← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaVATAP/15/2023dismissed

Excise And Taxation Commissioner v. M/S Samriti Products Private Limited

2024-01-08Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Lapita Banerji3 pages

  



   

      

 !"# 

 

 



    





! "

  %

 !"# 

 

 



  #



 



! "

 $

%&'&()&)*  &  '( ) *)*)* +(   '(*) *(  



% !

 !+

,# -





, - +"!

/ 0 + 1 !2

+

+.

!

  3(43)&)5  )*)*!",!-!.

!/)0!. ( !

 0 !



! # -

   

 /

 )7&')&(8

 &(&')&(8 6!! /  /-47&348)

-6!!+ 

 

+

/!

! 0

 0

 .

 

- )





 3(9(893::3)&)5   3(43)&)5 

&(&')&(86  .. !



  

 (5&8)&(8

 !

 / .  /- (5(()&(8   



 6

;

 . /-



.

! 

 

&4())&(8 !

 0!

.  ! 0 "/

6!!6 0

&(&()&)&6!!6 0

/ .. !



 

.!< 

)&&*)&)( 

3(8



 !





 

..+ !6 ;!

 

!.

+  

/.  3/ ; !

 /  

!         





 

# $

  5 :







 &'&4)&)5



06 ! ..

! 

=.. ! !

6 / .

))&')&)5

!



!

- .)

! !   .6 

 

 !/ ;/  !

! .>-

  !

-



!

)&

- !  !

 0 ! / . . 

 6!! 

 )'&))&))



!

/ 0

!

6

-..

 !

/ 

.  )'&))&))  ! .

 ))&')&)5 6!!  .



.(?-  !+   

-    .

  . !



!  ! .. !

/

 /- ! *1!1234 ) )#5)*!6,! !0!



%*  * !    !



  

,

 



/



..

0.



  . 

 "

 

 /   

! @ 0

!      44 72 34 1,2 , 24 351 !5120 220!. !" 31,205 85) ( 9 2"

! "

! (1") !" !31,20/     *   6! +  6 0 !

/ 

%3 A() :

 



! 

 

  6 6



6 ! !

  !/ 

.

; 0 !

/-6 - ..  



! !- 

  

!- !

 

 

. 

 6! $ 

 6     6 !  

 

 .

  6 !    0 :

/  .  /



/ 

+ 6 <

6!- -

/

!

 --/ 

!,

 

6 !,

 

  -/.

 !

0!6



  !.



.

-6! !6

 0  00  /

 

  ; . /

. +  /



!

/

@ +6 6

! .

 

+ ! $ 

 

;

0

    

 !  



. 

  ! -

! / 



 0- . ; 0 



 6 ! 

 !

 0 / 0 

 / !  6 



/ -/

 -/

-  !,

 

(5:



6+  !0!



  !0

 

/

+ ! 0 



 

  !-!



/



/



# $

 

-

! 6  /

.  ..

+ ! 



 !  

! . 6  ;  

0 .

    

!-  

 / 0 .   

  !   ! 0

 

 

 

  /0

  

!- .

 !

 6 ! 0 

   

 

- 

 

!



/



/ . 0

 

 

 ! 6!  -



! 0!

!



/6 / .  .6 

 ! .

! 6

   

..  /- ! $ 

 .

-   

 

+



+ !$ 

!

 /-.



0

- 

/

0

 

 ..

 

 !  !0 -  0-+

 /



!0

-B *  -+ 3(9(4&3::3)&)5   3(93)&)5+  /- ! # -

 /

 )7&')&(8 6  

.. 

 (8&8)&(8

 6

 / .  /- (4(()&(8 !



6! !

- 

0 ! 0 "/



!

0





 .



3(8

+  

/.  !

  ..

&'&4)&)5 6!  6  .

 ))&')&)5

!.

 .. .   . - . ; .

0 +

   3(43)&)5 9  0-+ ; 0  6 /

+  / 

- ..

 !

0/ 

+6

6!





6!! 

-/  /-

3(9(893::3 )&)5     3(43)&)5  3(9(4&3::3)&)5     3(93)&)5 !/-   0-+ !

<

.. 



 /

;

 



 

!   

 

+.

-+  

  . )*)* +(   !:!0;<1,/ = (    !"   C! ! ; 0

% D  C! !"

/%  1