Moshmina v. Anish & ORS

   

      

 !"#$"%&'&#()**

+  ,--".. (! /"0'1'

  ,*"'-#(2"(!'

#0 3) #(45." 0*1'!&%"*+*6 .&  0"'"(!)

0*&78&9 :;28#% !"$#0

0*'<&'< 1-! ;28#% !"$#0!<" --".. (!*

0*/&'< .=< !> 0;28#% !"$#0

0*+13&! 1-! ;28#% !"$#00"'-#(2"(!#**

0*+15< '< #: .;28#% !"$#0 0"'-#(2"(!#*?('10 (%" #3- (:*

0*/&> '=13 0 ( ;28#% !"$#0

0*+ (2""-=13 0 ( ;28#% !"$#0!<" --".. (!&( @A (2 $#0 0"'-#(2"(! #*  &(   * BBB *+*6 .& ;*

0 .
 <&'#02"0'< ..2"%&2" #*#$ (2 #* @#$A '!<"' 3" 0&'"#1!#$!<"' 3" C 02* %!'#$!<"% '" 0"5"&(7! >"($0#3 #*#$*
 0 :"0 &( !<" &('! (! --" . &' $#0 "(< (%"3"(! #$ %#3-"(' !&#( #$ '*A;@D;? C 02"2 !# !<" C&2#C?$ !<"0 #$ !<" 2"%" '"2+ <E 25:!<"." 0("2 #!#0%%&2"(! . &3'0&51( .; .C .

<"0"&( $!"00"$"00"2!# 'F!<"0&51( .G8&2" C 022 !"2*H**
 I" 0("2 %#1('". %#(!"(2' !< ! !<" --".. (!4' $ !<"0&( . C&*"*0"'-#(2"(!#*<"0"&(< 2$&."2  "!&!&#(#*A#$D 5"$#0"!<"." 0("2 #!#0%%&2"(! . &3'0&51( .; .C .&(C<&%<!<"

 --".. (! C ' 0"'-#(2"(! #* (2 !< ! #( !<" 5 '&' #$ -." 2&(7'; "8&2"(%" (2 '153&''&#(' 3 2"; !<" ." 0("2 0&51( . C ' -." '"2 !# C 02  '13 #$ '* A;@D;?!# !<" --".. (!C&2#C (2 $ !<"0

0"'-#(2"(!#*#$2"%" '"2+ <E 25:! >&(7&(!# %%#1(!;&(%#3"#$ !<" 2"%" '"2 ' '*D? -"0 3#(!< ' -"0 (#!&$&% !&#( -"0! &(&(7 !# 3&(&313C 7"'&(!<"+! !"#$ 0: ( 210&(7!<":" 0;C<"0" ' ' -"00"."8 (!#!&$&% !&#(2 !"2*A*;3&(&313C 7"'$#01('>&.."2 C#0>"0'&(!<"+! !"#$ 0: ( C ''*DH*D?-"03#(!<;'"%#(2.:; (#$1!10"-0#'-"%!'C"0" C 02"2!<#17<J#$!<""'! 5.&'<"2&(%#3" #$!<"2"%" '"2C '.& 5."!#5" 22"2!#C 02'$1!10"-0#'-"%!' '-"0 - 0 70 -< #* &8 #$ !<" 2"%&'&#( #$ #(45." !<" +1-0"3" #10! &(
 

       

 



!  "

; 5"'&2"' !<" --".. (!?0"'-#(2"(! #* C ' "(!&!."2 !# C 02 #$ '*;D? #( %%#1(! #$ .#'' #$ "'! !" ' 7 &('! '*D;? C 02"2 5: !<" 0&51( .; .&>"C&'" !<" --".. (!?0"'-#(2"(! #* C"0" "(!&!."2!# C 02#$'*;D?#( %%#1(!#$$1("0 ."K-"('"' ' 7 &('! '* ;? C 02"2 5: !<" 0&51( . 5"'&2"'; 0"'-#(2"(! #* C ' "(!&!."2!# C 02#$'*;?#( %%#1(!#$.#''#$$&.& .%#('#0!&13&( !"03'#$!<"2"%&'&#(&(#$%  

  
  &  

&

"'!&&!(((
 I" 0("2 %#1('". $#0 !<" 0"'-#(2"(!('10 (%" #3- (: %#(%"2"' !< ! !<" 3&(&313 C 7"' $#0 !<" 0"."8 (! -"0&#2 ' -"0 (#!&$&% !&#( 2 !"2 *A* &( !<" +! !" #$ 0: (  $#0 1('>&.."2 C#0>"0' C ' '* DH*D? -"0 3#(!< (2 !< ! ' -"0 - 0 70 -< #*  &8 #$ !<" 2"%&'&#( &( 0 ( : +"!<&4' % '" '1-0 ;  J #$ !<" "'! 5.&'<"2&(%#3"#$!<"2"%" '"2C '.& 5."!#5"! >"(&(!# %%#1(!$#0 C#0>&(7 #1! !<" $1!10" -0#'-"%!' 5"'&2"' !<" %#3-"(' !&#( - : 5." #(

 %%#1(! #$ $1("0 . "K-"('"' (2 .#'' #$ "'! !" C ' !# 5" - &2 L '* ;D?#(" %<%#1(!!#5"'< 0"2-0#-#0!&#( ..: 3#(7'!!<" --".. (! (20"'-#(2"(!#** "<#C"8"0%#(!"(2'!< ! ' 7 &('!"(!&!."3"(!#$ '*;? #( %%#1(! #$ .#'' #$ '-#1' . %#('#0!&13; !<" --".. (!?C&2#C< 25""( C 02"2'*D;?C<&%<C '.& 5."!#5" '% ."22#C(!#'*;?*
D < 8"%#('&2"0"2!<"'153&''&#('#$." 0("2%#1('".*
 23&!!"2.:;!<"2"%" '"2C ':" 0'#$ 7"*(%#3"#$!<" 2"%" '"2 ' -"0 (#!&$&% !&#( 1(2"0 !<" 3&(&313 C 7"' $#0 1('>&.."2 C#0>"0' &( !<" +! !" #$ 0: (  ! >"( &(!# %%#1(!C ' '* D? -"0 3#(!<C<"0" '&(8&"C#$ %%&2"(!5"&(7#$ %!#5"0;(#!&$&% !&#( M1 3&(&313C 7"'$#01('>&.."2C#0>"0'&(!<"+! !"#$ 0: (  '#( *A*C ''*DH*D*
A %%#02&(7.:;&(!<".&7<!#$!<"-#'&!&#((#!"2 5#8";2"! &.' #$%#3-"(' !&#( C 02"25:!<"0&51( . ' .'#%#3-"(' !&#( ''"''"2 5:!<&' #10!&' '1(2"0)
   

          

         * (%#3" #$ !<" 2"%" '"2 ' ''"''"2 '*D?-"03#(!< '*DH*D?-"03#(!< * 1!10"-0#'-"%!' &. J #$ '*DH*D? N DD*@ #! .DH*DO DD*@N'*A@HD*? * "21%!&#( !#C 02' -"0'#( ."K-"('"'#$ !<"2"%" '"2 ?02#$'*A@HD*N A@HD**AN '*D*? *

1.!&-.&"0 --.&"2 @ @ ?02#$ '*D ND*AN * '*D*KK@N ;;HA*?

0#1(2"2 #$$ !# D*

#3-"(' !&#( C 02"2 '**KK@N '*A;;*?

0#1(2"2 #$$ !# '*

 A;;? '*;A;? * 1("0 . K-"('"' '*;? '*D? A* I#''#$"'! !" '*D;? '*;D? @* I#'' #$ '-#1' . ?$&.& .%#('#0!&13 '* D;? !# !<" C&2#C '*? !# " %< #$ !<" --".. (!?0"'-#(2"(! #*&*"* '*@@;? H* (!"0"'! A*DJ-"0 ((13 A*DJ-"0 ((13   



  !"



 
@ %%#02&(7.:; &( !<" .&7<! #$ !<" -#'&!&#( (#!"2 5#8"; !<" --" .&' ..#C"2*C 02- ''"25:!<"." 0("20&51( .&'3#2&$&"2 (2 %#3-"(' !&#(- : 5."!#!<" --".. (! (20"'-#(2"(!#*&'"(< (%"2 $0#3 '* A;@D;? !# '* ;D@;? .#(7 C&!< &(!"0"'! L A*DJ -"0 ((13 ."'' 3#1(! &$ (: .0" 2: - &2* #3-"(' !&#( 5" - &2 !# !<" --".. (!?0"'-#(2"(!#* '-"00 !&#2"!"03&("25:!<"." 0("20&51( . &*"*&(AD?DJ0"'-"%!&8".:* #$
%  &    '

(  **