Shri Vishnu Processors v. Union Of India And Others

   
   
  

  

      ! "#
  ! "
   ! "
#" $%&%'(

$")'(*)')+)', $")',%%-)'&)./,01)(%&

$(*%-%(2(2'%$

$"3'2&*2',.2&*/,01)(% $(*%$%&-',%'(&  $ %% &'&!($' *%  4$2(  -%(2(2'  2&  2.%,  &%%52'6  73)&*2'6    -)'1*')+)/ +%+,)(%, 8

)', $,2$%1(2'((*%$%&-',%'(&($%(3$')..(*% ,13+%'(&)',$%1$,&%29%,' 8

 *%  :$2% )1(&  )$%  (*)(  

21%$&   2$%1($    %0%'3% '(%..26%'1%;

$&*$(/  <1',31(%,)&%)$1*' 8

2'(*% )1($= -$%+2&%& (*%-%(2(2'%$*%&%)$1*4)&2'1''%1(2'42(*2'0%&(26)(2' 62'6' $)0)2.2'62'%.262:.%,$)4:)15)',":=4)= )113+3.)(2'6 
 :=  -$13$2'6  )5%  -3$1*)&%  :2..&  :=  >&  $.,42,%  $),%.2'5&/ !3,*2)'))', >& ?'2( ):$20)(%!2+2(%,/!3,*2)')*%-%(2(2'%$ *),&3--.2%,+)(%$2).(&)2,,%).%$& 3$2'6&%)$1*/$%1$,4)&&%29%,)', -)'1*')+)-$%-)$%,

 ' 



/ ..42'6$,%$4)&-)&&%, @(21% +(2' '  (*%  )&52'6    (*% 
3$(/  $  "3'2&*  2',.2&*/ )11%-(&'(21%':%*).

(*%$%&-',%'(& !%)$'%,13'&%. $(*%-%(2(2'%$&()(%&(*)(-3$&3)'( ((*%.)&($,%$(*%-%(2(2'%$*),)--$)1*%,(*%1'1%$'%, '(%..26%'1%

21%$4*%$%2'-*(1-2%& 2.%& (

4%$%*)',%,0%$((*%$%-$%&%'()(20% (*%-%(2(2'%$:3() 1-= (*%*)$,,2&54*21*2&(*%%.%1($'21$%1$,4)&'( *)',%,0%$)&)$%&3.( 4*21*(*%-%(2(2'%$2&*)',21)--%,

$+)52'62(&)''3).)113'(& $%0%$/*%*)&&3:+2((%, (*)()&$%6)$,&(*%1A-%$)(2' $(*% $%'&21%B)+2')(2'

 (*%*)$,,2&5)&-%12 2%,(2+%:% 2B%,
3'&%. $(*%$%&-',%'(&*)&).&0%$= )2$.=&()(%, (*)((*%$%-$%&%'()(20% (*%-%(2(2'%$&*3., )((%',(*% 1'1%$'%,

21%,3$2'6

21%*3$&'(*% (* )',

(* 

1(:%$/  

 )',  (*%  ,%-)$(+%'(  42..  )$$)'6%  (*)(  (*% $%'&21B-%$(43.,).&:%)0)2.):.%)((*)((2+%)',2' 1)&%(*%$%-$%&%'()(20% (*%-%(2(2'%$)--%)$&)&&()(%, ):0%)1-= (*%*)$,,2&543.,:%+),%)0)2.):.%(*2+ '  (*%  1'1.3&2'    (*%  $%'&21  %B)+2')(2'  '





C (2&'(,2&-3(%,(*)(1-2%& &%29%,,13+%'(&)',$%1$, *)0%:%%'620%'((*%-%(2(2'%$)',(*%6$2%0)'1%'.'6%$&3$020%& *%1'(%'(2' .%)$'%,13'&%. $(*%-%(2(2'%$2&(*)( -)'1*')+)&*3.,:%73)&*%,)&

*),'D3$2&,21(2'(

E 1',31(&%)$1*)((*%-$%+2&%& (*%-%(2(2'%$)&*%2&'()'%B-$(%$*% )$63+%'(2&(*)(2'0%&(26)(2'2&42(*$%6)$,(!3,*2)'),%).%$)',2'1)&%  )'=,3:($,2&-3(%2(4)&'.=(*%

,&F"%$021%)B

%-)$(+%'(4*13.,*)0%-$1%%,%, 3$(*%$2'(*%+)((%$& )$)&(*% -%(2(2'%$2&1'1%$'%,(2& 3$(*%$)$63%,(*)((*%$%2&)6$2%0)'1%42(* $%6)$,(+%'(2'2'6(*%1'(%'(&2'(*%-)'1*')+)/73(%,:%.4 @':%2'6)&5%,:=(*% 

21%$&"*?)')0?*)'')(.,



21%$&2' $'( 3&(*%-)'1*)&(*)(*%*)&&., 5'2((%,A&*2$(&>&*2$(& '.=(  >& $.,42,%$),%.2'5&/ !3,*2)'),3$2'6(*%=%)$ GA

)', >& ?'2( ):

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

(*%
3&(+&1(/

H$%),&)&3',%$ @

  )      #*A  ;

<    (*%  &&2&()'(
++2&&2'%$ 
3&(+&/$2')'=)$%)),D2'2'6(*%.)',

$'(2%$ (*%1)&( ',2))'

21%$ 13&(+&&-%12)..= %+-4%$%,:=')+%2'(*2&:%*).

:=(*%)$,/*)&$%)&'

I (  :%.2%0%  (*)(  )'=  6,&  .2):.%  (  1' 2&1)(2'/  $  )'= ,13+%'(&$(*2'6&4*21*2'*2&-2'2'42..:%3&% 3. $$ $%.%0)'(()'=-$1%%,2'63',%$(*2&1(/)$%&%1$%(%,2')'= -.)1%/*%+)=)3(*$2&%)'=

21%$ 13&(+&(&%)$1*$ +)=*2+&%.

&%)$1* $&31*6,&/,13+%'(&$(*2'6& ;<*%-$02&2'& (*%
,% 
$2+2').$1%,3$%/ ;  G</$%.)(2'6(&%)$1*%&&*)../& )$)&+)=:%/)--.= (&%)$1*%&3',%$(*2&&%1(2'&3:D%1(((*%+,2 21)(2'(*)( &3:A&%1(2'; < "%1(2' H  (*%&)2,
,%&*)..*)0% %

%1()&2 $(*%4$,@ )62&($)(%C/4*%$%0%$2(113$&/(*% 4$,&  @$2'12-). 
++2&&2'%$   
3&(+&  $
++2&&2'%$ 
3&(+&C4%$%&3:&(2(3(%,C *%&%1(2'2&42,%.=4$,%,)',&%)$1*1)':%1',31(%,2

(*%&&2&()'($ %-3(=
++2&&2'%$ 
3&(+&*)&$%)&'&(:%.2%0% (*)((*%$%)$%)'=,13+%'($(*2'64*21*2'*2&-2'2'42..:%3&% 3.$ $%.%0)'(()'=-$1%%,2'6&3',%$(*2&1($&%1$%(%,)()'=-.)1%*% &%1(2',%&'($%&($21((*%&%)$1*'.=42(*$%6)$,(2+-$(%$$%B-$(%$/ (*%   (*%$  -$%+2&%&  1)'  ).&   :%  &%)$1*%,  *%  -%(2(2'%$  4)&  ) &3--.2%$>&%..%$((*%%B-$(%$&)(!3,*2)')/(*%$%4)&)'2'0%&(26)(2'(*)( 2'%.262:.%,$)4:)15 %(1*), :%%' 1.)2+%, :=-$13$2'6 '.=(*%:2..& 42(*3((*%$%:%2'6($)'& %$ 6,&/(*2& %&():.2&*%&(*%$%.%0)'1%

&%)$1*42(*-$1%%,2'6&3',%$(*%1( *%)$63+%'((*)((*%1'(%'(&73(%,):0%4%$%),,%,:= (*%

 (*%2$4'/2&),2&-3(%,73%&(2' )1(*% -%(2(2'%$*),4$2((%'.%((%$&()(2'6(*)((*%$%2&)+2&()5%2'-)'1*')+)2' $%1$,2'6(*%1'(%'(&)',&)+%+)=:%$%1(2 2%,*%&)2,)&-%1(1)''(:%

  6'%2'()((*2&&()6%)',43.,'(:%)$%)&'(73)&*(*%-)'1*')+)$ (,%1.)$%(*%&%)$1*2..%6).*%2&&3% %02,%'(2)$=0).3% (*%1'(%'(& 1)':%$)2&%,:=(*%-%(2(2'%$)((*%)--$-$2)(%&()6% *%4$2(-%(2(2'2&,2&+2&&%, +$ %% &'&!($,+$'$-.%$"!, ' (%' (%

)$1* / +5 *%(*%$&-%)52'6>$%)&'%,

%&> *%(*%$$%-$():.%

%&>