High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/37118/2025allowed

Satpal And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-08-18Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

$ "' !$5+&+" )

$ "' !$5+&+" ) 9=9& 9=9& 9=9& 9=9& /

! "

#$%& F-$ 6$%&9&

! "

#$%&

$ "' %( F-$& ) ) ) ) %$&$ ) %$&$ ) %$&$ ) %$&$ ) :* - :* - :* - :* - * * * * %- ; 9

/ !6"5

$ '"

+" $%&- %- <+&# + =#/ %(

%- +!

% - 4 #" / !6"5

'"% %$& "- A - >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> * * * */ - 2*?

/ - 2*?

%$&$

+" # & 7$$ '+$! 9 !$% $5 "!$ "' %+, ,+ %"5$!9%$/ @ 2'"% &#"%

3%- --:? '"% B9 &#+ = "'

"-.

! 1-1.- / 9 !$% $5 +" & / / .10/ / ./ A @ @ !+

$ "!$/ 01 2'"% &#"% :?/ %$=+&

"+5$

% 4

&97&$B9$

%"5$$!+ = =& %+&+ = #$%$'%", "

&+& "' 5", %",+ +&$C

$! 1@-1 . 2 $D9%$ ?/ 8#+5# +& &

6$ 7$$ $''

$! 7$ 8$$

+$&-

0-1- ./ #$ '""8+ = "% %!$% 8

&&$!) E#$ +" $% #

5#$!

2 $D9%$ ?

+ = #$%$'%", "

$''$5 $! 7$ 8$$

+$&-

+5$ "' ,"

&$$;+ = B9 &#+ = "'

5" &$B9$

&+& "'

%",+&$ # 6+ = 7$$

#+& &

=$/ %- &#+&

5$ " 7$# %(

55$

& "

+5$- +&# +&# "+/ / %(

' "' %$&

$ "'

%- +!

% + =#/ !6"5 %$&

"&- A - #$ & "5

$ # & '+$! 6

'"% ,$ 7$

;$ " %$5"%!-

%$ !+%$5

#$ '

9, "' 5", %",+&$ +

" =$

#$+% &

$,$ & %$5"%!$!

#$ '""8+ = , $%) % &#

% 7$'"%$

2+? #$ +" $% "9%

=+& ( !

=+&

$ '"% %

+" $% & 8$ 9, "' 5",

5$ +& =+&

$ &# !"

$,$ & "'

%",+&$-

"9%

$,$

6+!$" 5" '$%$ 5+ =

"9%

2++?

"' 6+!$" 5" '$%$ 5 7$ !9( +!$ +'+$!

#$+% %$& $5 +6$ 5"9 #$ %$&+!+ = '

2+++? #$ "9 5#""&$ " =$

#%"9=# &",$ ", "9% 8#" 8"9!

&9''+5+$

!+ = +& %$5"%!$!

#%"9= ",,+&&+" $%C!6

$% %$5"%!+ = &

+$& #

! %$5"%!$!

#$+%

#$ &

+$& #

%$& $5 +6$ 5"9 &$

+&'

$% %$5"%!+ =

+ $+ #$% "'

+! , =+&

$ &# &97,+ & %$ &" %$5"%!$!

" 8#$

B9$& +" +& '"9 !

" 7$

$''$5 $! 8+ #"9

#$%$ 7$+ =

$ 5" 5$% $! "

-1- & '+D$! 7( "9%

%$5"%!+ = &

$,$ & "'

& "'

#$ 5",

",+&$- & ! 8#$ ( &95# !$/

"9%

#$ $$!'9 '"% %$5"%!+ =

+$& B9

#$ '

9, "'

7$ "

=+&

" $+ #$% %$5"%!

+$& 7( #(&+5

%"5$&& "% 7( = & !$$,$!

$ 7( =+&

$,$ +& " 7$ %$5"%!$! 7( 8 5+ =/

+$& 5" 5$% $! &#

#%"9=# 6+!$" 5" '$%$ 5+ = 7( 9 &$/ &97G$5

+&'

''+5$%- "9%

=+&

$ , &"

$,$

+$& %$5"%!$!

",,+&&+" $%/

"+ $! 7( = ! 7$ &",$ !6"5

$ # 6+ =

#$ %-

$,$

9=# &",$ ",,+&&+" $%/ &95#

6"5

$ &# '9% +&#

$,$ #$ $''$5

%$! 7$'"%$ #+,C#$% ! #$C&#$ % &

$,$

! 7$$ !9( +!$ +'+$! 7( #$+% $- #+& &# 7$ &97G$5

"9%

=+&

$%/ "9%

&+& "'

$,$

6$ $ " 8#$ #$ 5", %",+&$ +

+! 5", ! # & 7$$ ( ;+ ! "' + '9$ 5$ "% 5"$%5+" -

"9%

%$= %!& #$ '""8+ = '

+ = ''+5$%/ 5" 5$% $!

=+&

$ &#

&" %$

$% &$$;+ = + '"%,

+" '%", !) 2+? H#$ #$%$ +&

+" $%/ %% ($! + #+&

2++? H#$ #$%$ +&

==%+$6$!

( "

+" I 2+++? H#$ 559&$!

''$ !$%I #$ %$ 7$ &97,+

$! 7

$ "' #$ %+ = +-$- -1- .- ( "

559&$! "

+" I ( "

#$% 5",

$!C

#$ %$& &/ %% ($! + !C $! # & 7$$ !$5 %$! %"5 +,$!

7$'"%$ 7$'"%$ #$ $D

$ %$ !+%$5 5"& & + 55"9 "' +=# 255"9

"-0.10@ .@/ "!$) .110/ ;)

$ # !+= %#?- (,$ "' 5"&

#$%$"' &# 7$ 5" !+

$,$ & + #$ , $% !+%$5 " !$ "&+

&9, "' &- 1/111C # "9% * 8($%& H$'

%$ 9 !

#/ "!$)

11.110/ % 5# ; "'

!+ / +=# "9% % 5#/ %"!95 +" "' %$5$+

%$5$!$ '"% %$5"%!+ = "'

$! '"% #$%$+ 7"6$-J - *$ % $! 5"9 &$ '"% $%& # & &97,+

9%&9

+! "%!$% !

$! 0-1- ./

+" $%& # 6$ &" !$ "&+

#$ 5"& &- -- 9%&9

+! "%!$% %/ %$

$! 10-1- . '%",

#$ !!+

#+$' 9!+5+ =+&

$/ 4 & 7$$ %$5$+6$!/ 8#+5# +&

;$ " %$5"

"%!- & #$ %$ #$ %+ "9% & %$5"%!$!

& '""8&) ?

& $% &

$,$ / !$&#/

/ 4 / *

%$&$ #$%$ +& " "

& #$ &

$,$

$!C ==%+$6$!

( "

$,$ / %"5 +,$! "''$ !$%- !?

!$%&+= $! %$5"%!$! &

! "

&+&

$,$ / & %$'$%%$!

#$ 5", %",+&$ +& =$ 9+ $ ,+&%$ %$&$

+" / %

#$% +&

%$ " ( '+6$ 559&$!

$%&" & ,$(

! 9&#+

%% ($!

559&$! +

559&$! + - / #$%$ +& " "

#$% 5",

#$ %$& &- 559&$!

$%&" # 6$ "

7$$ !$5 %$!

+$& 8+ # %$= %!

$,$

7"6$/ 9 !$%&+= $! +& "'

#$ 6+$8

! "

#$ %$&9 ( '% 9! "% #$ %$&9 "' '%$$ 8+ "'

+$&-J

*$ % $! 5"9 &$ '"% %$&

"- A !,+ #$ '

= 5", %",+&$!/ ! &

#$ # & " "7G$5 +" + 5

%"5$$!+ =& &97&$B9$

= + &

%$ B9 &#$!- .- +,+ %(/ $ % $!

$ 5"9 &$ & &

$! " "7G$5 +" + 5

+& B9 &#$! 7 &$! 9 #$ 5", %",+ +&$ 2 $D9%$ ?- 0-

6$ #$ %! $ % $! "9 &$ '"

! # 6$ 5 %$'9( =" $ #%"9=# #$ %$5"%!& "'

#$ 5 &$- - #+& "9%

#$ " :7$ $D "9% & %$

$!( !$

8+ #$ +&&9 9$ "' $D$%5+&$ "' G9%+&!+5 +" 9 !$% $5 #$ "!$ B9 %"5$$ $!+ = + " 5", "9 !

7$ "''$ $ 5$& + #$ 5 &$& "' + + =# + + =# + + =# + + =# # # # # 6&-

$ "'

6&-

$ "'

6&-

$ "'

6&-

$ "'

' 9 G #$%/ 1 21?

1 1 1 1/ 498+ !$% + =# A 498+ !$% + =# A 498+ !$% + =# A 498+ !$% + =# A #$%& 6&-

#$%& 6&-

$ "' 9 G 7 A #$%/ 11

$ "' 9 G 7 A #$%/ 11 2? 2%+,+ ? 1.

2? 2%+,+ ? 1.

, "

#$% 6&-

$ "'

#$% 6&-

$ "'

#$% 6&-

$ "'

#$% 6&-

$ "'

!#( % !$&#/ 2 ? ---

!#( % !$&#/ 2 ? --- - - - - 2%+,+ ? 2%+,+ ? 2%+,+ ? 2%+,+ ?

2%+,+

"- @

2%+,+

"- @

2%+,+

"- @

2%+,+

"- @ @ "'

1 !$5+!$! "

@ # "'

@ "'

1 !$5+!$! "

@ # "'

@ "'

1 !$5+!$! "

@ # "'

@ "'

1 !$5+!$! "

@ # "'

' ' ' '

$,7$%/

?- #$ "&+

$,$%=$& '%", !$5+&+" & %$ !$%$! 7( #$ " :7$ $D "9 9%

+&) ?

"8$% 9C& %--- 6 8+!$% ! +& 9 $! 7( 27?

"8$6$%/ 8+!$% "8$ 25?

#$ 9 !$%+ + = %+ 5+

7$ + 6";$ %$5"= +K+ = 5",

$%& 8#+5# %$ "6$%8# 5+6+ 5# $% +;$ 5",, "' ,

%+," + %$

+" &#+ 2!?

#$ & "8$% +& "

" 7 + 6"6+ = #$+ "9& !$ ( "% "''$ 5$& +;

$! 8+ #+& "9% +& ,95# 7( $5 +" 1 "'

#$ "!$- $% =%$

#$ 5 $ 8#+$ $D$%5+&+ = &95# "8$% +& " B9 $ 7$ 8$$

+$& + #$,+ =( %$!",+

( "'

,$%5+

+" & "% %+&+ = "9

#+ "% '

,+( !+& $&- 7$ $D$%5+&$! + %"&$59 +" & &$%+"9& "''$ 5$& "' ,$

;$ ,9%!$%/ %

$/ !

5"+ ( $ 5-

&95# "''$ 5$& %$ "

%+6 +,

" &"5+$ (- 2$?

$5 %--- 5

!6 5$ + $%$& "' G9& +5$

#+& !9 ( 5 $! 9 #$!

#$ +=# "9%

9 !$% $5 +" 1 ,$%$

#$%$"'- +=# "9% &9&

+ $!/ 8#$ #$% &95# +

#$ 7"!(C

9%$ "

2'?

95# $D$%5+&$

#$ #

$%,+&&+7$ " ( + 6$& +=

! 5# %=$ !9%+ = - 95# $D$% 8#+$ #$ ,

$% +& & + 9 2=?

H#+$ B9 &#+ = + "

8#+5# %$ "'

%+6

$ +

5" &+!$%

$5$!$ & "'

559&$!

! 8#$ #$% #$ & ,

=$!

#$ 5",

$ +

9%$ ! # 6$ &$%+"9&

& !9 ( 9 #$ +=# "9%

5$ & 8$-

+& + %$5"= + #$ +=# "9%

$D "9%

8"9! "

%$'9&$ " B9 &# $( 7$5 9&$ '+ !& ,$

&&$&&

9%$ "' + G9%+$& + G9%+$& + '+5 $! " 6+

C!$+5

"' 8$

" & 9&$! $ 5-

!& "' +=# "9% 8"9! 7$

#$ $6+!$ 5$ +& 5"$5 $&#$$ +& '+$!C5# %=$& '% ,$!

$%5+&$ 5 7$ 5 %%+$! "9

!$% + 6$& +=

" 5", "9 !

7$ "''$ 5$& $6$

9%$/ +=# "9% +& %$B9+%$!

559&$!/ 5" !95 7&5" !+ = "% 8#$ #$% #$

" $ $% + %",+&$- #$ &

"%( %"6+&+" "' $5 +" .

"' / +& &

"%( %"6+&+" "' $5 ' %- -- #$%$'"%$/ 7"6$ %+ 5+ $& "'

8 8"9!

+" 9 !$% $5 +" .

"' /

& 8$ - #9&/ ;$$ + = + 6+$8 '"

%$& +! '

! 5+%59,&

5$&/

#+& "9% +& & "'

#$ 5" &+!$%$! "

+ +"

+& '+ " $D$%5+&$ G9%+&!+5 +" 6 $! 9C& "' %- -- " B9 &) 2+?

+ = B9+$ 9&

B9++ ," =&

+$ 9&$ "' &97&

G9& +5 2++?

#$ "''$ 5$& $=$!

2+++?

6$ 5", %", 2+6?

& #$ %$ %$5$+6$ 6"9

%( + +

9%$L 26?

C6+5 +, +& % %",+&$ " #+& "8 6

%"5$$!+ =& 8+ 7%+ = 5$ $& A 8+ 55"%!+ =( '9% 5$L

%+, %+( "'

%+6

9%$L ,+&$!L #$ 5", %",+&$ +& & " 7$ %$ " # 6$ $ $%$! + 6"+

" &$B9$ (/ +" +&

"8$!- "-.

1-1.- / 9 9 !$% $5 +" & / / .10/ / ./ A @ "'

/ %$=+&

"+5$

+" % 4

5" &$B9$

%+&+ = $'%", "

#$ 7 &+& "' 5", %", ,+&$C

$! 1@-1 2 $D9%$ ?/ %$/ #$%$7(/ B9 &#$! B9

+" $%&- 1- $ !+ =

+" 2&?/ +'

(/ &#

&" &

! !+& "&$! "'- 9=9& 9=9& 9=9& 9=9& /

6+% H#$ #$% & H#$ #$% %$

+ =C%$ &" $!) $&C 2 * * * *?

7$) $&C