Balkar Singh v. State Of Punjab
! "#
!" #$%&' ()*+,' -+./0 !
#$%&' ()*+,'1(&2+3/+#40 ! $ % & ' ( $ ' ' $ !
) ' & '! "#
-+./0 ! 5
) " *
' #+ , ' & ' )- ./'#+ '( ( ( # 01!2 3( 01!2 * * + '45 +* ' * * 6* ) !7 &
,#8 ( + (*(
, 8 9 .
/ !
$ ',#8 !7&
# ( * ( !7&
9 6+ /
/ 0
$ ' * #+
# (
( ** *,#8 + ** *,# 8 ' +(
* + : ) + * ; # ,# 8 3(' (+ ( 7 + *' + ,#8 (+ *( " + ) *( '<6 ' #( =1'<6 4'( ) 5#+( 5**6* 1 ( ( * * ) 6* *#( ) * ( 0 2 *' 3* # (
$
$
(+ ) (# >
* + * 3* # # : ? # ( 3( ' # 3 ' @ A # * + A * +
#+ # # " * 2 #( 7
" * + + !7 &
,# 8 ( *
# + 9 .
/# !
$ '
# 8*2 *,#8 3 * 3 ,#8 * (# 3 ( ; * **+ 3 ( * *
9 6+# 0
$ ' # (
( , 7 + ' ( + ) + *# ) +( * ) + 5#+,#8 (+ ) ( * ) +( @ !
$ # .
!7@ " ! 5** 6* 3'<6 ! !** <6 !< 3 ( " #+,#8 *+( #( + #( + > 6 ** A * (
.
* ( # +*( C
' ( +6
'( ( + ) ##* #( 5**( ( 0 * #( " + ( ** !71
* * : &"* * <6 !3 * '<6 !3''<6 '( !7.1 >
/
/' 2* &
** '<6 ' (
* * ' #( =1'<6 4'( 3 ; 5#+( 5**6* ) ( =A'2 '#
3
* * +
3* # ' **
) 5** <6 !< ) ( +6 ' ( ( + ) ##*#( 5 **(( 0 #( " + (**
* +( #( + ( #( + ( > + 6 ** 1 * * !7 &
,#8 (*
# +#
3 * 9 .
/# !
$ * !7 &
** * 6 * ( # (
7 + ' +( + ( ) +
* ) +( * ,#8 + !( * 3* '<6 '(
: <6 ' (
* &"*
) ## * !# # ( 1 * 0 02 ' 3* # ( 5 ' *+'$
'#
6* $
) 5#+(
1( *6 1 < ( (
! ! "#"$ "&'%"
' ()#
*+ + "
-- * .$ % / "'+//
'""'/%!0"0 #+ $"
"'
"/+,# !//+'
$1%!
'
! ! "#"$ "
1"
!#' +
/ !" 2'!' 3/ + ''"#" "
2 %"' !
//+ 4% "&'%"
'%!
% !'+ 5
,+'
# !"," !! "#""' ! 3/
" '
/"! 0 ! "'!0 " "!8 ! !2 !1 "' 2!+ /0"'
" * " 9 " / ' 1%"/% !
: "/'"'
1"
% ""''+ !
! +'
!
" !0"
+ "'""'1 %
+/"0" %"'
/
5 ;4% <+ ""'1%
/,,"
!/", !
! /+
!/ !"!
= !
$1!'!
&!%
"'
! ;
4% &!
"1! "#", !';
1% ;! 1"'
+'
/ "
1% !!//+'
!> ' /+'
!
" 1% //+ > % 1!''
!!1!2 , //+ "
"' ", #!# % 1+ %!
! "/"
" /", "'
!#!'"/ !1 "!/","! /!'
$"1%"/% !//+'
"'
%!
" "/
%2'"/! "?+2 !
'$
#+ "' " !//+'
1!' !
'/ !%!' ! "/"
" /",
4% #+ 1+ # ''
#2 ,
!//+'
%!'!
! "#" 4%
!
!//+'
"'+/%/!'
'
# /'" 21%
#+ %!'#
"'/%!0 #2 "'!
"'
" 2
+ / "'+//
'""'/%!0"0 #+ "'"/+,# !//+'
$1%!
'
! ! "#"$
"
1"
%!#' +
/ !" 2'!' 3/ +
''"#" "
2 %"' !
//+ 7%
!//+'
!
'/ //+ %!'
#
!# "'% '!
"'
" 2#2 " %+0% "!# $ ,! 2 /+ 1+ # ' 1 #
!2 /+
% 1!'
1% 1% //+ %!
+ "
!+/ #2 !//+'
"' '+/%!<+! "
2! '+/%!'
!! /+ ,!2
!"', !'!#
+# 0!"0 %"' !
'/ 1%
//+ > $ !//+'
1+ $+# $#
#
!'!# +# @
+ '
$"
1+ # !'+ '"
" # !"1
$"'+/%/"/+,'
!/ '$ #+ !//+'
"'
!
% ! 2 1'$
$ '
"/ "'
<+" !# "'%"0
! ! "#" 4%"'+ %!'
#'
' ! "
//!'"' " +%!
%8! 2 *
A 8 = *
!%!!'% ! !'"0! B!0!!,8",
) A 3 D# *2
:
?22/ # ( < ' ( " + ( *(** ) A 5 6
!
!> ' "'" " !/2 !%+'
!"'+/%/"/+,'
!/ '1% !''!" ! '%!
!
+"
2 !!/,,"
!
", ! " /"/+,'
!/ ' " /%"/ $ "
1" # "
"/+ " ! !# "'%
0+"
!//+'
"
'
"/ "/"
/"/+,'
! "!
$!' "/ !# $"'"'"'
+ #2 + D+0 ' '" !/","! "! , 2 '
"/ ,!"' +"'% D+0 ! ' '" '
!0+"
2,! ' '/!
%! +# "/ + ' *
* " ! " 8+# "/8'
"- <+
1"
%!
! #2"?"
8!'!2!
$D "*
8+?!# E!!" *"0% *
4% !1 ' ?"!+ 2 " !
'+/%/%!!/
1%"/%"'! ,'
", ''"# # !
!2!
2"
"/+ # 4% + 2
""' !'+/% 1%"/%"
"'/!
!#
!"0$%! "0 0! '!/"/+,'
!/ '
/!'
( "
"' ''!2 >
","* ":
9 " / 1%"/%'!2' 1% !2 "'
/"! 2 1"
%" >1 0 !2
'$ #+ "0
.
"' + %", +'
!
" # !
%"'
" %1'', "0% /
!'/
%"'
"'"!"
!'5 #"'/%!0 1"
% !
"0!!" 1!21"
%+
"/>
4% #+ "0 % %!! "/>
"'
%", ; 7% !
"> ,+ "' /,,"
" '
/ /2 "'" !%+'
$ ""
"! #+ !# "'% /!'
1+ ++#
2# + "$#+ !
+ ! !,+ # #2"
!# "'% /%!0
/! # '!, 0
!'"' <+" " /!'
' /"/+,'
! "! 4% #+ 1+ # !
/, !!
2 "0%
/%!!/
"
1 * ":
9 " / 1" # !/ "0#+
",!
' %+'
0"
!/0 !!
"!' %1 /", 1!'/,,"
4% ",!
' %+'
/! 0
!1!2#2'", 2>
"0<+"
!
"0
!!
" '+
'
,"'
#+
!# "'%"
'/!'
"
' " 2+ "!
"'+ 2!
! !!//+'
!2 !!
" ', 1%!
'"," !<+ "1!' 3!," #2 %"'
+ "/ "1"
%* ":
! . * +'
,'/ " +'
,'$!!''
%,+ - * $ ! "
1" # !
+/ !!'
'1%"/%! !'+ 5 /! # "'
+
" /
"0' ", '"0
!
'+ !+'
. * ":
1%"/%* " . ' !
2$ #+
"0 0'! ',+00 0'$"'
! 4%"'"'! +!, ! + "0
"! /","! <+!'"/","! /
"0'$ 1% "''
+ 2 "'" / !2
+ "!
/"!
"0"
''/
! !
+
- +'/!'
#2"
$1 ,+'
!2+ 0! >" "/"
'$ '' +!, ! $ +"
'!
"/!
" ,"' "
! "' <+" "
'/!'
1"
,!
,!
"/! /"'" ! ,'
!# 0
= $ "! %+,!!
!"'!#' +
/ !" 2"'!,2 %$! !'8
"/"
+' 2 + '"
))! 3!/ ''"'!
!> ; 9 ! !#' +
# "0 +!
!"!# $ !1$!//
' "
$ #!#" "
2!'!
1>"0'+#'
+
" %"'1>!!21 4% !1 ' <+" "
", ''"# "
<+" '"' !# "'%, '+/%! 0
#!#" "
2 ! + ,!,!2$ "
'#!'"'$#
" 3"'
" "''+ 4%+'$ 0! "' ''!" 2
=
"
"' %"0, %!! + ,!)'
",!
!' #!#" "
' /!'
4% /!"! "/"
%! "0!", !
# !"0 "/" #+ "'
'+
"/"
/2 ! 1 "0% "' #
/'" +'
1' &!'
"
/% /%
1 : !
: ;!//"0 1%"/%"
1!'" 1 '" $!" 1 / !"/
; *"/ "
"' 3/
"0 2"
"/+ $"
!#' +
2", ''"# "
'1%"/%!
/"! 21"
%" >1 0
!//+'
$"
"' # "0
,!' ! "
' ",!2#+ *,+00 "0"'/ ! " / 2"0 0' ! " 0! + ' * / /2 ! '
% # "0 "
/ "00+!'$"
"'", ''"# 8
! +!
2 "> / ''
!2 ' "0 %"'" "/"
#+'" '' ,!""
'
/"!
/+ "! >1 0
' // ""
"/"
+ 2"0* " :$9 " / $ #+ !# "'% %'
"'/!'
'// =!"
% ! '
!# "'% !" %'
'$!! '
"
',!2!"'
!0!"'
%",$1%"/%/+
1"
'+,
!+/ #2 "
! 1+ #+ ""
"! '+,
" "/ " ! +
'$!"
'+ %",0+"
2 ' "
+ #2
" )&!1 9 " )$
%9 "/ $ !0 -$
;
'+,
" "/ "'$ +# $
'+,
"?+"'=#+
2!2)' !/ "/ '%1'
,!2 # '+// ''
+ 2 /+
#2
'+,
" 0+"
!"'"0 ,
+ !" ''
''" '
2;$ %+0%
!
"' 2! '+,
" 4%+'
#+ "
! ,!2#
/'" !# 2 "0%
#2'+/% '+,
"
!"'"0" " ! + (1
$ %"' '
! '
/"!
/+ "!>1 0
' /
!0!"'
1"
"
! !
0
#+
+/"0', "
" "''+ 1" 2!
"!
#+ $ "'/%!0
1%"/%$ 2' "0% ,!2'+
"/ C 9, %!'"''+
4% !
'!" "/"
%!'#
!
! 1 "
! !,8!'!0!1! *
"%!$-- -*.
1% !,!"
1,!%!/,,"
'+"/" !//+
" ,
+ % #2% %+'#!!" !1'!//+ ,! 12!# "0"''+
''
4% <+ " #+ 1% ', '!
1"
%"
'! >1 0 !//+'
1!'
3!," "*
7
0! "%!,,!,! . * .
%"' /!'
!''!" ! ' /"# 2 !00 !'
!% '% , %+'
1% % 1!'
!>"0'%
!//+
! !//+'
! > %", !1!2 !
!#+ " "0% !2 "
,"0%"',!0 #21!' + 2"0" %'
4% "! + / "/
!//+'
+ * ": !1"
%* "8!'
, 2 !'
4% !//+'
!!
! !0!"'
"/ "/ " #
("0%+ ! *
! ' !!
/%!
0"0 !/<+"
! !//+'
,+ /%!0
4% !//+'
%! 0"
!2 !!
"!' 1%!
!% '%!
% 1!'!#+/
#2 , 4%
! * ''"' D+0 !
"0 !1 /"/+,'
! "! %! #'
1!' !
,"''"0 ">" /%!" !
!'
1!'
!'
'
0
1"
% !//+'
'' !
"'/ 2 ! #2 " %'
! ! %! // + "%! !"
!# "'%
/%!0 ,+ !0!"'
!//+'
''# 2!2 !'!# +# 4%"'+ >
"'"' * " : 9 " / ! !" 1
1"0 "/"
" !!'
'5 ; 4% "'
" + #+ "'
" 0+"
!//+'
'%+ # !> !'! ''" "'
/ " !' %+0% !,"
' / '' "
"0 !'"0 4%
/ " '+,
""' ! "
!# + $ 1+ "
", !"
+
%!$"
!"
"! + "0 #+
""'! 1 # 1!
"
! "// !0 $
'"'
"+'
1+ # ,!? #
"/"!"
' ! '/"
1+ # /!'+!
2
%"'/!'
$1% "'+//
"
!# "'%"0 !
!!
/"/+,'
!/ '$
/+ %!' '+, 3"'
/ !" 8 '+,
""'!/+'
/0"'
#2 !1
/+ 2"/"
"''+/%!' %"' 8 '+,
" "'!"
!'
3"'
, 3"'
',
'$+ '' + % '+/%"
"'"'
8 '+,
" "'!+ " !1 !
1"'
+#
+ ,!2# "
,/ !" ' 7% "
"0 3"'
!
, '
'$ /+ /"'
! / '' !'"0 ! !/% ' ! 0"/!
// +'"!' ,'
#!# '"
" 4% !#
"/"
%!'0!" 0"' !
/0"
"""!
1% * ""'"/ !
" 9 "
/ 1 ' /+ '+, 3"'
!2 1%"/%"
%">' "> 2 %!
%!
/ '' /+ '%! %!
0!
/,,/+'
!
+!
'$%+,!/+/
" " ' /!'
7% "
"' '!
"'
" /+
!% '%1!'!#+/
#2 !//+'
!
>%",+ ! !$ !//+'
! > 1%!
%!
%",+ " % 1!'1"
% , %
1!' +,+ 1"
%"!'% ", !
!#+/ "
,"
!'"0 / '' 1+
!# /+ !1 '+,
"
!//+'
%!
,+ %", *+/%"
/!#
"'+
"
!//+'
1+
/+ 1%!
!% '%!
!'
+ " % 1!'" " /+'
2 ;
2"0 !
'!" "/"
$ %"' + 1%"
,!" !""0 / "/ "+ * ": !1"
* "8
'
!/<+"
! + * " !1"
%* "8!/ "/
!//+'
+ '!" "'" ! '
, ", "', "
!,B+ !,%!+%!2' *!
"%! .*$ !//+'
!
#+ ! 2!''!+ "0!
#2/!"
%",!1!2!
#21!' '
! "
%"' #2 1!' + 4% !//+'
$ %1
$
!!
"!' 1%!
2"!
2 > !1!2 #2 1!'% !#'
!2
!!
" , '" !//+'
!#+ #2$
1!'
2?+'
"/!
" !1"0!"
2%!
,+ #2 1!' + #'
%+0%* ": 9 " / ,!2 #
"
" "
'#+
0+"
!//+'
# 2 !'!# +# $#+
"1+ !
2 /!'
' "> $1%
"%!''+//
" "0 ' ,1%"/%!
!'!# "
/!# !1 0!"0 % 4%
!//+'
#2 " + "'
/"! >1 0 ,+'
!
!!
"1%"/%,"0% ! + !1!"
"
C :
/!'
$ #21!' +"'" %+'
!//+'
//+'
! >!*"0%( + ) ( * ) + #6
( ) +* * ( ) '
"%!' /!'
!0!"'
! # 2 !'!# +#
//"0 2$ !
! "' "',"''
+ % "0 1
!' ?+0, / #2 ! "! + *
! ! >!*"0%1!''+'
" !
. 4% %"''+'
'" '
"' > ( "' '+ #
"! + + 0%"' ,!""0'
!1! %",#2 "!
+ " ?+0, ! !
- :" *?
, :8
?
, 4 E4- # E4-