!'" ;;;;; "!

# $

'() "%$#*"%' ,<!0&/%=. 6)$!"#. 3/ %& ' "/# $!)#!". !$$#4"& '"%$#'+#/!7,#&4'6#'" , ,!)##'/!'6#,:!7.7#!,'#6$0'&#7,"/#!44#77!'" &0+*%"&"/!",#&4'6#'" /!676>#6!$7!%* .?.-9@+#,# %$, !'6 2*!77 '"#,4,%&#& !$%7%"!"%' 0'$%7 !" /!'6%>!,/ 0'6#, %$,2*!77!'6#6%0*'"#,4,%&#&#)#74*#'"$". ,&/,"

A$"B 3%'>""/#",!'&!$"%'/!)%'>"!=#'47!$#+#"3##'"/#4!,"%#& !&,#&4'6#'" /!6&0447%#6$#,"!%'>6&3#)#,."/#4!:*#'"3!& '"*!6#.,#&07"!'"7:4#"%"%'0'6#,2#$"%' C$"3!&*)#6 3#)#,."/#4,)%&%'&2#$"%'& !'6 C!,#&",%'>#'"%''!"0,#!&%"

#'"!%7$*40'6%'"#,#&"!'6!&3#77!&"/,##"%*#& ,!"#%'"#,#&".

3/%$/%&'"&0&"!%'!+7#!'6%'"/%&+!$=6,4"/#*!""#,."/#!3!,6+:"/# !,#*#'"%'#60'$%73!&!&&!%7#6+:*)%'>!4#"%"%'0'6#,2#$"%'? "/#,+%",!"%'!'6'$%7%!"%'$". ,+,#)%":. $"B .+0"

"/#&!*#/!&#,,'#0&7:+##'6%&*%&&#69,#1#$"#6/#!3!,6%'>%'"#,#&" %&!>!%'&""/#40+7%$47%$:!'6."/#,#,#."/#+1#$"%'&3#,#%7#63%"/%' "/#4,)%&%'&2#$"%'? $" ,<!0&/%=.7#!,'#6$0'&#7,,#&4'6#'" &0+*%"& "/!""/#!,#*#'"%'#64,)%&%'&"/#$"/!)#+##'#'!$"#6,"/# 40,4&#>#""%'>2*!77!'6%$,'"#,4,%&#&%'+0&%'#&&.,.%'$!&#"/# 4!:*#'"&!,#3%"//#76."/#:3076'"+#!+7#"&0&"!%'2%'$#"/#>6& 3#,#&0447%#6!'6"/#4!:*#'"&3#,#'"*!6#.%"%&%'"/%&+!$=6,4"/# *!""#,."/#$7!%*3!&76>#6/#!44#77!'"&3#,#!3!,#"/#&",%'>#'" !'6&"!"0",:4,)%&%'&"/#7!3.:#""/#:3%"//#76"/#4!:*#'"/#,#%& '6%&40"#""/#0"&"!'6%'>4!:*#'"!'6."/#,#,#."/#$'&#D0#'"%!7 !#$"2#$"%' $"3!&%'#)%"!+7##0,"/#,&0+*%"&"/!""/# )%,#&"/#$"$076'"+#$/!77#'>#6%'"/#4,$##6%'>&0'6#,2#$"%'? $"!'6."/0&.0,>#&"/%&0,",!%,*%'>"/#%'6%'>& /!)#/#!,6"/#7#!,'#6$0'&#7,"/#4!,"%#&!'6!44,!%&#6 "/#4!4#,+=

,"/#&!=#+,#)%":.2#$"%'& . !'6 C"/#$"!,# ,#4,60$#6/#,#%'+#73(@

& ' (&

)

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

,"/#,#>%'>,#!&'&.'$!&#,%'"#,#,#'$#%&*!6#0"

* 44#!7&"!'6&6%&*%&&#6 +,-.,'

'(-,01

#1,21,'

03,(45678',(06,9 :,08 #1,21,'

,3'2(.), :,08