Bishamber Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Another
!
"#$%&'$()*)%+,,
-.
,/ / 0 !" #$%! %& '(!) !!'!& '(!& )% *%$!& &!*!! +,#+!& '(!& ) -
/ 02, 3"4!
% ( ./- ) % 0 ) 01!, ( %!2), )3!%$) 45 ! -657-57& $ (-5&.-5&.689"$,*"(.68 0!(.860%%! )% :.6/! .80& ! ,( ! % !& ( ! !2! & ! !,, (3!,
( $ !$ %)1& % 2! ) (1 1 !' ! 2"% ! - ! 45/-5-4& % ! " ( !
!2)%,! !,0;,,!3! !$!&)$$% !1 ( < ! % $ ) % (1 1 (1 ,!( %)& )= (!, !$! 0,!& ! !2! &
-
! 457-5-4&%!2(' &"%&%!2( %!%
!%!', % !1(!2,*"%!* ),(& (( ! ) % !(( %!' 2 (,! !
(,!1 )) 4 >! (,)% %!)%, % # $1)% 10%(!)
& &( %!'%))( (.-5&.68& .8)0(!23!% %2!)(1 1 . %,1!!1&2#('! $!,)!,$!,*1 ((,%(!,(),(>!"3 ,*%! , %!')$%"%!(%%# (%$% *&$% ,)! ,2*! %$%( %12*%,$!,*1% (', !%(),(2"" !&%!'$,' )%(!, &(!,%!1*%(*!(%(!2, ) 1$'% !,% 2*(1 1&) (&(1$"%(!,$!,(3(!",,"'&% (1!, (!,*(%1,',*" ! % 1 ) % ( & (3( ! ))( % (1!,!( (!%))(! (3(' % (* ! ,!$ %)& % ,!" (2 %1& '
%1! %?1 %1&(, $ !% !,*) (1!,!( @ "'&1)%%(', (),( ) " ! !)1 %1,' (1!, ! (
4
%)&%,$!,*1 ,!*1 ,'%(),(2" " !<"%%! !A)$%!%! '1 !() 3!(*!,!$11B ,,%( ! ,'%(),(2"" 2* $%)&' %(1!,,!"3 $' $! %"%)% ! ($B$% ( ,,*&% !,$!,*1!,
' )($B$%(1 12"" )!(1!, (4-500!?
'%$! % (,* ' )(1 $ $%!,&2 1 (1 $'!!
,,!'!,!$"'2*'* ! ! ( & ( 4-5 00 (! 2 % , *< "% % ($ ! (1 1 2" % ! %!'< (!,*< 2 () % ( ,! ,* % ))(
(2 % !!,0 %!!,1))(
(2 0 '%))(?$%0"
1!! )111&1!A$%?$))(2 ,$%$! '"1 !,) ))))(!2$ ($ '")(%,$(!,! '!(1%(!! 3% ),A$2* (4-500($% (1 12"% ! 1!!%!(*) % ( (2 ) (1!, !,< % !, 0 (! 2
1 !',2* %( (2 %! ( (% )'A$(./-002*%$%0 6 &!2' !2'&%"%),* !% (1!, ", !,"!*2))(1!!(1!,!,
.
'")% !&,!2,))(<%( (", %!',) 3!%(*!,!$%)%))((11 2* ',' $'!(! 1!)!(3$))(!, " "%,?($))( "(!2 1 2(1 1 >A"& ' % ))( ','$ ,* " '! & 2 ),($ !'*)(%!!(','$(!$!,,) ,)(!$!,,) *2*? $11%!) ,),)<(!2 1 2(1 1 ?( %!2' 1 $!'))(&%'*!%!!,,%))( %, 2 1 2(1 1 2*%0(% )) ))(2)%0&!$!", ','%( ()% !
&%))%0 1%!12(1 1 %% !", ,!*(A %0% !(3!,)!(( 2*2'$%! 1!)(1!,#( '%)! 1!)(1!,#()( %(B,!! ! %(A $ 2 ,!* 0 2'%#(*1", !,"!*2%)#( ,)<%!%(1 12"% !($B ! %(B 1! 1 ! (11 % !, ) % *1 ) ! 1!)#(&!,!&3!%))(&"%(%%) (* 12(1 1 8 C2, % 1 0 %! !1 ,* (,!) % ,$!
($B$(1 1$%(!) !"# $ %& '& &! %!2' !
@
D
!
"
#
$%&
'
!
()* +
"
*
+
'
' !
' , !
,
'
'
-,,
',
'
.
'
#
' #
', '
-/
0
'
-
' )
'
1
'
'
,
'
,
,
,
,
6
-
'
',
'
'
' , '
,
,
'
-
" !
"
'
,
'
"
"
,
* +
,
"
2 / % (! )!,,!*)%?( '!$ !2'(&'")% )= (!, !$! 0,!& ! !2! & ! 457-5-41! !()% ! 45/-5-4 ! 2*%0&%0),%!), ", 2' 2*A $% ( $!,'",,2% )#(&)%,1!(% 2"% !!(( 7 (( $,*&% !,," 45 !
8
-657-57&$ (-5&.-5&.68&.6/! .80&! ,( ! % !& ( ! !2! & ! !,, (3!,
( $ !$ %)1& ! %2* 3!% 3! %
%2!)(1 1!' !2"% ! ,, / 0!
!'A1! E%%! ; !A$F
;
E%% !2,F
;