High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/942/2014disposed of

Dilber Singh v. Manpreet Singh @ Manni & ORS

2016-07-12Mr. Justice Arun Palli18 pages

!"#$%$&#'

(#) *+$$&#+( ,)

!"!

# !

($) *++$&#+ "% &" !

!"!

# !

'$( )*+,-$./01'-,$0012) 3!( 2"4

5 45

! !

65 45

75 45

891!"4'6 : ;;;

0 $ !<

= >" 6!

" !< , - .% !7

! 56 "

7! 7!

44'6!0"5

5 !! ? @

8546 !@ @

5 !46

!! " ! 44 % 48 8

46 !7 "4 AA B 4!45

@@ 1

! 467 7!

>" !44C

46! !% 46 46 ! 7 : 0"5 )7

5 "!

! 8!

! ?

! !7! 7!5 :! 7 ! :5 "

:! 5D4

D 4 4! 44

4 ! !!

!57 7! 4 !7 4 64:47 4 >"9 46 4!7 5 4

!3+9 99 8E0 !7"47 7

*+$$&#+ 8 4!5!% 6 7 0"5

8 8

5 7

!44!5447

5 7! 64:4 !3+9 998 5

:)7

946 !

! 6

= 64:44 +">5 "A(8 65 !

!! " 4

7! !

!5!

65 :

!% 64:4 + )7

7 )7

" ": !

!! 4 >"!7!% !

D:5

5 34& 6

44 '6! 0"5

5 !% 46 ! $!? 4!5 7 @F! "

5 "6 17!! 7!7% !"5 " 4! 2040: 4!52 52 57!! 44 : 6 5 :

46 $!

G9 6 89

46 ! $!?

G9 )7

/ 4 !!" 65 7 !45 !!

! 5

> 7 !6

% "!"

6:>4!7 6:54"!9!4

" : 46 7 46

5!! ! 4 17! " !4! !

7 44! 7 :5"

:4!5 7! 44 44 ? !"4 46 :5 !

8 5 7

6 47!!"5 ! 7!6!%

"!" 6:>4!54" !

4 445 4 "! ! 6!

!"4 4:4 6!5 46 :! 4"6 44 !% 46 A 7 !!"!7 6 : 0"(9 =

>"!

448 8

"A8 3

+">50 !& 6"!

43+9 99 8E :

= 43+9 99 8E7!

4 4! 6

44 !67! 7 ": " 64<3$ 8 = 46 ! 9>

4!!: !"6 75 !" 43+9 99 8E<3$ = 46 ! 6 6 ! 6<3$ ? = 6" 46 ! 46 ! 46! 67 6<3 A $ I

946 6! !

7!!D!

'= " D6

!'= 36

!'=8 !

!: 4" 4 !"4 4:54 4 : 44

4 4 : !4 4 45:7: 4"6: 4 !"446 :! 4 7

4 !4 4 4 @

! 45 0" " 4 !

45 : 445 57 4 !"4 :

7 : !

! J"4:GJ"4: 46 ! 7 46! 7!! 46! !7

!!7 %! :: !'" ! ! 46 ! :

5 !! ! 36

45 '

7)!

"! )65 57 ! !64"6: 45 0" "

46 " 4" 6" "

)7! !4 @

4:457 D " !6

$! ?5

G90 644 :6 $! ?5

G9 7!! : 457 !!6:7! "!

" 4!!9D6

G9 !67! "7 : !57 4

44!J":5! !4"D !!

4" 64 65 7! $! ?5

G9 !

46 !"

46 " 4"

6" 66 !

! :!5 7!

746 ! $!

G9" !"

44" :6: 7 6 !" ! 4"4 : 5 7! 46 ! $!?

G95:7: !! 46 $!8

G97!744" !

D !!$!?

G9 !

4 "!5!"6 $!A@5

G97!7

!46 !544" 4" !"

4"!

445 !"

5!!

D !! 7" 4"!

4!5 4" 4 6!"4 6

44 !

" 4: " 5 !

!7 >:! : : 46 !5 7 !

8 "6 : !"5!

1! # E?F "6 7! ! 7

46 !6"5" 6 46 K :6

8 2"4

54"!

5 " !'" !:5 0" 7 : !!!! !! 46

:$!?

G957 !

4": 6" 7% "6 !! 44" 4"5 467! ! 7 ! "!%" :

5 !$!

G9 6 !

" 7!!! 46

5 :6% !! $! A5

G9$!

!46 !" ) " !"6 !"

5 !6 "6 445 5 4 : 5

!:4 4

4 7%5$!

G97!7 :

J"46 ! " 54"!!"6 64 65!

46 !!

" 7

5 !

% .

65 4"!

5 !"446 :5!"6 7 465 6" $!?

G97: 0"5 %

" 7% 7 6 !57!

":J"46 !" !4 :!

4 6 $! ?5

G95 "!: " 46 !4"

! !!

4 !6: D5 4"!!* !"6!!! 7! 6" $!8

G9 $!?

G9!

4 :5 44:!!!!: 0"5 "

45 !"4 !"6!7

! 44 65 $!

G9 !"

J"46 !

? ) 4! ! "6!!! 7 0"51 7 4"!

D ! ! !"

" :

5 $!

G9!7 :J"46 ! )67 448 8

"6 44! 5 " %6

7 6 7%5

" 46 " 4" ! 6" "!:6" 7% 4" 46 : 7! :"

7%"7% )45 "65 !"

6"! "

5 ! 7 $!?

G9 !

46 !

A '6 !!" !! 4654"!

!44! ! 66"67 ! : 3">5 6 4

5!"4 66"67 !

"!%"7$!8@ G9 6 )45 !

% 4"5 5%" 86 ! 46 : ?

:!7!

!6 : "!7% "5 "!5 "!:6"

7% "8 6 !!!"4 546 ! 4"!!

46!

"!!!!! "!5% 7! "$!

G9 6

6" 7% "8 6 !44" 4457" 646 !5 4"!! 465 $!

G9'!J":5 "5!7$!

G9 "

E ! ! 46 ! !

D "!

65 ! '"5 0" 7 $!8

G9$!?

G9!

4 :" !7 ! !!"4 5 !46 !! 4 6:57 6"!

$! ?5

G9:7: 4"6: 451! ! 7 7 0"57 4 !! 4

@ 1 7 7 ! 5

7 46 !! 7!(9 !"

$!?

G9 07!6"!

6 $! ?5

G9 !! 4"46 $!

G9 44" !

D !!

$!8

G9 44" D"!

6 $!?

G9 !

#%#/%&&&01

)45 46 !77: !>" 6!

$! 5

G9 6"7: 0" 446 !7"4:!#EF "65 " 6 46 5 !

7" :>:! ::

! 57 !

8 6 :

5 7 4 5 46 !4": ! !"

!44 : :757 ! 4!!

*++$&#+

1 !

5 !5 7754

! 4! )7

!% 46 46 !6" $!E5@@5

G97: 0"5 7

E?F!"

!"65 "6 1 46:

!946! !

!5 )7

7! :

!!5 4: G!2040: 4!5 2 57 !: $!A

G9 6 7!! "7% G" 4! $!?

G9 : !"0 "!5 !467!!$! @5?

6 46 ! $!?

G97!465 7 @F ! "6 "

1 ! : !

!5 46 "

7 4 !

!!5 !6>4!7!!7!

46 57 4 4 !!"

46 !!5!6>4!7%

!! !:4 4 4!)7

5 0" !46$!A

G9 6 57 ! :46: " 7% " 4! 4!7!!8 :! 57 4 7!

44 : 0" !! !66 0"

G84""

!46

$!A

G9 6 : !! 46

! 5$!

G9 6 5$! @5

G9 "6 6" A7!

5 :7 46 !"

!! 46$!E5A@5

G9 $!?

G97!77! "D !!5 $!?

G97!7 !!

77 4!$!

G97!7 :7:

!! 4!"6 "!56" $!E5@@5

G97!7

2"4

5 4"!

!5 !"6 !4 7!D46! 0"5"4 7! ! D !! 4! 4" "4 G856! >" 6 "

6'"

" " 5$!

G9!75! 4"!5

7!!! 4!"6!$!

G94

64 4!

! 87 7

E:!!

4 : 6 46 5"

! 6 ! 44 6:54"!!"6 J"6"

46 !!7 ! 4!5

! ?5 !! ! 8 :!!

" 5 "D !! D !$! ?5

G9 756! >" 6 "

6'"

! " #!

! ! " # $!! %&$ !'# !! !

$! $#!'(

!!$!(! ! # # %)' !* +#'

!$ $# !

, !'# #- !( $ . $# $!(! ! ! / !!

#! !! !! / !!

!! $! # (- ! !!! - $ $ ! $! #!

$ #'$!

%+#' !'# # #

0( ' #"'

$'!

!$-' " # $! $# ! '( !! !

$! $!

$#0 !'#

! "

!! # !! !

$#!(( #! # # !

' 1$ # !!$

! $# ! 0- $!

! #!

!!)( 2 ' (!3 ( $!

! - / !! $!/ . !!!!! $#!-'$

!!-'((!!! $! # !! - $ / !! ! ! $! 3# #( $! !

/ $# ! ( !! !

$! $!

$# $' !'!

$ !

4' #

$!! )$$ $$ $# $! ! - $ '5!.6!!!!!'2 ' $!'

# ##( ! !$ ' !* (* ( ' 7"' &-# - . $ !

! $# '! # !! $#

! 5! .6 # 5! .6 # 2 ! !##

!(!

'2 ' !# !! $# 5!8 .6

! 3#'!

, ! $!( ! #! " # #

#$!! $'' !! !!!

$ -$ !$!

! (! - '$!

, !!(' ! # $ #

' ' (!!(' ! ((! $

$ #!- $$ !( !!$ $! (' !! 2# $!

!!('!

'!#* !

,'$$ ' ! !$$ 0$ ! ! ! $# ! 5!8 .6

(!!! $#

! !# !'"$ $!

# !# ( $(' ( )! (! $!!! ( ( $!

, !

.6(!!! $! # (!!!' (!# 5!

.6( ! !! - $ !! $! # 0$ ! ! 5!8

.6#((!('2 ' !$$ (!# )! !!! - $ ! (

" #! $!!

4' # ! $! ( 5!

.6 ! $# ! $ (!5! .6(!( # $! $! !9 ! ! ' ( '( 5!

.6 5! .6 # $ $!

$! #' $ 3

!$! !

!, (!! ! # '#!' $ #

!( -! !- $ $ $ ' $# ! 5!

.6$ ( $ !$!9(# )! ! ! $!

( !# 5! .6$ !! - $ ! !!'$- ( !$$!!

! $ 3

!, (5!

.6$ (! / !! $! !# 5!

! " #!

$!!! 8 0$ $# ! ((' !" #

!! (!:6 07!!! 46 $!@5A 5

G9 07!!! 4!"6

G9 07!!!

4 $!

G94

! 8 L$!

G9 07!!!

4 $!?

G94

! ?

L$!

G9 07!D !! "!!

$! ?5

! !

#$%2*%&&&01 !!"6!$!?5

G9 7 7!7:

0"5 $!E5@@5

G90 ! 46"

46 !7"4:!#EF "65" 6 46 5 K

! 6"5 4 4!5

! 87" $!

G94

7" $!@ 5?

?7" $!A@5

5 77 4!57" $! 5?

G9 ":5 ! 6"! 7" 4 4: ! :

7 7 6"5EF "65" 6

46 5 K 54

46 '6 ! !!" :6 "" !

465!46: 4"!

! 1!! "

4!)7

!*467!

$!A

G9 6 !! !:4 4 "45 7!! 7!7% !4 7 44

7! : 4 5 4664 " !!5 7 5 ! 44 !

7 "46 46 :5444" 6 :6 4!7!

:% 64 4:

)45 4 4"! !

44 5" !'"! !4!!:

!6 !! "" !

4! 46

!5 !! " : ! 4 !44 :5! ! !"4 % 4!!5 7 4! 7! "

6!6 :65 !! "" !

4! 46 44"6! 77$>!

!* 4! !"

5" 44"!"67"!"!

>" 6 "

6'" +4 4!!"

5 !

4 !! "" !

4! 46 : 46!6 44446!4!!

4!7! 6!6 :6 )45! 4!7! $!A

G9 6 5?

6"5$!8

G95!%! ! 44" !! "" !

4! 46

!56! >" 6

4!$>!*4! 4! !! :!

"4!6 6 !!"6

$!8

G957! ! D !! 4!5 :

6% 6 : 4:

!5 !! ""

4! 4!46 4!5$!

G9 5 "!! "" !

4! 46

!57%!"$! E5

G957 4 6" A!

546 !"6 $! 58

G9 6:46 :

!5:7: !! "" !

4! 465

>" 6 "

6'" ! !"4 46 !! : 46!!"4 %4!! )45 !

85 !"4 46 :5 !

! !!"65$! 58

G957 0"5 7

!#AF "65" 6 46

5 !"4 ! 0"!

" !!"6 !

D !4: 6D6"6!57 K% >" 6 "

6'" 4! !"

46! " 46! !"4 % 4!!5 !!"65 7 ! 7" 44" D !5 7" !"!

! !6 6 !

46 !6 44446!4!!!!"! 46!!"4 4!!57 " 4 !'" 5 5 *"

6'" ! !! "" !

4! 46 :46!!"4 % 4!!5 !"446 :!

857"

!!"6 "! "

46 0"5 7 ! !44""

D ! !

!44 :! :757 !

4!! .": 5

(, - .)