← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6747/2016dismissed

New India Assurance Company Ltd v. Ishabbir Singh And ORS

2016-12-23Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal17 pages

      

!" "#$%$&' ( 

 ")&*$ %%+, &#"-. &/0!*1 .."22 &!

3% %4 55$,6$&74 &*!4",% "%.&*"&!% '



    

         



  

 ( 89

     !

"

! #     

$ % &'(

 !

    )* )" +) ,   

  .-( /( 0  1 .-(12 $+% 3    



   4

,,  5 

6**

0  1 12 #( # # +"+* ) +)  ## 8/(   /(       4 3( 4

 4# 4  &(   #      /(  !

 ! #   

    !

   ##  (/ #    -/  (  ( :(

&( 4 3( 4

 4# 4  ( :(

   (  :(!

 ( :(  

   -(

 7;

         <(   $7%





+      '

# # 



4 !



 7     ( #( $=%    # -    # (&  

       



       



!"!#      $ 

(     

 % &

' 

      $  (

)   *    ) *% & + #  $  *      

 , ))     

 % & + # +

).

$;% 3       (  

$,%    .-( (  <( /  (  ## # #  '(

 + #!

 (   -!

# 

 ,)"*,))& (   



> (

 7  (  #   



# #   ( !

#  ?@  (

+ )7 +)    (

)7 +) ,





(   <(  <( /  (# !

 ( !

#! .-(   ( ( (

 + #  " ;A  (   #    B  (   #     :!

!

- !

.       - 

$"% &'(

 !

 #  #( ## <((  ((  $*% '

   (   $6% C (    #(  ?@ D&= D&="

#    (#  -!

!

!

 / /    <( ( (  ## :(    

D&

': 4#    

( #    #   ( ( -(!

##   .-(  # ((    ( *)A   -!

 #!



))A   -!

(  -# !

  #!

 -(    

 ,)))& -(   ;)A  ((  !

( $ )% C (  !# ( ( -

:

 B   

    !"   #  $

% &!#& '2 

  !"

 #$  #& '(     -  C# 3   (  ((  ! $

% C ( (  !   - (

 +*7=,))& (  -  # @ 3( E '(    (

6 )+;;&  !

  (  (   (  @( (   ':(    @  !

    5   @   (!

    (  (  :(      C (  B !

 -  <(  :( $ +% C (  ## .-(   @  ((     (( !!  (#    C (   ((      (  - 

 $ 7% C (  (  ) $ *&  !  ! +,,- .+-/'(0

&  $  #  &  +,.1    .+21  '(0 &&3  $

4  3&   +,.2    .+1-  '( $  $

!  +,.2'5(  %  /25  '%6(   ((  & !    - $ =% C (   ( :(#  E1- @

  

  #  $ &&& 6  $!! -7258+,.7 ' 4 8%'$( .51.+9+,.1(    (    !

  5 

$ ;% '

  (-    (     $ ,% E#  (   



:&  #  &   $

:;   +,.1    .5,1  '( E1- @

  ((   /#   ( -  .  # 

 $ )!

<  +,.2 .-/2'( ? (#   -  C# 3 -(

(  

:&#&  

    0(2   - ! !

   

   !

(- @  # ((  (

$ "%   ( .-(  ( -(!

## !

  #  #   !

( #   4

,,  5   ( !

( 3#  #  !

?     <(  #   -     #( /  <(   # :(  $ *% ?@  D&7 D&= D&, (!

# ( - '## F  # D&=  



# #   ##  &@  '## F     --!

 /  (  ## # 



4 #  (

;

&@ #    D&7 D&= ( !

 (      #    



     -@   #!

/ #   (  &(   ( ( :(  

  ( .-(   ( -(!

## $ 6% +7 ! #      +;

      (    !

  

 +))))&   G ( *)A   -!

( 

:<  $ :"<   +,.. %4   -!

  -!

 

))A

-  !

 (   -!

  !

( / (  / /    !

! E  ( #    / (  ((  $+)%

:(!    &

?@ #   B     ( @

0+2 C #  #  :( (  #    - :( .  (& # (#     (( # (   -!

((  @

0=2

&(!

 # #  #   <(    (# (  <( :(

0;2 C    (# 

#  0,2 C @    # #!



$+ % $#=#$) >#

  !"

 #+,..'5(  '$(/.? EH- @

 #        -!

:(

$++%

< 

&) >#

  !"

 ##& +,.1'.(  '$(1.+ EH- @

   -! :(  #    -!

  # !

    # !

- (          #( / !  - ! !

 / ( -( (        -:  .  # !

 (  - (   ( ( (  :( /#  (# :(  $+7%

  3  $   !   !   ! #+,.1'1(  '$(7-7  ( EH- @

  :(  <( -B '  -   <(- 

-  ( 

     -!

 # ! -            -!

  # !

$+=%

  $# &@

&># ")   $ #& +,.1'1(  '$(-15 EH- @

 #( :( :(  # ( ( :(! # :(   <(      / @ (   (# B ((  @  B   #   (# (      #  @   (( #   EH- @

 (

 +) +)  $+;%

3&    )    



 !"# +,.1'1(  '$(--7 EH- @

7)A -!

    (   -!

( 

))A ( -!

C  (  /#  #   # +   .-( @



 =+;) 

$+,%



!  & &

) ># 

  !"+,.1'5(> #'(15++   EH- @

  -!

(  (  -   (!

 #     (  (    

    ! . 

))A # !

 E#

# ")A    ( @

  (

   (# (     (

 +         (

    @    #   #!

$+"%

=#$  <   )  &  *$ 4 

  !"# #&  +,.,'5(  '$(.22  EH- @

##    -  # G #  #  :(  :( (      :(!

( ( -/ :(  -     :(!

  / 

( -   <((    ((      $+*% .-(  #!

  (   ((  (   -!

 # !

  :( # (  .-( ( (# (

(   -

 +=,* ="&    E   (

6 )+;;&  '(

 !

 #  (  #( ( (  @( >(!   (

6 )+;;&  '(

 !

  !



$+6% <(     (   !

<( (   I

.-(   (  @   !

  -  :  <   =#$  $  A#  # &   +,.2'1(  %  +..  '%6( ?   ( !

 E  !

 -  !

!    (   (  (     5  $7)%

      

     #  0(2 E1- @

# 4 

( +)),   E! J   #    !

@&# 

   #   !     

(  !

J   !  !

 ! ( (  ( <( !

      !   ( #      !     !  !    # 7;

!  

+ !

@  ! -  #

$7 % ( !

 -    !

  # #(       ! @  (    -  !

     E    (      #  !

4( (!

# (   &   (  ( ( (      (  ( #    !

 '(   #   #   ( ( &  ! :(!

    

:

$7+% ' (!

#      5    (  - -  ( !

     (!

# (#    (!

 #        (    ( -  4 !

 !

 !

    -(        <(  (  !

. ( (!

# (   &      (     ( - !

(   -( (     (!   ( (!

# -  !

( E   ! (   ! # :(!

  # (   (  # (  !

-  ( -(   !

C '(    ( !

   /   -  :(  $77%    E1- @

    ;  #  &   $  & &     #  !  ! #& .--/ '(1.-.

  ( C '( !

 (  (# !-  5 

$7=%

>  #  

     #   $

&&3;&  3&< &#  'B !!  ++718+,.5>&$!!  ?,278+,.5 B !! ++718+,.5( G 3 J(: E#

     :(   (#   

  ( (   .-( #  (   G 3 ( E1- @

4C

 ,,

+) ;     

6 ) +) ;

$7;% :  <   =#$ 0(2K  

  # $  <!

#& +,.5

.15+ 

  # $ : +,..'.,(  257'< (       :(  #  (  

  .-(

$7,% !

  

  



  # ' !

(  @&#     #(   !

  !   #   @( -: #  !

$7"%   ( '

    (  .-( .  #!

  G - +7 +) ,

 6  

  D /# L 

 D - L