New India Assurance Company Ltd v. Kalawati And ORS










 





 





















 

 







  




 



 





  















 

 







  




 



 






  
  



    !"# $%&$'( # #)(''"    

 !

"

##

   



#)(''"*% $"%&%##% 


%#'("&) *

+

(, - " +   ./

'("!!% %+$%'*

#0"%&

% % "1"$%'*

#1% -  "2 %3% -"

3"%  4

+ "%!*# "

5 ! .

 6

* #  " %

! !+

( "

 %# % -  "$%'*

# %* &%"- % # + " "%!#%

&## 7*

*+!+ +% '("$%'*

# $" % *'+%%  +  '( !* # % "

 "
% +  % "1
)18 .   6& #- "% 

! :;

'*% "
)"%  !% %(

 "% " ##- - "%!# #

;

 ' <;6=;==8    :;

 %

 (;&%   " !!* ! ""%%+ (% #

  % -"

" 5

!* "

-#%- % % -" ##- - "%!# >% :;& ?

+%   "  !>%  "    %   ! %  "
) #-  " % 

!   *%!%   "

>% "

' *! &% # "

* !# %+ !% -) %% %%*'+%"

>% % "% !?

+%

"

 "

"% + & !'(" #%! ? ("!!* !)% -*"

>% ' 

" "&   "%+ #-"
) :%"- 7*

*+!+ %  *  3+

+

 " %  -    "  2 % 3% -" " # *'+%% + '(!* #%"

"+ &%"- -

 ** !% -! % ' , -0 !"< 1'# " 3* + * %  %&   ! +  %  


 
!"#
$#
%&
'!

()
#*+,-.
/
01*2&
"

"

"

10#1,#01*2 +* !+   % %% & **

! # -&%"% " + ('%!' %% %?  % !%

  #( %    "  % +*  "*# '

+%'

%"!#

%##"+ %!%'(", - 0 !"
"% * ""

+  ! /8 .

'(< 1'#"3* + *% 


 
!"#
3#
'%
4%"

5
"
%  %% 3 !% #,  

# % %#

=.@  $"$%'*

##&!+ 3+

%

"

  !  3"%   4

 6.= . @; '(

.

% - "% 

* # % !+  .

. @; % - 8A &  ** ! '%

+*   .@; *  !

" $"#-%

!?

'(!* #"

##

%"

"$%'*

  +*#% #% = "'

% -!  

* + %'(% ! -

! &"&8;8 ( # "%+!!* !) *

"%!  ""

#% *  9*-+   < 1'# "  ? * # #
'%6
3#
78 &



 


#
!"#&
01*+

0211#

) % !

 " !#

 

# 5% -  "

!+     !   "   "

    B  3"

5*   &" % %      / 

 " -   ( $" %+"% -- % -*!% "?  8A

+*#% #% 8&%""' "

% %+%(%* % "*!%

+*#% #% "! & '

!"#

-" +"& ! % +%

+*#% #%  )"

" !* #"

##

 *"

;'5

%!*# #(" 

'("$%'*

# % * '#( !!* ! %  7*%  5 ! %  " #    -.

 6$"
)& -%   6'(   +3% -"'"! 2 %3% -"< %  % "% % % '( & (  ?

+%

 !"%

   "

 *  9*% !%  %  "  2 % 3% -" %   " 

 3"% 

 % %  C)3 " 5   !

*% - "    #" -!

 "

# ($" & &% '(>%    +"

%%  %## -* " + ( " "!% % + "  +'%# " 

 

-%  "%!#" %%" :" "

!""  -# ;

!

' -<;6=;;==8

+!(!# ' - <;

0;

./6 & #(% -   " 

  '("%'"& C  + " % #$"

+  :;

%

(;&% "!!* !" "& !!

% "%+5 & '*  !>%  "  >%  %  % !"% % %

  '*" %+

+

" %'*% - "



-#%- !%  " -!

*#% -% %*% 9*%"%+!(!# <;

0;

./6D*% -"!*" -!* #+ 

%# '# %" +  :;

>% :; * #"

 %#  % *

(%!

!(+ % # !#%!%% !?

+%

>% ! *'"

>% &  " ""

 "!!* !$"% " ##- - "%!#%

% "&% '?!* !

"!#



%!*# #(  + 

>%  ;  % "

##-

(%##;&%## +%( - "%+'(

>% !% "%  +  ' " #%! %'*% -  "



-#%- !  % " - "%!# "% %&"+ )% +(#*

'# !! " *'+%% + '(!* #"%

!!+

(%  *#% "% -!'("$%'*

# %*  $"% '% - " *  " *'+%%  &%" -   7*  "2 %3% -"$"$%'*

##& ' %  % !  % !+  ** ! '( #(% - * 9*-+   < 1'# " 3* + 9 %
"
% 
3#
9:
'8%
"
% &
01*-

*21-  $" +  ! "

  ! %

-' , -0 !"% *%!%  (" %' %

< 1'#"3* + *% 3

" "

#&

"!

*  "

%!"

##

;%

!!+

( %"  +*

# -&%"% *  @;%

+3

"

"

#& # %&( ' &"  %%!

##( * %#%  #"

#$"%  "%? %% '

%  ( 7* #(  3+ 3

" "

& # $"% %!%  & %*'(" "

'("%

!!+

("

'  5 - %  %&  ! #%!% - 9*-+    %  " !

 "

"

#%'% -% '("% *"%

!!+

(

(

(*!"% %+ 

-+ 

* #"

##

 %

%*+*#% #%7*

%  

%

" &%" -    "  3"%  4

) B3"

5* 

"!

* < 1'# "3* + *"

%+"% -&%"- *!%  "? 8A

+*#% #% 8 "! & '

!"#

-"+"& ! % :%"*- " ' + % " % *"%(" *"

! %"

 %* 9*-+    " %* '

#
'
3  
"
% 
$ 
 %


"
% &
011;
(-)

($)
,,

";2*-' !"!%%

% 
4 
"
% 
3#
7"
7%
"
% &
01*-

*0.-) 3 # >+ 1!

* "

* %

   '% - * %+%( %  " !  +    + "%!*#  !

 # % &  !

!% #&%"- +*#% #%*!%

** !$"

* "# "

 9*%!

 9*  +

 + 7* #%( %   +  % !(

"*-"

% 9*%!

 % 

* %+%(  " !%% ;+ 5% !

 " !%%  :"%# % + (  '

%'#"

+ "+ %!

!%% % %!

% %   +  %+%#   ! "*# #    %  "  +

-  :"  "  !@%

*  "  +

 " +*# @#-

!% # " +! % !(

* %+%(

% -

 5%  "*# ' " *#  9*%!

  %   9* )% $%'*

#!

#!*# !

#!*# % #( "  +  ! " !#

 " #%%-

 " !++  +

 &%## ' *  #?

 '&%# ) " % %- %%!

 % -

+ -$%'*

#% +% -"7*

*+!+  %+%#  !%&%### %; % !%

%*% "(+) "

!

 < 1'#2*-&! !%*" ! "

* + %  &"%# #% -&%""7*% *!% "? 8A'( 5%

 %&"

"+" # &%##'! %  , % "+ %1!

* "+*#% #%&5*% 3 # >+ 1  *  & %+ &%"

%%  "

 %  !

 -  " !  % *   8 (  % !%   3!%   .; *  &"%!""!# %+!+ "

' + +*#% #% 8%

+  % %!

 %  " 3!  3!"*#   "  >"%!# !

== *'9!  !!% %  * %  !#*+    "  '#

% 3 # >+ 1!

* "*#'##&3%###   "!%% B3"

5*  1!

* " ? *% 7
!

"
% 
$ 
3
4 
'% 
"
% &
01*.(-)

($)
22,"

"#%

7*"*;  $" + - 7*%  %  #(   +*#% #% $" <%-" ##&% -3

"D %* "

. "+*#% #%:"" "+*#% #%"*#  -" 

"

" ! "

' "

-% -%+%+F'*"

' -%  7*%* '(

" ";2*- 0 !" !%%  "+ % * )& "#"

"+*#% #%%'*&%" !"

/

-"!   

'"

"%! (&%" -   " -  " !  '*    "

   

 % ! "&%## #& ('+% * &""" -  " #  (* -     "  - ! % '   $ 7* E. ) 3 # >+ "% *"

 *%+ #%(" "&%!+ #??!% + # !(

 +%

  !+  !# %+ +  *  3!%  ) "

'  %-"#(   %  3 #  >+  "

 " !#

 %  !

   " !# %+  " *   +* '#%"  -"! F'% !+ "! F

!" *+' 

$ %  " #   !( " $%'*

# +* ! % %

%% @*!% '+  % % "% !+F%% "*!% '+ & " 

##% % -?

  " ! F

 %%% " +*#% #%  '

#% &%"  !  " -  " !  :   "% 5 % %

! (* %%"# & % & % *##

-+ &%"" %&% 3 # >+ G  %& * !% # &# %& 3 # >+ 1!

 * 

 " 9*-+    '(  ";2*- 0 !" %  "+

%1!

* 

*

, #2

"1!

* )% %%%!*#' * '("*'+%% !* #"%

("

"$%'*

!++%

'(  % -+*#% #%  = % !  +*#% #%  -  +"  " ! 

 "!+ 

"! 3"%  4

%#% '#'*! " % '  %  %&&"

' %!*"%

' "

#  %#

 !!% -#(%+%% 

 37
;&
01*+















( 4
7!)
HDC*# %I

















 

:"" 5% -@    (@  :""  '#  (@