High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22521/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. No 654043 Mwo Himanshu Shekhar And Another

2024-11-06Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

!"#"$%&

!"#$# $ $%&$ '(

'% ()'

* +

()'

* ** * ' )(*+, # - &.- - / 0(12- 3 /' *

* +

, "/ )// -8 '0/' 3 (-0 '

-+ 3 / ) - ( 3 / ( (-( 9!

50 - '-

( *+ / ;- ( .( 2 "

*-;

22 (08/ /2;-.3 '( 3 /) -3 ( -*;+' 8- -;;8(

- . !/01-$2 '( <((- 2===9 -3 -3/-;/ )/2

3/ 120/2

(/ ( -*;+3> 1"3 1445

$#"$(-(8- ( 2/- )(3 . 12 !/.3( 2/- )0/ ( -*;+8- -

!@3 ;3*+/#(2-;A- ( ! "/( -*;+;.2;-.3/ '(8- <2( *+/.'/ +0/ /) (/-/ -( -*;+ 8- / - *-*; *)-)) -1-(*+ (3.;- +

'( 3;( - -''-; (-( 9 0 /81 0/ -. '()-(<(2- ;)-)) 1(0 '( 3;(0*3 / ;- ( .( 2 "

*-; 22 (0 8/ / 2- - 2/-;;)/-3 -( <2 ( "/ -(0*2-. -;;8(1( ( (-( 9!"/' -1'- 3/ -( ( : -2(/ -3

"# $

#"""(#(#

! ! "

# $ %

"#"((#")* ;)-)) 1(3 ./-3 -( ( - '-

(' /4 -50*+/;- ( .( 2 "

*-;22 (0/ ' 3(-/- 3;(/ -)- / -8 ' *3 /

$ $!

# 6"#-1 B A3 '

2().-C-3321-(<(2-' /'

8 '0 - 3;-

-23 ( .)8//

/*3-;;.3-+( 1 D1 -+..* 3/(32 '

;0*' / *) ;;(/- .+0( '-/-;

-)0'/ *2.); (0- -..* 3/2.*-- (32 -*; /.0 / -. .-)(2(0+/ -'' '0/ ' ; ./2*)2 -*;* / 2)-; *)2 -*;*2.-)) -1-( *) - *-*;.;- 120/ -2E (03 .0/'

2'; 3 //<(). (*+/$>*;': 02- ;( - &' ( ' $ "

# 0 ' ( )! * + ( , "/ ;1- '- -) -'/ 3 / -( 1 (2 - : -2( / -3 (

% %

+ , - ./

(#1 %

! &

2 3 4

"5(6

'077-3 "89. -

7 % &

:3 ; <3 ")-.= -

.> -

-3 . - %.7

:3 ")- .= -%.7

:")-.= -% .7

:")-.=B -%

.7 @

077 6C

-@ .

(##( D 62 , C

8 5

% 9#

% %

9 2 1 -()4 53/-*1: -2('

2'; /)/'(;+(2;- 0/-8/-( -*;+*2. -;(' -+..* 3/2.*--(32 -*; /.0-(8/2/ / : 3 @ 1 0 / '0 /)/ -+ 2/ ( -*;( ..* (* 1-;(( 3 ./ .+0*+ /

(*-

)(/*33( -*;+' =

0/-

).3( -*;+' -+ ..* 3/2.*--(32 -*; /.08/*2. -;( 8/ - ( -*;+ - E-. 3 @ . 0 * .' -1;+

- (2;- - 3 . / #(2-; A- (0 2-((;+ 2)/-/ -(--(( -*;+*)- *-*;

*2.)-)) -1-(*+.;- 12"/ -((2;- -*2.

<(*+/2 3 4

"5(6

'077-3 "89. . 0/)// -'

.' -

)( % 0F0% / ('/+ 2-;-(.-;/-;/3-+..* 3/ (32 -*; /.22 (0 '2-;;+8/-/ -)3/

*2.) ;;(0/ 2 (-*/ *2.)* 8/-+( # 1 0/)// / -;

-3

.'0 /- 8/ -+ ( - / 0 / 22

* E;+0 / / -( /-'') 3 ( -4 5

) 3-+( 0 *'

.(*- E;3/

) 12 - - ..* 3 / (32 -*; /. .' -1;+0/ 3 '

1)/(8. E-*3

-5% 0F0% /22 (0* (/.';+ 0-( 2- 0/ -( .- ( 2/- )(0/ '0/2;-.- *2. ;( 21( -*;+' # 1 0-;;/3-2

-( 2 2.

-2 -(- / ( 3 12 *+ / 22 (0- *2; ;+ F(0/ 3 (2;- )8// / 3-+( 1 D1 /22 (0 - E;E- (

3 .;- 12 -(6 / -. *) -)) -1-( *+ *) - *-*;.;- 12 A/-- .-+0/ *2. -;

3 /-3

2';4 5/-+/ 2-*(-;3( -*;+' / 22 (0*;+',

-5/.3-22'-23/22 (.;- +

120 .) *2.) 2 ((*+/#(2-;

A- ( 1 -1 / *) * 8/ - ( 8/2/ /81 0*2. 22;((*+ )/.

3*2.; ( *5 + 3 ( - / 3 0 .-+ -;

* E;+*2.22;((*+/#(2-;A- (0 - 3 . ( 3 .;- + 12 *) - *-*;.;- 120 / -.*)- 2)-;( 03/.(2-;'/;( /-/( 2;( /-1*(2(.(2-;:-.-3/22 (*) .-(0/ '

/ *2.); ( 120/ ' 0/

-.8;;*(.(/-1- ( ) 120+/

-4 -50/#(2-;A- ( ( -/ 3

22;() ! # 1 0 -;

(2;- ( -0/- .-(- + 3 /#(2-;A- (3;;8/)(; ;-((8/-' 3/GH(#(2-;4#;- + 50IG%;., H -; 2'; G "/ 3 0/- *8( .(8// .

3 /-*1'

2'; 08// -/.3; .3/'

'(/ .+0/ -3 -'

;.- +.(2-;:-.- *).-( % 00% /-;/0/ -*2-. 2 ((-*

.( * )/.-(6 8// .*2-.-''(( /-/ -(( 8- -( .- -)# 1 0 -;

(*( .(03 ./3-2 -/-(08// / - 2- -;:

/ '3/( 0-(6 / )

3 0/ '

0/ ' / ;;.3/'

'( -C) ';-20 % 00% / -21 ( *+ /. 3 .;- 1208/ 0/ .-+22;(/-/ 3 /( * 8- - E;3/ ) 12/ .+ -(- 2/8- - *-*; *2-.-)) -1-(*+/ ) .;- 12 -((0 -;

(*)-/ (3 ./

2 ( 08// /#(2-;A- (0((-;;+'

2(.-C- (-;(2 1-2(-;2/2C0'- 2;- ;+-'' -)/ -(13/( 0/ )/.';+. 3-3 .(2-;

2/E 0 / 1;) / *;2C 2/- )2 220 8/ 3 .

0 /( *2-. 2(# 1 03/ -( .';+.3-;

;-;+0/ .-+*2.22;((E- ' / 30/ * E/-'' ; .-C) ';-20 8- 2)-;*8( ) (3 .;- 12* ( *)- *-*; *2.)-)) -1-( *+' 3 .-23.;- 12 - ;+03/ -.';+( 2/E -/ -)3-'' ; .-C)';-20/ *+/ #(2-;A- (22 (0;-( -22;

0/-/ -

( .-2(2 3-+( 0*+/ -(( .-( /*)/; .3-+'

;/- .+0-1+ -

3 2 ;-;+/ * E-21(26 '/ 3 ( )/2

3 (3.;- 120*8;(- -;;+ ;-(-8;;22;

*+/#(2-;A- (0/- -21 '

* *2-. 2( 3 . - 3321 2- -; )2 22 8/ / 8;(*(-;3( -*;+' $81 08/ -((-1 0/ ( *: -2)/2 3/'0- *2-. 2 ((*+/

;- .(2-;*- ( -.##- -/ 012 32&#4 5-%& ;- (

( 6( -*; 2/ ;)2-; ( 322

2 -*;+ *-*;

124J6 )) -1-( *+

124J6 -;(< 32-

3 ( -*;+ % - /-()- /'-2- -"/ / +3

K -3

12( ) 3( -*;+ (1(-; 8- 1) ;(- 0$0-

;)( -3;- 12 ( ) ( -*;+$2 ( -*;+ 22((- *+ 12 .

3- - .

3- - !3/-' 3 H# #; 4-.(.59 B -()3/ 2 ( 1-;

/--/.3/ .- + $+' 4;(5 -'' ; .-C)';-2 *2-..-( .

3/'

2'; 4 -5(2;- (*+/$>*;': 2- ;(- &' ( ' $ "

# )**+/#(2-;

A- (0/- .( 8/2//81 0((3 *(/'

'(0*2.; (/ .+0((.-C '

;.- + ) 3 0 / (2;- - 3 ;-8 <(). 4 -5 /- / -'

.'/-/2

)3/ -(( 8- - E;3 (3 120 (*3-1 -*;+ (8(1 -1 / '("/)/ / -( '

*-*;*/ ;-(1(2 */ -('

.' *2-. 2- ' / ' $81 0 / -( 2- 1(2 -((2)( 2/- )) 1 -1 / '(0 3 2);+

*)/ -('

.'0*- -;;+-;

((2- -

(+-;

'/#(2-;A- (0)-) ;3/(-1 3 - /)0 / )/ .';+. 3 / - 3 *;2C 2/- )2 2- -; 22 2/E4 50 8/ .-+ *2-. -1;(/-/ )3/( /- .+'

;0 *2-. 2(3 .-2(-;)23-.;+/ +# 1 8- -;

(* -(/.(2-;'0/- /( *3 -8;;3 .( 8- -2)-;( -(*2-./ -)) -1-(*+ *2-.- *-*;.;- +

12 9 $81 0- -()3'4 -50( 2; /-/-

* 2 ((- +'(3 .-( /-1* 2 (( / : 4 -5 -(;+0 2 1(2 * / .'4 -5/- *;(*+/' 0/ 0/ 2 -()18)/-)/'3/.(2-;*- (0 - : -2( 4 -5 '2 ;+0 / 2 (2 2- * -

)(/ -;;3 .( 0* ( / / ) 3/( 2-* -(*- E;3-2(-;)2 3-.;+/ + - ;+0 (*(2;- (- 3 .

(3.;- 12-((0 (*(2;- ( *- *-*; *2.)-)) -1-(*+ (3.;- 12 *+/'

'( = # 1 0/)/ -(/ /-/( 4 22

(8/; 12*2-.' 3 .(*+/(32'

;

-'-2- -0* 2/ :'

.-(-/

;1- );- 08/2/.-C / ) 3/( 4 5-

'-2- -0*)-3 E;/-- 2/0> ) (( - 3 ./ (3.;- 12 *2-.-)) -1-( *+ (3/.;- 122 E20/;-2C3/ -( :'

.-(- / );- 0 ( 2 - / 22;(0/-13/ ) 3/ -(( 4 5'/ '(/ 22

(-'-2- -0/ *+0/ -( ) - * (2;- ( *2. -)) -1-( *+ *) - *-*; (3.;- 12 0 2 .

3/<(). (*+/ ': 02- ;(- 6"

# $ % ?

( -

+, 7 8/ 0-(2;- - .-(/ :0/-/*33 ()330 /- *2.(8( /22 ( ;-;+-;

/ (

-(3- *; )/ *2-. 1 ( / '

'( 3 / C) E- / -'' () 33*).-(/ 3-1 %1 / 8 2 / (2;- - 3 ;-8 .-( 1 (24 -5.-C / -((2;- -*-:' ;-3;-8 .0/ 0/:' ;-3;-8 .0- .-(1 (2 -5-;

.-C // (

(*3 1 -1 / (32 '

; 22 (0 0

0 -;

; / 22 (0/ --+. C/) -)3/(8. -

.-(/ (

0-(/-0/3;; 2.';.0- '; (

0* (

'213/*- 03-+03(;-+-(;-2/ "/ 3 0 / ) -) 3 / *3 3 / -''

() 330 .

3/1 (24 -5 (*+/"

*-;

22 (0-;

( 33 3 .-+;;)-;+-( (* '/;(

"$ . 12 1 6"#-1 ! -3 .-/0/ 3( . /8 ' -(8/* 1- -*10/ -. ( .

( "/.')( ( 0- '-

(*+/;- ("

*-;

22 (0 .--(-(-33 .( ' (3-;)8/-;;'()-'';2-4 503-+ 7*

* +

7* * '8 & LM // '-C)6 ( , J // ' -*; , J