High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7493/2018allowed

Jogender F/No.155111096 Rt/Gd v. Union Of India And ORS

2020-03-04Ms. Justice Nirmaljit Kaur13 pages

! " #$

!"# # "$

% & $ '"() * %+*$ , () *( "$ % '"'-() *( " $ "$

% ."$ " /- "$0- $ " 1 $ " 2

- # *-3 / $$1-

."$ / $- 02"$ "

4$ 02"11 (#. &%( * /""( " * / /-- "

1" 2$$-02")$$--)" 2/-- "

1" *02 $ 65 10-/" " $ 2 "1/" $* /"--7-0 2 * ." $ 6

4 89 :#.;& < / $$ 0-:& <#35

5"*2 =& $ (#3(6$ 1$ 20."$

$ # .

( 1(, -'

0 1& $ (#3(--$ 1."$ / />0 /

4/""

/" $ 1* $ " 2?1$- /> 0 ("$ / 5 21 1-* 1

4$ " " - " $

1"1 1-*

4."1

"$ / 9 02"$

4#--2("$ 7

1$" 2 4 2-*0"1/ " 1$-- 1( " $ -

"15

4 1

$ 0>#.&% , -

40/--/ 1$-" 1 " */

40211 (#. &%, -* 1$

4."$ - 2$$-"!$ & -! (%10 $ 69$-" 1/"""$ /1$-- -* "1 1

."$$- / 1 02 " !$ & --(%10 $ 6*

!/1 "

"@ @

" $- 2 $ @ * / / -2

4($ $ * '0#- :

<#-5':.1$ 2' *<#- 45 /"#- :<#3(#- 55."$ - * ' "#3#- 45"--" 1 " A" $$-#$ 65$

"- " * 10- "- $ 2 " " 1$

( - - "$ 01 ""//

* $"$ 0 -"$"1 1 *' -2(" "/ 2 $- $ / 0 1" *"$ ."

( " 0 " $ 0 * 1 (/""1 " 1" * "$ ." (/10$" $ 1"-

$ 1- 7 2 0 - 1A $"1 3 "( " $ " --21$- 4/> /"-2 - $$ ." (" *- 0 " ""/0- " *3"("$"1 1 -2A(" " $ $ - #$-2"0- )$ " $-2("$ "

01 $$- 4 2-*/

4" "1

40" -*/ " "/1 2 "("/> $$"1

--1$-" 0 ?5

4(0

" (/ "" $ " -"1$/"2 1

-2 "/

"1$( 02 (0 (

-/20"- 0 B("1 $ / - 1 - '( , 5

4.""("$ 1$- 1 ""-" 4/> "$ 0-27 /""

- -"3 (0"" "1$/----2 ."$ $ "/

4( 10 1

2; 2?"

*-("/$ 1 " " / 2 / "" $ " 11 1 " 1$ /"$ 1 10/----2 2'"2$ $- $ 0 "-3 ->#3( /"" 7 ""

$-)

-2(" */ "/"0211 (#.(#3( 1(,

;

(

402--/"1 -117*-"1"$2$---/ " $ 1"("1 /"""/

/11 -2 0 " 1" * ("120 "$

02/"""--" 1" "$ *

'0#-:

<"#-5'.1$ 2' *#-( 45

/"#- 4:<#3#- 55." "$

" " 0 1 " 2 /" 2 1 9$- " $ /

" " 2*-"0-" 21* 1-

!/ " 01 ""1$" 2"

-2*- " "$ "10- *" ! / " "$ #-5 -*-' *:.1$ ' *<#- 45(1$ 2&* 1 *0 1 * /" 2 " $ 1- 7 2 7 6 0("$ (" */ $ "$ * '0 #-:

<"#- 5'

5 .1$ 2' *#-( 45 /"#- 4:<#3#- 55( /""$ 1" " 1 *211"@ 02"$$" 2

" "

2 --1

"(/" 1$ 2"--0-0- " 1"@ 0" 1"" " /-- #- 4)" -# *-3 #- 55

'0#-:

<"#-5':.1$ 2' *<#- 45 &'()*+'(,)-' :<)--110 "3 "--0 -- $ "

"$ 1("2"--0 -0- " 211"@02" $$" 2)" "$ "* 0*"--0 7$ 12 "$ *" -*-' *:.1$ ' *< #-( 45 ." - 7$ 1 " - "-- 0 1$ &* 1 1$-2 - "2 -1 " $

" -")."/" 1$ 2"--0-0-

" 1"@ "/" 7 $ 1"--0-0- " "

1"@

/"" -(1 11 1 .'(/)012)02'/3(1(4+'(,)-' :

<:<." *1$ 2&* 1 *"-- 0-0- 12102/ * " 02"&* 1 *"$$" 2

02"$$" 2"&* 1 *D :0<"$ ""--01" * "" *2"&* 1 *12 0 "/" " 1( "

4 &* 1 *"--0- -117*- "1"$2$---/ "$ " " 1 /"" " /

/ "1 11 -20 " 1" *( " 120( "$ 02/"""--" 1"E ) " - - "$ (--/ "*1 :<) 1 -2("$ /"1$ &* 1 * :0<."$ @1

4 :<B01 $$- 4 2-* 1

4 5

4" 1

<."-*/ ."$ -/" 1 5

4 $ " /

10 2 :<. 1

/$ 0211 (#.

4 :<."$$-"

1/ 1

02"- "1@ @ :<B/ "- @ @/"2"/ 7 2 ." 7" " 0 " /"" " *"$ 0 /""/ ;7 21$ 2&* 1 * ."$ "0 "- "1@ @

"*11 *1 .")$$--)" 2" $--2" "$ @ @/" *1 ."

-*#- "#3#- 45 0"/

@ @

$ /--0 /"" "/ /-- $$ " 4 2 " 111

(0 * 2-*." ("11 "-- 10-" 7 2-F

/" 110 (/""--0" $ * 0

7 " (0 * 2-* ."

#--""11 "--$0-""1 /" 7 2 - "1@ @ B/* (""$ (" 0> 2 "/ /-- ""0 - @ @/""- 27 2=@ @ --(/""0 $ * /"27 2."/- "*0 ( ("1$

1$- !* 1"

")$$--)" 2/-- "/ 1" 0" " 1

/" -- 1 !" 1( / 2

10/--1 2 " $ "- 7 2! /--- $ $-/"*$ 0 "$ " 0 2 1 $ 0 -- $ ." * 1$ 2 1$-2 0

0 -2 $*-2/"$$-2"$ $- -A ."B@0-)$9 " )"-*'

A0 " (:

<' "- 1"" *"*0

$ 0$ 02*>" 1 "$$1/""$ 1 1* /"02"1$-2" - $ 1" 2( 1 $*"*/"/ 1-

"B" "'$ 1 "0> /"""$$--" / 64(( G " A 1 C4 + - " $ "

""$$--( $$1(/$- $ 0 """$ $ 0//2 (" * - 0 21

"$ $ 0 /"2("$$1- ! ""$$---12 ""$ /"""/$$ 0$ 0("/ > /--- 2 "/ > / 2(" */ 1 " ")$$1?

."$- 0$ )$ 0 (->1$ 2 *(--

$ " * 0

0 -2( " *0 $* 1 /" 1$-2 /" " $ $- - A

." *- 02"$ 0 "B" -" "0> /"""

( 1" *"$$--(10$ '"

/""("(1(- "*0$ /""- - 7 2 * $$ 2" "$$-- ." -//" $H$ 0 H/

*/ 02"

." --2* "/--( $ - -2"("

1$ 1 "E !"$ -(-""(" 1

" 0$ 1"$$102*1"@0 "

$ 02")$$--)" 21>-

"" 1/ )$ "

" )$$--)" 2C/@ @02 $- ((" */ /

4($ $ * '0#-:

<#-5':.1$ 2' *<#-(

45E"- 1"$$-(/"- " 1" 3 -> #3 * 1 " 02 " 11 (#.(#3 1"$$-- 1 1" */

.""/"" 1

0 1

@1$- @!* "" 1/ --87 21 1 --*1$-2$ 0 1$ 21$-2 ."A 1 " )"A@:$ <( 1$-/ "70*)01 - (@ @ --." ("$ 1 > "--1 ( 1

*1$ 21$-2/"7 20 ." 7/"" "$"1 1 /A ""$

." *="#A"B" ." '*#/'"( 5#+ /"- -/""1 @ @ $"- " ' 7 " " 020 * C."- ' "7 "

0"" 4:<")/--

!'4:<$ * $"1 " *( "7"/ 0 "-

' /0"1"/

@ @ B/"*/"@ @1$- 0 1 @ $ $- /" " -- + $2&* 1) * " 1"/

@ @." 0 0"" /

@ @ 1$-21-*"$ 1

$ 1 " $ /" $ 1 ! 1 1"1 ( "1"1 "*

"$( /2/"" * "F

2( " >21$ *!" $ @ " " - /" " * 2"F

2 " >21$ * 6 "0 2$ * "" " 2--)--""$ " 00-$ *""" -"$ /"-*." " 1 "."' /(" ( " 7" 4:<")E )$$-2""#/'"@:$ < "" ("$ / -* "/1

( "1/"-*0 0" "/ $ 1"1

B/* ("/--/ A." $ !("1 (--(0 1

2 0 1 @ @B("* 2$"1 " "."B@0-)$9 "%->'"*' A0 " ( 4: <'.5 -11- 1 "" "

"'>0>"$$-- " *02"- $ 6" C

&'$

(

) ! * )

/ " ("B@0-)$9 "#A."> * ! : ?!< " (:

<'4

/"--> " $ $ -2"- ""7" 71 $"1 0/""A % -0"- ("- 0* * -2" " "- 0 $ $ "> !"$ ("$ " $$- -* " / 1

." " " $ / 1

$ !" $$-("$ "$--21

"/ 1$-- 1""$ -" "1

12." 1

" - 209 02"$ /- "*010

1 -2 " -*"$ 01 " -

--"$$-(/"/ "1

12#A" -*" 1-"/""$ 0-* " '("$ A0>("$"1 1"$ "0@" "@ "

*0 )"("A 1B@0-")$9 -

$ 02- - " $ *-)$$- 65

- ! " *%A /-

" (

5( "-$!" ("7

/"- " 7 2("$$--/ - @ @

"- ""$$--/- * 0 - B ("$

/"- @ @/""- 7 2% * ("$ "

1$- 4/> "$ - $ / 0 * 2 2." $ - $

4 $-

)9 $ 0-/ C:< )3.8# '8?6 %?6.B 81$-2 " ; B*-2> B/ > 2E !" 1(0 ""/--0 )

-2(-*/"-

"*0> !*/"0*("

." $ >0>" $ * "/" B/* ( " $ "-- 0 - "0>/ )--/ 0* 5 "$

" 1- "" '$>;# I;6 "" #$ 0- I;6