Gurgaon One Residents Welfare Asso. v. State Of Haryana & ORS

CWP-18679 9-2010 (O&M) & connected matte ers -1-










 
 




 '&(
)*+,(-
-.

/01

  &



      





   

    

 

 '&(
*3,(-
).

/01

  

 4&





  

 4


!
"#

 
 

    

 4&





  

 4



$
 %&   
 

 4&



  

 4



-2-

! "# $
%&





'
(()

"%&%*&+ $
%&
'
( ()

,-%.$ $
%&




'
( ()


   

 

     

  
'

 /0

(
 1
10
 2

 1


 /0

(
 1
13










44444

&

5 0 % 6#  .   1 0& # 0##    

2

. '&(
)*+,(-
-1 0  2#  .   1 07 

8 #    

22 (2

. '0(
-!!*('&(-
, '0(
-!!+('&(-
,1 Mr. Vikas Dhawan, Senior Advocate, (arguing counsel through V.C.) with Mr. Ajiteshwar Singh, Advocate (arguing counsel) for the petitioners (in CWP-1538-2019).

Mr. Lokendra Singh, Advocate, for the petitioners (in CWP-20989-2018).

Mr. Manuj Kaushik, Advocate, Mr. Tarsem Rana, Advocate, for DHBVN/respondent (in CWP-18679-2010).

Mr. Deepak Balyan, Advocate, for respondent-M.C., Gurgaon.

Mr. Deepak Sabherwal, Addl. A.G., Haryana, for respondent-HSVP.

Mr. Ankur Mittal, Senior Advocate, with Ms. Kushaldeep Kaur, Advocate, Ms. Sharvi DAdwal, Advocate, for respondent No.3-HSIIDC.

Mr. Satya Pal Jain, Addl. Solicitor General of India, (arguing counsel) Mr. Dheeraj Jain, Senior Advocate (arging counsel) with Mr. Akash Vashisth, Advocate, for respondent-UOI.

***** SHEEL NAGU, C.J.

1.

This order judgment shall dispose of four petitions i.e. '&(

-3-
)*+,(-
- '&(
*3,(-
) '&(
3!)(-
,   '&(-,),(-
)  

  

 9    :       # #     

;  

 7 8

 '&(
)*+,(-
-

2. 

2 .'&(
)*+,(-
-1 # 8 ::

 2 # %   '   * :  + 

'

  72

(



             =   2

#  

  #

2 = #   :

7  ,--

 

#  ;  

  > 2   

8    

 ! ;     

    #

 2       2  7  :5( .1 ;   :

  0   

  

 

2 #   8  > 

 
,-!?& %7

  '

   

    > #  2

 
,*!?   > #  2



   7    
,+3     7 > #  2

 .& #  <

1

 
,+,   

 22    

#    8

2    

8 

  

2 = #   :

7   ,--0  

#  @;  

  > 2A   8    <

: 2 :



    

: 7  :   :



   #     7

  7   

 2 7 :      2

 7



22

    

       2  :

 2

      

> 

 B   CD2  & 2  &   C 22  # #   
$ 
 

'

   E> .1    

22 2 :    :



-4-   F7  '   

8  

      

  $ ' 

   

2 D % 

2 D'  

   
)
-$#

  
 

  

   7 '# 22    '# 22  E *-+,  -
+ '# 22  E *-+
  -
+ '# 22  E *-*+  -
+ '# 22  E *-*,  -
+ '# E *-)- -
+'#22 E *-)*(*-), -
+'#22  E *-+-  -
+ '# 22  E *-+$(*-+3  -
+   '# 22  E ,-
$ -
+7

   $


      7  

 2 D '   

 :

    

 %

G   2  7   '    

  

   

 :   7 2    #  7    

    # 7

 :

   ,--

  2  :         !
-

,)!   G !  

 8 > 


,-!. 7 #H


,-!F1 2 7 D 

 $

D' 7

 

   
)
-$ 

 

# 2 8 :

  G! 


,-!    !
-

,)!

              #   8 

 2    :

# 

9  

   !
-

,)!:8 2 7    2   ! $

 

7

 #

  

 7      G! 


,-!<

'#22   

D' :

 :

  :  5( @.1

2

%

 

 '    .71

2

   ! 


,-!  !
-

,)!

2

 

79

-5- .1

 7 #  9   

      

   7  2 !
-3-3 1

 '

  #

 :  7   7    27      ! 


,-!:

7 # 

:

     

   

  27 

1 E    :  7  8

 7 

 

 



7 

  !
-

,)!  ! 


,-! 1     

 ) 



   1

 

   2 

       :



 

     ! 


,-!A 3   2   

7 # 22 

D'   

#  

    *

 ' 

9    0  & 6  

   

   :

   

   

   

   :

H

# F +

# : 

7 #  7#  

   #  

  7

   

D'  


 .21 )

 2 D '      

 

    8 2   

'

 #

 )
      

      7

      # #  7

  

 

8    

         


,-!    

 #  

2

.1

2 .1 



-6-     , 

  2 . )52
 ) 2
  
.&$
  2


   2   :   

  2

D'  
)
-$

  
 

         

 '#  E *-+,  -
+   

 

  '# 22    22      2  

 
-  2

  22 .1    '0(
)))$('&(-
)  '0(
-!!*('&(-
,  2    (SHEEL NAGU) CHIEF JUSTICE (SANJIV BERRY) JUDGE 13.05.2026 Ajay Prasher Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes / No Whether reportable :

Yes / No