← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7728/2015dismissed

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Raj Kumari And ORS.

2016-05-05Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj9 pages

 

     

    

 

 ! ""

 #



$%& !'

 

"!



  !"# $%&'( #&% (# )%*'

 ( ) #"*' &+!,  - ) **+!,  - '

""

 &+,-,)+./$ '  ""

 - ! ./   

 &"/ !01 !! !23245236" !./) 

&  .+  '.! 7

-

!   8'

  .9: 1'

./ &"

-36+;2+<4<=>11 !- !

'-

&.

*0'& , 

1', .

 0

0  ><>;33?7

-

!8'

-- !0 9: 5 

@"

522A523<'

 . !  !

!'

" @ ./ &''

!

!1 @ ! "

 ! 1  0 52+222=> "

 &' !   !'&'/ & ;222=> !

0'&.

 .

  '

&"

 - 36+;2+<4<=> 1 ! 

&1   !./'

 .-1(>   

  7:  & -'

!

! &.

*0' ;222"

&'

  7: <2B-7:., .

!!

! -

"

"

 ;222C5<22D E<22"

&' 7: 3=<'-7:!

!  !"



F"

 -'

!

! E<22>5322D ;A22"

&' 7,: &"

-

&"

-34 "" ! 7<;E2G35G34:D 35E6522 7,: -  &+, ! --

 322222 7,: 

 F"

 !  !  "  32222 7,: ) ! . 3;654<  36;2<4< A

 !  - '

""

' ' 0 !'

1 !10 !  /+'1 -  . / 00

  '

 

 @ "

 1'

 '

! 1 .

'

!>0'*

!/+'

 .'1 0/ 1 ! -

 "

"

 ./

/0  '

 $!0&    -          

+  

 

1' '

   0  - -

 "

"

  '

 -

& ,

& &"/

<  -  .& -   !   -  '

""

 

 1 0', 1-'

- '

"!

 .

-

 '

  .  !0 '

  

 &"/ ' 1'

" !

!''



@"

!   . / 00

'

" -!

!'- 1!

 !'

   &  - ! ./  

 &"/ ' &.

*0' 1 ' ./ '

 -- !0 ,  1'

 '

 1  '



 

 '

!>0'  '

   ,!

 

 ! ' '

 

 '! @  "

 1'

 '

! '!

 ! '

!>0'   ""

  - & "

 -  ! '

!

 - &

  1' ' 

 @ "

  0,   '

  ' "

 - 

 ' .

 !



.

! 

!>0' &  !" 5;-'

"

'

&

'

!

- $"0 +1'1 0.

8

!>0'9

 '

!'

"'1'"

1'

'



'!@ "

'.

!



.

!./ &

!>0'!& 0./ &''

!

! 1'

"



-

0

!>0'1'

'



@ "

0- ''

/1 , /'

'!@  "

 1'

 '

! 1 . 

 '

 8

! 0'9  '

   ,!

 ' !

! 1 ' ! 00  /&

 . !'



 H>3*

& ' %&  ' .  ! '

 -  ' !

! !! 

 8

! 0'9    '  ! ' 

 @ "

  2?A2"&1'  --  0'

0

/1 '

!--2E22 "& 1, 00--

'

0

./"

!'1'

00  !' -- 0'1

 1'

'



@"

 6  

! "  - & ' '

  . ' 0/ 1 ! !!   &  - '

! 1 ! -

 "

"

   1' &

  !   -  '

""

'

-

!.

,-'

!0  '- '

"

F  -  ! "!     #  #     $ %&' 

+ 1'

  ' .

 .

!-1(>

     !      " 

##$ $ $%&'  %&  $$$ "$  (

) $$%  "       *  # ' + "    # ' "     ##$ $         $" ,+    +) '    # + ' * &     )  '    # +"  &         "    '  (#" -+&.  # '  " # ' 

- /            "$'       -  ' # $%   # " .  # ""  #'  "  ##$ $ +$$$  $# "+%$$'+ ,#   - '#"

  %' -$  0 ; H'  &@0 .,  .

,  1 .

!  " A6-1(>

( &       "  ## $ $ .  (! . 1#         !!  )!

.   *+$ , -.,   $&$ ) 2$  # 3 

 45"  % 6 $1$ .7

89 411

5 :;&.<42  $1$.% #"% 4# "" " 7; 9. 88)7 9411    46-74"9% => %. 7 92228 ? 79411 8 ) +=!+#% 6'6:.:&4#%' / .

79411 )

  ) @@@/ %    "$ +    # .   %#  $&    #   #"+.     *  # '# '"      ## $ $ .         $" ,+     + )  '  7(  # "     -+ &.   # '0 #  +   

# ' 

 -09   

#  + '  *    &       )  '  #  +   .   &         "    '  #&  %  "'    

 $&    .    

' 

        %  

 '  +& $$   

 "    # +&  $  (       "$'     -  '7#$%   # " . 9.  #   # #'  '  # "   "   $# " #  +" ' -$  %%& $#"

 0 4  &

 - 0  - !! 1 ! -

"

 1 0 !  ! ./ '

 "

F     -

   *   /   0 % '

    -         ,     $ %&' 

+  '

 !0   ' - '

 "

F  1' &@0

-

'

.

,'

-   *% 1 '.

!" ?-1(>

8 /    .     * %     /    0!    2 

9  411 ) . #  +'    #  7:4 4&%. A9.    (! 3  7 #$9 

#+-$ &    "

 /   +    B&$

 

 3

 ( %       $% &#"  #&.  & ,# $#  %$    #'    %     " $  .  ,# &"   % +&  "       !   

# &  "$  $'+   %"

   "   .     $%        

" "     + C#' %  $&%  &&

%# .

 &+! "'  "$   $$0 E  '@ -'

.

," 

 3<3E  *4 % 1 '!.

!" 33- '

$!0&    % 1 '-1(>

4.1#  *3  7 #$9 #'       $$        $          (! 3  7 #$9 "$$+      "$'    $    -  & .          &#$      * '

?     %      & /   .       "$'   $    -  & .  .     %"  + )  ' .  "#  +     *   # "        "$#& ##$ $  

 ' #" # +" $'&  -.   '   #  +  *            & &#$  )    ' 0 ?  .,  .

,   -   % 1 '

-1 !./'

!0  ' -# 0

    (1"!  !     %$' %  '5./11   ! 0"

" !@

"0, 1'

- '00  , + '00

& ! !  &"   '

 ,  - "

"  ' !!   &  - '

!   &  ,  

1' &"0&-!

!

/.

1 !

 -  *% 1 '+'

"

F '.

!'    - ,0 --



/  

 '

 . !    -  1' ' .!/  !

/ ! !

!

 - '

!   &  ,  

  -  '

 !  0 / !

.

0

!'

"

F " 36!3; -   *% 1 '+'.

!-1(>

         %& 

  %' 

  +  /    " '  +  $  "  .

  $  ' "$   %& ""  "-"#"   "$'  & - "D"#" '  

 $$ .'$# - 

   &   " 

'  # & " 

        "$'  #   1   4 :%"     & D  #"  % + %  

" "  "  $%   #  &    & $    $%   % + "   $% & #'   "       "$'     "$' $%  %    "    +#     &. + ' #  % "&   '   1

 /5 "$'    :%" #  +  %

8

&#  "#"  &    %  

  &#  #$ 0 32  "

F   ' 0, 

 1'  - '

. 0 '

 1! !1   -   (!  % 1 ' 1' 10 !!   &  - '

!   &  , 

 1 ! ' -

 "

"

   ' @    - '

.

, -  (! % 1 '+1' '1

 ! -  !  "!  % 1 ' ! '

 !

"&  - 1  0,    4  % 1 ' ! -1 !   - #  0  % 1 '.

"

 ! 33  , 1 - &/ .,  ! +   !  . '

&& !

 -1!- 1' 10!! & - '

! 1 ! -

 "

"

 '

 .& &!

 ./  !   -  '

 ""

  '

0 ! '  &

 !  !  !

! 35    I  - &/ .,  ! + '

  ""

1'&

!'

& !& ! 0 /

  &% (# )%*' $@  $%)#