Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited v. State Of Haryana And Others

 



        


























































  

 !"#$#$%#$  ,-!
!

,- ./ 012  3-  !

- 4 
 

-5! !1 , -  6!1 ! % ,-!
!

,- ./ 012  3-  !

- 4 
 

-5! !1 , -  6!1 ! &"'

80 & 
 

9













:;-
,-32 )-<+









!

"#$$%
 &$'(

!

"#$")

&$'( 


*





+

 
 

*



 


,
*
 





-



*.


/ *.



*







 
 




+0.
*-


 


"%$
 


 .




 








!

"#$$%

&$'(




   
*.


1
&
-

1
"/


*

. 



-


 
1 "



 






.



  



.





-


 

'%'



 


1
&

 

 


')2 3"4
 



.




-




 
 

-



-


1
"

 -


5




-


/
 6,!
1 '&

'2 $' &$'$


7
'"3'434


 


-
-


1 "/

 

-



1
"


**

 

*.
8-
**/
 -
.


 


* 









- 
 


1
"



 


 

-

 *.

  


1
"
 


*
 

0-



6,!

1

*

*.

 


 -

1
"



.



 *
6,!




-

-

 - 

*
0-




 
 
--
  


- .

9



.

 











.

 
1
&
-


 

-


6,!

-

1 "/




-



1
"  
--


-

-




 




.




1
"
 



.


 



 
 


 

!

-
 .

 

 -


*

-
 

1
"

''

 

:;










  --
*.


1 "

*





 .





*

*.


1 "

.







.


.

,
 

-



1
"


9



  







-

-
 .

 

-
 


9



.

 .

-












.





8
*.

 


 

<

*


-


.


1 &
 
  
*

- 

-

  


-

 


 


 -

.


/

0

 '(7
 



*
* 

1 &


-

 

 







- 


<


-
 -


'$ $2 &$')
-


1 "/
 
%$(
, 


 
*.

1 "

  



$& $2 &$'2 

1 "
 

-




!

&(7"# &$'2


 
*
-


.
-

-





,



--



! ,
 
1 &
-


 


 

&& '& &$'7
 -


6,!
-

1 "/
8-




-
--
-


- *8
 -

*-

'('

.


.
*.
8-
8
*



-
9 
<

 

*.


1 &

6,!

1
7$"

&2:'&:&$'7

-
-

1
"
 
'&$ =

%$(
, 

 


 




8
-


1 "



 


 
*

-

&' $) &$'#
3!-

&$ $( &$'#4/


--



  
*.

 

6,!
1
7$"/







  
 
-



.
*.

  -

-


 





 -

 .
 
-
-

6,!
1 7$"


&2 '& &$'7


1 "



 

 
 


-

 


  


.
&$'$ ''
 /
-



*
. *.

-
 

 





 *

-

&$ '$ &$'# 


 
 &' $) &$'#
 
*.

1
&

 .
>


  


-
 **





 
 /



"$ $% &$'( 

- 

&& $7 &$'(

*





 
 

.



--


 

/






--



!

"#$")

&$'(

 

1
&
*
*-



 


 
 .
1
?*
@
,

.





'7'








--



-
-
- 


1 "

 
--


.


*.
 


* 


 .


?* @ 8-





1
"
 


  

.
&$'"
-


1
&


+

 1







)$$
)$'

)$& , 

 

 

* 



. *
*.

1 "
 -

*

9


 .

;-


9


1 "

 
  

-
0
*.


1 &


*
 
!

,

A



1 "

  

 

 
*




* 
<
  /

-

8


 



.




1 "

,

 

1 &

  . 
A




/





 
 


 

1 "


 




1 & 


1 & 

 
*





1 "

  

-







9
*.

 .

 
 


+





 

.


-




. 
  

 




8

* 
 

-


"%$
 
*
 -

1 "






 
 -

-


"%$
  





'='




.

/


/


 



*




 

<





*



 




*




1
&

1
"
 

-
* 

*



*
-




 

 
*.


,

* 


1
"

 *
8-
-


 







 
-
.



1
&


*
 9- 




=


*
-

-
 


8















-
 



-

 .





.
 -










 
  









 
 





:



 * 

 



./


/
*




A 
--







 *








-

 .






.


-








 
,

*



1
&

 

  
-
 -


1
"



*

 


.




1
&


* * -




 





 
.





-

*.
 




*




-

*.


'>'


1
&

*


-
*

-



 
.


-
*





 




*
*.




/


 
*.




*

*.


.

 /



  



.
 





.

0

  
.



-
* -






 
 
:

1
&






*
 

 -

B
C

*.



D



*




-

*

*. 
.



.
  


+

 .
  


*

*




 .
 


*





: 








:

 







.

-


D






 
 /





.
*


-

*. D




,

-





 


/




--

B
C
 -





*

 
*

-
  .



.


*

* 


.



* 





?
 
*

/






.



-





.








''

.










.
. 
.






- 



 





-
*.

 

 

 





*.
* 
* 





.
*





 
0
*.

 /
 

*
*.

 
 .

>




* 
*.



 
0

*


-







,




 .






-

 
*










0 


 

-


 

6

-



 
 -
*.



 






*  

*
?




"''

 


  








>
.


 
,
 
*







--
 
"''
 



- E




  
 



 
     










  

  
   
 

 



 

  



 

 



  
 





 


 
 


 

    
  
 






 
  


 



 


   



 
!


 


"

  


 #

'$'


*









 9

>
.






?


* 






 

*



 


*
0





 


 








>




 

.

?











-

.






:


 

*










*.
   










.
9
 


.


 


 * 


.


--







 * 

 -


-






 



 
.



-




 



*.


/
-

-
/
 






 

0

 
*.


.





.
.




0


 .
-

 
 
9







 



*.










 



.






*.



 
 


9

>

- *8
  

*





.



 



*

>



.






.


*

*




'#'

*.
-





 

. 



-
 


*?


 

 - /


 

*

 .
*.


 








.





 
/









 * 

 
.






 
*
 *





. 
*.
.

 

 





./
 


 
-





 


 
.


*


-



 
*>







8








-







* 

* 
 .

*
?

1>
-









 



*.





 













-

*

>

 . -



-





 
  




*

*.








 


.

*

!-

-
*.



 -


*


5 





*.






*



-

 

 



.

1 

.






 



*

0
 




 

.




.


 


*





-





''


 







 -





*

  
:

1
&


* -



 


-



.
 


*
8
 




 
 
*.




 
-

*


.
 

-
*-
*

 -   
-






.



 0






 
 
*.





*

.
 .


- 


 *









*
8

*
-










8

-

  
 
*.

 :
1 &

 
.

.
*.
.



 

*
8
 


 .
*

 


*
 * - 




.
 



 *




-

  
-



*

 





1 "

,





 
1 "



.

 
 
 - -


1
&: 
,



-
  :
1
&


*

*.


 






 

 

* 

 
.
-

1 "




 
 


-



1
"

 .
9

  

  D .







*


'%'






-

*.


1 &:

 



 .
.


-
*
 
/




*.





 


*
0 

-




 


 


.
 
6



/


-

 





-



  --

*




 
*
.
*.

  . 



8




.


-

0
 -
-
*


/






*.
 


*
0


-
6



 .
 
B
C

*.



.


   

 .*/





* 




 -
*





-



  . 
.





-

 
*.

-
 

 
 
*
0

*



 
 

-

.
-



0



.



-


 
 



 B
C
*.




*




1

-


*.




 

,



*
-





 




6 /;

- #$2 %#$ ) 

9 + - !?



A
8-:
F:1 A
!* 
F:1